Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Electric cars - so worried

488 replies

Northernlurker · 11/04/2022 18:28

I keep worrying about being forced to buy an electric car when I change my car in a few years.
Reason being the long journeys and (mostly) self catering we love. In Scotland.
We need a range around 50% higher than the current max. It's no good saying charge it on the way if there are no fast chargers. Been looking at details today, even the fastest chargers need just over 30 minutes. Thousands of people drive UJ the Highlands and Islands annually. There won't be anything like enough chargers to cover that. We can charge overnight using an ordinary plug but it's not going to hit the max. Feel like we will spend the whole time worrying about finding a free charger in the middle of nowhere.
How is this ever going to work? It takes two Minutes to fill up a tank with petrol, electric is going to take hours!

OP posts:
PermanentTemporary · 13/04/2022 08:46

Just to make the obvious point as well that as numbers switch over so the majority of vehicles on the road are EV, it is drivers of ICE who will start to experience 'range anxiety' because liquid fuel outlets will get less common. That might be quite a difficult patch in fact.

User843976 · 13/04/2022 08:20

Probably most people that use them will do very few miles and have a drive so it will get to the numbers required to have them, without using the chargers much, I only fill my petrol car about every 6 months so would not need to use a public charger for an ev

FirewomanSam · 13/04/2022 08:02

Shock horror but we've seen just how ineffective the petrol station network is when too many people try and panic buy fuel. It definitely didn't take 5 minutes to fill a tank then. However most of the time, people just aren't buying fuel at the same time. What makes you think EV's will be any different? Clue. They won't.

EXACTLY. Thank you.

I’ve had this conversation so many times with relatives who just don’t seem to get this very simple point.

When we say most journeys are short so charging isn’t an issue, we don’t mean that you will never have to charge in public. We mean that most drivers will be doing the majority of charging at home, so the demand on the public charging network is far less than people seem to think it is. I’ve had my EV for six months and so far have used it for short trips around town and longer day trips that have still been in my car’s range. I’ve not needed to use a public charger at all yet - the only time I’ve used them has been a quick practice to try them out so that I’m prepared when I do actually need to use one.

So my EV has so far placed zero demand on the public charging network, and I know many many other EV drivers who are the same. So for people worrying that every single EV in the country might need to charge at the same time, in public: that’s just not a thing.

I’m not saying for a moment that the infrastructure is perfect, but in the six months I’ve had my car I can tell you of half a dozen new public charging points that have sprung up in my local area, which already had quite a few to begin with. I expect that will continue at the same pace. Meanwhile over the next decade I’m sure battery range will get longer and charging times will get faster, which will hopefully also help ease those concerns.

FirewomanSam · 12/04/2022 23:05

YABVU to be ‘so worried’ about how you will manage to take a hypothetical holiday in a car that you haven’t bought yet, and that nobody is going to make you buy, at some possible juncture in the next decade.

RagingRagingAndMoreRaging · 12/04/2022 22:46

Also, there are currently waiting lists to buy EV cars. This is known. There is money to be made. For example, we go to a specific restaurant on a regular journey we do, because it has a charging point (and it’s nice). They didn’t have to pay for it to be installed. The EV charging company did, who then make money charging the cars. The restaurant gets more business.

Lots of businesses will start to get them installed to attract customers as it’s such a growing market. You have a captive audience essentially, with 30 mins to kill. It’s a no brainer.

RagingRagingAndMoreRaging · 12/04/2022 22:39

We love our EV. It’s an old one with a lower range but we like that it forces us to take breaks on longer journeys. Charging really only takes the same time it usually would to have a coffee and nip to the loo.

There is a lovely community too - we talk to each other and help each other out when we can’t get the chargers to work.

I’m just one year of having it we have seen so many new charging points. It’s getting smoother and smoother to charge when out and about. Quicker too if you have a newer model.

The infrastructure isn’t quite right yet but once you get used to it, it’s great.

The acceleration- even on our small car - is amazing too!!

TalbotAMan · 12/04/2022 19:52

@Dreamstate

I'll be getting an elector car at the very last possible day I can. I love driving my manual car. Fuck automatic cars I hate them, no fun in driving. Lets also not forget to mine the lithium for these batteries is not environmentally friendly either considering how much energy is required to do so. Nor to mention having to dispose of them. So screw the rhetoric its better for the environment.
Have you ever considered how much energy is needed to drill for crude oil, transport it thousands of miles, refine it and transport the petrol and diesel around to local filling stations? (Clue: it's a lot.) And then it's burned and gone for good.

Once the lithium is out, it's out and it's infinitely recyclable (though I'll concede recycling does need further energy use),

Dreamstate · 12/04/2022 19:01

I'll be getting an elector car at the very last possible day I can. I love driving my manual car. Fuck automatic cars I hate them, no fun in driving. Lets also not forget to mine the lithium for these batteries is not environmentally friendly either considering how much energy is required to do so. Nor to mention having to dispose of them. So screw the rhetoric its better for the environment.

changingstages · 12/04/2022 18:55

I’m in a very small Highlands village right now and I can see two electric cars charging in the car park right now. Chill out.

TalbotAMan · 12/04/2022 18:52

[quote raspberrymuffin]*@TalbotAMan lameasahorse

"Maybe people who live in homes without off-road parking won't be able to own cars."
Bloody hell.

Why does their incovenience give them the right to pollute the environment for the rest of us? *

It wouldn't be inconvenience when I had no way to transport my husband to his radiotherapy sessions 30 miles away from our very small town where the very infrequent buses go in the wrong direction and are unaffordable on a daily basis. By the end of 5 weeks of daily treatment he definitely would not have been fit to do what would amount to a 2 hour journey each way on a bus, a train and then another bus, and we'd have been at breaking point financially at about £20-25 a day in fares. He wouldn't be inconvenienced, he'd be dead.

"Just move house," I hear you say. I would guesstimate about a third of the homes in my very small town have no offroad parking and nowhere to create any. That's quite a lot of people you're asking to move (which they can't afford to do since no one will buy our homes if they aren't allowed cars) or give up any chance of a normal life. And what of the carbon footprint of all these empty buildings?

As it happens I think that before we take away my only practical means of transport, maybe the rest of you could stop the intercontinental holiday flights and the meat eating. And perhaps you could agree to pay a little bit more tax so that we could just install a sensible number of public chargers, rather than destroying entire communities to save you having to think about any consequences of what you're proposing.[/quote]
Sorry for your husband.

As others have said, there need to be adaptive solutions. What if you hadn't had a car because you were unable to drive or unable to afford one? The system would have stepped in. Possibilities might be

Being taken into hospital as an inpatient
Being accommodated in a hotel or flat near the hospital, paid for by the NHS
Non-emergency ambulances taking him and others to and from the hospital every day
Taxis paid for or reimbursed by the NHS
Membership of a local car club

'Just move house' is a bit impractical and clearly a solution of last resort.

I have no problem with public chargers here, there and everywhere. The rapid ones are quite bulky, but the 7kw ones could, if we had the will, be fitted in every parking space in public and near public (supermarkets, shopping centres, many workplaces that have parking, rail stations and the like) - they are just like taller bollards with a couple of sockets at the top. 8 hours on one of those while you are at work will more than replenish what you used on your commute.

Your circumstances are unfortunate, but they are also fairly unusual. They're not a justification for allowing people to keep driving petrol and diesel cars. Those cars have to go, for the sake of the planet and of the local environment.

FloBot7 · 12/04/2022 18:31

@WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll

Sorry if that seemed uncaring or dismissive when referring to your Grandad as just one person - I worded it badly; but what I meant to say was that, although it's great that he is so capable in spite of his many challenges, not everybody will manage as well as he does.
Don't worry. It didn't sound uncaring or dismissive. In an ideal world it wouldn't be a hazard for blind people to be aware of but in reality there are hundreds of hazards they contend with everyday so it's not a good argument as far as councils or the government are concerned. I mentioned in a different message that I worked in personal injury. I've had successful claims against my local council for tripping injuries (not just a scuff but actual broken bones or the worst one, broken teeth and jaw) and walked past those same places months later to find the same hazard hadn't been fixed.

Not everyone will be willing to pay for chargers to be installed but the number who do will gradually increase. We're planning to move but have had an EV charger installed today. We can afford it and had booked it before realising a standard plug was enough. I don't expect it to be a selling point at this point in time but I do hope it makes the next owners look into EVs. I had debated getting a Renault Zoe a few years ago but didn't know you could plug it into a standard plug and didn't bother looking at installing a charger. With hindsight and having used my DH's Tesla to commute, I know the Zoe would have worked well. I thought I'd be regularly panicking about being stranded with no charge but realistically, even the smallest car can cope with my 26 mile commute. We also (now) know that we can easily run two electric cars on the one charger. Not something I would have believed until we got one.

Lunar27 · 12/04/2022 18:03

@Ifailed

Some seriously flawed maths there unfortunately.

I have a charger on the side of my house so rarely ever use the public network. Many millions of other drivers will be the same so the numbers you're quoting are innaccurate.

So long as you stay in range of your house? Flawed, possibly. However whilst you may be lucky enough to have the space to install a charger on the side of your house, many 'millions of other drivers' won't be able.

Add in all the vans, lorries etc which clearly can't be charged at the side of yours and others houses, and I still see a problem.

The government announced a target to install a smart meter in every house in 2016 by 2020, that's now slipped to 2025, and I expect will slip again.

I doubt very much if the current target to ban ICE engines by 2030/35 (pick a number) will be met, especially as the cost to install all these charging points will almost certainly be passed onto the consumer who are already reeling from higher energy prices, tax increases and the cost of food.

The next general election can take place no later than January 2025, There's no way that any political party will promising to force people into buying EV vehicles with only 5 years to go to the ban.

Sorry but this doesn't detract from your rather shonky maths, which attempted to account for every car on the road using public chargers (simultaneously too it would seem).

Again you've got some skewed logic there. What you're failing to appreciate is that millions of people can charge at home. It really is irrelevant that a lorry can't visit my house because they don't need to. The fact that millions of people won't need to visit a public charger means that the demand on the network is less. It's like me having a petrol pump at home and never having to occupy a space at the local petrol station i.e. it frees it up for people who do need it.

Shock horror but we've seen just how ineffective the petrol station network is when too many people try and panic buy fuel. It definitely didn't take 5 minutes to fill a tank then. However most of the time, people just aren't buying fuel at the same time. What makes you think EV's will be any different? Clue. They won't.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 12/04/2022 17:25

Sorry if that seemed uncaring or dismissive when referring to your Grandad as just one person - I worded it badly; but what I meant to say was that, although it's great that he is so capable in spite of his many challenges, not everybody will manage as well as he does.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 12/04/2022 17:23

My grandad is blind and has used a stick for about 30 years. He manages very well on uneven surfaces (the pavements in our town centre are a serious hazard) as he knows when the height is about to change, even a little. He has and will manage just fine with a cable on the road (not unusual around roadworks). Also, don't underestimate the number of helpful people in the world. People warn him about all sorts of hazards. The most frequent is when the traffic lights he's waiting at aren't working (drivers as well as pedestrians and workmen have stopped to tell him and help him cross). I assume guide dogs would see a cable as a hazard but I'm not really sure as I don't know anyone with one.

He's just one person, though. I'm not blind and I would be concerned about not seeing a trailing wire and tripping over it.

You make it sound like blind people should just 'not make a fuss' - like they don't already have enough challenges to deal with in life and should just put up with another big one on top of the rest.

There will not always be helpful people around, but even if there are, blind people should not be reduced to having to rely on the serendipity of others when walking down the road. Would you like to have your independence taken away by being told that you 'just need to hope that there's somebody around who will help you' when you previously managed just fine on your own?

I can't imagine getting to a point where councils actually suggest residents trail wires across the pavement. Far more likely to gradually increase charging points. Or perhaps we'll arrive at the stage where you can pay the council to install a roadside point that is powered by your house with buried wires, in a similar way to how you can pay for a dropped kerb and H bars.

I think you're probably right there, but I think the key phrase is 'you can pay the council'. Do you really think that everybody will be willing/able to do that and not just take the cheap way out? Plenty of people who have concreted over front gardens already don't bother (or can't afford) applying/paying for a dropped kerb. Some of them leave blocks of wood there permanently, which can be quite a hazard - but at least road users should all have sight to be able to avoid them. Never underestimate how many people there are out there who couldn't give a stuff about other people if they can save themselves some money.

People who rent, with landlords who don't pay for a proper charge point, also aren't going to want to pay for it themselves. Similarly, many people who are planning to sell up and move before long will not see the point in making an investment that they won't benefit from long-term.

Badbadbunny · 12/04/2022 16:36

@etulosba

Lots of things are "unnecessary" but people still buy them!

They will struggle if there are none to buy.

Where there is demand, there will be the supply!
mudgetastic · 12/04/2022 16:05

The ban is only for new car sales

There will be plenty of petrol cars around for decades after that

etulosba · 12/04/2022 15:52

Lots of things are "unnecessary" but people still buy them!

They will struggle if there are none to buy.

Ifailed · 12/04/2022 15:45

Some seriously flawed maths there unfortunately.

I have a charger on the side of my house so rarely ever use the public network. Many millions of other drivers will be the same so the numbers you're quoting are innaccurate.

So long as you stay in range of your house? Flawed, possibly. However whilst you may be lucky enough to have the space to install a charger on the side of your house, many 'millions of other drivers' won't be able.

Add in all the vans, lorries etc which clearly can't be charged at the side of yours and others houses, and I still see a problem.

The government announced a target to install a smart meter in every house in 2016 by 2020, that's now slipped to 2025, and I expect will slip again.

I doubt very much if the current target to ban ICE engines by 2030/35 (pick a number) will be met, especially as the cost to install all these charging points will almost certainly be passed onto the consumer who are already reeling from higher energy prices, tax increases and the cost of food.

The next general election can take place no later than January 2025, There's no way that any political party will promising to force people into buying EV vehicles with only 5 years to go to the ban.

user1497207191 · 12/04/2022 15:39

@etulosba

The sale of new ones will be banned. As the EV charging infrastructure improves, they will be largely unnecessary anyway.
Lots of things are "unnecessary" but people still buy them!
user1497207191 · 12/04/2022 15:39

@yellowsuninthesky

My hybrid is 2017 though so unlikely to still be in use by 2030 and certainly not by 2035.

Maybe not yours, but people will still be buying them up to 2034, so they'll be on the road throughout the 30's and 40's, the average life of a new car being 13 years.

etulosba · 12/04/2022 15:33

The sale of new ones will be banned. As the EV charging infrastructure improves, they will be largely unnecessary anyway.

FloBot7 · 12/04/2022 15:29

@etulosba

New ones or banned altogether and wiped off the face of the Earth?

I think you know the answer to that question already, don’t you?

No, that was a genuine question. I haven't looked into hybrids at all. I wondered if you were about to say that the government said they were great but now say they're worse than anything so they're going to be banned. 🤷🏻‍♀️
etulosba · 12/04/2022 15:24

New ones or banned altogether and wiped off the face of the Earth?

I think you know the answer to that question already, don’t you?

flaglady · 12/04/2022 15:22

@worriedatthistime

None of you have said yes you have looked up how we get all the components for the batteries and if these are in abundance and will last forever.
Sorry, I have. See my first post.
flaglady · 12/04/2022 15:20

I'm attending a work event where research projects are being presented. Some of just a few of the project titles "next generation batteries- beyond lithium ion", "hydrogen production from sea water for carbon free aviation", "design and manufacture of multi-layer coatings on heat exchangers to improve performance in waste to energy plants" and "carbon accounting in aerospace manufacturing supply chains". That's just a few from one university in a department that's focussed on engineering, not renewables or the environment. Most students are doing research that leans towards it because there's a demand for solutions. I'm going to go out on a limb and say it's not the only place where research like this is being carried out.