Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel jealous and irrationally annoyed by this woman's life?

436 replies

WalkingAcrossAFord · 11/04/2022 10:29

Name change for this, as I don't want it linking to my other posts.

I met this woman (my neighbour,) 3 years ago when DH and I moved into this village. DH and I have been to the pub a few times with her and her DH, and she attends 2 of the same village groups as me. She is 2 years younger than me (I'm 52, she is 50,) and she is very proud of the fact that she doesn't work, and never intends to again.

She says she 'retired' at 46 after 30 years of working and has 'paid her dues.' She said it's wonderful to not have to work, and to never have to work again.

She lives in social housing (nice cottage too, on the edge of the village overlooking fields,) and her DH works part time - 4 days a week in a supermarket, and I just can't fathom how she does is/how they do it. They have a 5 year old car, and a 25 y.o. DD who is getting married in September, and they're giving them £5000 towards the wedding. They have also just booked a holiday to Greece for June!

I've said a few times 'you must be good with money, and very good at saving,' and even once said 'how do you do it, do you cope OK with one wage?' She just smiled and said 'we do all right. I have got my own income thanks.' What income would someone get in their late 40s? Confused Can't be a pension!

I am actually annoyed at myself for feeling this way. I have another 15 years to work in a job I absolutely loathe. DH and myself don't have a pot to piss in, we have a car that's 20 years old that's held together with sellotape, and our mortgage makes up 45% of our joint salary(s.) DH and I work 45-50 hours a week some weeks, and never get any surplus income because there is always something to pay for, and ALWAYS something going wrong with our bloody house.

We have mutual friends in our 2 groups, and she is the only one who 'retired' at 45! I have spoken to a couple of women in the group about this, and they said it's nobody's business but hers. I know they're right, but I can't get rid of this deep resentment I have for her. She has the best life; finished work in her mid 40s, potters around their huge garden, goes for walks and bike rides, meets up with friends and family/her DD once a week, draws and paints and writes, sunbathes all day (some days) on the lawn in the summer, and sometimes lies in til 10am! I have been at work for 2 hours at that point!

AIBU to feel irrationally annoyed by this woman? She seems to have a blessed life, and I don't know how she does it. It CAN'T be an inheritance or big lottery win, otherwise they wouldn't be in social housing would they?

OP posts:
Ricksteinsfishwife · 11/04/2022 15:44

@RevealAll

I don’t think the Op is rude by asking. She has said the woman is happy to let everyone know she’s given up work and paid her dues. She has openly said it’s wonderful not to work or work again.

If one of my friends gave up working job at the age of 46 I’d ask how they would survive on one wage too

They are happy to tell people he works in a supermarket so why the big mystery.

Becayse they aren’t friends. And because you don’t keep asking after the first time. Then start asking mutual acquaintances. Then start a thread on line asking how she’s got her money. The op is not entitled to know her private business.
IheartJKRowling · 11/04/2022 15:42

I was medically retired before 45 but had spent my whole career working in local government which had an incredibly generous pension scheme. When I retired my final salary, on which my pension was calculated was excellent, so my pension is a lot more than the average wage.

My dick of a next door neighbour is always making comments about how can "people on benefits" afford to live in a nice area and take three week holidays abroad. He thinks because I don't work I have to be on benefits and like you, he's judgemental and outright rude about my finances.

How anyone finances their life is no one's business but their own and I actually find it sad that people like you and my neighbour devote so much time and thought to my life instead of getting on with their own, envy and bitterness must be horrible to live with.

AChocolateOrangeaday · 11/04/2022 15:39

My lovely, late DM hated two things.

Liars and Jealousy.

We three DD's were brought up from the get go to never lie and envy others. It's a VERY ugly and pointless trait.

As Mum used to say "Never envy anyone as they haven't got that little bit that you have got and no one knows what goes on behind closed doors".

I actually feel sorry for you OP, it must be a horrible feeling.

Teesht · 11/04/2022 15:36

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

twingirlboys · 11/04/2022 15:34

I know a woman who retired at 45 and is very vague about why with new and nosy people, completely understandably. she suffered terribly from bullying at work, became very unwell and took them to a tribunal. She got a cash payout, signed an NDA.

She lives a lovely quiet life and doesn't give a rats about buying status performance things, preferring peace and privacy.

Shame on you OP! your nosiness and jealousy are very unreasonable.

Blossomtoes · 11/04/2022 15:34

If one of my friends gave up working job at the age of 46 I’d ask how they would survive on one wage too

And if I were that friend I’d tell you to mind your own business.

Bodgerbarbara · 11/04/2022 15:31

Not read whole thread but sorry I think you are super nosy and bordering on creepy. Leave her alone.

JustLyra · 11/04/2022 15:29

@SoyaChai

I don't think people asking how you will manage retiring in your 40s are rude. Perfectly valid question and the type of question would be fine to ask friends usually.
The OP isn’t her friend. She’s a neighbour who socialises in the same place.

Also the OP has asked more than once. When someone gives you an answer you shouldn’t ask again because it’s bloody rude, even if you don’t like the non detailed answer.

CounsellorTroi · 11/04/2022 15:29

If she was working for the local authority they may have run a voluntary early exit scheme. The package will have included a lump sum and pension (reduced for the number of years early she left) based on her 30 years service.

RevealAll · 11/04/2022 15:28

I don’t think the Op is rude by asking. She has said the woman is happy to let everyone know she’s given up work and paid her dues. She has openly said it’s wonderful not to work or work again.

If one of my friends gave up working job at the age of 46 I’d ask how they would survive on one wage too

They are happy to tell people he works in a supermarket so why the big mystery.

LondonJax · 11/04/2022 15:28

I think though, @SoyaChai, it's the fact that the OP appears to have asked her friend, got a non-committal answer and then said 'We have mutual friends in our 2 groups, and she is the only one who 'retired' at 45! I have spoken to a couple of women in the group about this, and they said it's nobody's business but hers.' It seems to come across like she must know at all costs. And she doesn't need to. It's none of her business.

lonelyapple · 11/04/2022 15:28

Getting a social housing home is like winning the lottery these days!

Gardeninspring · 11/04/2022 15:28

OP, don't compare yourself or feel jealous. You don't know what's going on behind the scenes in her life. They could have inherited money, had a lottery win, absolutely anything could have happened that they aren't about to disclose. Rightly so, as their finances are none of anyone else's business. They could also be up to their eyes in debt. You just do not know. Confused

Concentrate on what you're doing and your own life. I mean this in the nicest way possible! You'll never fully get to the bottom of anyone else, we all have our personal stuff going on behind closed doors which should stay private. Just be breezy and smile when she mentions what she's spent etc, don't ask questions. Take it all with a pinch of salt.

JustLyra · 11/04/2022 15:27

@Viviennemary

Probably on some kind of fiddle or illegal earnings. Maybe she is one of those non dom folk. Do they get social housing.
Or she could just have an income that is, you know, none of the OP’s business?

That’s more probably the case.

Or would you go sharing the details of your finances with a random nosy prick neighbour?

SoyaChai · 11/04/2022 15:26

I don't think people asking how you will manage retiring in your 40s are rude. Perfectly valid question and the type of question would be fine to ask friends usually.

SkirridHill · 11/04/2022 15:25

@Ricksteinsfishwife There's been a glut of posts recently where people disingenuously claim to be baffled where people are getting their money from, but it boils down to a not particularly veiled attack on people claiming benefits.

I personally wasn't suggesting that the OPs neighbour is commiting benefit fraud - but I am suggesting that that is what the OP is implying.

LondonJax · 11/04/2022 15:25

I agree @Blue4YOU, I think OP comes across as very nasty. It's a wonder she's still in the group if she's asking questions to other people on the sly.

And my friend, who I mentioned upthread, who has ME drives a Motability car. It's been adapted but you'd never know it from the outside, obviously. So it's possible the five year old car could be related to that...or not...either way it's not the OP's business.

I'm still agog that she's working 50 hour weeks and still knows (or is trying to find out) everyone's business. You'd think she'd be to exhausted to care.

Octomore · 11/04/2022 15:21

Back again with another sour-faced take on life, Viv. How grim it must look in your world.

Ain't that the truth!

ReadyToMoveIt · 11/04/2022 15:20

@Viviennemary

Probably on some kind of fiddle or illegal earnings. Maybe she is one of those non dom folk. Do they get social housing.
‘One of those non dom folk’ 😂. People tend to claim non dom status when they have billions that they don’t want to pay tax on. She hardly sounds like she’s living the life of a billionaire, does she? Her ‘crimes’ seem to be staying in bed until 10am and sunbathing.
GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 11/04/2022 15:20

Some very nasty replies, OP.
I don’t blame you for wondering, though. Maybe she’s had an inheritance, or won something on the Ernies/the lottery? Maybe not a massive amount, but enough to be comfortable on.

Ricksteinsfishwife · 11/04/2022 15:13

@SkirridHill

Sounds to me like you think she's fiddling benefits somehow. Sigh. You sound really bitter OP. Maybe work on getting a new job? A word of caution, too, that I'm sure your jealousy is transparent to your friends also.
How on earth does it sound likes she’s fiddling benefits?

What’s wrong with people, folks suggesting prostitution to benefit fraud. This is a woman in social housing, who hasn’t worked from mid forties, so possibly due to a hidden disability or illness, and a husband who works down the supermarket. Who has five grand she’s giving to her child and booking a holiday but otherwise lives very frugally.

SunshineGone · 11/04/2022 15:12

Dh retired at 48. People asking how we will manage for money are rude.

You are rude OP.

RobertaFirmino · 11/04/2022 15:11

This woman doesn't have the life she has through sheer luck though. She's in this position because of one or/and two things:

  1. The choices she makes. She chose not to buy, one DC, to spend little on clothes/hair/makeup. Maybe she chose to invest her money when she worked? Perhaps she chooses the cheapest options for utilities and services, groceries, household goods etc. too?
  1. Tragedy. If she came into an inheritance at 46 yo, at least one parent has met an untimely end.

You could have made similar choices and I bet that if your parents were decent people, you'd choose them being alive over being able to retire.

I suggest finding a way past all this, life is far to short to waste on bitterness.

Babyroobs · 11/04/2022 15:11

Most likely inheritance. Most of my friendship group have lost both parents by their late forties. My dh inherited money in his early fifties. It's really not that unusual.

PussGirl · 11/04/2022 15:08

I think you want to find out she has a dodgy sideline going on like online sex work or cannabis farming or something - those HA repair men that come round like a shot must know something after all.

Swipe left for the next trending thread