Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Panorama( Young families Struggling)

413 replies

dottydodah · 12/04/2022 11:12

Did anyone see this last evening? A lady with 2 small DC and a husband working as a Research Scientist was struggling with bills .Another young Mum in tears as her energy bill was so high.A third lady (working as a Nurse) not able to run a car. How will they manage to keep going? Surely Govt could do more?

OP posts:
OnlyFoolsnMothers · 12/04/2022 21:33

@vickyc90

How old are the nurses kids? In the daily mail article they look old enough to get themselves home until mam finishes work. She could pick up bank shift doing 7:30am-7:30pm 3 days a week which would be 36 hours so nearly full time.

We have two good salaries, we stuck with one child as we could comfortably afford it. As soon as he starts secondary school he will be getting himself home from school.

Not every 11yr old may be comfortable or able AS SOON as they start secondary- depends on the route- depends on many factors. My god the judgement on a snippet of information on this woman’s life “Oh we stuck at one” “Oh we stuck at two” Anyone can struggle, even with no kids people struggle. No empathy is exactly why these fuckers of a government get away with doing nothing to help people.
vickyc90 · 12/04/2022 21:24

How old are the nurses kids? In the daily mail article they look old enough to get themselves home until mam finishes work. She could pick up bank shift doing 7:30am-7:30pm 3 days a week which would be 36 hours so nearly full time.

We have two good salaries, we stuck with one child as we could comfortably afford it. As soon as he starts secondary school he will be getting himself home from school.

Dairymilk50 · 12/04/2022 21:22

Have you read the full thread? It's swings and round abouts. It was a short programme pointless in fact. It didn't explain how she was struggling so much maybe she wasn't applying for all benefits? I don't know.

But I stand by my comment.. in the eyes of the law if anything happened to her kids it would fall on her legally, as they are kids.

Carriemac · 12/04/2022 21:18

I agree 30 hours is enough with three kids but not being able to afford shoes or enough food for the kids? Weekend overtime would be really worth her while

Dairymilk50 · 12/04/2022 21:12

@Carriemac

She was a radiology nurse - only worked three days a week. She could Massively increase her income by doing few weekend bank shifts a month - that's not a criticism as I don't kn ow her circumstances but we are crying out for her skills at my trust
She had 3 kids though. It didn't look as though she had much support any where. I think 30 hours is enough. I don't know what it is with British culture is, that once your kids hit teens you can leave them at home.

Yes for a evening or if your really stuck. But I personally think that's what's wrong with today's generation of kids!

kerrypeeper · 12/04/2022 21:12

Look at all the celebs who have 3.

Why on earth do you think celebs are representative of the rest of the population?

Babyroobs · 12/04/2022 21:11

@Carriemac

She was a radiology nurse - only worked three days a week. She could Massively increase her income by doing few weekend bank shifts a month - that's not a criticism as I don't kn ow her circumstances but we are crying out for her skills at my trust
Yes but seemingly she didn't have an ex on the scene to help with childcare at weekends ? There isn't an abundance of weekend childcare unless she had relatives who could help.
Carriemac · 12/04/2022 21:06

She was a radiology nurse - only worked three days a week. She could
Massively increase her income by doing few weekend bank shifts a month - that's not a criticism as I don't kn ow her circumstances but we are crying out for her skills at my trust

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 12/04/2022 21:02

@orangeisthenewpuce

I only saw a bit of this last night. I thought the nurse's children all looked in their teens. If so, why does she need childcare? I'm aware I've probably got this wrong.
Depends she might work nights and require childcare or long shifts where you couldn’t leave say an 11 year old for the full amount of time. Not enough info.
mydogisthebest · 12/04/2022 20:57

[quote foxster22]@mydogisthebest 'craze for 3 children'
Wtf ? I have 3. Hardly anyone has 3 or more now, 3 is the 1990s '4'

In London I'd say it's 40% 1 child 48% 2 child
2% 3 children (never met anyone in London with

mydogisthebest · 12/04/2022 20:44

@moimichme

Right, so if someone were to have one child and then twins, they didn't 'plan' their life sufficiently well and deserve whatever bad happens to them, and the kids. Got it. /sarcasm
Oh don't be so stupid. Of course if the 2nd child is twins or even triplets or more that is different.
orangeisthenewpuce · 12/04/2022 20:43

I only saw a bit of this last night. I thought the nurse's children all looked in their teens. If so, why does she need childcare? I'm aware I've probably got this wrong.

Alwayssupportingdifference · 12/04/2022 20:20

@TheNoonBell

We are bankrupt as a country. We have spunked it all on increased benefits and vanity projects for the last 25 years backed by massive borrowing. Now times are bad there is nothing left in the kitty and soon no one will lend to us. Worse still our gold reserves were sold off for pennies (thanks Gordon Brown) and we have promised an awful lot of people very generous government job pensions.

A fifth of working age adults are economically inactive and we have the highest disability rates on the planet.

We are completely Donald Ducked and it is going to get a lot worse before it gets better. The government won't be able to help you and it will go after any assets you have so expect to see taxes rise even more.

That's interesting re the disability rate being the highest. Can I ask the source for this comment? And do you think there is something in our population that drives this or that we classify disability differently?

Not just a question for you but in general as I hadn't heard this before.

Dairymilk50 · 12/04/2022 20:17

The nurse definitely must of had some other finicial debts or a very high mortgage. £30 isn't extortionate for shoes.. I can't believe she tried to fix them. The shoes were dangerous and I'm surprised the school didn't step in.
She worked 30 hours not "very part time". Childcare is capped I'm not sure what the figure is for 3 kids... but I know UC will only pay upto £648 a month for 1 child.

Again the couple with the shop... it was nice but it was located in the wrong location. Rice from a fancy shop like that.. I don't know anyone personally who purchases their groceries from anywhere like that. I can see how there was only 1 customer during the whole week.

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 12/04/2022 20:11

Who works in an art gallery? seriously the dumbest question ever posted- it was probably the only job that worked around school hours, essentially it’s a retail job- get a grip.

kerrypeeper · 12/04/2022 20:06

well my cousin & 2 best friends did. All only wanted 2 dc. Obvs anecdotal but that seems to be taken as fact 🤷🏻‍♀️

Porcupineintherough · 12/04/2022 20:01

@moimichme

Right, so if someone were to have one child and then twins, they didn't 'plan' their life sufficiently well and deserve whatever bad happens to them, and the kids. Got it. /sarcasm
Very few people with 3 children had a single pregnancy followed by twins.
kerrypeeper · 12/04/2022 19:47

One or two is enough though. Why this craze for having 3?

What craze? 😆

OfstedOffred · 12/04/2022 19:13

A fifth of working age adults are economically inactive and we have the highest disability rates on the planet.

Why is that though?

Is it a) childcare costs limiting parents from working b) the poor mental health epidemic c) something else? I dont see why we would have higher disability rates than (for example) france or any other European country.

Crikeyalmighty · 12/04/2022 19:13

The thing is showing a family earning say £42,000 net family income but living in Redhill is not atypical, no more so than showing a family living in Preston and earning £33,000 net family income. Given the huge disparities in mortgage or rent— the end results of what you have to spend are roughly the same. Unless you are mortgage free or don’t pay rent or are lucky enough to have social housing that’s a given . I think one thing these programmes don’t show is debt— it’s very possible people have quite a bit of previous debt they are trying to keep up with and don’t want the world and his mother knowing that or they get a certain amount of housing benefit if they rent , but it’s minimal because the ‘allowance’ is calculated on much lower rates than they are actually indeed paying. It’s easy to say just move then, but if you are in private rented that means large amounts up front before you get anything back on current place or you may well fail the kind of punative income calculations a lot of agencies have or they won’t allow anyone who has ‘any’ element of benefits— even if working and you can end up stuck even if your circumstances have changed . There are many practical reasons people are stuck in what seem to others as illogical situations, although I do think the lady with the failing shop needs to have a think on this— there is no point running a business unless it’s making money or has great potential to do so and certainly not if it’s causing this level of financial issues— better to do 30 hrs a week at M&S or something. Nurses are not on great money to the person who said that and certainly not if you are having to use childcare and pay rent. My FIL nearly fell through the floor when he saw our rent and also our sons too in a London flatshare. Many older people (and I’m 60 ) simply don’t get the amounts needed to house yourself and then wonder why we can’t save for deposits on mortgages— and given 10% deposit in most areas in south east can be 40- 50k it’s not peanuts and you would also need to be earning around 100k between you to get a mortgage too. I had a look in a few towns/cities up north and many of those were not that cheap either if you were being at all fussy

moimichme · 12/04/2022 19:09

Right, so if someone were to have one child and then twins, they didn't 'plan' their life sufficiently well and deserve whatever bad happens to them, and the kids. Got it. /sarcasm

Libertybear80 · 12/04/2022 19:05

I've always been completely paranoid of being skint and bills increasing. I'm a nurse but stuck with having two kids when I wanted 3 because I couldn't afford it. People make choices!

LaQuern · 12/04/2022 19:03

@Lennybenny

I've just watched this... a few things struck me as I'm a single parent with kids. Firstly....one of the kids was eating Branded food before eating a meal, a nurse is on good money and she could work more hours but chooses to use a childminder. The self employed woman with her shop...she opened it 6 months ago in a time of financial uncertainty. If she's that stressed....work another job. Who works in an art gallery? Seriously if you're struggling get a full time job or work more hours. £75 a month going to £240....they weren't paying enough to start off with so that wasn't just the increases. There are a lot of options to help and I do think this show didn't really represent the right people.
If the nurse works more hours won't her need for a childminder increase even more?

I'm not entirely sure I understand your point

Getyourarseofffthequattro · 12/04/2022 19:02

@Smileyaxolotl1

I don’t doubt that it is going to be very difficult for people with rising fuel and food prices but the nurse worked 3 days a week. It’s not surprising that she couldn’t run a household on that few hours and as usual no sign of a man anywhere to support the three kids.

And the idea that the people are worse off than miners in the 20s? Do you realise how dumb you sound? I’m sure if miners had been spending money on cars, internet, trainers, take aways etc then they would have been hungry too rather than on a couple of bits of coal and some meat and vegetables.
Unfortunately there are far more things that we all see as essential now which take up large parts of our income and the difference is that we don’t expect to have to live frugally like they accepted then. Things like internet and phones have become essentials.

That's ridiculous. I don't think the issue is people having internet do you!
Organictangerine · 12/04/2022 18:57

That’s why I said Tory voting boomers, Blossom. Not all boomers.