Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Electric cars - so worried

488 replies

Northernlurker · 11/04/2022 18:28

I keep worrying about being forced to buy an electric car when I change my car in a few years.
Reason being the long journeys and (mostly) self catering we love. In Scotland.
We need a range around 50% higher than the current max. It's no good saying charge it on the way if there are no fast chargers. Been looking at details today, even the fastest chargers need just over 30 minutes. Thousands of people drive UJ the Highlands and Islands annually. There won't be anything like enough chargers to cover that. We can charge overnight using an ordinary plug but it's not going to hit the max. Feel like we will spend the whole time worrying about finding a free charger in the middle of nowhere.
How is this ever going to work? It takes two Minutes to fill up a tank with petrol, electric is going to take hours!

OP posts:
Ifailed · 12/04/2022 11:29

There are 8,400 petrol stations in the UK, lets say with an average 20 pumps, so 168,000 petrol 'charging' points.
Average time to fill up with petrol is 5 mins, compared with 30 mins to 'top up' an EV, so it takes 6 times longer. That means we will need 1 million fast charging points to replace PFS.

There are currently 5,400 rapid charging points in the UK, so we need a further 994,600. Each charging point is roughly 8 m2, so this will take up around 2000 acres of land. Hands up who want one built next to their house?

MrOllivander · 12/04/2022 11:28

@lameasahorse

I think the 78% is lower as well. It is a dedicated parking space. My brother has this, it is not next to the house.
Same. I have a parking space. There's no room to fit anything. On the left of me is a garden, on the right is a garden and a fence in front of me. None of it belongs to me except the parking space
Infinitemoon · 12/04/2022 11:24

Sorry I meant ^^ for the previous post.

I don't believe EV are the future. I think we need to stop using cars altogether if possible and have excellent public transport systems put in place. I think people should start working locally etc. The use of cars for personal use needs to be phased out - and I love my car.

We need to completely rethink our transport system. For people to say we cannot be inventive just because we don't believe EV are the future is ludicrous quite frankly!

user1497207191 · 12/04/2022 11:23

@lameasahorse

I have lived through so many technological changes that did not live up to the hype or brought new problems. Maybe you are just too young and inexperienced and so trust the vision being given.
Well said. It's just life experience!
WTF475878237NC · 12/04/2022 11:22

I've even wondered if there's some emotional reason for this. Maybe people are evolved to imagine bad things, because they need to avoid them, but imagining neutral/good things, well there's no need for the brain to wear itself out thinking about things that aren't a danger.

^ from an evolutionary perspective there is no survival advantage to positive thinking although there certainly is for problem solving (being favoured by and therefore offered status in the group, but also the intrinsic value of being able to find solutions).

There is also a lot of evidence that people with certain adverse life events are more likely to just get stuck on potential issues in their mind and cannot move past them without help/support. Parts of the brain that respond to threat and emotion are over activated in these people This is where hopefully Mumsnet comes in to help people see the other perspectives.

Infinitemoon · 12/04/2022 11:19

^^ Exactly

BottleBrushTree · 12/04/2022 11:18

People probably felt this way when cars started to replace the horse and cart. How will you find fuel? What if the road is shite? What if you break down?

I really don’t think you need to worry about something that has not yet happened and won’t happen for a few years. Maybe think about sustainability and what will happen to the world your children will inherit if people aren’t “forced” to buy electric cars and the giant shite show of changing temperatures and weather patterns, that’s something way more worthy to stress about.

lameasahorse · 12/04/2022 11:16

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Getoff · 12/04/2022 11:08

Also, I think people just don't like change so will find all sorts of issues to avoid changing the way they have to do things.

Yes, I think resistance to the idea of change has been a huge thing on some of the threads I have in mind. Someone poses an idea of one thing that could be different, and poster after poster will respond giving reasons why it can't happen. Even though it would only take one second and one imaginative step for them to demolish their own objection, they appear to dislike the OP proposition, and simply post the first issue with it that comes into their head, their thinking stops there.

Getoff · 12/04/2022 11:00

i think this is the difference between successful entrepreneurs and inventors and regular folk. Some people just aren't wired to be able think abstract or distant concepts through to solution (even unrealistic ones).

I've seen over and over, just perusing mumsnet. People worrying about some future "problem", yet somehow unable to imagine the (to me) blindingly obvious other future changes that make the problem a non-issue.

In the past I've thought it's because some peoples only ever think one step past reality. People care about cars, they therefore bother to imagine electric cars increasing in number, but it's too much to ask them to go to step two and imagine everything needed to facilitate electric cars increasing at about the same rate.

I've even wondered if there's some emotional reason for this. Maybe people are evolved to imagine bad things, because they need to avoid them, but imagining neutral/good things, well there's no need for the brain to wear itself out thinking about things that aren't a danger.

user1497207191 · 12/04/2022 10:58

And hybrids aren't being banned (under current rules), so people will still need petrol for their hybrids, especially the non plug in ones!

user1497207191 · 12/04/2022 10:57

@etulosba

and are planning to replace one next year and the other in about 5 years time, both will be petrol, so that should see us right throughout the 2030's

Petrol will become harder and harder to find as petrol vehicles become less common. Diesel is likely to be more widely available for longer as the switch to suitable alternative fuels for heavy vehicles and plant poses more of a challenge.

Yes, but not within relatively short timescales. Modern cars can easily last 20 years so petrol stations will still be common until the mid to late 30s. I'd suggest it will be well into the 40s before people start finding it hard to fill up with petrol.
user1497207191 · 12/04/2022 10:54

What is is about people that enables them to imagine future problems, but not future solutions?

It's called life experience!

etulosba · 12/04/2022 10:53

and are planning to replace one next year and the other in about 5 years time, both will be petrol, so that should see us right throughout the 2030's

Petrol will become harder and harder to find as petrol vehicles become less common. Diesel is likely to be more widely available for longer as the switch to suitable alternative fuels for heavy vehicles and plant poses more of a challenge.

Lunar27 · 12/04/2022 10:43

^ i think this is the difference between successful entrepreneurs and inventors and regular folk. Some people just aren't wired to be able think abstract or distant concepts through to solution (even unrealistic ones).

Also, I think people just don't like change so will find all sorts of issues to avoid changing the way they have to do things.

In my 3 years of ownership, I can honestly count on one hand the number of genuinely reasonable reasons for why an EV wouldn't work for them. Mostly it's hysteria (the OP is a classic example).

WTF475878237NC · 12/04/2022 10:37

What is is about people that enables them to imagine future problems, but not future solutions?

^ i think this is the difference between successful entrepreneurs and inventors and regular folk. Some people just aren't wired to be able think abstract or distant concepts through to solution (even unrealistic ones).

Getoff · 12/04/2022 10:32

@Northernlurker

Saying it's fine on long journeys NOW isn't actually the point either. Yes you can plan your charger use because the number of cars is still low and the number of chargers rising slowly. But if 80% of the cars at the services want the charging points it will become much less fine. Unless there are a huge number of points - and the slowness if rollout of broadband and mobile reach in remote areas says that bit of infrastructure will not keep pace!
What is is about people that enables them to imagine future problems, but not future solutions?

Specifically, why do you imagine the number of car charging points will be less than is needed so no-one ever needs to wait longer than they currently do for a petrol pump?

The only thing stopping every car space in every car park in the country also being a fast charging point is that we don't actually need that many charging points, so the cost wouldn't be justified. There will be as many charging points as will get regular use, because that's how economics works.

I'm not saying there will never be an issue: just that it will be as rare an issue as finding petrol. (Believe it or not, from experience I can tell you that getting petrol is an issue I've encountered in central London. The Park Lane station was my emergency option on more than one occasion.)

user1497207191 · 12/04/2022 10:26

@Infinitemoon

Infrastructure is improving all the time. I wouldn't consider buying a new petrol only car now, we're looking at hybrid minimum but probably full electric.

I wouldn't buy an electric car yet and am sticking to petrol. This is from the advice of numerous people a few of which have had a lot of trouble charging as reps all over the country. Unless you have the cash for a Tesla...

We buy new and keep our cars for 10-15 years (one lasted to 19), and are planning to replace one next year and the other in about 5 years time, both will be petrol, so that should see us right throughout the 2030's. We're not worried about the roll out of EVs and will just review the situation in the mid 30s as to whether we replace them or just keep them until they fall apart!
Infinitemoon · 12/04/2022 10:20

Infrastructure is improving all the time. I wouldn't consider buying a new petrol only car now, we're looking at hybrid minimum but probably full electric.

I wouldn't buy an electric car yet and am sticking to petrol. This is from the advice of numerous people a few of which have had a lot of trouble charging as reps all over the country. Unless you have the cash for a Tesla...

yellowsuninthesky · 12/04/2022 10:11

@Boxowine

I'm so tired of people saying that it's not a big deal to run charging cables across the pavement to their car. Of course it's a big deal for people who are jogging, pushing babies, in wheelchairs, etc.
It's much less of a deal than parking on pavements is and people seem to have no concerns about that.

I can't really see what the issue is for "joggers" - I run myself and can see if there's something on the pavement - even at night. I don't disagree that it could be an issue for wheelchair users and other people with reduced mobility though.

Lunar27 · 12/04/2022 10:06

@WimpyKidYouNot

Engineers and scientists have already found ways to work without lithium. As ever, people typically find the path of least resistance to arrive at a product/solution but when things don't work (or are found to be limited) they find an alternative. That what is engineers do.

EV is a great, albeit slightly flawed, solution because electricity is everywhere and we already have a network for distribution. So no more tankers using fuel to deliver fuel.

Now that there's already been huge investment into battery technology, it's going to take something really special to shift the trajectory. I don't think hydrogen is it and neither do manufacturers, who are already phasing out the ICE and adopting EV wholesale.

user1497207191 · 12/04/2022 10:04

Another aspect is that "charging" parking spaces are larger, so places like motorway service stations will end up with car parks with fewer parking spaces.

FloBot7 · 12/04/2022 09:56

[quote lameasahorse]@Lunar27 there are only 20 locations. I have no idea of the amount of chargers as they all list a wide variety of type of chargers.
www.zap-map.com/locations/nottingham-charging-points/[/quote]
Over 120 charging points by the look of it (but I did give up counting). The majority of public points are universal. We went to a retail park at the weekend and the charging points were being used by lots of different cars from a Porsche to a Fiat 500.

CapMarvel · 12/04/2022 09:41

@MrsSkylerWhite

Hydrogen will be a game changer. Five years, tops.
Not a chance.

Hydrogen has a place but you still have the fundamental problem that producing and transporting hydrogen is nowhere near as sustainable and convenient as simply plugging a car into the grid, and there is no mainstream car manufacturer really buying into it in the same way as EVs. It's just not going to happen.

raspberrymuffin · 12/04/2022 09:06

*@TalbotAMan lameasahorse

"Maybe people who live in homes without off-road parking won't be able to own cars."
Bloody hell.

Why does their incovenience give them the right to pollute the environment for the rest of us? *

It wouldn't be inconvenience when I had no way to transport my husband to his radiotherapy sessions 30 miles away from our very small town where the very infrequent buses go in the wrong direction and are unaffordable on a daily basis. By the end of 5 weeks of daily treatment he definitely would not have been fit to do what would amount to a 2 hour journey each way on a bus, a train and then another bus, and we'd have been at breaking point financially at about £20-25 a day in fares. He wouldn't be inconvenienced, he'd be dead.

"Just move house," I hear you say. I would guesstimate about a third of the homes in my very small town have no offroad parking and nowhere to create any. That's quite a lot of people you're asking to move (which they can't afford to do since no one will buy our homes if they aren't allowed cars) or give up any chance of a normal life. And what of the carbon footprint of all these empty buildings?

As it happens I think that before we take away my only practical means of transport, maybe the rest of you could stop the intercontinental holiday flights and the meat eating. And perhaps you could agree to pay a little bit more tax so that we could just install a sensible number of public chargers, rather than destroying entire communities to save you having to think about any consequences of what you're proposing.