Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

if you think windmills are ugly what do you think of pylons?

92 replies

12yearsinazkaban · 12/04/2022 09:11

Or solar panels?

We have ugly looking lampposts on every street. not as big but just as ugly. Big massive triangular towers that buzz in the rain? they are everywhere. some in people's back bloody gardens, not to mention the big boxed off electric areas that have the electric will kill you warning sign.
Cities are full of them, every other road has one so why no wind Mills?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Momijin · 13/04/2022 16:58

I think they look great!

junglejane66 · 13/04/2022 16:27

[quote MiddleOfThePack]@junglejane66 - assume with clogs on?[/quote]
Well I declare

Boood · 13/04/2022 14:56

Especially when they are on big, bleak expanses of moorland where everything is on a grand scale, I think wind turbines look majestic. They enhance the landscape rather than detract from it. It would be different if they were plonked in smaller-scale, streams and flowers and woodland-type environments, but I don’t think that happens.

toomanytwinkies · 13/04/2022 14:47

Ah yes that’s the proper word - wind turbines! I knew windmills didn’t sound right but couldn’t work out why.

toomanytwinkies · 13/04/2022 14:46

I think windmills (the new type not the traditional Dutch type) look so futuristic! It’s almost like they belong in a film set in the year 2100! I personally love them and think pylons are awful dated metal monstrosities- why they can’t make new modern looking pylons I’ll never know.

Whatwillbewilbe · 13/04/2022 14:45

I love wind turbines and I think they’re beautiful. I could spend hours watching them working, it’s so relaxing. Pylons don’t bother me at all, I barely notice them.

Lemonyfuckit · 13/04/2022 14:30

@Dilbertian

They're less of a blot of the landscape than power stations!
Exactly!
Lemonyfuckit · 13/04/2022 14:29

I think they're rather elegant actually, and certainly nicer looking than a coal powered power plant belching out smoke. So no issues at all with more wind turbines being built, whether on or off shore (and I say that as someone who does live pretty near to some).

Alphabet1spaghetti2 · 13/04/2022 14:27

@etulosba

Ooo he’s rather grand!

etulosba · 13/04/2022 10:47

Why can’t the lines go underground like in France?!

There isn’t such an urgent need because UK pylons don’t frighten children, unlike the ones in France.

if you think windmills are ugly what do you think of pylons?
VestaTilley · 13/04/2022 10:33

SO MUCH THIS!!

I have such a bee in my bonnet about pylons! I loathe them. They look bloody awful, ruin the view and the landscape. Why can’t the lines go underground like in France?!

The reason nobody minds them now is because people are used to them - but they look shit!

I don’t mind wind farms but don’t like to see solar farms, though I accept it as a necessary thing, solar panels on roofs I think are fine, though ideally at the back of houses. But pylons are the worst!!

IcedOatLatte · 13/04/2022 10:25

@etulosba

I'm guessing by windmill you mean wind turbine. Do you mean pylons when you talk about triangular lamp posts??

I don’t think there is any need to be precious about the term windmill when referring to a wind powered electrical generator.

People are generally happy to refer to the structures shown in the picture as windmills, despite the fact that they are actually drainage pumps, not mills at all.

That's interesting as before reading this thread I don't think I've ever seen or heard of wind turbines referred to as windmills. Maybe it's an age thing but does anyone's mind conjure up a picture of a wind turbine when they hear the word windmill?
Giggorata · 13/04/2022 10:18

Didn't they have a previous competition for new pylon designs about 20 years ago? I don't know what happened about bringing in the new designs. One of them was a super tall fake pine tree… which might have looked OK, or might have been really annoying, not sure.

I don't mind the ink pen drawing-like old design pylons we have now, marching across the land, but maybe I’m just used to them.

Wind turbines are OK, but they really shouldn't put them in beauty spots.

Solar farms are a great idea and apparently there are thriving ecosystems on the ground between the panels. It's not that much of a stretch to have slightly larger gaps and let wild flowers flourish, maybe with hives?

etulosba · 13/04/2022 10:09

I'm guessing by windmill you mean wind turbine. Do you mean pylons when you talk about triangular lamp posts??

I don’t think there is any need to be precious about the term windmill when referring to a wind powered electrical generator.

People are generally happy to refer to the structures shown in the picture as windmills, despite the fact that they are actually drainage pumps, not mills at all.

if you think windmills are ugly what do you think of pylons?
jcyclops · 12/04/2022 21:43

I don't mind pylons or wind turbines.

Several areas on the outskirts of my town have pylons heading in to substations before the supply goes underground in the town. Nearly every line of pylons has parks/recreation grounds underneath. I am certain that the parks/recs are safe from house builders due to the pylons. Parents taking kids to play in away football matches who are not totally sure of where the venue is just head for the pylons!

MiddleOfThePack · 12/04/2022 19:24

@junglejane66 - assume with clogs on?

WildRosie · 12/04/2022 18:14

Pylons aren't pretty but they have a kind of majesty about them. Standing tall, out in the open in all weathers, bringing us our electricity. That's quite cool. I don't have an opinion on wind turbines.

Zazdar · 12/04/2022 18:07

zazdar - here you go!

Oooh, thanks!

Alphabet1spaghetti2 · 12/04/2022 18:04

@junglejane66

Wind generators look ok. But I like the brutalist v fragility aspect of pylons. They last a lot longer than wind generators too. So could be argued to be more beneficial environmentally. (?)
Windy is fine! Is the whomp whomp whomp of the blades that’s damn annoying. Perpetual headache. Don’t even benefit from cheaper electric or any of the village subsidies that are supposed to be paid - our local wind farm is around 6 years behind in payments. God alone knows if we will ever see anything from the new solar panel farm (right eyesore) that’s going in.
When a wind generator fails due to structural or has to stop due to too much or too little wind, you begin to wonder if you get the returns we were ‘sold’ them on.

worriedatthistime · 12/04/2022 18:01

None of them look great
all about where there put but im guessing you need a lot less pylons than windmills and solar

CentrifugalBumblePuppy · 12/04/2022 17:26

Pylons are magnificent (but I love them, great iron giants striding across the landscape).

Obviously that’s a very personal view, but the cost of digging up vast tracts of land to bury high voltage cables (and cost to dig them up to find faults) would increase energy bills exponentially.

The new design pylons aren’t my cup of tea, but any pylon is a necessary evil. They’ll grow on me I’m sure.

I’m a big advocate of green energy, so turbines are, again, a beautiful thing (I live near many). Unfortunately, there is concern for bird life due to habitat loss, collisions & migration disruption if sited on migratory or near breeding sites. However, as the greatest threat to wild life is climate change, building more wind farms would be a vital piece in our nationwide energy strategy.

The real green winner would be nuclear, specifically smaller local reactors which can be made production-line style (fully capable by our current submarine contract Rolls Royce), unlike our ‘bespoke, made to measure, every one is different’ current stock, or larger, higher output reactors replacing our existing reactors at Hinckley Point, Sizewell etc. A possible solution would be thorium salt reactors where high level waste is burnt up as part of usual reactor operation, lowering the dangerous, high level waste that persists for hundreds, if not 10s of thousands of years (plutonium 239, I’m looking at you). Or the CANDU Canadian reactors that can be refuelled online saving downtime.

I’ll be honest, the government’s announcement to start building the C reactors last week took me by surprise (I wouldn’t wee on this lot if they were on fire normally, utter bastards).

Shame it’s 15 years later than they were meant to start breaking ground…

Would I live next to a reactor? Absolutely. We need to disengage the relationship between nuclear power = nuclear bombs. Yes, some of the current reactor fleet were designed to produce plutonium for our nuclear arsenal (Windscale and Calder Hall for example produced the first fissile material, now decommissioned at what is now Sellafield). With a thorium reactor, there is no thermonuclear bomb making stuff left at the end of the fuel’s lifetime - it’s been used to generate electricity!

Nuclear power good, nuclear bombs bad.

Chernobyl happened when I was 13. Parents not allowing us out in the rain when the cloud might be coming over. Panic on the TV. Reports of swathes of land contaminated & not eating English lamb because of strontium 90 & cobalt 60 contamination.

But Chernobyl happened due to political pressure - fear if the test wasn’t performed they’d lost their status in the Party - and a flaw in reactor design (the graphite tipped control rods). The exponential rise in power in a reactor of the same type had happened at Ignelina. Politics & not disseminating this information to other RBMK operators played a sizeable roll in the catastrophe at Chernobyl.

We don’t use RBMK reactors in the UK!

I’m a bit of a nuke nerd these days, but I come from a position of having radiophobia (like, can’t leave the house, all terrifying anxiety, proper panic attack level phobia) to, through a 20 year journey of learning, studying & now advocating for nuclear energy.

It’s a zero CO2 producing technology. There is CO2 produced in uranium mining & fuel manufacture (less so with thorium, monazite sands can be harvested from beaches - environmentally sensitively of course), but so too is mining for rare earth elements to build the technology inside wind turbines or solar panels.

Blimey, that was a bit epic, even for me.

TL;DR pylons & windmills = necessary evil, nuke power good, nuke bombs bad, thorium & CANDU reactors are the dog’s danglies.

ConsuelaHammock · 12/04/2022 17:22

We have a wind turbine on our farm. There is definitely a faint flicker sound from it so I can understand why people wouldn’t want to live close to one.

palmplantcirca1980s · 12/04/2022 17:18

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Ponderingwindow · 12/04/2022 17:13

Much prettier than pylons and wires.

Concerns about noise pollution should definitely be considered when placing. I’ve only ever seen them in extremely isolated areas

junglejane66 · 12/04/2022 17:11

@Alphabet1spaghetti2

I love pylons. Happy to live next door to them. Wind generators are horrible to live by - been their and got the t shirt.
I dont blame you, I hate to live near a wind generator as well,, must be v windy