Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Panorama( Young families Struggling)

413 replies

dottydodah · 12/04/2022 11:12

Did anyone see this last evening? A lady with 2 small DC and a husband working as a Research Scientist was struggling with bills .Another young Mum in tears as her energy bill was so high.A third lady (working as a Nurse) not able to run a car. How will they manage to keep going? Surely Govt could do more?

OP posts:
SockFluffInTheBath · 12/04/2022 14:14

It made me cry.

I made our teen DC watch it, they’ve grown up in a very comfortable bubble- not extravagant but always enough of everything. It’s not always been like this and when they were small things were pretty hard financially which we talked about after the programme. It made them realise how bloody lucky they are. The penny seemed to drop for DS in particular (oblivious, thinks it all grows on trees). We’re being hit by the price rises, NI increase, new monthly vet bill c£200, floating 2 sets of elderly parents and we’ll manage but ffs that’s because we have 2 good wages coming in. We should be in clover but will be ‘getting by’. How the hell this bastard government expects people on less to manage is beyond me. They should be made to come up with a workable budget for a family on NMW & UC and fucking well live on it for the next 12 months. They have no idea and care even less.

MissyB1 · 12/04/2022 14:14

@Babyroobs
Did they specify she only worked Monday-Friday 9-5? Radiology have to have out of hours staff, X rays and other procedures are needed out of hours and weekends. These days it’s very hard to get a contract that lets you out of those commitments, even if you are a single parent. Flexible or family friendly is merely paid lip service in the NHS.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 12/04/2022 14:12

I’m sure if miners had been spending money on cars, internet, trainers, take aways etc then they would have been hungry too rather than on a couple of bits of coal and some meat and vegetables

But the internet is essential.

DogsAndGin · 12/04/2022 14:10

People are in denial. I was talking to two older, financially secure people about this, and they both said, ‘I don’t see why they can’t just work harder and not have children if they can’t afford them.’ Infuriating!!

Porcupineintherough · 12/04/2022 14:05

@Onlyforcake yeah, but you know what, that's shit. Your employers are treating you appallingly. The care sector needs to up its fucking game, maybe then there wouldn't be such a recruitment crisis.

Babyroobs · 12/04/2022 14:00

@Snoozer11

"Why aren't the government doing more?"

The government aren't doing ANYTHING!

I think they are going to have to do more to help towards energy costs whether that is giving out more payments etc/ grants to the most vulnerable. The UC taper rates and work allowances changed quite a bit earlier in the year to help those on benefits but only really helped those working not those unemployed or carers etc, and the rises have in no way kept up with inflation.
Babyroobs · 12/04/2022 13:59

@OnlyFoolsnMothers

It’s terrifying- I know I’m financially lucky and I’m petrified so god knows what will happen come October for the masses. I’m also grateful I have such young children, if I had teens using electricity , growing into adult size clothes, eating more, all activities costing we wouldn’t survive
Until recently we had four teens and yes it's a nightmare. I know it was our own decision to have them and we have always knackered ourselves out working around each other to provide for them but yes they are so expensive. I have 3 boys and they eat tons, bus pass to college costs £400 a year etc. We are lucky in that 3 out of four of our teens have managed to get well paying cleaning jobs at their old school so that helps in that they can buy stuff themselves.
Onlyforcake · 12/04/2022 13:53

Oh yes. I also have to access the Internet to demonstrate I've worked in my care job. Clients don't have WiFi. I have yo have a phone, work do not provide that, nor cover the cost of my data

Snoozer11 · 12/04/2022 13:52

"Why aren't the government doing more?"

The government aren't doing ANYTHING!

Onlyforcake · 12/04/2022 13:50

Another crazy answer pushing the blame onto the lifestyle of families. No-one would get a job at the care agency I work at if they don't have a car. Honestly, they schedule everything on the basis of travel between calls in a car (not a city centre role), you can't cycle or walk. But, drivers get paid at minimum wage and fuel only between qualifying calls (calls less than 30 mins apart, only between calls not from.office etc). Its not enough to run everything, all of us relying on partners to support us really.
You can bet not one of us is earning enough for a household and running a car (essential to our job but definitely not provided). Employers are not being pressured at all by distant, uncaring politicians that literally blame individuals for not having higher paid jobs.

I've got a degree, in a role that also would not cover the cost of childcare/ car that would be necessary in that role too.
Politicians and their best buddy business owners won't be happy until employees are paying to go to work.

I am looking for work, in care, where I won't have to run a car. No joy yet.

Babyroobs · 12/04/2022 13:50

@MissyB1

For those criticising the nurse. You need to understand that for nurses it’s very hard to find childcare that fits in with a job that is not family friendly. Even those that have a partner struggle. I’m not surprised that particular nurse only works 3 days, for her to work full time with 3 kids, as a single parent, is going to be almost impossible in that job. Also it would probably be pointless anyway as any extra wages would simply pay the childcare. And with no benefit to her or the kids.
she worked in a radiology department so quite likely she works regular hours rather than shift work. Also she will be on Uc or tax credit both of which pay 70 or even 85% of childcare costs.
painauraisin · 12/04/2022 13:49

I'm surprised nobody has been on yet to say that they shouldn't have had kids if they can't afford to support them. That's usually one of the first lines trotted out.

Porcupineintherough · 12/04/2022 13:48

I think one of the key things that the government could and should do is to do more to ensure that absent parents pay child maintenance. CMS has to be held accountable for their failings and get these people paying for their kids.

^^THIS! How many more years do we have to watch single mothers struggle whilst dad waltzes off lead his best life?

ChiselandBits · 12/04/2022 13:45

About 8 years ago, ex DH and I lived in the SE. Our combined salaries in professional, graduate jobs totalled nearly 100k but with 2x fulltime childcare and a mortgage of £1250 p/m, running two cars because logistics meant we had too, we didn't have much left at the end of each month (and we had small phone contracts, no Netflix and no takeaways). If that was now and you added another £150-200 to the energy bills and another £50 odd with food prices rising and another £100 on top of what we used to pay for petrol, we'd be in the red, even on those salaries. To the PP who said we all see things as necessities that are really luxuries, that is v shortsighted. To navigate modern life now you pretty much DO need a smartphone for apps, QR codes, covid passes. Infrastructure has changed to make car use essential in many many set-ups. Its not realistic to say we can all go back to a 1920s style of life and blame people's skintness on not wanting to cut back. If you think that's the answer, you obviously aren't paying attention to the thousands of people saying that cannot make ends meet.

TheNoonBell · 12/04/2022 13:36

We are bankrupt as a country. We have spunked it all on increased benefits and vanity projects for the last 25 years backed by massive borrowing. Now times are bad there is nothing left in the kitty and soon no one will lend to us. Worse still our gold reserves were sold off for pennies (thanks Gordon Brown) and we have promised an awful lot of people very generous government job pensions.

A fifth of working age adults are economically inactive and we have the highest disability rates on the planet.

We are completely Donald Ducked and it is going to get a lot worse before it gets better. The government won't be able to help you and it will go after any assets you have so expect to see taxes rise even more.

elbea · 12/04/2022 13:36

The other family with a research scientist, the wife was running a shop that seemed to be making a loss. Whilst I don’t doubt they work hard you can’t sustain a shop that has one customer a day, if I was in the same position I’d close the shop and get a reliable income. The husband is spending loads on a 80 mile commute, it isn’t difficult to see why they are struggling.

Antarcticant · 12/04/2022 13:29

@mydogisthebest

I didn't see it but the nurse is in The Mail today.

She only works part time so it's not that surprising that she is struggling. Plus why did she have 3 children? Why do people not stick with 1 or 2 when they have no idea what the future holds?

The article says: the mother-of-three says she doesn't work full-time because the cost of childcare means she would end up with less money.

That in itself probably needs addressing - more affordable childcare/better wages etc. but isn't her fault.

As for having three - she's not psychic - presumably at the time she could afford them. No one would have any children if they had to factor in all conceivable future events.

Orangesandlemons77 · 12/04/2022 13:27

Also I guess the 2 child policy with tax credits / UC (?) will make it difficult for some of these families with 3 DC?

The other couple with both working were getting some UC...the nurse said 'family allowance' (?) not sure if she was in the UK or not, or meant UC (don't think family allowance has been around for years)

MissyB1 · 12/04/2022 13:26

For those criticising the nurse. You need to understand that for nurses it’s very hard to find childcare that fits in with a job that is not family friendly. Even those that have a partner struggle. I’m not surprised that particular nurse only works 3 days, for her to work full time with 3 kids, as a single parent, is going to be almost impossible in that job. Also it would probably be pointless anyway as any extra wages would simply pay the childcare. And with no benefit to her or the kids.

Merryoldgoat · 12/04/2022 13:26

@Blossomtoes

You have it bang on. It doesn’t matter what job you’re doing, any two full time salaries shouldn’t mean you struggle.

desiringonlychild2022 · 12/04/2022 13:25

@Blossomtoes I don't think anyone should be going hungry. But I am a bit pessimistic about the general public caring unless it really hits them. There are a lot of poor people in the UK. There are also many people on good incomes /bad incomes and inherited/unearned equity who are still happily going on holidays and shopping and doing home improvements. I think we need second group to be affected.

Orangesandlemons77 · 12/04/2022 13:24

I wondered about the couple where she was self employed and had a business - with hardly any customers- surely the overheads for that must be really high if she's not selling much? It looked like a liability to me. So even if the DH was a research scientist I could see how they could be struggling.

dottydodah · 12/04/2022 13:23

mydogisthebest How much better would she be even if she had 2 children though? Who knows what the future holds.Maybe she was happily married and was expecting to be with the DC father long term. My friend has 3 DC ,and has been working nights for a long time (SM)She is always tired and is run ragged .No support from ex .Surely we should have a better system for people who fall through the net?

OP posts:
Merryoldgoat · 12/04/2022 13:21

My monthly bill has gone from £104 to £252 (dual fuel).

It’s absolutely horrifying - I don’t know how some people will manage.

Blossomtoes · 12/04/2022 13:21

[quote desiringonlychild2022]@Blossomtoes haven't watched the show yet but 2 good incomes? Is a civil servant and a teacher on full time hours going to struggle for example? Or 2 mid-level financial services employees on 50-60k each (in London or HC) with 1/2 kids (assuming they have a manageable mortgage)[/quote]
For God’s sake. No family on two full time incomes should be struggling. Your privilege is appalling if you think it’s only a problem if things get so bad the top 5% are struggling. Meanwhile, here in the real world …