Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel jealous and irrationally annoyed by this woman's life?

436 replies

WalkingAcrossAFord · 11/04/2022 10:29

Name change for this, as I don't want it linking to my other posts.

I met this woman (my neighbour,) 3 years ago when DH and I moved into this village. DH and I have been to the pub a few times with her and her DH, and she attends 2 of the same village groups as me. She is 2 years younger than me (I'm 52, she is 50,) and she is very proud of the fact that she doesn't work, and never intends to again.

She says she 'retired' at 46 after 30 years of working and has 'paid her dues.' She said it's wonderful to not have to work, and to never have to work again.

She lives in social housing (nice cottage too, on the edge of the village overlooking fields,) and her DH works part time - 4 days a week in a supermarket, and I just can't fathom how she does is/how they do it. They have a 5 year old car, and a 25 y.o. DD who is getting married in September, and they're giving them £5000 towards the wedding. They have also just booked a holiday to Greece for June!

I've said a few times 'you must be good with money, and very good at saving,' and even once said 'how do you do it, do you cope OK with one wage?' She just smiled and said 'we do all right. I have got my own income thanks.' What income would someone get in their late 40s? Confused Can't be a pension!

I am actually annoyed at myself for feeling this way. I have another 15 years to work in a job I absolutely loathe. DH and myself don't have a pot to piss in, we have a car that's 20 years old that's held together with sellotape, and our mortgage makes up 45% of our joint salary(s.) DH and I work 45-50 hours a week some weeks, and never get any surplus income because there is always something to pay for, and ALWAYS something going wrong with our bloody house.

We have mutual friends in our 2 groups, and she is the only one who 'retired' at 45! I have spoken to a couple of women in the group about this, and they said it's nobody's business but hers. I know they're right, but I can't get rid of this deep resentment I have for her. She has the best life; finished work in her mid 40s, potters around their huge garden, goes for walks and bike rides, meets up with friends and family/her DD once a week, draws and paints and writes, sunbathes all day (some days) on the lawn in the summer, and sometimes lies in til 10am! I have been at work for 2 hours at that point!

AIBU to feel irrationally annoyed by this woman? She seems to have a blessed life, and I don't know how she does it. It CAN'T be an inheritance or big lottery win, otherwise they wouldn't be in social housing would they?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Villagewaspbyke · 15/04/2022 15:18

@mathanxiety yes. Because we are all paying for them to live there in houses much larger than they need when homeless families are in one room in temporary accommodation. The housing budget is finite and should not be allocated so much in favour of the elderly just because they turn out to vote

Villagewaspbyke · 15/04/2022 15:14

@ToothGrinder - you haven’t really understood the link you posted. Government subsidies to house builders are to build affordable housing or to individuals to help them buy it (so called “Help to Buy”). Actually private builders pay to build a lot of affordable housing and schools etc as part of planning conditions. That housing is then handed over to councils and housing associations to rent at below market rent. But what isn’t happening is that house builders are being generally subsidized to build housing to sell to individuals.

One reason the current government prefers to fund the private sector to build affordable homes is that they commissioned a study showing that the private sector built homes at less than half the cost of the public sector.

We need more housing and can’t afford to vastly overpay to build it.

whitewashing · 14/04/2022 15:26

How she funds her lifestyle or where she lives isn’t any of your business. If you dared to ask me about how I managed my finances, you’d be dropped like a hot potato. Keep your nose OUT.

AliceAbsolum · 14/04/2022 15:16

Only fans. 100%

mathanxiety · 14/04/2022 15:08

'Better allocation' is a recipe for social disaster in communities.

What you're suggesting is older people be removed from homes they have spent their lives in, from gardens they have worked and often beautified, from jobs in the locality, from friends they've made, churches they attend, children and grandchildren who live nearby, and all of their social support networks.

ToothGrinder · 12/04/2022 18:32

@Villagewaspbyke bit disingenuous. Yes the government gives grants to social housing providers but it also gives grants, top ups and incentives to commercial housebuilders - four times as much as councils and HAs get. The substantial subsidy same as the substantial subsidy tenants get via help with rent money involves public money being handed to commercial companies and investors.

www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/affordable-housing-spending-private-tory-government-a7945616.html

Villagewaspbyke · 12/04/2022 16:28

@MaryAndHerNet - I also do think tenancies for life in subsidized housing is an issue when we have such a shortage of affordable housing. I don’t think the answer is as crude as to end the tenancy but I do think large discounts to buy council housing should be stopped and I don’t think it’s fair that pensioners get housing benefit to cover much larger council properties than they need when they are usually precisely the people who need to downsize. There is a crisis of affordable housing in the country and better allocation has to play a part in the solution imo.

Villagewaspbyke · 12/04/2022 16:19

@JustLyra and @MaryAndHerNet housing associations and council housing is subsidized. I used to work in this area. Block grants of billions each year are paid to these organizations to subsidize them (abs that’s not including any housing benefits for rent, funding to build houses in the first place, tax advantage status of these entities). You might not like it but housing associations and councils are subsidized from central government to provide housing. That’s literally the point of organizations who provide affordable housing!

I’m not saying I don’t agree with it (I do) just that it’s a fact that public housing is subsidized.

SierpinskiSquare · 12/04/2022 09:26

@Molecule

You need to make friends with the local gossips. They’ll have an idea (or two) as to how she funds her lifestyle. You’ll just have to accept the fact they will gossip about you too.
I think OP IS the local gossip 😅

OP, fair play for admitting you are being unreasonable. I get why it must be jarring but there is nothing you can do about it. Lots of people get inheritances or have private incomes. It's not unusual.

You really must stop asking her about it or talking to other people about it. Appearances can be very deceptive anyway.

MaryAndHerNet · 12/04/2022 08:19

As for judgement I’d be judging her for using social housing when she no longer needs to and can afford private. Weirdly there are no rules against this but it’s morally wrong

What a dumb comment, and here's why:

Imagine, of you're able, a family of 2 parents and 2 kids. They're homeless in a hostel.
They're awarded a tenancy from a housing association. For the first time in 3 years they have a home and not a hostel.

Now what?

Do they:
A) find work and improve their lots and improve their kids lives. Afford some treats like holidays.
Or
B) do nothing, be unemployed, they've learned the system since being made homeless, they know how it works.

Now think, if someone said that family,
"If you earn more than £20k a year, you'll have to give up your Housing Association House"
Do you think that would encourage option A or option B?

It's not difficult when you think logically about it to see how stupid it would be and how much better, morally speaking, it is to support the people to better themselves and make them feel as secure as possible.

CharSiu · 12/04/2022 08:18

I was retired through ill health at 50 and receive my full work pension which is really quite a decent amount and I have another small one from my very first job but I’m leaving it currently. I also make some money from my investments. DH does still work FT and does have a well paid job.,

So I’m quite like this friend of yours that you actively dislike but I would give anything to have my health back. I’m stable now but I almost died a few years ago and need monitoring etc for the rest of my life.

JustDanceAddict · 12/04/2022 07:54

Probably inheritance. But really it’s none of your business!

Octomore · 12/04/2022 07:54

Totally agree JustLyra and MaryAndHerNet

2DogsOnMySofa · 12/04/2022 07:53

My friends partner gave up work in his 30s. They live in rented accommodation because they couldn't afford to buy, my friend works in a school. He came into a large inheritance and takes out £1000 a month that he puts towards the bills. He'll end up coming unstuck at some point tho, as he's not invested any of the capital and it's slowly reducing. He's not paid into NI so he's fucked his pension and eventually he'll have to work. I think he's relying on my friend getting so fed up that she'll buy a house and he'll move in. He's got another 8 years max of not working before it all dries up. I guess the reason for telling you this is don't compare yourself to others, she might seem happy and 'together' but you just don't know what goes on behind closed doors

JustLyra · 12/04/2022 07:52

It's a pretty efficient system really and overall it costs the country a lot less than paying housing benefit to top up private sector rents to the levels that private landlords are looking for.

Exactly.

And when there’s a good amount of it it helps stop private rents getting silly.

There was a raft of new social housing round here over the last couple of years. It really helped shake everything up. Decent landlords that don’t charge crazy amounts and have decent properties weren’t affected. My tenant moved and I found another one very easily (in fact they were put in touch with me by the HA as they’d just missed out - they likely will moved before long and it’s known I’ll not rip them off).

The scumbag landlord downstairs who charged an eye watering amount for a place that was mouldy and grim couldn’t find tenants. His place was sold and he still grumbles to this day about the subsidised housing that put him out of business.

Social housing should be more of a thing.
When my grandparents were married where they lived was all social housing. You went down and told them when you were getting wed and they told you where you could have and when.

People paid a fair amount for decent quality homes. That’s how it should be. Houses don’t have to be a massive profit earner for everyone.

Hesma · 12/04/2022 07:45

YABU, YABV rude, get on with your own life OP and leave the poor woman be

Ricksteinsfishwife · 12/04/2022 07:43

@Waferbiscuit

Op it is unusual to be retired at mid 40s and one is bound to be curious. In instances like this i say ‘follow the penis’ - most women’s wealth comes from men either a husbands income or inheritance from a man. Sad but true.

As for judgement I’d be judging her for using social housing when she no longer needs to and can afford private. Weirdly there are no rules against this but it’s morally wrong.

What a sexist mysogynistic answer. Do you mean the penis who works four days a week down Tesco?

And there is nothing at all to say this woman can afford private and doesn’t need social housing. A one off five grand to her child and a holiday to Greece doesn’t mean you’re some wealthy woman living off sone man. Other than that she lives very frugally and there are many reasons she might not be able to work.

I actually can’t believe someone even wrote that. I really hope it wasn’t another woman.

MaryAndHerNet · 12/04/2022 07:39

This whole myth that social housing is subsidised needs to die once and for all.

Agreed.
There also seems to be a myth that Housing Associations just hand out tenancies to anyone, not the case.

At some point, OPs neighbour applied and must have been assessed as in need and awarded the tenancy.

Also the myth that HA homes are secure. Nope. I'm HA tenant, we have a tenancy. The HA will threaten your tenancy to make you toe the line. Happens often and over such things as your grass being a bit long, bin being a bit full, car parked wrong etc.
As HA tenants tend to be at the lower end of incomes, it'd mean homeless if evicted so homelessness is a very real shadow for a lot of HA people.

ToothGrinder · 12/04/2022 07:38

This whole myth that social housing is subsidised needs to die once and for all.

Agree with what you say. Obviously HA rents have to cover costs including staffing costs. Nobody is getting subsidised.

If the houses have been standing for any more than around 20 years the cost of building is now well recouped and the rent money the HA gets can all go towards maintenance and investment in future social housing builds. This will be how this couple's rent money is getting used.

It's a pretty efficient system really and overall it costs the country a lot less than paying housing benefit to top up private sector rents to the levels that private landlords are looking for.

Octomore · 12/04/2022 07:34

@Waferbiscuit

Op it is unusual to be retired at mid 40s and one is bound to be curious. In instances like this i say ‘follow the penis’ - most women’s wealth comes from men either a husbands income or inheritance from a man. Sad but true.

As for judgement I’d be judging her for using social housing when she no longer needs to and can afford private. Weirdly there are no rules against this but it’s morally wrong.

But you don't actually know that she can afford to buy a house, do you?

Her lifestyle sounds very modest, so her income might well be very low.

Octomore · 12/04/2022 07:32

Who will ever really care, except pusillanimous you.

I don't think that word means what you think it does.

JustLyra · 12/04/2022 07:26

Plus @basdonamosla if the neighbour was really at anything dodgy what are the odds of her husband working 4 days a week in a supermarket?

It’s far more likely she has a legitimate source of income and has just declined to share financial details with her nosy fucker neighbour

JustLyra · 12/04/2022 07:24

@basdonamosla

I don’t understand people saying it’s “none of your business” when it’s our taxes that are going to subsidise someone’s accommodation who has been able to “retire” at 46’ due to some unknown source of funds. It’s our business and we need to do something about such an unjust system.
You’re not subsidising her. This whole myth that social housing is subsidised needs to die once and for all.

HA’s charge the rent they need to charge to do their repairs and fund improvements. Just because they don’t rip the arse out of tenants like many landlords does not make them subsidised by tax payers

HangingRock25 · 12/04/2022 07:13

@Coyoacan

It is sad that you are miserable because of your neighbour's good fortune. I bet you are really enjoying the war in Ukraine
Gees, that's harsh and unfair!
Coyoacan · 12/04/2022 03:19

It is sad that you are miserable because of your neighbour's good fortune. I bet you are really enjoying the war in Ukraine

Swipe left for the next trending thread