Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Electric cars - so worried

488 replies

Northernlurker · 11/04/2022 18:28

I keep worrying about being forced to buy an electric car when I change my car in a few years.
Reason being the long journeys and (mostly) self catering we love. In Scotland.
We need a range around 50% higher than the current max. It's no good saying charge it on the way if there are no fast chargers. Been looking at details today, even the fastest chargers need just over 30 minutes. Thousands of people drive UJ the Highlands and Islands annually. There won't be anything like enough chargers to cover that. We can charge overnight using an ordinary plug but it's not going to hit the max. Feel like we will spend the whole time worrying about finding a free charger in the middle of nowhere.
How is this ever going to work? It takes two Minutes to fill up a tank with petrol, electric is going to take hours!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
starlingdarling · 31/05/2022 11:55

I know quite a lot of people who have/have had electric cars and they all say that you need diesel/petrol one for long journeys. I think the people who have no problems stopping several times for 30+ minutes a time and always being able to find a charge point that is both working and unoccupied, are mostly limited to Mumsnet.

My DH has almost been caught out twice. The reason was because he's an idiot, didn't plan and magically expected no traffic and chargers galore. Last time he drove all the way from Bedfordshire to Manchester (few hours away, not sure of miles), stopped on the way back for 5 minutes which charged to 35% (and wouldn't have gotten him home anyway) then continued on his way. Before he reached the next charger he was planning to use, he met three accidents on a short stretch of the M1 and was stuck there for an hour. He still managed to get to a slow charger but why he couldn't just sit for 20 minutes at the first one is beyond me. It would have gotten him comfortably home despite the traffic.

The other time was when he wanted to see if his car could get him to his hometown and back... The car got to 8% battery and said he'd arrive home with 1% so he panicked, drove the opposite direction to a charger, found a queue and had to wait.

On the other hand, I drove up to Newcastle, has no issues finding a charging point and never had the battery go so low that I needed to worry about traffic. Same again when I had to drive his car to Portsmouth.

Quite a long story but in conclusion, your friends are idiots like my DH.

amicissimma · 31/05/2022 10:36

The Sunday Times was reporting that electricity may be rationed at peak times this winter. So that will require even more careful planning regarding charging.

I know quite a lot of people who have/have had electric cars and they all say that you need diesel/petrol one for long journeys. I think the people who have no problems stopping several times for 30+ minutes a time and always being able to find a charge point that is both working and unoccupied, are mostly limited to Mumsnet.

3 of my nearest neighbours have EVs (second cars) and this morning all 3 had a cable across the pavement, one in a rubber channel, one stuck down with tape and one just trailing. We have to watch our step.

MrKlaw · 31/05/2022 10:00

Local adjustments may need to be made - already some people get large solar panels rejected as there is too much local generation being fed back into the grid. Local microgeneration, battery storage, car charging, on street charging, electric heating - all needs to be factored in and potentially changes made.

Overall the grid should be fine. Cars likely to charge overnight (with smart chargers adjusting start times to avoid a 'big switch on' creating issues), and spreading the charge times like Intelligent Octopus does now - you tell it when you need to charge by and how much and it'll pick the cheapest slots for you so can balance demand overnight. Heating will be more needed during the day so heating/EV demand will mostly be in separately timeslots. And heating will increase demand but will be more efficient than old storage heaters and less 'spiky' so should allow the grid to predict demand fairly well as more households go electric.

Yes, if you have a driveway and can fit a home charger you'll have the convenience of charging overnight on a cheap tariff like you charge your phone. But if you have a driveway you already have the convenience of off-street parking and thats factored into house prices etc.

Lunar27 · 20/04/2022 12:03

@Badbadbunny

Do you have a link for these estates that can't cope?

I think you're neglecting the simple solution and thing that many EV owners already do, which is to charge well outside of peak times. I exclusively charge between 00:30 - 04:30 when the demand is extremely low. In the future I'd expect for us all to charge at varying times to spread the load.

CapMarvel · 20/04/2022 11:10

The idea that the national grid can't keep up with demand for EV charging has been debunked. As long as there is supply to a location then the grid can cope.

Some older properties to allow for a home charger to be installed will require pretty minor upgrades to the wiring as it comes into the property but that is all.

Compare that to the logistical difficulties of sending petrol all over the country and it's trivial in comparison.

Badbadbunny · 20/04/2022 11:06

@CapMarvel

The huge advantage we have with EVs is that electricity is far easier to transport than petrol so we can basically stick a charger anywhere so accessing public chargers should eventually become easier than going to the petrol station for those in rural locations.

You're missing the important point about the capability of the electricity infrastructure. There'll be many locations which simply don't have the capacity to charge lots of electric cars at the same time. There are already cases where you have, say a housing estate, that's struggling when lots of cars are being charged at the same time. I don't understand the technical aspects, but apparently there are different grades of supply, it was put simply to me that some transformers are larger (more capacity) than others and some wiring is thicker (more capacity) than others. So if there's too much "draw" on the supply, it can trip. If we add more electric based heating systems into the mix (i.e. when new gas boilers are banned), it could be the straw that breaks the camel's back when it comes to the electrical infrastructure in some places.

As for rural areas, many already suffer from poor broadband and poor mobile signals, as the infrastructure in some rural locations is simply not geared up for the modern "connected" world.

Ifailed · 20/04/2022 10:55

@Lunar27,
I expect (naively, probably) that state-funded charging stations to provide a service at cost, aimed at those who cannot charge at home. Instead it looks like it will be 'market led'.

Lunar27 · 20/04/2022 10:37

@Ifailed

Sorry but I don't get what that has to do with your previous post about government funding.

But anyway, yes, it'll be a bit variable but some will get free charging at work. I can also visit a number of free public chargers where I live. And what about those even more fortunate who have solar and can mostly charge for free? There'll be a few more tiers but it may end up being necessary to either regulate pricing or for councils to work with those who have fewer options.

But ultimately it's far too early to tell how things will play out given the immaturity of the network today.

CapMarvel · 20/04/2022 09:21

It's really not that different a model from what we have currently.

Currently ICE cars have to drive to a for-profit garage to fill up. The only real difference with EV's currently is the time it takes, which on the face of it causes problems with demand but given that a large number of people will be able to charge at home should in fact balance out. The huge advantage we have with EVs is that electricity is far easier to transport than petrol so we can basically stick a charger anywhere so accessing public chargers should eventually become easier than going to the petrol station for those in rural locations.

Ifailed · 20/04/2022 09:11

The point is simple, the many who don't own their own parking space will have to use public charging points.

There will be a 2 tier system, those lucky enough to be able the charge their vehicle(s) at home at cost, and those reliant on using a charging service provided by for-profit private companies. The latter will be further split into those who'll pay for a time slot, fast charging etc.

This is a completely different model than the one currently used for re-fuelling ICE cars.

Ifailed · 20/04/2022 09:11

The point is simple, the many who don't own their own parking space will have to use public charging points.

There will be a 2 tier system, those lucky enough to be able the charge their vehicle(s) at home at cost, and those reliant on using a charging service provided by for-profit private companies. The latter will be further split into those who'll pay for a time slot, fast charging etc.

This is a completely different model than the one currently used for re-fuelling ICE cars.

StCharlotte · 20/04/2022 09:01

raspberrymuffin · 11/04/2022 18:40

Since those of us who actually live in rural Scotland like to occasionally visit the shops, access healthcare and go on holiday ourselves, I think it's fair to assume that by the time all new cars are electric there will be lots more public charging capacity. Otherwise you won't be able to walk down the street without tripping over cables hanging out of the windows of people without drives.

That already happens in our street.

Lunar27 · 20/04/2022 08:44

@Ifailed

Sorry but I don't understand the issue?

Ifailed · 20/04/2022 08:35

Zapmap is not very clear on how many chargers are Government owned, the top 10 companies all look to be private.
The Government is making £20 million available for 2022/23 to local authorities to fund new chargers, but only 60% of capital costs. Presumably the other 40%, and the on-going maintenance, will be picked up by council tax payers. I wonder how many people, including the vast majority who don't own an EV, are aware of this?

Lunar27 · 20/04/2022 07:43

Ifailed · 20/04/2022 05:59

As the network is a mixture of private and government owned

Government owned - where are these chargers?

You can find them on zapmap. There are lots but again, vary from region to region.

Whetheryouthinkyoucan · 20/04/2022 06:56

@Ifailed the Scottish government owns “chargeplace Scotland”. Zap-Map shows a fair proportion of Scottish charges to be those ones.

Ifailed · 20/04/2022 05:59

As the network is a mixture of private and government owned

Government owned - where are these chargers?

Lunar27 · 19/04/2022 22:59

@MiddleOfThePack

Most MN'ers do say that as it's mostly true. From experience, people like yourself are outliers.

Lunar27 · 19/04/2022 22:54

@lameasahorse

The network as it stands is hugely variable but it will improve so best not to worry about it too much, although I admit it doesn't sound great where you are. From discussion here, it sounds like you're a year or two from taking the plunge so expect things to change by the time you do.

The thing I always bear in mind is that there are around 33 million cars in the UK, 450,000 of which are electric. As the network is a mixture of private and government owned, I find it amazing that it's as well developed as it is. The way I see it, if someone came to me and asked if I wanted to invest millions on a network that only 2% of the public would use, I'd tell them to bugger off. Yet here we are.

However, in order for the network to improve further, I think the number of EV's needs to increase as the revenue will need to be sufficient to repay investment.

It'll come but it will need some people to be brave and be prepared to come out of their comfort zone.

MiddleOfThePack · 19/04/2022 22:28

Just hopping on this one a bit late in the day. To those MNers who say that the only car owners with range anxiety are not the ones who own an electric car, I beg to differ.

We have an all electric, but for long journeys we use our ancient diesel guzzling old MPV.

EVs are great if you don't need to go too far or don't mind frequent breaks to drink crap coffee, stressing out when the app that told you that the nearest charger was available and working only to get there and find the app was 'lying', finding that when you get there at 2115, the chap in the shop has turned the chargers off as he goes home at 2100, etc etc

I really hope the infrastructure catches up but it'd better get a move on.

lameasahorse · 19/04/2022 22:12

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Lunar27 · 19/04/2022 21:50
  • drove
Lunar27 · 19/04/2022 21:48

I have a friend in the Met but I still say the police are friggin useless. My daughter was involved in a hit and run (rear ended) and the police wouldn't come out. She was in shock so drive to the nearest car park, where miraculously, she found that the offending car had been abandoned (front end smashed in). So she phoned the police again, who still couldn't be bothered to come out. They had no idea if the offending car had been stolen or anything and weren't even interested in taking the reg number. Instead they advised her to log it on the police website.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 19/04/2022 21:29

@Kris02

Would anyone else be glad of the silence? Noisy cars seem to be in fashion atm. Over the Easter break, I went for a long hike in the countryside. But every time I stopped to listen to the birds, all I could hear was the screeching and popping of cars. Apparently, boy racers drill holes in their exhaust pipes to make that horrible backfiring sound. It's illegal. It's also illegal to have an engine over a certain noise level. The police just seem to ignore them, however. This weekend has been a nightmare. All you hear all day and night is the mmmm...pop,pop,pop sound. Ugghh, bring on the electric cars!
Totally agree - it’s the same around here and Police clearly couldn’t care less.
Kris02 · 19/04/2022 16:39

Would anyone else be glad of the silence? Noisy cars seem to be in fashion atm. Over the Easter break, I went for a long hike in the countryside. But every time I stopped to listen to the birds, all I could hear was the screeching and popping of cars. Apparently, boy racers drill holes in their exhaust pipes to make that horrible backfiring sound. It's illegal. It's also illegal to have an engine over a certain noise level. The police just seem to ignore them, however. This weekend has been a nightmare. All you hear all day and night is the mmmm...pop,pop,pop sound. Ugghh, bring on the electric cars!