Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel jealous and irrationally annoyed by this woman's life?

436 replies

WalkingAcrossAFord · 11/04/2022 10:29

Name change for this, as I don't want it linking to my other posts.

I met this woman (my neighbour,) 3 years ago when DH and I moved into this village. DH and I have been to the pub a few times with her and her DH, and she attends 2 of the same village groups as me. She is 2 years younger than me (I'm 52, she is 50,) and she is very proud of the fact that she doesn't work, and never intends to again.

She says she 'retired' at 46 after 30 years of working and has 'paid her dues.' She said it's wonderful to not have to work, and to never have to work again.

She lives in social housing (nice cottage too, on the edge of the village overlooking fields,) and her DH works part time - 4 days a week in a supermarket, and I just can't fathom how she does is/how they do it. They have a 5 year old car, and a 25 y.o. DD who is getting married in September, and they're giving them £5000 towards the wedding. They have also just booked a holiday to Greece for June!

I've said a few times 'you must be good with money, and very good at saving,' and even once said 'how do you do it, do you cope OK with one wage?' She just smiled and said 'we do all right. I have got my own income thanks.' What income would someone get in their late 40s? Confused Can't be a pension!

I am actually annoyed at myself for feeling this way. I have another 15 years to work in a job I absolutely loathe. DH and myself don't have a pot to piss in, we have a car that's 20 years old that's held together with sellotape, and our mortgage makes up 45% of our joint salary(s.) DH and I work 45-50 hours a week some weeks, and never get any surplus income because there is always something to pay for, and ALWAYS something going wrong with our bloody house.

We have mutual friends in our 2 groups, and she is the only one who 'retired' at 45! I have spoken to a couple of women in the group about this, and they said it's nobody's business but hers. I know they're right, but I can't get rid of this deep resentment I have for her. She has the best life; finished work in her mid 40s, potters around their huge garden, goes for walks and bike rides, meets up with friends and family/her DD once a week, draws and paints and writes, sunbathes all day (some days) on the lawn in the summer, and sometimes lies in til 10am! I have been at work for 2 hours at that point!

AIBU to feel irrationally annoyed by this woman? She seems to have a blessed life, and I don't know how she does it. It CAN'T be an inheritance or big lottery win, otherwise they wouldn't be in social housing would they?

OP posts:
Spinachtastegud · 11/04/2022 16:23

Ericaequitas you are right imo....

DoorWasAJar · 11/04/2022 16:23

She does dominatrix online/webcams 😃

Runningupthecurtains · 11/04/2022 16:22

@CoralPaperweight

It's interesting the number of people on this thread who have been retired or know someone who has retired on 'ill-health' grounds. IME this is extremely rare these days even in the public sector. Having known colleagues who have had brain tumours and significant chronic illnesses, the default position is to make adjustments/ offer another type of role rather than retirement.
In the case of neighbour my understanding (and I could be mistaken/misremembering) is that either it was a condition of the critical illness payment or the fact that the payout had cleared their mortgage meant she didn't have to work anymore and the necessary adjustments would have been significant (despite that fact you would have no idea from seeing her in the street, meeting her at the WI etc). So as they were financially OK (but not in any way wealthy) with the payment she doesn't work because they wouldn't have been OK 20 years ago when she couldn't work and the kids were school age without that money.
Cornettoninja · 11/04/2022 16:20

@Ericaequites

Why isn’t need for social housing for under 65s reevaluated every 24-36 months? This way, those whose circumstances have significantly improved could be asked to leave within 120-180 days, freeing up places for those in genuine need. Social housing is not a right; it’s a form of social welfare.
I suspect that for the majority whose circumstances improve it’s not in a particularly significant way given the cost of housing, cost of living vs wages.

I would guess that removal of social housing would plunge a lot of people back into poverty and debt.

I don’t think the answer is to put up more barriers to social housing, I think we need more of it. We live in an aspirational consumerist society, I actually think a lot of people would use it as a stepping stone to secure private housing arrangements.

Laburnam · 11/04/2022 16:16

She's a neighbour is it really that important??

catmothertes1 · 11/04/2022 16:14

@chipsandpeas

maybe they have won/inherited enough to stop/reduce working but not enough to buy somewhere

tbh its really none of your business

Exactly what I thought.
In any case,it sounds as if the woman and her family are not splashing the cash around,they are just living a quiet life and it's really none of the OP's business.
AngelicaElizaAndPeggy · 11/04/2022 16:13

She's clearly one of these things:

  1. in the pay of the Peaky Blinders
  2. a secret oligarch
  3. shit hot at trading Forex in her guest bedroom at night.
IncompleteSenten · 11/04/2022 16:13

If she's on the old social housing tenancy then she could indeed win the lottery or receive a massive inheritance and not be asked to leave.

I think either some new tenancies are income dependant or at least that was suggested, not quite sure.

You should stop talking to other people about it. They are telling you to mind your own business and they will form a very negative opinion of you if you're not careful.

For whatever reason, she has more money than you. Lots of people do. And lots have less. Focus on your own life.

Ricksteinsfishwife · 11/04/2022 16:12

@SoyaChai

It's a VERY ugly and pointless trait.

True, but it's also a natural feeling. You've really never felt jealous? Never thought "oh wow, I wish I could afford a dress like that" or thought "this house is miles better than mine, I wish mine could look like this". Because that's jealously too, just not in the same league as OPs.

I’ve felt jealous but never like the op no, I’ve never felt resentful, bitter, or obsessed about someone like this. I think trying to normalise it does rhe op no favours. As humans we have many negative emotions, anger, bitterness, vengeful, desire to be cruel, , desire for violence. It’s on us to control it, to understand it’s unacceptable and to manage accordingly. Not to feed it.
Babyroobs · 11/04/2022 16:10

@Ericaequites

Why isn’t need for social housing for under 65s reevaluated every 24-36 months? This way, those whose circumstances have significantly improved could be asked to leave within 120-180 days, freeing up places for those in genuine need. Social housing is not a right; it’s a form of social welfare.
Yes totally agree with this.
CoralPaperweight · 11/04/2022 16:10

It's interesting the number of people on this thread who have been retired or know someone who has retired on 'ill-health' grounds. IME this is extremely rare these days even in the public sector. Having known colleagues who have had brain tumours and significant chronic illnesses, the default position is to make adjustments/ offer another type of role rather than retirement.

mathanxiety · 11/04/2022 16:09

Why not take steps to improve your own circumstances instead of inviting the green eyed monster into your life?

Debt counseling might be an option for you. Apologies if you're already doing some sort of programme.

worriedatthistime · 11/04/2022 16:08

@Ericaequites its not social welfare its paid by the tenant bot you the taxpayer, you obviously have no idea about socia housing and how it works and why we have it do you

TruthieRuthie · 11/04/2022 16:08

@thisplaceisweird

I'm not going to be kind, I think you're a nosy jealous cow. Back off and leave the woman alone!

It's not her fault you're miserable, why don't you spend your energy trying to make your own life better?

This. Absolutely this. Well said.
LovelyYellowLabrador · 11/04/2022 16:07

Once your mortgage is paid off she will be still paying rent I guess

SoyaChai · 11/04/2022 16:05

It's a VERY ugly and pointless trait.

True, but it's also a natural feeling. You've really never felt jealous? Never thought "oh wow, I wish I could afford a dress like that" or thought "this house is miles better than mine, I wish mine could look like this". Because that's jealously too, just not in the same league as OPs.

IvorCutler · 11/04/2022 16:04

This is life. Get over yourself.

Calennig · 11/04/2022 16:03

As for what income....inheritance, pension from retirement on ill-health grounds, lottery win...

These would be obvious answers - it's also possible she runs a p/t bussiness she doesn't want to talk to OP about -buying/selling, writing, painting something OP can't see her do but she can do to her own timetable.

We have mutual friends in our 2 groups, and she is the only one who 'retired' at 45! I have spoken to a couple of women in the group about this, and they said it's nobody's business but hers. I know they're right
You've asked her asked her friends and now started a thread on MN about it all - seems very OTT. Hoenstly I wonder if she winding you up with some of her comments.

I suspect though this yet another dig at social housing and HA housing. We did private rental for years and it is shit and it should have more protection for both renters and landlords - but I'm still glad HA exists as it helped my siblings get out of dangerous situations and gives them some stability - it's not the free ride some make out on here but it's better and more secure than private renting and IMO should be expanded.

SoyaChai · 11/04/2022 16:02

And if I were that friend I’d tell you to mind your own business.

This is just bizarre to me. This is something that wouldn't be considered rude in my friend group, the "mind your own business" answer would be considered more rude than simply asking Confused

Although, yeah, they aren't really friends, just neighbours, although it sounds as if this woman enjoys gloating about it and making people wonder.

CaliforniaDrumming · 11/04/2022 16:02

Lol at the woman being a high class call girl. Are call girls usually 50 years old?

coconuthead · 11/04/2022 15:56

@Octomore

I think this all stems from the fact that you have an expectation of being superior to the social housing tenants, and that expectation has been thwarted. If she was living in a privately owned mansion, you wouldn't be questioning it, you'd just assume she was lucky to have inherited or something.

It's the fact that she should be inferior to you and have a worse life than you (in your eyes), but somehow she has managed to have a better life than you, that is grating on you.

In other words, you're being a snob.

This.
Ericaequites · 11/04/2022 15:52

Why isn’t need for social housing for under 65s reevaluated every 24-36 months? This way, those whose circumstances have significantly improved could be asked to leave within 120-180 days, freeing up places for those in genuine need. Social housing is not a right; it’s a form of social welfare.

internetpersonme · 11/04/2022 15:51

@MrsWinters

I’d be annoyed that sock housing is supposed to be for those in need and is a limited supply and this woman chooses not to work whilst taking a valuable national resource. She hasn’t paid her dues-she’s a CF taking from society when she doesn’t NEED it
How do you know this though? Without knowing her medical history etc? My friend gets benefits and social housing. Had a brain tumour 15 years ago. You would never know to look at her ie if you were a nosey neigbour just seeing her pottering about the garden twitching your nets, but shes still on a lot of medication and sleeps a lot its really affected her fine motor skills too. I suppose you've disclosed all your medical and financial business to your neighbours have you?
ClemDanFango · 11/04/2022 15:47

Jealousy is a normal human emotion. As long as you don’t allow it to affect your behaviour towards the object of your jealousy allow yourself to feel it and work through it.
Try and focus on your own life and making changes that enhance its quality which is much more productive than expending energy and headspace on this woman’s set up.

saraclara · 11/04/2022 15:44

My late husband's retirement at 50 was on ill health grounds. No-one who didn't know him well would have had reason to think there was anything wrong with him. But no-one would have wanted to swap places with him had they known the reason. If you'd pried into his life I'd have been livid, and I hope his friends would have told you to fuck off.

Swipe left for the next trending thread