Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Electric cars - so worried

488 replies

Northernlurker · 11/04/2022 18:28

I keep worrying about being forced to buy an electric car when I change my car in a few years.
Reason being the long journeys and (mostly) self catering we love. In Scotland.
We need a range around 50% higher than the current max. It's no good saying charge it on the way if there are no fast chargers. Been looking at details today, even the fastest chargers need just over 30 minutes. Thousands of people drive UJ the Highlands and Islands annually. There won't be anything like enough chargers to cover that. We can charge overnight using an ordinary plug but it's not going to hit the max. Feel like we will spend the whole time worrying about finding a free charger in the middle of nowhere.
How is this ever going to work? It takes two Minutes to fill up a tank with petrol, electric is going to take hours!

OP posts:
lameasahorse · 13/04/2022 23:16

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

lameasahorse · 13/04/2022 23:12

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

CapMarvel · 13/04/2022 23:03

Once upon a time the "average" person couldn't afford a mobile phone and now everyone has them.

This is how it works and you only need to pay attention to the cars on the road that the number of EVs driving about is increasing rapidly.

user1497207191 · 13/04/2022 22:36

@DrWhoNowww

Clearly the people who don't see any of these don't regularly have working days that are already 12-14 hours long and include driving 4/500 miles, so they don't have the time to hang around service stations drinking coffee that they wouldn't otherwise have bought while they wait for the car to charge up

But these people are hardly your average daily user are they?

The U.K. average is 20 miles a day/140 miles a week. A battery with a 300 mile range is perfectly adequate for the vast majority of users.

But the “average” person can’t afford an electric car
DrWhoNowww · 13/04/2022 22:11

Clearly the people who don't see any of these don't regularly have working days that are already 12-14 hours long and include driving 4/500 miles, so they don't have the time to hang around service stations drinking coffee that they wouldn't otherwise have bought while they wait for the car to charge up

But these people are hardly your average daily user are they?

The U.K. average is 20 miles a day/140 miles a week. A battery with a 300 mile range is perfectly adequate for the vast majority of users.

TalbotAMan · 13/04/2022 21:09

Clearly the people who don't see any of these don't regularly have working days that are already 12-14 hours long and include driving 4/500 miles, so they don't have the time to hang around service stations drinking coffee that they wouldn't otherwise have bought while they wait for the car to charge up.

In The Future, that lifestyle may no longer be possible. Probably a good thing too.

lameasahorse · 13/04/2022 21:07

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

BarbaraofSeville · 13/04/2022 21:03

Electric cars are significantly more expensive than petrol/diesel equivalents. Which means that they are not affordable or to low to medium income people.

If you have some spare money, you might be able to justify the cost based on savings on petrol/diesel. But if you are paying for electricity from service station prices, it works out nearly as expensive as petrol, so little in the way of cost savings. So it's an expense that may not be justified on your budget.

And if you are driving more than the range of the car, which isn't very far, you will have to buy this £££s electricity, because you don't have the luxury of filling up at the supermarket and your car being good for 4/600 miles.

And that's before you get to the time it takes to charge, and finding the right charger/account and it being working, which doesn't seem like a given.

Clearly the people who don't see any of these don't regularly have working days that are already 12-14 hours long and include driving 4/500 miles, so they don't have the time to hang around service stations drinking coffee that they wouldn't otherwise have bought while they wait for the car to charge up.

Lunar27 · 13/04/2022 20:28

@etulosba

But please explain how lower income people will be driving a 'hugely expensive car' as you describe? Andy why would they 'forever' be spending time/money at service stations? Doesn't stack up TBH.

They may need to charge more often if they have bought an older EV.

Nissan estimated that battery capacity will be approximately 80% of original capacity after five years.

Sure, but an old Leaf isn't going to be 'hugely' expensive and if your range is limited to 50 miles, I doubt you'll be up and down the motorway pouring money into service stations. Is that what poor people usually do, spend all their time on motorways?
TalbotAMan · 13/04/2022 20:18

@BarbaraofSeville

stopping once on a 500 mile journey is hardly an inconvenience

It is if you've got to be there 40 minutes instead of the 10 that you have available.

That's if there's a charger available and you don't have to queue.

There's also the cost of charging at service stations, which isn't much far off that for petrol. Plus people seem to think you'll be buying food and drink while you're there.

So as well as having this hugely expensive car, you'll be forever spending time and money at service stations wiping out any savings you need to make to justify the higher purchase price.

Yet again Mumsnet completely misses the needs of lower income people.

You can, today, if you wish and are able, buy a Tesla Model 3 Rear Wheel Drive. It will cost you somewhere between £45,000 and £55,000, depending on the options you tick. In UK conditions it will have a range of around 250 miles from full,

Clearly poor (and quite a lot of not so poor) people can't afford that.

But, that car uses a different kind of battery. It's known as an LFP battery, for various reasons they are only currently made in China, which is where Tesla get them from, and they are a bit heavier than the LNCM type generally used in North America and Europe. They also don't use cobalt - that's the C in LNCM.

The yardstick for battery degradation is a fall to 80% of original capacity/range. Because electric cars are, overall, still quite new, the data is a bit limited, but the estimate for current LNC batteries is around 100,000 miles. The estimate for LFP ones is 200,000 to 500,000.

So in 10 years time, that car bought now will probably be good for 220 or more miles on each charge, but will be a 10-year-old secondhand car.

Soon, a lot of Chinese manufacturers you've never heard of will be selling cars in the UK. MG (which, despite the name, is now a Chinese company) already do. You can buy an MG ZS EV new from £29,000, but it's not clear which chemistry it uses. The Ora Good Cat is coming later this year in the same price range, and it uses LFP.

And in 10 years time the rich people will be buying cars with batteries that give a range of 800 miles and have a million mile life, and they'll be the 10 year old cars in 2042. Soon, people won't need to get a new battery for their car, they'll need a new car for their battery.

But as I said before, continuing to burn petrol and diesel is simply not an option, whether you're poor or rich, young or old etc etc. It has to stop.

etulosba · 13/04/2022 18:53

That depends if you're the only driver. If there's 2 of you, you can changeover and just spend 10 mins in the loo and a quick drink/snack.

That is us. A driver change takes barely five minutes.

etulosba · 13/04/2022 18:51

That was a worst case estimate though.

Badbadbunny · 13/04/2022 18:51

@LimitIsUp

Oops posted too soon - meant to say that if you are not prepared to stop for more than 10 minutes in a 500 mile journey this makes you a danger to yourself and other road users
That depends if you're the only driver. If there's 2 of you, you can changeover and just spend 10 mins in the loo and a quick drink/snack.
etulosba · 13/04/2022 18:50

But please explain how lower income people will be driving a 'hugely expensive car' as you describe? Andy why would they 'forever' be spending time/money at service stations? Doesn't stack up TBH.

They may need to charge more often if they have bought an older EV.

Nissan estimated that battery capacity will be approximately 80% of original capacity after five years.

CMZ2018 · 13/04/2022 18:50

You won’t be, it’s all an absolute load of bollocks. I’ll be sticking with my 4x4 pick up, we’re rural and I won’t be getting an electric car until they’re as convenient

LimitIsUp · 13/04/2022 18:41

Oops posted too soon - meant to say that if you are not prepared to stop for more than 10 minutes in a 500 mile journey this makes you a danger to yourself and other road users

LimitIsUp · 13/04/2022 18:40

BarbaraofSeville
'stopping once on a 500 mile journey is hardly an inconvenience'

It is if you've got to be there 40 minutes instead of the 10 that you have available.
That's if there's a charger available and you don't have to queue.

yellowsuninthesky · 13/04/2022 17:29

I was just talking to DH about this and we were thinking that we'll have to have quick-charge-portable batteries - not just because of people who live in flats or terraces without allocated parking - but also because once everyone is using electric cars, the queues for charging points will be terrible. I don't even like queueing for petrol which generally only takes a couple of minutes to put in - so having to wait while someone take 45 odd minutes to charge their car isn't really an option (and much more patient people than I am will get irrirated by it). Though even if they get it down to 10 minutes it will still be awful so I think swapping out the battery is going to be the only option.

And yes, the issue around tyre "emissions" is exercising a few minds too. Of course, we recycle them into pathways in green areas - which perhaps isn't that great an idea with microplastics. Everything we do has some sort of bad impact, it seems :(

I can't understand why you'd hate an automatic though, you can concentrate on driving and forget the gears though we did have an automatic which was a bit of a pain as it forgot to change gear at times, I used to drive it as a clutchless manual which got around the problem, but my current hybrid uses continuous variable transmission which is lovely.

Lunar27 · 13/04/2022 16:57

@flaglady.

That's really interesting so thanks for the link.

Reading it reminded me of the huge elephant in the room that no one is really talking about. PM2.5, PM10 and nanoparticles are bad news and affect all vehicles. In some ways a bit less with EV's due to regenerative braking but some EV's are heavier so the tyre wear is slightly greater.

It's totally obvious really, given we all replace worn tyres, brake pads etc etc, but never really think about where all that rubber and brake pad goes. Sadly straight into our lungs. So while EV's do solve local emissions particles, the other stuff remains.

My guess is that it'll be the next big thing that needs addressing but is currently not on the radar.

Lunar27 · 13/04/2022 16:49

@BarbaraofSeville

stopping once on a 500 mile journey is hardly an inconvenience

It is if you've got to be there 40 minutes instead of the 10 that you have available.

That's if there's a charger available and you don't have to queue.

There's also the cost of charging at service stations, which isn't much far off that for petrol. Plus people seem to think you'll be buying food and drink while you're there.

So as well as having this hugely expensive car, you'll be forever spending time and money at service stations wiping out any savings you need to make to justify the higher purchase price.

Yet again Mumsnet completely misses the needs of lower income people.

I can't tell if you're joking (looks like it) but I think 30 minutes would be the least of your worries if your margins are that tight!

In the UK a 500 mile journey will take upwards of 10 hours, given you're likely to pass through two lots of rush hour traffic, road works, accidents etc. I'd imagine you might want to take 1 or 2 breaks too.

I don't know many people who would set off on a 500 mile journey needing to be there in a massive hurry. Sounds unfeasible or an extremely rare situation. I'd also take a packed lunch to save money as I don't usually buy food/drink at the services.

You're right that electricity at service stations is higher but not as high as petrol/diesel. One thing you're neglecting though is that people might only pay for 1 charge as they'll leave the house with a fully charged battery, using cheaper domestic rates (I'm still on 5 pence/kWh). Whereas petrol/diesel is either expensive or more expensive.

But please explain how lower income people will be driving a 'hugely expensive car' as you describe? Andy why would they 'forever' be spending time/money at service stations? Doesn't stack up TBH.

flaglady · 13/04/2022 16:20

Yet again Mumsnet completely misses the needs of lower income people.

I think you're trying to use lower income people to validate your argument because you see them as an easy tool to use.

The cost of an electric car today doesn't reflect the cost in the future. It might be more, it will probably be less (notwithstanding inflation). Petrol prices might go down because the demand isn't there and countries want to sell their reserves before it stops being used altogether. Then again, they might all get together and decide it's better to restrict supply to keep prices artificially high (like the diamond market). It's another thing we don't know and have no control over. What we do know is that petrol cars won't suddenly be thrown on a scrap heap forcing people into the EV market, it will be a gradual shift. Mass adoption by those who can afford it will lead to more investment and increased manufacturing which will lead to more choice for consumers and a more varied (and affordable) second hand market. Mass adoption will also lead to increased investment in generating our own electricity and moving away from dependence on other countries. Those countries being the ones where our petrol money funds obscenely wealthy people who openly keep slaves because they know we can't/won't do anything (those slaves aren't even lower income, they're zero income) and the country with the madman who shall not be named.

This webpage from Imperial is quite an interesting read on pollution and poverty by the way. It's a statement on what they've been doing but it references some interesting studies www.imperial.ac.uk/stories/pollution-and-poverty/

PermanentTemporary · 13/04/2022 16:10

Well, it isn't compulsory to buy food and drink at a service station?

'Not far off' the cost of fuel is quite a bit less than, in fact, especially at the moment. A recent big jump in the cost of charging means my boyfriend reckons about £15 for his Corsa to fast charge at a service station. The unbelievably painful prices of liquid fuels at the moment don't get me very far on £15, and I don't have the option of a cheaper source of fuel at home. He uses a local street charger overnight instead of charging from a home plug due to the cable on the pavement issue, it's about £8 for a full charge there.

Yes, he has a car and a job and place to live. So do quite a lot of people.

mogsrus · 13/04/2022 15:19

Battery technology will evolve & we will possibly see 5or even 6 hundred miles on one charge, it’s progressing industry just as mobile phones were the size of a house brick when they were invented, look where they are now,& I think the same will happen, so no need to worry, electric vehicles will take over & the rest will follow, another 10 yrs & it will be a whole new landscape as always

BarbaraofSeville · 13/04/2022 15:02

stopping once on a 500 mile journey is hardly an inconvenience

It is if you've got to be there 40 minutes instead of the 10 that you have available.

That's if there's a charger available and you don't have to queue.

There's also the cost of charging at service stations, which isn't much far off that for petrol. Plus people seem to think you'll be buying food and drink while you're there.

So as well as having this hugely expensive car, you'll be forever spending time and money at service stations wiping out any savings you need to make to justify the higher purchase price.

Yet again Mumsnet completely misses the needs of lower income people.

FloBot7 · 13/04/2022 13:37

Trouble is that a lot of the older multi story car parks are very tightly spaced, i.e. only just fit 2 cars between the pillars and short spaces.

That's a problem for any modern car. I live near several multi-storeys where 2 cars fit in 3 spaces. Occasionally I can fit my little one litre petrol car between two as long as they aren't SUVs. Charging a car doesn't require more space than opening a door so they wouldn't need to widen the spaces any further than for a modern petrol car. We have a new Aldi near us with modern sized spaces (feels positively luxurious compared to the old Tesco next door!) and they could easily use the same spot for charging.

Swipe left for the next trending thread