Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Appointment with GP - heart sunk

261 replies

MarriedThreeChildren · 11/04/2022 10:12

Had an appointment last week with my GP. I’ve had a bad flare up from a chronic illness.

Went through everything, agreed to be referred back to hospital consultant. And then came the killer question

Do you have an insurance and want to go private or are we going NHS?

With the clear feeling that really the ‘right’ answer was going private :(:(

Since when is the NHS pushing patients to go private? Not so long ago it was such a big No-No. No GP would ever ask that question as a routine question. Rather people would ask if they knew they could get quicker/see who they wanted to see.

But here we go. The system is so fucked up that GPS are now trying to push people to go private rather than NHS.

I find it extremely worrying (I mean which insurance will ever cover me with a chronic condition that has been there for 15 years anyway??). Is it now the only way to get some decent medical support?
I have no idea when I will be able to see the consultant. GP ‘wasn’t aware about the lead times’ (last time I went to see them the wait was about 1 years. It was pre covid etc…. So I suspect…. much more than that…)

OP posts:
itsjustnotok · 11/04/2022 11:58

OP why are you letting a basic question make you feel forced? It’s your right to chose whichever and let’s face it do they really know your finances or insurances? I have an insurance i forgot about and if they hadn’t of asked I would have been paying it for nothing.

Gwenhwyfar · 11/04/2022 11:57

"It works because the doctors concerned are usually seeing private patients outside their contracted NHS hours. Simple as that, it has no impact on how many NHS patients they see."

As long as they are full time for the NHS I suppose.

SheWasNuts · 11/04/2022 11:56

22 years ago (I remember because DC1 wasn't yet crawling & I had to do a nappy change) I was around at a colleague's house chatting about her cancer diagnosis. Colleague was a secretary, no huge income. Colleague was unhappy because she & husband were quite Labour voting but had gone private (with an NHS consultant) for assessment to fast track her assessment/earliest possible diagnosis. So it was well-established thing in 2000, too, leapfrogging into the system like that.

PILs always had modest means then MIL very unexpectedly inherited +100k. Am pretty sure that soon after that FIL had a hip replacement done privately in 2001 -- he had stubbornly refused to acknowledge his increasing hip problems until he was almost housebound, never even tried to get on an NHS list.

Darkstar4855 · 11/04/2022 11:56

I don’t think it’s anything new tbh. When I needed to see a knee specialist in 2006 I was encouraged by the GP to go private for the first appointment as the waiting lists in Wales were so long.

Doggirl · 11/04/2022 11:52

Not all self-employed people but a number have it as it makes sense for them.

DF went this route, in 2000 and 2006, for hip replacements. His job involved walking, so (leaving aside pain etc.) if he couldn't walk, he couldn't earn. If he couldn't earn, then given (AFAIK) there was no unemployment relief for SE, he couldn't have paid the mortgage and would have been on the breadline. I don't suppose any of the people fulminating against private insurance would have been offering to pay his bills.

PlainJaneEyre · 11/04/2022 11:50

If people pay for their treatment as opposed to using the NHS then that is one burden off the system. Some people do have insurance as per their job or private payment and some will pay for a one off investigation then revert back into the NHS. I have done the latter as paying for insurance was just too expensive and paying for an MRI gave me a jump start. These are the facts about health today plus there is a huge backlog of cases left over from Covid. I think doctors like vets and dentists always check this .It's normal.

tiredwardsister · 11/04/2022 11:49

Firstly the private sector does not want and is unable to cope with acute emergencies baring a few hospitals in London and even then if your being scraped off the road the NHS will always be the best place for you because quite simply it has the expertise.
But the private sector is keen to pick up routine stuff e.g. hip replacements and hospital appointments for some chronic illnesses dermatology rheumatology etc because this is where they make their money and they are relatively straight forward.
As a life long NHS worker I am appalled that so many feel forced to the private sector for the more routine stuff because they know the wait in the NHS is too long. My DC requires a easy money making smallish surgical procedure the wait just to see the consultant is 15+ months then he has to go on the waiting list 18 -24 month. He is young and has a chronic condition which although not life threatening is affecting his ability to work. So we will against my every principle pay, when I told colleagues they seem genuinely surprised even the consultant who work in the speciality he needs to see. I live in deepest rural Scotland most people hill farm or work in the tourist industry so wages around here are low so there are no private hospitals for 100 miles so maybe thats why people are surprised. certainly his GP didn't ask him if he wanted to go private or NHS.

Doggirl · 11/04/2022 11:46

What needs to happen is that it is used for the NHS round the clock

In an ideal world, yes. But you would have to deal with a lot of people who don't think medical staff (except those in designated emergency services) should have to work unsociable hours.

I've posted elsewhere about my experience needing an ultrasound out of office hours. I was admitted as an emergency late on a Friday evening, no-one even talked about a scan until I'd been left until early Saturday morning awaiting a bed. They then said no USs were done between noon on Saturday and Monday morning. For an emergency! In a 'world class' London hospital! Because of the backlog, I was finally scanned late on Monday afternoon. I was no longer feeling ill by then, but almost certainly permanent damage had been done.

Andouillette · 11/04/2022 11:44

@Gwenhwyfar

"I taught she would be happy to keep people off NHS lists were possible to speed things up for those who couldn’t afford insurance."

How does that work if it's the same doctor doing the work? It's just jumping the queue.

It works because the doctors concerned are usually seeing private patients outside their contracted NHS hours. Simple as that, it has no impact on how many NHS patients they see.
Wheresthebeach · 11/04/2022 11:41

I agree the NHS is on it's knees and something has to be done (and no...not privatisation). This round of Covid is appalling and we've a backlog that's going to take years to clear. Seems to me that its a sensible question though in the circumstances - the more people that use their private healthcare the less people going through the already over burdened NHS.

EmbarrassingHadrosaurus · 11/04/2022 11:41

@Hersetta427

Maybe that was just a way if you have private medical insurance through work maybe not necessarily asking you to pay out for private treatment
Yes a number of firms provide this. Not all self-employed people but a number have it as it makes sense for them.
Gwenhwyfar · 11/04/2022 11:39

"I taught she would be happy to keep people off NHS lists were possible to speed things up for those who couldn’t afford insurance."

How does that work if it's the same doctor doing the work? It's just jumping the queue.

Andouillette · 11/04/2022 11:37

@Trulyweird1

I am in Scotland. This has been a question asked by GPs for a long time, well before Covid. Back in 2018 I was given the choice of urgent referral on private insurance or 20 week + wait for NHS, for what GP was convinced was a cancer ( she was correct). There is no such thing as urgent in NHS Scotland, unless you are in an ambulance. It totally sucks, and breaks many a medics heart.
So true, and I am very sorry to read that you were on the pointy end of this. Where we are (also Scotland) we still can't see GPs usually and many other things have just fallen by the wayside. A dear friend is experiencing woefully lacking cancer 'care' and mental health care is literally non existant. My already diagnosed DD has had no communication from Psychiatry since 01/21 - not a typo. And the real kicker? No private Psychiatrists within 50 miles even if she/I could afford that.
Cazalet · 11/04/2022 11:32

Just had a video consultation with a private GP for the first time. One of my children needed advice on a condition, decision needed to be made this week as to what to do. Their own GP couldn’t speak/email etc for over a week at best. They were very vague.

I googled and there were a half dozen private GPs near me. Two of them were too busy for new patients (their patients take out annual memberships). Found one who could video consult in a half hour and no problems to write referrals etc the same morning. 20 mins consult and referral email was £90.

The GP was great, very attentive, knowledgable and has helped hugely with decision to be made. Yes I am lucky I could throw money at the problem. I have never done anything like this before.

Point of my post is that I am certain 5 years ago none of these private GP practices existed in my area (not London area).

Doggirl · 11/04/2022 11:31

I would rather GPs (and other medical professionals) were honest about the priority or lack thereof given to things on the NHS--rather than promising a service that doesn't exist.

So many times I or relatives have had referrals forgotten, 'lost', randomly cancelled, not rung back for...I had a GP agree to my referral request, which was a lie as I later found he'd decided not to make iton completely spurious grounds, and he'd decided not to tell me he wasn't making it. That decision would likely have cost my ability to have children if I hadn't chased it upand there's a fair chance it would have ended in me losing my uterus.

In my extended family I have someone who is gradually being crippled by a condition that requires specialist surgery with, granted, no guarantee of success. Most of her communication with doctors so far has been along the lines of "We want you to consider very carefully how you would feel if it didn't work" and "Are you sure your life is really that difficult as it is?" Reasonable questions to ask on their own--but this seems to be pretty much all they're talking about, with what looks like a clear push to get her 'deciding' she doesn't want treatment.

Yes, there are arguments to be had about funding the NHS--but first of all let's have an honest discussion about what the NHS is actually doing and what it sees its role as.

Getupoffthesofa · 11/04/2022 11:31

My go refused to recommend or refer my daughter to a private doctor even after saying that she should be seen quickly - but it wouldn’t be before three weeks on the NHS as there was a wait. She was ideologically against it. That really arsed me off.

SucculentChalice · 11/04/2022 11:29

godmum They will rent facilities in NHS buildings which in effect subsidises the NHS. There is also the little known aspect. Its better for the NHS if clinical equipment is well used so that it wears out and gets replaced with more modern options. Equipment that gets less use and is still in good nick will be at the end of the queue for replacement unless its actually no longer safe. Where I used to work actually had a small ward that was used by private patients. Any NHS resource it used was charged for and made a profit and it was staffed by people employed by the private company. Nurses etc could have both an NHS contract and a private one but could not work on the private ward during their NHS hours and vice versa. The small NHS hospital involved could not have afforded to fund the extra ward and as a matter of fact didn't need the beds as they were moving towards a care at home model. Winner all round

An office or a room in a hospital has no need to be used outwith NHS times and does not suffer due to not being used in this way. And equipment which is used more frequently needs repaired more frequently too which means it is out of use for NHS patients. What needs to happen is that it is used for the NHS round the clock and not by NHS staff using it to make extra money for their private practice.

This is a very unregulated hybrid model and it is typical of the chaos the NHS system causes. The German, Dutch and French systems are far far better and this conflict of interest in the NHS is just an absolute carry on.

godmum56 · 11/04/2022 11:27

@MissyB1

Its often done evenings and weekends when NHS clinic services don't run.

ancientgran · 11/04/2022 11:25

@BoodleBug51

DH went private for cardiac investigations, and it took him to the top of the queue for investigations. Only the treatment he needs isn't available privately, it's only through a specialist NHS unit about 60 miles away. He's been waiting 7 months for "urgent" treatment and only after persistent chasing on my part has been given a date for the end of next month.

So we spent thousands for very little gain, tbh. It was the first thing our GP said too. I think they're just being realistic about the NHS waiting lists to tell the truth.

To be honest I think that is fair enough. Why should your husband jump the queue for the treatment because he could afford the initial tests privately?
godmum56 · 11/04/2022 11:24

[quote MissyB1]@SucculentChalice
Consultants holding private clinics in NHS facilities? Certainly not in my area, all private clinics are done in the Nuffield private hospital. I’ve never heard of any consultants being allowed to use NHS premises to run their clinics 🤔[/quote]
They will rent facilities in NHS buildings which in effect subsidises the NHS. There is also the little known aspect. Its better for the NHS if clinical equipment is well used so that it wears out and gets replaced with more modern options. Equipment that gets less use and is still in good nick will be at the end of the queue for replacement unless its actually no longer safe. Where I used to work actually had a small ward that was used by private patients. Any NHS resource it used was charged for and made a profit and it was staffed by people employed by the private company. Nurses etc could have both an NHS contract and a private one but could not work on the private ward during their NHS hours and vice versa. The small NHS hospital involved could not have afforded to fund the extra ward and as a matter of fact didn't need the beds as they were moving towards a care at home model. Winner all round.

AnnaMagnani · 11/04/2022 11:24

Even Great Ormond Street do this - of course they do, the Trust makes a fortune out of it.

Every NHS Trust that can, has a private wing or consulting rooms to make as much money as possible for the Trust. It certainly isn't the evil consultants making the biggest mint here.

Big name trusts can make mega bucks - people fly in from all over the world to go to the private suite at the Marsden. At UCLH they have a whole floor called 'Harley Street at UCLH'. Moorfields has a whole building over the road from the main hospital for private patients. The list goes on and on.

Even the total nonentity trust I used to work for had a set of rooms for private outpatients and small ward of single rooms for private surgical patients.

Those trusts would be gutted if their NHS consultants weren't doing private work as well to bring in the extra money.

Moodlesofnoodles · 11/04/2022 11:21

I think this is what the government has been aiming for. The NHS not coping to the extent that people feel they have to go private or really suffer. Makes it easier to sell the NHS off to private American healthcare companies and pocket "their share" of the profit.

SucculentChalice · 11/04/2022 11:19

[quote MissyB1]@SucculentChalice
Consultants holding private clinics in NHS facilities? Certainly not in my area, all private clinics are done in the Nuffield private hospital. I’ve never heard of any consultants being allowed to use NHS premises to run their clinics 🤔[/quote]
I just had one last week in an NHS hospital. Lasted 15 minutes, nice little earner for the consultant involved because I couldn't get the appointment within a reasonable time in the NHS.

Its a really well known practice. I'm surprised you haven't heard of it.

MissyB1 · 11/04/2022 11:19

[quote Rubyupbeat]@MissyB1
It is a done thing, they hire NHS rooms and theatres, which I guess helps the hospital out. Even Great Ormand street do this.[/quote]
Wow, I suppose they must have the space. We certainly don’t.

godmum56 · 11/04/2022 11:16

sorry but I think you are overthinking this although I understand why. There are many reasons why the GP would ask the question and none of them are to do with pushing the privatisation of the NHS.