Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Midwifery Placement woes

40 replies

DilemmaOfCourse · 11/04/2022 18:05

DN has received communication that she’s being investigated for potentially unsafe practices on placement.

Is this something that happens regularly or is it a case of ‘if it’s got this far, it’s a done deal’?

I know nothing about the field so would welcome any insight please. How can we support her?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Tront · 14/08/2022 21:58

Thank you for updating and congratulations to your niece x

DilemmaOfCourse · 14/08/2022 21:05

Just thought I’d come back and provide an update, as well as thank everyone for their replies.

DN’s investigation concluded and she is now required to complete her placement, which she had to stop going during the investigation.

She’s got all her academic results and has passed those. So fc, the placement proceeds with no issues. She’s keeping her head down so she can complete this successfully. Hopefully, we’ll have a midwife in the family soon 😅🎉

OP posts:
MidwifeLecturer · 17/05/2022 10:35

I run a midwifery programme at a large UK university (namechanged, obviously!)

There is no way that we would 'investigate' a student simply for not turning up for a shift, let alone remove them from the course. Yes, it's unprofessional, inappropriate for a 3rd year and she would be pulled up on it (and offered support for any issues leading to the absence) but this would be an informal process - eg: a chat with her placement facilitator / her personal tutor.

It is not an issue of safety per se, as all students (even 3rd years) are supernumerary, meaning that all care of the women can and should go ahead normally whether they are there or not. As a student, she should never be in the position where her absence makes care unsafe.

In my experience, if she is requiring support from the SU or RCM, there will be much more to it than simply missing a shift, OP.

However, the likelihood is that she will be put on an action plan and required to repeat a placement, rather than being summarily removed from the course.

Springhassprung86 · 17/05/2022 10:03

@Shardonneigghhh even students who are caseloading are directly supervised when providing care. The patient is still allocated a named midwife who will be responsible for providing the care and supporting the student, so this wouldn’t happen.

Lex345 · 17/05/2022 07:28

I trained as a nurse, so not exactly the same but similar standards are expected. I know that some students did this and were definitely not investigated for unsafe practice. It is unprofessional though and inconsiderate to the mentor, who may have put their own time into planning the day so your DN could achieve her learning outcomes. I was always sympathetic to students I mentored, but I did expect certain standards of conduct from them-after all, I am signing my name, with my PIN, to say I have no concerns about their conduct or character, as well as their ability to perform with the appropriate level of skill and autonomy for their stage in their training. For a final year student (I am assuming she is a Sept intake), she has nearly finished-she should be almost fully autonomous. If she isn't, it would be unfair to sign her off anyway-she will then qualify unsafely.

As a student, one student was investigated in a similar way you describe and was removed from the course, but it was a far more serious incident.

Either the mentor is extremely strict (but still has a point-you cannot just not turn up for shifts) or there is more to this IMO.

Shardonneigghhh · 17/05/2022 07:00

There's definitely more to this. Was it a case holding shift where she was responsible for providing care for a patient, and she didn't communicate that someone else needed to provide that care in her absence?

If the outcome of the investigation is that she needs to repeat the placement or the year, that is a good outcome. Students on occasion get failed on their last placement and have to leave the course, which must be heartbreaking considering how much work the degree entails.

Springhassprung86 · 17/05/2022 00:41

Agreed @Mouldyfeet . There’s no way this is the full story.

Mouldyfeet · 16/05/2022 07:36

She is not telling you the whole truth. It’s really not uncommon for a student to fail to turn up and not call in, unprofessional yes but this wouldn’t be classed as unsafe unless lots of other stuff has been happening.

KangarooKenny · 16/05/2022 07:34

It sounds like there’s more to it than the one incident.

TabithaTittlemouse · 16/05/2022 07:31

It could be that they worry that she is not ready as she is not able to deal with upsetting situations and that she stayed away rather than attended a debrief etc. Although I’m not sure it would be classed as unsafe practice.
She definitely needs to contact her union and uni placement lead.
( I’m a nurse not a midwife).

MakeMineALarge1 · 16/05/2022 07:23

Not turning up for shift as a student is not career ending, but it is very irresponsible! Yes she has been affected by an incident and the midwife supervising her should have been aware of the ramifications and checked in on her, or asked someone to.
Again, I don't think you'd would fail a placement on one incident of not turning up , for a shift, or be investigated for unsafe practices, are you sure there isn't more to it?

DilemmaOfCourse · 15/05/2022 22:22

ItsAllGoingToBeFine · 15/05/2022 22:09

Is she responsible in any way for said incident?

She was not responsible for the incident in any way but it really affected her.

OP posts:
ItsAllGoingToBeFine · 15/05/2022 22:09

Is she responsible in any way for said incident?

DilemmaOfCourse · 15/05/2022 22:06

Thank you, that makes me more hopeful that it’s not unheard of among placement students. Inside, I’ve been very concerned but I’ve been telling her that we’re very hopeful she’ll get a second chance.

She’s been given a chance to respond and has apologised and said she was struggling mentally that day due to the incident.

OP posts:
Fifi0102 · 15/05/2022 21:51

DilemmaOfCourse · 15/05/2022 21:20

So, I found out that DN didn’t turn up for a shift. She didn’t ring or make any excuses. She just didn’t turn up. Inside, we’re both seething that she could be so unprofessional but outwardly, we’re showing support and trying to help her through this.

Does she have a chance at all?

Something happened during her shift that made her really upset but is anything really upsetting enough to to pick up a phone to ring, email or text?

Does she have a chance at all?

She’s part of a union and has asked for help from them.

I’m very worried for her because this is her dream and she’s brilliant with patients.

That should be fine , she just needs to apologise and explain she was affected by what happened. It's not career ending sometimes you do get a bad placement she might want a fresh start somewhere else.

00deed1988 · 15/05/2022 21:46

DilemmaOfCourse · 15/05/2022 21:20

So, I found out that DN didn’t turn up for a shift. She didn’t ring or make any excuses. She just didn’t turn up. Inside, we’re both seething that she could be so unprofessional but outwardly, we’re showing support and trying to help her through this.

Does she have a chance at all?

Something happened during her shift that made her really upset but is anything really upsetting enough to to pick up a phone to ring, email or text?

Does she have a chance at all?

She’s part of a union and has asked for help from them.

I’m very worried for her because this is her dream and she’s brilliant with patients.

I am a midwife and students often don't turn up with no warning. As far as I know they get told they should call by the CPF but that's it. Maybe if it were reoccurring and affecting their competencies being signed ect.

It isn't really unsafe practice as they have not made anything unsafe. They are supernumerary and them being there or not makes no difference to the women's health. Obviously if they are qualified then it would be unsafe?

If that is what it is, then she needs to apologise and reassure them it won't happen again, she has the union to help but seems very extreme for not turning up as a student. Did they try and call her to find out where she was or anything. If they didn't then they probably wouldn't get anywhere with it.

Springhassprung86 · 15/05/2022 21:28

Sorry OP but I don’t think your niece is telling you the whole truth.
She wouldn’t be investigated for unsafe practices for that alone. She’d maybe get a bit of a telling off from uni, but that’s about it. In the grand scheme of things, it wouldn’t be a huge deal.
There is definitely more to this than she is letting on.

choosername1234 · 15/05/2022 21:26

Ok, firstly I am a nurse not a midwife but I am an experienced mentor and "sign off" mentor.
This is not career ending. Enough to fail the placement which would require another placement before registration could happen. How did she react when the incident happened? Did she run from the ward, tell her mentor she was upset or just not turn up the next day?

DilemmaOfCourse · 15/05/2022 21:20

So, I found out that DN didn’t turn up for a shift. She didn’t ring or make any excuses. She just didn’t turn up. Inside, we’re both seething that she could be so unprofessional but outwardly, we’re showing support and trying to help her through this.

Does she have a chance at all?

Something happened during her shift that made her really upset but is anything really upsetting enough to to pick up a phone to ring, email or text?

Does she have a chance at all?

She’s part of a union and has asked for help from them.

I’m very worried for her because this is her dream and she’s brilliant with patients.

OP posts:
Toddlerteaplease · 11/04/2022 20:19

@Springhassprung86 yes. It suddenly dawns on people that they may well be on shift with that person when they are qualified, and they suddenly realise that they are not safe enough.

MakeMineALarge1 · 11/04/2022 20:10

It's very unusual for things like this to come from nowhere in third year, normally its failure to fail, no one likes to fail a student so they pass, then all of a sudden the realisation hits that within the next 12 months they will be practicing on their own!
I am not saying this is the case with your daughter, but its something to think about.
Now in relation to her, she needs to contact her uni asap, she needs to fully understand what she is being investigated, or what is being looked into, she will need support but its better to sort things out now whilst she has uni behind her than when she is NQM

Springhassprung86 · 11/04/2022 20:02

Agreed with @Toddlerteaplease
Failure to fail can be an issue, then it comes to third year and people are a bit “yikes-this person will qualify soon and be flying solo”.
It’s not always a bad thing, she may have to repeat a placement but if it’s necessary it will definitely benefit her. Definitely better to deal with her shortcomings as a student rather than a NQM.

FelicityBeedle · 11/04/2022 20:00

Has she definitely done nothing at all a little dodgy? There are sneaky little bad habits that can easily slip into your practice if you aren’t careful.

Toddlerteaplease · 11/04/2022 19:50

I've known a few students fail their last placement. In almost all cases it was 'failure to fail' in previous placements. I think by doing another placement most of them passed. If there have genuinely been no issues previously, she must have done something fairly major.

DilemmaOfCourse · 11/04/2022 18:54

Thank you so much for your help, everyone. Each one is so helpful and has made me feel hopeful about supporting and helping her, no matter the outcome.

She’s always wanted to do this for as long as I can remember. She’s not the strongest academically but has fought so hard to make her dream come true.

I’m still waiting for her to send me more detail and will report back as soon as anything is sent through. She says nothing has come through yet.

On previous placements, she’s had glowing recommendations from both mentors and patients.

@Monr0e, yes it’s the same mentor.

OP posts: