Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Panorama( Young families Struggling)

413 replies

dottydodah · 12/04/2022 11:12

Did anyone see this last evening? A lady with 2 small DC and a husband working as a Research Scientist was struggling with bills .Another young Mum in tears as her energy bill was so high.A third lady (working as a Nurse) not able to run a car. How will they manage to keep going? Surely Govt could do more?

OP posts:
kerrypeeper · 12/04/2022 14:53

It's always best to look at statistical rather than anecdotal data.

Well maybe people are being more sensible then.

people can't afford them. It's not a good thing particularly when you factor in out ageing population & Brexit.

Crikeyalmighty · 12/04/2022 14:51

Oh and if you fancy living and working here— fat chance now as criteria for non EU is so tight unless you have a very in demand specific skill or family already here.

mydogisthebest · 12/04/2022 14:50

@kerrypeeper

If people stick with 1 or 2 then there is far more chance they will manage if something happens. For a start benefits are only paid for 2 so having more is not sensible.

How you seen the birth rate? hardly anyone is having 3 or more dc nowadays.

Well maybe people are being more sensible then.

Lots of my neighbours having 3 or more children though and almost every story I read or see on tv about a struggling mum or family has 3 or more children.

Crikeyalmighty · 12/04/2022 14:50

As I’ve mentioned many times we live in Denmark. It works very differently here— wages are much higher but so is tax . Therefore many people earn almost double what they do in the UK but take home pay is around the same as average UK incomes. The huge difference though is full time quality childcare at about £300 a month , far more family friendly work policies , no council tax , no NI and masses of good quality social housing (of all sizes) for Danish nationals and far better pensions. . So they bring home the same but the expenses especially if you have children and work are far less. The thing is though most couples both work , because even working full time here it’s normal to knock off at 4pm and pick your kids up from after school or daycare. It's a totally different mindset but the Tory’s wouldn’t go for it because a great many of their voters just see a headline figure of 46% tax and think ‘I’m not benefiting from cheap childcare or Flexi hours or good social housing’ — A lot of decisions aren’t made for the good of the people, they are made for ‘does this appeal to our particular voting demographic ‘ . Then of course we have people voting for Brexit— how are those speeches about how much better off we would all be looking?? The only people better off are a few who got rises due to staff shortages and the seriously rich as we could then not have to be part of new EU tax avoidance rules. And no we don’t have any noticeable shortages here, yes we have had energy rises- but not as much as UK and the government is a social democratic lead coalition. It doesn’t tolerate fraud or corruption and Sunak and Johnson , indeed every MP issued fines would be out on there arse.

kerrypeeper · 12/04/2022 14:48

But as I said the idea that people are popping out dozens of dc, particularly for benefits is not correct.

Babyroobs · 12/04/2022 14:46

@kerrypeeper

If people stick with 1 or 2 then there is far more chance they will manage if something happens. For a start benefits are only paid for 2 so having more is not sensible.

How you seen the birth rate? hardly anyone is having 3 or more dc nowadays.

People with 3 kids born before the April 2017 cap came into play will be significantly better off if claiming tax credit or UC. they get help with all three kids and the first child gets a higher amount on UC. For people with kids born after April 2017, you no longer get the higher amount for the first child and you are capped at 2 children which can mean if you have 3 kids but only get Uc for 2 kids your Uc entitlement is around £280 less than a family with 3 kids with older children. that is quite a big difference. Fortunately you can claim help with childcare for any number of children.
kerrypeeper · 12/04/2022 14:46

With choices come responsibilities, which is something people don't seem to think should apply to them.

So you don't think pension credit should be a thing?

ChiselandBits · 12/04/2022 14:45

@OberthursGrizzledSkipper - many pps have outlined why the nurse is likely part time - mostly v good reasons about working hours and cost of childcare - but also, If she is a single parent to 3 kids, when do you think she should do the washing, help with their homework, god forbid, maybe PLAY with them or read them a story? My ex had a hissy fit about me working 4 instead of 5 days when the kids were pre school age because he would not acknowledge that you have to actually be there to be a parent sometimes and also that I can't run a house and be at work and parent at the same time. As you say - where is the dad? Ooh, let me guess, at best, seeing them for a MacDs twice a month. Yay. How about forensically examining that and the, what is it now, 9 billion owed in unpaid child maintenance?

SockFluffInTheBath · 12/04/2022 14:45

With choices come responsibilities, which is something people don't seem to think should apply to them.

Mind that blue scarf doesn’t get too tight. What about the children- should we just stand by and watch because it’s the parents fault?

cptartapp · 12/04/2022 14:44

Time for the winter fuel allowance now to be scrapped, rebranded as a cost of living allowance and allocated on the basis of need across the board, not simply dished out to everyone over a certain age regardless of their financial circumstance. Many many thousands of older people receiving this cash every year they don't even need to dip into.
As for the cost of means testing argument, we'll they changed the child benefit rules not so long ago quick enough.

Blossomtoes · 12/04/2022 14:41

Must be lovely living in Smugville @OberthursGrizzledSkipper.

OberthursGrizzledSkipper · 12/04/2022 14:37

I can't see why anyone thinks you should be able to manage with only one parent working full time. The woman with the shop wasn't making any money. If she went to Tesco as a manager full time they would double their income.

The nurse part time and where is the father?

With choices come responsibilities, which is something people don't seem to think should apply to them.

We were really poor when our kids were small, it's normal. We were able to earn more as the children got older. There wasn't any help at all for childcare so we worked in shifts around them. UC helps with childcare costs and there is much more available.

kerrypeeper · 12/04/2022 14:35

I'm surprised nobody has been on yet to say that they shouldn't have had kids if they can't afford to support them. That's usually one of the first lines trotted out.

It so depressing that the answer to people struggling is you should be suffering more, you don't know you are born, etc.

kerrypeeper · 12/04/2022 14:31

If people stick with 1 or 2 then there is far more chance they will manage if something happens. For a start benefits are only paid for 2 so having more is not sensible.

How you seen the birth rate? hardly anyone is having 3 or more dc nowadays.

whenwillthemadnessend · 12/04/2022 14:29

These times come in cycles and we have been riding the wave of low interest rates, never never cheap loans and cheap food etc for longer than I ever expected.

Now we have to weather the latest rough cycle but it's been 25 years since the last bad one so some on MN will never have experienced it.

Hole in the shoe, let's the snow come through and chills you to the bone anyone remember that???

RedWingBoots · 12/04/2022 14:28

@elbea

The other family with a research scientist, the wife was running a shop that seemed to be making a loss. Whilst I don’t doubt they work hard you can’t sustain a shop that has one customer a day, if I was in the same position I’d close the shop and get a reliable income. The husband is spending loads on a 80 mile commute, it isn’t difficult to see why they are struggling.
When you decide to set up a retail or restaurant business you do research into your market and it takes months to set it up.

Lots of retailers, cafes, restaurants, pubs and bars were screwed by lockdown.

mydogisthebest · 12/04/2022 14:28

@Antarcticant but no reason or need to have 3 children. Just because she could, presumably, afford them at the time doesn't mean she would always be able to afford them if things changed.

If people stick with 1 or 2 then there is far more chance they will manage if something happens. For a start benefits are only paid for 2 so having more is not sensible.

So many women/couples just don't think about it. My neighbours have just had their 4th child. Neither of them work (well not officially but he works cash in hand). If anything happens to one of them or they split up they will never manage.

Manekinek0 · 12/04/2022 14:25

The reasons why people are in these situations are complicated and you can't put the blame on one single thing. I'm sure plenty of people could take more personal responsibility but there are many who really need supporting. We have been spoilt and sheltered from the realities of life for a long time and this has been often at the expense of people in other countries.

What is the solution? We only have a finite amount of resources, so making energy cheaper is only kicking the can down the road. Renewable energy isn't a realistic option because all the other resources needed to make it work are also finite.

Agriculture is a even bigger problem, they are reliant on fossil fuels for not only machinery but for fertilizers. Modern farming practices are degrading the soil, we have or are about to hit peak food production and population continues to soar.

I can't help but feel we are on the precipice and many don't realise how bad things could get.

Dairymilk50 · 12/04/2022 14:24

@sockFluffInTheBath thank you.

mydogisthebest · 12/04/2022 14:23

@dottydodah

mydogisthebest How much better would she be even if she had 2 children though? Who knows what the future holds.Maybe she was happily married and was expecting to be with the DC father long term. My friend has 3 DC ,and has been working nights for a long time (SM)She is always tired and is run ragged .No support from ex .Surely we should have a better system for people who fall through the net?
Obviously I can't say how much better off she would be with 2 children but she would be spending less on food and clothes for them for a start.

She says she can't work full time because of the cost of child care but child care for 2 is, obviously, less than for 3.

I don't think anyone (unless you have lots of money) should take it for granted that they will be with their OH for ever. Even if they do stay together one could become too ill to work.

Of course no one know what is likely to happen in the future but sticking with 1 or 2 children is likely to be a lot safer than having more

Dairymilk50 · 12/04/2022 14:22

*she worked in a radiology department so quite likely she works regular hours rather than shift work. Also she will be on Uc or tax credit both of which pay 70 or even 85% of childcare costs.

I notice you assume everyone on UC gets the full childcare costs paid. That is not the case especially if you are a nurse. 85% is the maximum they will pay. But if your hourly rate is decent its likely she won't get that in full and let's not forget you have to find the CC upfront on UC unlike the old system.

@MissyB1 you are right. There's few nurse roles that are 9-5. I work in outpatients and I start BEFORE 9am. Its often 8-6 but I will be honest.... I bagged the role in recent times and its because I already worked for the trust 8 years on a ward doing weekends/nights

You cannot assume @Babyroobs

desiringonlychild2022 · 12/04/2022 14:20

People are in denial. I was talking to two older, financially secure people about this, and they both said, ‘I don’t see why they can’t just work harder and not have children if they can’t afford them.’ Infuriating

@Blossomtoes this is what I mean. Until Mr and Mrs Comfortable in their semi detached in Surrey realize heating is £500 per month, and petrol for their range Rovers is several hundred more and they have not gotten any bonuses and the interest on their variable rate mortgage is 5% (5% on 500k!) so they barely make ends meet, they are going to be condescending and irritating.

SockFluffInTheBath · 12/04/2022 14:19

Ref the nurse on the programme, I think she would be working more hours if it was that simple. Do we really think someone smart enough to be a nurse can’t balance childcare costs?

Dairymilk50 · 12/04/2022 14:15

@Babyroobs I haven't watched this can someone tell me the channel please? Maybe she was part time because of the hours hospitals often start at 7am till 19.30.

It doesn't make a difference though she would be entitled to UC? Sounds moving I would like to watch.