Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To end a friendship due to his use of sex workers?

318 replies

Cornishjam1162 · 11/04/2022 11:45

It has recently come to light that a friend of 15 years is a regular customer of sex workers. We have always wondered why he never wanted to date again after getting a divorce and now it makes sense. I would have never had him down as the type and I'm shocked to say the least. I don't know the circumstances behind why the women do that line of work but there's always the risk that they're not doing it out of their own free will isn't there? I feel like he could well be exploiting vulnerable women.

Would you end a friendship over this? Am I being too judgemental?

OP posts:
KettrickenSmiled · 19/05/2022 17:11

Based on your statement, how would you prefer your views to be considered ?

By you old horse? Not at all.

KettrickenSmiled · 19/05/2022 17:10

You have not been violated in any way even though you find it intolerable.

You have some amazing assumptions going on 😂
I'm finding it amusing, not intolerable. I don't think you've fathomed how little weight I'm giving you ... am luckily on hols today, with a few chums round.
We're enjoying the garden, & they are mightily entertained by this anonymous, ludicrous spat. A bingo/drinking game started half an hour ago, & I'm 2 shots down on the strength of the other PP's sealioning alone - cheers!

Hawkins001 · 19/05/2022 17:09

KettrickenSmiled · 19/05/2022 17:03

But in order to give credibility to your statements, proof of sources to confirm your perspectives would be appreciated

But I have no need for you to find me credible, & don't value your appreciation.

Based on your statement, how would you prefer your views to be considered ?

KettrickenSmiled · 19/05/2022 17:03

But in order to give credibility to your statements, proof of sources to confirm your perspectives would be appreciated

But I have no need for you to find me credible, & don't value your appreciation.

KettrickenSmiled · 19/05/2022 17:02

Because I dared criticise you on a public forum you accuse me of being a rapist.
??? How ridiculous.
You know 'consent' informs areas of life other than sex, don't you?

This is the epitome of the hysteria I mentioned earlier.
Inventing non-existent accusations of rape is a perfect definition of hysteria.

My advice to you is get better at debating or get some more easily defended positions.
😂Cracking.
But ... suppose I don't want to debate, & see no obligation to 'defend' a position?

You are the gift that keeps on giving - more hilariously pompous with every post.

Hawkins001 · 19/05/2022 17:00

KettrickenSmiled · 19/05/2022 16:57

Well hello again @Hawkins001 . Nice sealioning!
But, as everybody with a grasp on reality knows, we're not actually in a tutorial, Oxford or otherwise, & as noted previously - it's not my job to do your homework for you.

If you want the info, you know how to look for it.
Start with Sarah Forsyth's book - it's been linked on here enough times.

But in order to give credibility to your statements, proof of sources to confirm your perspectives would be appreciated,

it's easy to say x, and then say do your own research, but then it does not give you any credibility similar to buzz words and newspaper headlines, with out the details, it's then basing your perspectives on Faith.

AdamRyan · 19/05/2022 16:57

Because I dared criticise you on a public forum you accuse me of being a rapist.
Where did she do that? [Confused]

KettrickenSmiled · 19/05/2022 16:57

Well hello again @Hawkins001 . Nice sealioning!
But, as everybody with a grasp on reality knows, we're not actually in a tutorial, Oxford or otherwise, & as noted previously - it's not my job to do your homework for you.

If you want the info, you know how to look for it.
Start with Sarah Forsyth's book - it's been linked on here enough times.

misssatan · 19/05/2022 16:56

KettrickenSmiled · 19/05/2022 14:03

"Yes, every angry word you write is just highlighting what we already know - you have issues with other people's consent."

This is a perfect illustration of why most women distance themselves from feminism. Because I dared criticise you on a public forum you accuse me of being a rapist. This is the epitome of the hysteria I mentioned earlier.

In reality you found it hard to argue your case and rather than lose face flounced off determined to have the last word and you're furious that I didn't play along which is why you came back despite your earlier declaration of wanting nothing more to do with me. You just couldn't help yourself.

Let me make this crystal clear. I don't need your consent to disagree with you or criticise your opinions or behaviour. You have not been violated in any way even though you find it intolerable.

"Hence your refusal to believe evidence - even from sex workers themselves - that abuse & coercion is rife thoughout the industry."

On the contrary, unlike you I actually do listen to what sex workers say themselves and not those determined to speak over them while claiming to speak for them.

"Here's the thing though. Your fulminating is so confusing I can't be quite sure what "truth" you are referring to."

In that case I was trying to get you to admit that feminism is divided between two mutually exclusive camps, particularly focused on the issues of sex work and the trans issue.

"There's really no need to respond to me further, it's not doing your blood pressure any good dear."

You are projecting your own fury onto me. I'm not the one getting my knickers in a twist and trying to restrict who can and can't speak to me.

I've dealt with hundreds of people like you, very dogmatic people who can't argue their case and try to dictate to others and call them names and deliberately misrepresent them. It's water off a duck's back by this point.

My advice to you is get better at debating or get some more easily defended positions.

AdamRyan · 19/05/2022 16:55

Read the book "men who hate women" Hawkins. Laura Bates has done all the work for you

Hawkins001 · 19/05/2022 16:53

AdamRyan · 19/05/2022 16:24

I'm not sure that's true. Quite a lot of the manosphere is anti-porn and against sex industry and female sex workers in particular.
Hahaha nice one

Quite a lot of the manosphere hate all women, so hating female prostitutes says nothing

Quite a lot of the manosphere subscribe to the idea that men who women won't sleep with voluntarily, have a "right" to sex and so are perfectly entitled to rape women/pay for sex

Quite a lot of the manosphere think the government should make "marriage" aka sexual slavery compulsory

I mean, I think kettricken (fabulous name BTW, my favourite books) has a good point thar your views on consent line up quite well with the manosphere

Do you have detailed examples to provide a detailed analysis of point by point ?

Hawkins001 · 19/05/2022 16:35

Daphodils · 19/05/2022 16:32

And then storming out while screaming "don't ever talk to me again!" and slamming the door Grin

That's very true,

Daphodils · 19/05/2022 16:32

Hawkins001 · 19/05/2022 16:18

I detailed rebuttal of misssatan points would help boost your arguments and perspective. It's like your stood in an Oxford tutorial, say some generalised paragraphs, but then don't back up your perspectives with a lot of detail to confirm your perspectives, and then when called out on your perspectives and analysis, instead you just floundering, and spouting generalised words rather than engage in a constructive manner.

And then storming out while screaming "don't ever talk to me again!" and slamming the door Grin

AdamRyan · 19/05/2022 16:24

I'm not sure that's true. Quite a lot of the manosphere is anti-porn and against sex industry and female sex workers in particular.
Hahaha nice one

Quite a lot of the manosphere hate all women, so hating female prostitutes says nothing

Quite a lot of the manosphere subscribe to the idea that men who women won't sleep with voluntarily, have a "right" to sex and so are perfectly entitled to rape women/pay for sex

Quite a lot of the manosphere think the government should make "marriage" aka sexual slavery compulsory

I mean, I think kettricken (fabulous name BTW, my favourite books) has a good point thar your views on consent line up quite well with the manosphere

Hawkins001 · 19/05/2022 16:18

KettrickenSmiled · 19/05/2022 10:55

Try, just once, to be honest and admit the truth.

@misssatan OK dude. You know me better than I know myself, your intellect puts all others to shame, & it's not weird At ALL that you loathe feminists but support MRA.

I was going to ask if we're done now, but caught myself in time! ... We're done.
Don't tag me again, & if you need to vent your frustrations you'll find plenty of like minded individuals on various red pill sites to prop up your asinine views on the sex industry.

I detailed rebuttal of misssatan points would help boost your arguments and perspective. It's like your stood in an Oxford tutorial, say some generalised paragraphs, but then don't back up your perspectives with a lot of detail to confirm your perspectives, and then when called out on your perspectives and analysis, instead you just floundering, and spouting generalised words rather than engage in a constructive manner.

KettrickenSmiled · 19/05/2022 14:03

"We're done. Don't tag me again."

I don't take kindly to orders. I'll respond to anything you write if I choose to. I don't need your permission. It's a public forum. Respond or don't respond. I really don't care.

Yes, every angry word you write is just highlighting what we already know - you have issues with other people's consent.
Hence your refusal to believe evidence - even from sex workers themselves - that abuse & coercion is rife thoughout the industry.

I know you are a moral coward and won't admit the truth certainly.
Sure you do dude ... {backs away slowly} ...
Here's the thing though. Your fulminating is so confusing I can't be quite sure what "truth" you are referring to. That I'm a coward? That you don't understand how to respect another person's "no"? That I don't know what a lesbian is, or what additional issues she faces cf: her het sisters? That All Feminists Are Bad & Wrong And At War?

So much nonsense to choose from I can only humbly apologise for not knowing which bit to pick. There's really no need to respond to me further, it's not doing your blood pressure any good dear.

Neverendingmindfuck · 19/05/2022 13:47

@JayniSummers thank you for posting that link.
That is one of the most disgusting, depressing & vile things I've ever read.
Who the fuck do those 'men' think they are rating those women like they're a chip shop or theme park 😡
I genuinely hope they get knob rot.
I would not knowingly be friends with anyone who bought a womans/mans/child's body. They are beyond forgiveness.
Unless you personally know the person who is selling sex, every single detail about their whole life, you will never know why they are doing it.

misssatan · 19/05/2022 11:40

KettrickenSmiled · 19/05/2022 10:55

"OK dude. You know me better than I know myself"

I know you are a moral coward and won't admit the truth certainly.

"It's not weird At ALL that you loathe feminists but support MRA."

Have you actually read through what I have written? On several posts on this thread I have stated very clearly that I view MRAs as the male version of feminists, silly, whiny and annoying but who, like feminists, occasionally make some good points.

Also pointing out your double standards when it comes to sexual exploitation isn't the sole province of any one ideology or movement. Basic logic and a lack of bias will allow anyone to do the same.

"We're done. Don't tag me again."

I don't take kindly to orders. I'll respond to anything you write if I choose to. I don't need your permission. It's a public forum. Respond or don't respond. I really don't care. People like you are legion.

It's funny that people always run away when they can't answer difficult questions and do so in such a pompous, overly dramatic way. You know I am pointing out the reality of your double standards and hypocrisy as well the unbridgeable divide within feminism but cannot bring yourself to admit any of this.

"You'll find plenty of like minded individuals on various red pill sites to prop up your asinine views on the sex industry."

I'm not sure that's true. Quite a lot of the manosphere is anti-porn and against sex industry and female sex workers in particular. I'm most likely to find support from my 'asinine' views on the sex industry on feminist websites, just not 'swerf' ones like Mumsnet.

KettrickenSmiled · 19/05/2022 10:55

Try, just once, to be honest and admit the truth.

@misssatan OK dude. You know me better than I know myself, your intellect puts all others to shame, & it's not weird At ALL that you loathe feminists but support MRA.

I was going to ask if we're done now, but caught myself in time! ... We're done.
Don't tag me again, & if you need to vent your frustrations you'll find plenty of like minded individuals on various red pill sites to prop up your asinine views on the sex industry.

misssatan · 19/05/2022 07:33

"Suggesting that women are ‘shocked’ by reality is a good way to imply women are prudish frigid pearl-clutchers though, and that our opinions are hysterical rather than reasoned. It’s a standard tactic of misogynists."

It might be but it's also accurate when looking at quite a significant proportion of mumsnet posters, male and female. No misogyny is required to point that out. Calling your critics bigots and 'ists' or 'phobes' of some kind is just a way of deflecting criticism without having to deal with it.

The majority on here will be women but some are men and being hysterical is hardly the exclusive preserve of any one sex, race of political persuasion. At the moment the woke left is being especially hysterical but the right is equally capable of it as well.

It's also true that the kind of feminism you find on here is very priggish and comically bourgeois and reflects the faults of a particular section of a society. That doesn't mean no other people are that way or that they don't display flaws of their own.

MissTrip82 · 19/05/2022 01:14

ErmIDontKnow · 12/04/2022 08:06

But that's my point. If another job paid as much and was simple, would you elect to spend your time talking to sleazy men who are partly getting off on the fact that you have to do stuff with them, whether you like it or not? I'd be surprised if you really thought that you would.

See but that's the thing. Again, not speaking for everyone. But in my circle you only take on clients you want to take on. You speak beforehand on what you both want to happen and then do what you have agreed on.

Again, not everyone. But in our circle, you do what YOU want. Not what the man wants. He is paying you yes but you've agreed to his requests before hand. I've turned down so many requests from men because I'm not into what their after.

I know people have kinks ..... theres a well known kink site within "my" community and so many women love that sort of thing.

It just depends who you know really doesn't it. So many are shocked on here yet if your on this side of the world then it's all pretty normal stuff

I don’t think anyone’s shocked, are they?

It’s depressingly predictable, not shocking.

Suggesting that women are ‘shocked’ by reality is a good way to imply women are prudish frigid pearl-clutchers though, and that our opinions are hysterical rather than reasoned. It’s a standard tactic of misogynists.

misssatan · 19/05/2022 01:02

KettrickenSmiled · 18/05/2022 20:27

"As the human race is always at war with itself to be a human mean you have to choose a side"

"Yeah - piffle dressed as meaningful insight ...."

The human race isn't at war with itself at all times but feminism is absolutely and constantly divided on particular issues. You are being incredibly disingenuous to pretend otherwise.

There is no common ground between so called sex positive and sex negative feminists, those who want to ban prostitution and those who believe it to be a legitimate industry. There is no common ground between those who think trans 'women' are real women and those who don't.

Mumsnet is a notorious (in the eyes of trans inclusionary feminists) site for 'terfs' and also for 'swerfs'. It is absolutely despised by a very large and influential group of feminists whose views are so diametrically opposed to the majority on here to make it ludicrous to pretend you belong to a single movement.

Try, just once, to be honest and admit the truth.

misssatan · 19/05/2022 00:53

KettrickenSmiled · 18/05/2022 20:25

"Only if you are the kind of person who needs to assign herself ridiculous labels."

Like a feminist you mean?

"Women are free to practice - or not practice - any form of feminism they choose."

And those types have so little in common they are tearing each other to pieces.

"Because gay women experience even more discrimination than het women, so they are more alive to it."

Do they? How would you know? Wouldn't the same apply to gay men? Shouldn't they all be MRAs by your logic?

"Also because this is my direct experience of all the gay women I know."

Their experience is not yours and, as I said before, we are not a hive mind. There are women who criticise feminism, black people who criticise BLM and CRT, gay people who despise Pride, trans people who have no time for Stonewall. Your low grade identity politics tries to ascribe views based on sex, skin colour, sexuality etc.

"You clearly are not one of them, & move in different circles."

Have you heard of Camille Paglia? She is one of the fiercest critics of the kind of feminism you and this site personify, prissy, priggish, pearl clutching, bourgeois and frequently hysterical. Her kind of feminism I can appreciate but most feminists don't want her in the sisterhood.

NewPanDrawer · 18/05/2022 22:46

My central question remains unanswered, presumably because you have no answer. Why is porn only exploiting women if both men and women take part and why is the exploitation of men in porn something that doesn't concern you?

I have to say that I wonder what the answer to this is too.

Pinklemonade1 · 18/05/2022 21:16

Some interesting responses.
I used to work in a sexual health clinic and the vast majority of the working girls who I treated were happy with their profession. It afforded them a certain lifestyle. I must admit to being really surprised by that. They used to enjoy talking to me about it because it wasn't the kind of thing they could discuss with people. I could only assume that the really chaotic girls that were drug addicts etc were just not accessing services.
You can't make gross generalisations about either the women who sell sex or their clients.
It's the oldest profession around and it's not going anywhere.
Whilst I wish it wasn't a thing, what I'd like to see is much stricter regulations. So basically legal brothels.
If a man is single and he is paying for sex with a woman in a place where they are well looked after and it is absolutely their choice...what's the issue? They are providing a service. There may be many reasons why a man can't have sex 'normally'.

Swipe left for the next trending thread