Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel jealous and irrationally annoyed by this woman's life?

436 replies

WalkingAcrossAFord · 11/04/2022 10:29

Name change for this, as I don't want it linking to my other posts.

I met this woman (my neighbour,) 3 years ago when DH and I moved into this village. DH and I have been to the pub a few times with her and her DH, and she attends 2 of the same village groups as me. She is 2 years younger than me (I'm 52, she is 50,) and she is very proud of the fact that she doesn't work, and never intends to again.

She says she 'retired' at 46 after 30 years of working and has 'paid her dues.' She said it's wonderful to not have to work, and to never have to work again.

She lives in social housing (nice cottage too, on the edge of the village overlooking fields,) and her DH works part time - 4 days a week in a supermarket, and I just can't fathom how she does is/how they do it. They have a 5 year old car, and a 25 y.o. DD who is getting married in September, and they're giving them £5000 towards the wedding. They have also just booked a holiday to Greece for June!

I've said a few times 'you must be good with money, and very good at saving,' and even once said 'how do you do it, do you cope OK with one wage?' She just smiled and said 'we do all right. I have got my own income thanks.' What income would someone get in their late 40s? Confused Can't be a pension!

I am actually annoyed at myself for feeling this way. I have another 15 years to work in a job I absolutely loathe. DH and myself don't have a pot to piss in, we have a car that's 20 years old that's held together with sellotape, and our mortgage makes up 45% of our joint salary(s.) DH and I work 45-50 hours a week some weeks, and never get any surplus income because there is always something to pay for, and ALWAYS something going wrong with our bloody house.

We have mutual friends in our 2 groups, and she is the only one who 'retired' at 45! I have spoken to a couple of women in the group about this, and they said it's nobody's business but hers. I know they're right, but I can't get rid of this deep resentment I have for her. She has the best life; finished work in her mid 40s, potters around their huge garden, goes for walks and bike rides, meets up with friends and family/her DD once a week, draws and paints and writes, sunbathes all day (some days) on the lawn in the summer, and sometimes lies in til 10am! I have been at work for 2 hours at that point!

AIBU to feel irrationally annoyed by this woman? She seems to have a blessed life, and I don't know how she does it. It CAN'T be an inheritance or big lottery win, otherwise they wouldn't be in social housing would they?

OP posts:
Snog · 11/04/2022 13:37

Life is essentially unfair and always seems especially so when you feel like you are struggling yourself.

There are huge issues with housing in the UK at the moment which are having a negative impact on many people.

Yellowhighheels · 11/04/2022 13:35

@CousinKrispy

I can't be bothered reading 11 pages of people tut tutting over how you shouldn't be nosey or compare yourself to others, OP, so I'll just say I sympathize with you.

Yes, I know, intellectually, comparison is the thief of joy, blah blah.

But the thing is ... yeah, it also sucks for you. You feel stuck in a job you hate, because you weren't lucky enough to get a sweet deal with social housing. Instead you're paying through the nose for your mortgage and upkeep, and that means you don't have the extra money and time that she appears to. That doesn't mean you're a horrible person who wishes she hadn't been lucky. But why isn't there more affordable housing to go round (including mortgages not being so inflated), so all of us can have a better work-life balance?

it's the overall system that sucks ... well, not for her, because she's been lucky. But it sucks for many of the rest of us. I'm not sure I could bear to have much contact with her, not because I think she shouldn't be living her best life, but because it would just be too frustrating to be continually faced with it.

Anyway best wishes.

But the point is, OP doesn't know that she's been lucky. I have a good friend who came into a very substantial sum when she was widowed extremely young. As in mid 20s. I know other people retired through seriously ill health. One in particular looks to be having a great life online and is very cheery but I wouldn't swap with them. She could just be frugal. This is why there is no sense in scrutinising or comparing. OP just needs to make the best of her own circumstances .
bluebellsandcustard · 11/04/2022 13:34

Inheritance I'd say. It doesn't mean to say they'll be comfortable in retirement.

worriedatthistime · 11/04/2022 13:33

@M0RVEN social housing isn't run by the council its run by a HA and they run on rent and service charges
Not all are £350 rent, they also do shared ownership and other types
Quick google will tell you
My rent is £550 a month 3 bed semi

SinisterBumFacedCat · 11/04/2022 13:31

I reckon she has inherited a property and is renting it out and that is her income. If that’s the case, it’s understandable that you’d feel annoyed at this. Not necessarily for yourself but I bet there are very many people in your village who are struggling with private rent on low incomes, or in overcrowded multi generational family homes, etc who are much more in need of an affordable home than she is.

Blue4YOU · 11/04/2022 13:30

I have not read the full thread as I can’t type as fast as the comments!
OP - you have e given a lot of identifying details about this woman.
Her physical description (slim, blonde etc).
Type of house
Her former job
Her age
Her husband’s job
Her activities- painting and writing are two that stand out
She has a daughter getting married soon
…and … none about yourself
I suspect you are hoping people will (as some have) “Only Fans” or prostitution or something you can use to try to report her.
Maybe she IS good with money.
Maybe a lot of things.
Beak out

CousinKrispy · 11/04/2022 13:29

I can't be bothered reading 11 pages of people tut tutting over how you shouldn't be nosey or compare yourself to others, OP, so I'll just say I sympathize with you.

Yes, I know, intellectually, comparison is the thief of joy, blah blah.

But the thing is ... yeah, it also sucks for you. You feel stuck in a job you hate, because you weren't lucky enough to get a sweet deal with social housing. Instead you're paying through the nose for your mortgage and upkeep, and that means you don't have the extra money and time that she appears to. That doesn't mean you're a horrible person who wishes she hadn't been lucky. But why isn't there more affordable housing to go round (including mortgages not being so inflated), so all of us can have a better work-life balance?

it's the overall system that sucks ... well, not for her, because she's been lucky. But it sucks for many of the rest of us. I'm not sure I could bear to have much contact with her, not because I think she shouldn't be living her best life, but because it would just be too frustrating to be continually faced with it.

Anyway best wishes.

Twolostsoulsswimminginafishbow · 11/04/2022 13:23

You could almost be one of my neighbours describing me. They know nothing about my personal circumstances other than what they see. I ‘retired’ in my early 40s, live in a lovely three bedroom semi in a highly desirable area that is ex HA and drive a brand new car.

The house is mortgage free and I spend my days pottering about in my garden or sat ‘sunbathing.’ I’m seriously ill (neighbours wouldn’t know it and my port for feed and meds is hidden.) The car is leased from Motability. I also had a payout years ago that is in a trust. I can access it whenever needed and it cannot be taken into account for benefit purposes.

Please stop being jealous when there could be so many reasons you wouldn’t want her life. I’d swap it all to be healthy and live a few more years.

anniegun · 11/04/2022 13:21

Akshata Murthy inherited more than a billion pounds, opted out of the UK tax system for most of her earnings, claimed £100k furlough support for her company and has a free flat in central London paid for by the tax payer. That is a woman who I feel annoyed about

OnaBegonia · 11/04/2022 13:19

Yet another SH bashing thread, MN seems to have some very skewed ideas about SH.
It is not easy to be allocated a house and it is a secure tenancy which you are not obliged to give up.
Having a mortgage is a choice and the to be frank vile comment if she needs a repair she clocks her fingers is pathetic, she does pay rent and council tax etc it's not free.
OP you sound very petty and jealous.

gettingolderandgrumpy · 11/04/2022 13:17

To be blunt I’m not sure why you give a shit ! There is always someone with a bigger house more money I don’t sit wondering how or why as I’d get nothing done . Op your unhappy that’s not her fault find a way to make yourself happy , if you hate your job do something you enjoy . Resentment isn’t healthy and you will look a right miserable so and so .

Seeingadistance · 11/04/2022 13:16

You would be better off and more contented yourself, OP, if you could just be happy for her.

cansu · 11/04/2022 13:16

You are torturing yourself unnecessarily. It s highly likely she won some cash or inherited and chose to luce off that cash rather than buy anything. You shouldn't be asking and how will it help you? However all that crap from her about having paid her doesn't is really boasting and not especially nice either. I know someone like that. I just avoid her.

carefullycourageous · 11/04/2022 13:14

I am glad you have listened to the feedback OP, you are definitely being unreasonable in my opinion.

I had a period being very skint and it was really tough, but the only thing that happens if you obsess over other people is you get bitter.

You are having a tough time but actually still doing much better than others. I found it really hard to balance those two things in my head. It is OK/natural/healthy for you to acknowledge negative feelings about your own problems but when you compare upwards you also have to be mindful to compare downwards.

KellyanneConway · 11/04/2022 13:14

I know someone who has a degenerative disease. An outsider would never know there is anything wrong but behind the scenes she is in a lot of pain, there are lots of medical appointments, a cocktail of drugs to be taken and there is a lot of self-management stuff she has to do e.g. exercise and adaptations. She had to give up work and got an insurance pay out to cover a percentage of her previous salary (after lots of fighting the insurance company). The only people who know about this are her husband, parents, brother and me as she doesn't want her DCs and GC to find out. She regularly fields off questions from people who wonder how she has managed to give up work but seemingly retain her lifestyle and does say similar things to those you have quoted. Have you considered that your friend could be going through something similar?

BrieAndChilli · 11/04/2022 13:14

well my mum and step dad live in social housing in a small village. She retired in her 50s as she got a 6 figure inheritance from her aunt when she died. She had enough to buy thier house from the authority on right to buy but didnt - she did however retire and lives ok. Shes in her 60s now. I think she was crazy not to buy the house as she would now own that asset but i suppose she has secure tenancy until she dies so isnt bothered about owning it,

Foolsrule · 11/04/2022 13:14

From what you’ve said, she sounds as though she may not need social housing and if that’s the case, she’s taking the piss. However, as others say, she may have her own source of income for a number of reasons, not all positive. I can understand your upset though. You’re similar ages and she appears to have it all sorted. That said, her life sounds like my PILs’ - fine if you’re in your seventies but is she really going to plod on like this for the next 40-50 years? I’d be so bored!

Christinatherabbit · 11/04/2022 13:13

I'm sorry but you sound awful. Try to concentrate on your own life and buisness and definately don't carry on this gossip and phishing for information from mutual friends if you want ant left!

babywalker56 · 11/04/2022 13:11

You don't need to be a pauper to live in social/council housing.

This!!

Also I think if you asked people about their repairs, it is not a matter of "clicking your fingers and they come a running". It can take months for a simple repair.

Also this! It can be such a hassle to contact the council and continuously chase it up for someone to come and have a look at the issue. It’s not a case of clicking their fingers just because you may have to wait longer than she does

OP you sound very bitter, you know nothing of her personal life. Make your own life better. Or maybe get a poor friend so you can truly feel superior.

Haha yes definitely. Maybe get a poor friend who’s struggling and constantly using food banks so you can feel great about yourself

anniegun · 11/04/2022 13:09

You could have a legitimate beef about not having access to Social Housing (there is nothing to stop the Tories building enough for all low wage families). However projecting that issue onto this women is very unfair

CounsellorTroi · 11/04/2022 13:08

@MummyBobbles

I think the fact she worked in a Local Authority is your answer. If she started work at 18 she could have retired at midish forties on a final salary pension. Completely possible a few years back. May have taken early retirement as well. Its been changed now. Also a lot of old school LA workers would also be social housing tenants.
By the OP’s figures this woman is 50 and retired four years ago. Public sector final salary pensions have not been a thing for a lot longer than that.
Ratatoo · 11/04/2022 13:08

Have you recently bought to be in negative equity?

babywalker56 · 11/04/2022 13:07

I hate threads like this. You sound miserable as fuck! And horrible too.

Why don’t you focus on improving your own life. Is it her fault that you and your DH don’t have a pot to piss in? So because you’re both struggling it’s not fair that she doesn’t work and seems to have a great life. Sorry but that’s your own business. Not sure what her living in social housing has to do with the price of fish. You can still live in social housing if you’ve received an inheritance. Maybe you should have got yourself on the council bidding list instead of taking out a mortgage.

As for this I have spoken to a couple of women in the group about this, and they said it's nobody's business but hers. you really need to get a grip. Speaking about your neighbour to mutual friends or people you know? Soooo unnecessary and bitchy. Fix your own life instead of being jealous of others when they literally haven’t done a thing to you

ickky · 11/04/2022 13:04

You don't need to be a pauper to live in social/council housing.

There has been huge developments near me that are targeting Police/Nursing and Teaching professions to live in their flats.

Social Housing rent is the actual cost of upkeep and repairs. Private rent is so high as you are basically paying someone else's mortgage and insurance.

Also I think if you asked people about their repairs, it is not a matter of "clicking your fingers and they come a running". It can take months for a simple repair.

OP you sound very bitter, you know nothing of her personal life. Make your own life better. Or maybe get a poor friend so you can truly feel superior.

Pixies74 · 11/04/2022 13:02

@SaggyBlinders

Your time would be better spend looking at your own finances and reviewing your budget and where your money goes.

45% of your take home pay on your mortgage when you have two incomes and both work full time/45 - 50 hour weeks is insane. Unless you are making overpayments to pay it off earlier.

Agree. I'm trying to work out how that can be. Is your house incredibly expensive or are you both on really low wages? I'm part-time and my DH is full-time (being 37 hours, not 50!) on distinctly average wages and ours is 21% (and we're in the SE!).

If the latter, (and you say you hate your job!), is there no way you can get a new job?