Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Appointment with GP - heart sunk

261 replies

MarriedThreeChildren · 11/04/2022 10:12

Had an appointment last week with my GP. I’ve had a bad flare up from a chronic illness.

Went through everything, agreed to be referred back to hospital consultant. And then came the killer question

Do you have an insurance and want to go private or are we going NHS?

With the clear feeling that really the ‘right’ answer was going private :(:(

Since when is the NHS pushing patients to go private? Not so long ago it was such a big No-No. No GP would ever ask that question as a routine question. Rather people would ask if they knew they could get quicker/see who they wanted to see.

But here we go. The system is so fucked up that GPS are now trying to push people to go private rather than NHS.

I find it extremely worrying (I mean which insurance will ever cover me with a chronic condition that has been there for 15 years anyway??). Is it now the only way to get some decent medical support?
I have no idea when I will be able to see the consultant. GP ‘wasn’t aware about the lead times’ (last time I went to see them the wait was about 1 years. It was pre covid etc…. So I suspect…. much more than that…)

OP posts:
Theredjellybean · 11/04/2022 15:11

I cannot see how the GP "was pushing"
Really bizzare... Your post has a tone of the GP was in the wrong asking you... Honestly as a GP, my heart sinks when I know a pt is in for a long wait and I will always ask if they have insurance.
My heart sinks even more when I read another stealth bash the GP thread

SVRT19674 · 11/04/2022 15:11

Some posters have a point though. My aunt was kept waiting for years for a knee replacement and when she got it the other knee was crap as it had to take more weight and over compensate. She waited in awful pain for some years for the second knee replacement and when she got it the surgeon visited her after the op to apologise to her because her knee was in such a bad state that the bone was crumbling as he worked with it. He told her it should never have been allowed to get to that state. The strong pain killers those years ruined her stomach also. If that first knee replacement had been done on time though...She still thinks the nhs is marvelous because she didnt have to pay. I did have to mention there is a middle ground between what she got and the American system. What she got was substandard.

ArtVandalay · 11/04/2022 14:59

Tbf, it’s nothing new.

My dh had various procedures 10-15 years ago and was advised my his GP to go private every time. I think it’s a good thing as it takes him off waiting lists and frees up his space for those without insurance.

Doggirl · 11/04/2022 14:47

No, you don't get a tax discount if you pay for private healthcare, but nor do you get one if you you don't need the NHS because you are never Ill.

But it is reasonable to question oneself about taxes if you pay them in but still don't get any benefit where needed.

I had to pay over £10k for surgery that I needed to restore my health and fertility. I've never had insurance and am on national median wage, but at least had savings.

Because such things are only likely to become more common as I get older, and I now have a DD who might also need private care before she's able to pay for it myself, I now make damn sure to stick every penny I can into an ISA.

Tillsforthrills · 11/04/2022 14:44

@Horcruxe

She wasn’t blaming the GP

Mogs43 · 11/04/2022 14:42

What is happening in some areas is very worrying and I feel so sorry for those experiencing a poor. service.

I went to my GP for help with mental health issues , as you are advised to do. He was lovely prescribed medication but said that waiting times were so long for specialist help (which he felt that I needed) that unless I paid privately I would be waiting years. I don't have insurance with work so have had to self fund for over a year - £400 an hour to see a psychiatrist (who also works for the same NHS Trust I would have seen through an NHS referral). It is crazy, has resulted in debt and causes all sorts of issues in terms of who is responsible for what (medication, med certs etc) but unfortunately where I live it appears there just aren't sufficient NHS services. Very frustrating when there are adverts telling you to go for help but it just doesn't exist. I know that there are better NHS services in other parts of the country but my own experience has been concerning and I feel so sorry for others going through something similar.

godmum56 · 11/04/2022 14:40

@SucculentChalice
not only do you not get any kind of discount for holding private medical insurance, you actually pay insurance premium tax.

SucculentChalice · 11/04/2022 14:39

Fifthtimelucky No, you don't get a tax discount if you pay for private healthcare, but nor do you get one if you you don't need the NHS because you are never Ill.

Similarly, you don't get a discount if you don't need schools - either because you pay for private education for your children or you don't have any children.

That's the point of taxation and the welfare state. Thankfully, what we take out of the system isn't related to what we pay in. I suspect that over our lifetimes many of us (especially those of us with children) won't pay enough in tax to cover what we take out.

Yes, I am aware of that. I don't need the basics of how a tax system works explains to me.

I did however previously live in another European country which provides a much higher standard of healthcare cover through a private insurance system, without the NHS. That to me, is a far better allocation of resources by the state and a far better return on the tax i pay. I do object to paying twice - once through general taxation and once privately - to get standard care in the rest of the developed world without a 3 year wait.

The NHS is in out of date, inefficient and often grossly negligent system. Its a poor performer and its so bad that entrusting my future health to it as I age is enough to make me want to retire abroad (and yes I do know how several of the foreign systems work and they would still suit me better).

Doggirl · 11/04/2022 14:39

Her response "because you'll be seen quicker, this service isn't seen as a priority so the waiting lists are very long."

See, this is where I wish the NHS would be honest, and save people waiting about for stuff the NHS doesn't really want to do.
The NHS does some basic things well--eg universal vaccinations are OK. And at the other end of the spectrum, if you have a diagnosed life-threatening condition needing intricate surgery, the treatment can be world class.

It's the stuff in the middle where it falls down. Where you're not going to die (or at least that's what your diagnosis says) but your life is going to be more miserable without treatment. And where if you're offered treatment at all, it won't to restore full function but to restore a bit of it. (See the report of the relevant Parliamentary Group in 2018, where many women in their reproductive years were pushed hysterectomies for gynae conditions, even though this should only be an absolute last resort.)

Fifthtimelucky · 11/04/2022 14:35

@SucculentChalice

I know several people who have had to go private to get extremely painful conditions dealt with (hip replacement, cataract surgery, knee injuries) due to ridiculously long waiting lists on the NHS. When you factor into account that going private is not unusual and it offers you no discount on the tax you pay for the NHS, in reality many people in this country are paying twice for healthcare. Which makes it one of the most expensive systems in the world (and our private sector is less developed and therefore more expensive due to the NHS).

Its also a clear professional conflict of interest and banned in other professions. The fact that some consultants use NHS facilities to hold private clinics one day a week is utterly ridiculous.

No, you don't get a tax discount if you pay for private healthcare, but nor do you get one if you you don't need the NHS because you are never Ill.

Similarly, you don't get a discount if you don't need schools - either because you pay for private education for your children or you don't have any children.

That's the point of taxation and the welfare state. Thankfully, what we take out of the system isn't related to what we pay in. I suspect that over our lifetimes many of us (especially those of us with children) won't pay enough in tax to cover what we take out.

Tamrastarr · 11/04/2022 14:35

I used to have private medical through work, and whenever I mentioned it to my doctor he seemed to try and direct me down the NHS route. I would expect that if you had private cover it would make sense to take some of the strain of the NHS and use it. I admit that this was around 10 years ago though

HN400 · 11/04/2022 14:29

That’s terrible the gp asked you that. I also have a chronic illness and have never been asked that question and would be just as concerned as you. While being diagnosed I had private insurance so I’ve seen both sides of treatment. What’s interesting was that it’s the exact same consultant I saw privately as I did on the NHS. And with regards to waiting times, I honestly found there to not be much difference. When I went full nhs and needed urgent surgery, I was even sent to a private hospital for it due to waiting times being too long. And majority of my appointments were also at a different private hospital because of the same reason. But that’s my experience. I will say my gp has always been very good at making sure I’ve been seen quickly (nhs) when necessary though. Will be interesting to see if this is some sort of common practice now of asking patients or just this particular gp you saw felt the need to ask you this

NurseButtercup · 11/04/2022 14:27

[quote MarriedThreeChildren]@JinglingHellsBells can I ask

Where is your evidence that they had been doing that for years?
Do you have a time line as to when they started to ask if one has private health insurance?

The level of cognitive dissonance on this thread is quite a thing. Soon I will be told that the NHS has always asked if they can go private etc… that people have always gone private even to see a GP etc…

Fwiw if this had been something so usual, I wouldn’t have been taken by surprise by the question….
Because, you know, they would have asked that to the many previous appointments have had for that chronic condition…[/quote]
I remember being asked the question by my GP approx 20-25yrs ago. It was a teaching practice so they had links with the local university. When I was asked, I had the foresight to ask my GP "why are you asking me if I have private healthcare?". Her response "because you'll be seen quicker, this service isn't seen as a priority so the waiting lists are very long."

I did go private for the initial consultation, but received treatment via NHS after waiting for 8 months.

My current GP has never asked me this question. And I've had appts with my GP pre & post the covid19 pandemic.

The point I'm attempting to get across is; I don't believe there is a huge conspiracy to push everyone to private healthcare. It depends upon the GP you've seen, it depends upon their knowledge base and what they've been reading, which will in turn determine if they ask you if you've got private healthcare. From what I can see, the main agenda being pushed by NHS England (and they're ignoring socioeconomic factors with this agenda), is for people to be more accountable & proactive in managing their health & mental well-being, by adopting healthy lifestyle choices and accessing the plethora of self help resources.

VanGoghsDog · 11/04/2022 14:26

@Doggirl

Oh, and DF and being SE. Given that this was over 20 years ago, I don't know what benefits he'd have been able to get if he'd been unable to work. It would have been difficult even short-term for someone in his 60s--and with waits as they were, it could have been months. Also of course, by him getting his op sooner he was able to be back out working and contributing taxes again. Someone who is languishing unable to work is by definition not funding the NHS.
Yes, of course, that's all part of the equation.

But I was only responding to the part I actually commented on, and on the current rules. None of that negates what I posted.

VanGoghsDog · 11/04/2022 14:24

For those with a prescription pass or for whom they're free, this makes sense.

However the OTC costs might be worth it for some who might not want to attend in person appointments and take time off work.

Pill prescriptions are always free so the pre pay cert is irrelevant to this situation.

Also, you need an in person appointment once a year to take blood pressure etc, other than that they can be supplied on repeat. Free.

ajandjjmum · 11/04/2022 14:23

[quote Rubyupbeat]@MissyB1
It is a done thing, they hire NHS rooms and theatres, which I guess helps the hospital out. Even Great Ormand street do this.[/quote]
Great Ormond Street has a private wing - DS stayed there. It seemed to be used largely by oversees patients.

I remember my mother being asked whether I was to have surgery privately or on the NHS - I was around 7, and am in my 60's now, so certainly not a new thing.

By the same token, the consultant who saw us when DS was born (we had private cover) emphasised that the treatment he received would be exactly the same whether he was a private or NHS patient. Gave us great comfort at the time.

EmbarrassingHadrosaurus · 11/04/2022 14:22

@StayAGhost

I'm still aghast from my recent NHS audiology appointment Discuss options for suitable hearing aids Registrar had a laminated sheet, with photos and advantages and disadvantages for each model Along with their price!! SadAngryHmm
Weren't you offered any choices through the NHS?

I understand the discussion of options as this is part of the shared decision making process. Different features matter more to some people than others.

iloveeverykindofcat · 11/04/2022 14:22

A while ago I was advised to go private to get a test for something that may or may not have been something serious. Then it did turn out to be serious, I'd get faster NHS treatment. Otherwise I'd have to wait for the test on the NHS...by which time....it could be serious :S.

It was a moot point anyway because I got a cancellation slot and it turned out not to be the serious thing but damn. Puts it in perspective doesn't it.

godmum56 · 11/04/2022 14:17

@StayAGhost

I'm still aghast from my recent NHS audiology appointment Discuss options for suitable hearing aids Registrar had a laminated sheet, with photos and advantages and disadvantages for each model Along with their price!! SadAngryHmm
why not. There are much better hearing aids available privately than on the NHS so why not tell you?
Doggirl · 11/04/2022 14:17

Oh, and DF and being SE. Given that this was over 20 years ago, I don't know what benefits he'd have been able to get if he'd been unable to work. It would have been difficult even short-term for someone in his 60s--and with waits as they were, it could have been months.
Also of course, by him getting his op sooner he was able to be back out working and contributing taxes again. Someone who is languishing unable to work is by definition not funding the NHS.

godmum56 · 11/04/2022 14:16

@knittingaddict

10 years ago, you could get a quicker appointment but you weren’t told to go private to have a cancer diagnosed. It was about not a thing to wait and about having ‘special treatment’ and jumping the NHS queue. It was often NOT about going private as such.

2 years ago, I was simply referred back to the consultant. Was told it would be a year (ended up being less).
2 years ago I was referred to a heart specialist within weeks, had a 24 hour monitor etc…

Never has a GP asked if I had a private health insurance rather than going on the NHS waiting list. Despite a few scares, incl cancer, heart problems etc….

You might not have experienced it, but 14 years ago my husband did. He chose NHS to start with and then had to switch to private due to the NHS making a mess of his referral. I spoke about it in a previous post on here.

same story here...it seems like a lot of us have had similar experiences. I can't prove it but belive that the NHS screw ups contributed to his death
Silverclocks · 11/04/2022 14:16

Private schemes worry me too though.

I know three people who've recently had what could well be unnecessary surgery and I have a friend who's had the same recurring foot problem as me for the last 3 years. I've "managed" mine following on-line advice and she's had numerous costly interventions through her insurance. She's in a far worse state than I am now, some of the treatments seem to have made things worse. She never sees any specialist and comes away without needing something costly doing.

StayAGhost · 11/04/2022 14:16

YANBU

StayAGhost · 11/04/2022 14:15

I'm still aghast from my recent NHS audiology appointment
Discuss options for suitable hearing aids
Registrar had a laminated sheet, with photos and advantages and disadvantages for each model
Along with their price!! SadAngryHmm

godmum56 · 11/04/2022 14:14

@MarriedThreeChildren
"10 years ago, you could get a quicker appointment but you weren’t told to go private to have a cancer diagnosed. It was about not a thing to wait and about having ‘special treatment’ and jumping the NHS queue. It was often NOT about going private as such.

2 years ago, I was simply referred back to the consultant. Was told it would be a year (ended up being less).
2 years ago I was referred to a heart specialist within weeks, had a 24 hour monitor etc…

Never has a GP asked if I had a private health insurance rather than going on the NHS waiting list. Despite a few scares, incl cancer, heart problems etc….

My late husband had his cancer care privately 15 years ago. At the time the GP asked him if he would be using private medicine. He got faster and better care than he would have done in the NHS. Sadly it wasn't enough. He did move between NHS and private care during his illness and every single bloody time he needed the NHS it was a shit show....not because of funding but because of piss poor management and organisation. I worked in the NHS and I know whereof I speak. Its 10 years since he died and I am still angry about it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread