Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Panorama( Young families Struggling)

413 replies

dottydodah · 12/04/2022 11:12

Did anyone see this last evening? A lady with 2 small DC and a husband working as a Research Scientist was struggling with bills .Another young Mum in tears as her energy bill was so high.A third lady (working as a Nurse) not able to run a car. How will they manage to keep going? Surely Govt could do more?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Cacti82 · 21/04/2022 18:53

I've been following the Welsh lady on FB and since the documentary she's been doing much better and has had a lot more footfall and online orders which is great!

I wonder if family friends or work colleagues have helped out the families since the documentary? Not that they will be wanting that but they may not have known how much they were struggling.

desiringonlychild2022 · 21/04/2022 01:04

@Blossomtoes When my DH and I first graduated from uni and DH began his masters degree program, we wanted to be together and the UK had a spouse visa threshold income requirement of £18600. Thankfully, DH's masters degree was in Europe so we were able to marry in Europe and move back to the UK using EU free movement law, plus he had a job in Europe while doing his degree.

I remember confiding in my SIL (DH's sister) at how unfair the requirement was, i don't think any other country has a fixed income requirement (generally you just have to show that you can support yourself etc). She said offhand- that is not a lot of money. At that time, she was also a student and had never had a job herself. And if you look at the comments on any forum, people would also say similar unsympathetic stuff. Fast forward 6.5 years, DH's salary alone is 50k, rising to £65k. We own our flat in London. But the same isn't true for a lot of people we know, a lot of people we know have gotten poorer, salaries haven't gone up, many would be struggling. A lot of people our age are renting and their rent is so high that they are forced to rent, rather than it being a lifestyle choice, they have no spare money etc.

What i am trying to say, is that what goes around and comes around. From what I have observed, people who are smug and dismissive about other people's finances are often not financially secure themselves. All it takes is for some bills to rise and they will be in a sticky situation themselves. Or they will get poorer over the years due to inflation. maybe thats why they are mean, because they are so terrified they will end up in a bad situation themselves.

OnlyTheBravest · 20/04/2022 17:35

To make it clear for you as you seem hellbent on painting me as an uncaring individual. I am using absent parent in the same way as the Child maintenance service would. Not dead, not incarcerated, not long term sick or disabled.

A person who started a family and walked away. An absent parent.

Blossomtoes · 20/04/2022 17:34

I bloody hate this thread. If this is how it’s going to be as money gets tighter, MN will become intolerable. Blaming single parents for their poverty. Describing a career as a research scientist as a lifestyle choice. Criticising a nurse with three kids for not working more than 30 hours a week. Sanctimonious, smug, self righteous twaddle.

RedWingBoots · 20/04/2022 17:26

OnlyTheBravest · 20/04/2022 17:03

@RedWingBoots Read through my previous posts. I was talking about absent parents and making them far more financially responsible for their children. Obviously, not bereaved parents. Stop being ridiculous and derailing the conversation.

A parent who is long-term in a hospital/facility or in prison is absent.

There are serious issues around both for the children involved including finances. Or don't those children count because you have never come across families in those situations?

When you talk about single parent families and measures to help them you have to include those in situations that aren't straight forward, otherwise as a PP pointed out you are creating deserving and undeserving single parents.

OnlyTheBravest · 20/04/2022 17:03

@RedWingBoots Read through my previous posts. I was talking about absent parents and making them far more financially responsible for their children. Obviously, not bereaved parents. Stop being ridiculous and derailing the conversation.

RedWingBoots · 20/04/2022 11:14

OnlyTheBravest · 19/04/2022 21:33

I am not shaming single parents. I think there should be more outrage that people are being left single parents and more should be done to make the absent parent accountable.

Including when the other parent is dead and died young not leaving anything for their young off-spring who could be a baby?

Or when the other parent is seriously ill and is in a long term hospital/facility?

Or when the other parent is in prison?

These may sound ridiculous to you but these events aren't actually that rare.

howtomoveforwards · 19/04/2022 23:12

Well they are shunned, so you're incorrect in your rant.We don't know why this particular woman is a single parent

I’ve been a single parent for 13 years. My ex and the OW - and copious women after her - fitted right into our friendship group. It was me who was shunned. He has never had an issue, despite not paying maintenance for all that time. No end of women happy to be with him - he is very vocal about ‘not giving the money-grabbing bitch a penny’. So, no, I’m not wrong.

We don’t need to know why anyone is a single parent. It is sod all to do with anyone. Ever.

Society really does need to start encouraging parents to work together. Single parenting is a key indicator of poverty

No. Society needs to accept that people who have been lied to, abused, cheated on, ignored, gas lit etc etc etc should not have to somehow work together with their abuser. This isn’t in anyone’s best interests.

So course single parenting is a key indicator of poverty. It isn’t bloody rocket science why that should be so. You don’t solve poverty by making women face their abusers on a regular basis. You will solve poverty experienced by one wage households if you change society’s view of how acceptable abandoning a child is; if you have a robust legal challenge to those who fail to financially support their children; if you ensure that childcare is affordable and accessible 24/7 so single parent’s can work full time.

Single parents are not the problem here. Stop blaming us.

OnlyTheBravest · 19/04/2022 21:33

I am not shaming single parents. I think there should be more outrage that people are being left single parents and more should be done to make the absent parent accountable.

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 19/04/2022 20:21

@howtomoveforwards

I think we should be questioning why a person is parenting as a singleton and why the other parent is not contributing. I wondered why this had happened in her case as you can not assume that she had a partner previously, some women use IVF, others for various reasons choose not to inform the father

So.....deserving and undeserving single parents? Why do you think you should be allowed the finer details of someone's life? The only reason anyone thinks they have a right to that is so they can judge - worthy/unworthy. It's not your business.

Maintenance can be collected directly from salaries protecting those from violent partners and non payers

How does collecting at source protect an ex partner from abuse? You really think it makes a difference to someone determined to make the ex sorry for ever thinking their children might have an entitlement to maintenance from their other parent?

The non-payers of maintenance are not those that work on a PAYE basis. They are the self employed, people who work cash in hand, serial job hoppers, agency workers, or shirkers. There are no laws whatsoever to manage that. That's always been the case. There's no political will to ensure that children are supported by both their parents. As a soceity we again and again and again choose to believe that women are responsible for all things children and that they should just suck it up if they had a child with someone who chooses not to pay. There is no come back for the non-paying father: he is never shunned by his family, friends, colleagues or society as a whole.

Well they are shunned, so you're incorrect in your rant. We don't know why this particular woman is a single parent.

Society really does need to start encouraging parents to work together. Single parenting is a key indicator of poverty.

howtomoveforwards · 19/04/2022 19:52

I think we should be questioning why a person is parenting as a singleton and why the other parent is not contributing. I wondered why this had happened in her case as you can not assume that she had a partner previously, some women use IVF, others for various reasons choose not to inform the father

So.....deserving and undeserving single parents? Why do you think you should be allowed the finer details of someone's life? The only reason anyone thinks they have a right to that is so they can judge - worthy/unworthy. It's not your business.

Maintenance can be collected directly from salaries protecting those from violent partners and non payers

How does collecting at source protect an ex partner from abuse? You really think it makes a difference to someone determined to make the ex sorry for ever thinking their children might have an entitlement to maintenance from their other parent?

The non-payers of maintenance are not those that work on a PAYE basis. They are the self employed, people who work cash in hand, serial job hoppers, agency workers, or shirkers. There are no laws whatsoever to manage that. That's always been the case. There's no political will to ensure that children are supported by both their parents. As a soceity we again and again and again choose to believe that women are responsible for all things children and that they should just suck it up if they had a child with someone who chooses not to pay. There is no come back for the non-paying father: he is never shunned by his family, friends, colleagues or society as a whole.

Countdownis35 · 19/04/2022 19:43

@OnlyTheBravest

Actually, I think we should be questioning why a person is parenting as a singleton and why the other parent is not contributing. I wondered why this had happened in her case as you can not assume that she had a partner previously, some women use IVF, others for various reasons choose not to inform the father. There is a negative impact for the children concerned. In this case the oldest child was pretending not to be hungry, you could see it on her face. If the CMS service is not hunting down those responsible that is something should be dealt with immediately, considering the cost of living is increasing. Maintenance can be collected directly from salaries protecting those from violent partners and non payers. It should not be OK that someone can start a family and then walk away with little responsibility. A few posts suggested that she should increase her hours but with high childcare costs, this may not be viable. However, if she was getting the correct maintenance that could go some way to improve the living standards for the children. Maybe if more absent parents contributed to their children upkeep then additional funds could be redirected to those who have lost partners through bereavement or domestic violence. We need to change the mindset that is all on one person.

The more I think about it the more this programme irritates me. Far too many details were assumed. Playing on emotions instead of facts will not solve anything.

Honestly I haven't even read the end of your long post. There are many single mothers in todays generation. CMS payments don't cover the cost of raising 1 DC never mind 3 so good luck with that one right there!!

There's no law in UK forcing a parent to do their parental responsibility even the court process is shabby I've done it...

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 19/04/2022 19:31

@OnlyTheBravest

Actually, I think we should be questioning why a person is parenting as a singleton and why the other parent is not contributing. I wondered why this had happened in her case as you can not assume that she had a partner previously, some women use IVF, others for various reasons choose not to inform the father. There is a negative impact for the children concerned. In this case the oldest child was pretending not to be hungry, you could see it on her face. If the CMS service is not hunting down those responsible that is something should be dealt with immediately, considering the cost of living is increasing. Maintenance can be collected directly from salaries protecting those from violent partners and non payers. It should not be OK that someone can start a family and then walk away with little responsibility. A few posts suggested that she should increase her hours but with high childcare costs, this may not be viable. However, if she was getting the correct maintenance that could go some way to improve the living standards for the children. Maybe if more absent parents contributed to their children upkeep then additional funds could be redirected to those who have lost partners through bereavement or domestic violence. We need to change the mindset that is all on one person.

The more I think about it the more this programme irritates me. Far too many details were assumed. Playing on emotions instead of facts will not solve anything.

I think the general idea is-single parenthood for whatever reason puts the parent under significant financial pressure plus all the other factors involved in parenting are not shared. The others were all in jobs that I would deem as lifestyle choices.
OnlyTheBravest · 19/04/2022 18:31

Actually, I think we should be questioning why a person is parenting as a singleton and why the other parent is not contributing. I wondered why this had happened in her case as you can not assume that she had a partner previously, some women use IVF, others for various reasons choose not to inform the father. There is a negative impact for the children concerned. In this case the oldest child was pretending not to be hungry, you could see it on her face. If the CMS service is not hunting down those responsible that is something should be dealt with immediately, considering the cost of living is increasing. Maintenance can be collected directly from salaries protecting those from violent partners and non payers. It should not be OK that someone can start a family and then walk away with little responsibility. A few posts suggested that she should increase her hours but with high childcare costs, this may not be viable. However, if she was getting the correct maintenance that could go some way to improve the living standards for the children. Maybe if more absent parents contributed to their children upkeep then additional funds could be redirected to those who have lost partners through bereavement or domestic violence. We need to change the mindset that is all on one person.

The more I think about it the more this programme irritates me. Far too many details were assumed. Playing on emotions instead of facts will not solve anything.

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 19/04/2022 15:33

@howtomoveforwards

I would liked to have heard more about how the nurse ended up as a single parent. I totally understand why she was part time but was she pursuing a claim for child support? What were the other bills she was paying It was too vague. It could have led to a nice piece about the CMS and is it fit for purpose

How someone ends up single is neither here nor there if the result of being single is that they are plunged into poverty. It's not OK to say 'tough, you can starve' just because you left a perfectly decent man you had grown apart from anymore than it is to say 'you married him, why didn't you ask him before you married whether or not he would support his children 15 years later?' We are a rich country, no one should be choosing between heating and eating.

As for 'was she pursing a claim for child support?', there are lots of reasons why people don't. Fear and retaliation is the main one. For me, I pursued a claim for around 7 years and the CSA did nothing whatsoever for me. By the time the CSA morphed into the CMS and I had to open a new claim I had frankly lost the will with it. Chasing the CSA is, frankly, a full time job. It is stressful and upsetting and you rarely get anything other than frustrated. It has been far better for my mental health to take the £0 assessment of a working father and get on with doing my absolute best for my children myself than to phone up on a regular basis to be told nothing further had happened and nor was it likely to. Oh, and that's before I mention the £thousands that were written off because they couldn't get it from him. That's an absolute scandal.

I agree, however, it would be good to highlight the failings of the CMS but frankly, no one with any power (read: men) give one about those caring for children (read: women) single-handedly.

It really shouldn't be the case that we question why a working single parent might be struggling. It's very obvious, maintenance or no maintenance. One salary vs. two salaries, one person dealing with childcare vs. two people dealing with childcare, one person dealing with illness/appointments vs. two people dealing with illness/appointments is enough for anyone with half a brain to see that bigger picture. Simply put, we can't make people responsibly parent unless we have a massive, enormous change in how we view single parents (women). And that's not going to happen, is it? Way too much invested in the patriarchy weighted down by a good dose of misogyny.

Your last paragraph was perfect, the conclusion was illogical.
howtomoveforwards · 19/04/2022 14:47

I would liked to have heard more about how the nurse ended up as a single parent. I totally understand why she was part time but was she pursuing a claim for child support? What were the other bills she was paying It was too vague. It could have led to a nice piece about the CMS and is it fit for purpose

How someone ends up single is neither here nor there if the result of being single is that they are plunged into poverty. It's not OK to say 'tough, you can starve' just because you left a perfectly decent man you had grown apart from anymore than it is to say 'you married him, why didn't you ask him before you married whether or not he would support his children 15 years later?' We are a rich country, no one should be choosing between heating and eating.

As for 'was she pursing a claim for child support?', there are lots of reasons why people don't. Fear and retaliation is the main one. For me, I pursued a claim for around 7 years and the CSA did nothing whatsoever for me. By the time the CSA morphed into the CMS and I had to open a new claim I had frankly lost the will with it. Chasing the CSA is, frankly, a full time job. It is stressful and upsetting and you rarely get anything other than frustrated. It has been far better for my mental health to take the £0 assessment of a working father and get on with doing my absolute best for my children myself than to phone up on a regular basis to be told nothing further had happened and nor was it likely to. Oh, and that's before I mention the £thousands that were written off because they couldn't get it from him. That's an absolute scandal.

I agree, however, it would be good to highlight the failings of the CMS but frankly, no one with any power (read: men) give one about those caring for children (read: women) single-handedly.

It really shouldn't be the case that we question why a working single parent might be struggling. It's very obvious, maintenance or no maintenance. One salary vs. two salaries, one person dealing with childcare vs. two people dealing with childcare, one person dealing with illness/appointments vs. two people dealing with illness/appointments is enough for anyone with half a brain to see that bigger picture. Simply put, we can't make people responsibly parent unless we have a massive, enormous change in how we view single parents (women). And that's not going to happen, is it? Way too much invested in the patriarchy weighted down by a good dose of misogyny.

Keepitonthedownlow · 19/04/2022 13:32

@Angelswithflirtyfaces

Still a lot of petty wrangling and condemning of vulnerable people. I have added a screenshot from the book Nickled and Dimed its from the 90s its based in America but the universal truths are the same today. This book opened my eyes to the poverty traps people find themselves in despite hard work. I think we have reached this point and its easy for people to dismiss them as they would a homeless beggar.
I've not read The Ragged Trouser Philanthropist but it sounds similar in thrust
Angelswithflirtyfaces · 17/04/2022 21:06

Still a lot of petty wrangling and condemning of vulnerable people. I have added a screenshot from the book Nickled and Dimed its from the 90s its based in America but the universal truths are the same today.
This book opened my eyes to the poverty traps people find themselves in despite hard work.
I think we have reached this point and its easy for people to dismiss them as they would a homeless beggar.

Panorama( Young families Struggling)
OnlyTheBravest · 17/04/2022 11:11

I just watched the documentary. Unfortunately, they took a real life problem but used poor examples to make/back up their points. Instead of making it factual, they make it emotive and I think this is why people are raising questions.

You would need to see the full financial breakdowns for each family, not drip feed. It might have been better if they focused on two stories and really explored all the issues effecting each family. The family with the 75 mile commute and loss making shop could have been left out. The main issue there was poor business planning.

I would liked to have heard more about how the nurse ended up as a single parent. I totally understand why she was part time but was she pursuing a claim for child support? What were the other bills she was paying It was too vague. It could have led to a nice piece about the CMS and is it fit for purpose.

The other family with the lady who worked at the art gallery and the 3 young children could have led to a nice piece about the rising cost of childcare and unaffordable rents, which require both parents to be in employment.

I do think there is something fundamentally wrong with how the country is being run and people not being able to cope with the rising energy prices is a consequence of this. It has been building for years and lockdown/Brexit has accelerated the decrease in living standards. In my opinion, measures to reduce fuel poverty is just sticking a band aid on it. Focusing on fuel rises is detracting away from the real issues.

BoredZelda · 17/04/2022 01:17

A fifth of working age adults are economically inactive

Wrong. 20% of those between 16 and 65 are economically inactive. 27% of those are students. 22% of those are stay at home parents or full time unpaid caters. 13% have taken early retirement.

Only 12% said there was some other reason for their economic inactivity.

and we have the highest disability rates on the planet

No we don’t. Our levels of disability are around the world average of around 15%. And almost half of our disabled population are of pension age. Of the working age disabled people, half of them are in employment. Disabled people make up 26% of the 1/5th you cited.

Blossomtoes · 16/04/2022 20:21

That letter’s very powerful @DesidaCrick. Believe it or not, someone came up with this gem yesterday “Food banks get used because they are there to be used”.

Giraffesandbottoms · 16/04/2022 19:45

@JustAnotherPoster00

I’m very happy for you or anyone else to
Explain to me. I’m really interested in what,
Specifically, people want the govt to do. There’s no need to be rude.

JustAnotherPoster00 · 16/04/2022 19:17

coffers are pretty empty

I take it you dont understand economics

DesidaCrick · 16/04/2022 19:16

@BoredZelda

I haven’t seen this documentary but I watched a news report about a woman struggling to provide for her child because of the rising costs. What struck me was, I could help her, but there are so few options available. I donate to food banks, but that’s not really enough for families like hers. I’d happily pay more tax, but the government won’t use it to help those families.

It shouldn’t be up to charities to support people who the government is failing, but given the current situation more needs to be done. I know people feel too proud to accept charity, but in some ways, it’s no different to me paying more tax to support people who are struggling, it just means the money doesn’t get wasted by government. Does anyone know of any charities which provide this kind of support. I’ve googled for my local area but all that comes up are food banks.

We need to write to our MPs. Like this letter from hundreds of food banks to the government…

www.foodaidnetwork.org.uk/letter-april22

Giraffesandbottoms · 16/04/2022 19:13

A fifth of working age adults are economically inactive and we have the highest disability rates on the planet

This is extremely bad if true. I’m geniunely not sure how much people think the govt can do - they’ve just had to support everyone financially as best they can through a once in a lifetime crisis (COVID) and the coffers are pretty empty.

I agree forcing fathers to pay maintenance is a start, as would looking at the NHS wastage. I don’t think that just giving out more money is the answer. Help with childcare costs would be great though.