Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to not tell anyone about my ‘legal wedding’?

246 replies

ShotgunSummerWedding · 11/04/2022 09:42

I should be so happy, but I’m so upset by my family’s reaction. I know MN is usually well in favour of the married couple to be doing whatever they wish, but just really want to vent and hear some similar stories. I want to preface this by saying I am my parents only child.

Me and my fiancé are due to welcome our baby girl in June after miscarriages and general misery. This pregnancy is going well and I am feeling a bit more hopeful each day that we will meet her. We really wanted to be married and have a lovely small family wedding before DC, but the first pregnancy was unplanned and stuck us on the TTC treadmill as we tried to regain what we had lost. We thankfully have, and now marriage is back on the cards. Before it stopped being a priority as the only thing I cared about was being pregnant again.

Now I am and we definitely want to get married before the baby is born. First and foremost, we want to be a legal family and cement that before she is here. Practically, we are also worried about the medical aspects of not being each other’s next of kin (particularly if anything goes wrong at birth). My partner is also a foreign national and if we are not married at birth it is notoriously difficult for her to get his citizenship without a lot of paperwork and expense. Financially too, he is worried about me being a SAHM and not having the legal protections of marriage, particularly if he died before we planned a wedding.

So we booked a registry office for next month and have given notice to marry. This would be our ‘legal’ wedding in jeans and trainers, just tick off all of the above. Our witnesses will be two friends. No one else.

I don’t want family there because I am still not very well and I’m terrified that something will happen to my baby. If my family are there then that ceremony becomes my wedding day and it will be forever tainted. Also, my fiancé’s family are not able to travel at the moment and I do not want my MIL and FIL to feel excluded. This ceremony is our legal protection together. Nothing more.

We do want a wedding though. Next year we are then going to take our family and friends on a destination wedding blessing next year and have bridesmaids, a cake, speeches and a nice party. When I am hopefully happier and in a better mental place after my daughter arriving safely.

I told my mother my plans (not set dates, just intentions) and she was furious and unkind. She is usually a lovely, non-toxic person. In her eyes, the vows are the most important thing and she is will be heartbroken if she doesn’t see them. She told me that if I am just going to see my marriage as a piece of paper, then I may as well bin my engagement ring and get a plastic one Confused

She eventually calmed down and sent me a text saying that she was sad, but I needed to do what was right for my family. I though this was her blessing and tried to talk to her a little more ‘would you like to know when we book somewhere?’ ‘Would you like pictures?’ but she quickly got angry and asked to be there. I explained all of the above, and she still didn’t get it and pulled faces. I have tried to get her excited about our ceremony next year, asking about bridesmaid’s dresses and planning dress shopping, but she rolled her eyes and said if my destination wedding guest list was so small then there was no point.

I’m at a loss of what to do. She keeps asking me about it but everything I say upsets her. I’m currently in the mindset that I want to just say “we’re not doing that because of how you have acted” but just go and do it anyway. And to tell no one. This is actually what my dad has advised…

But it just feels so untruthful Sad I’m so excited to be married and this just feels like something else (like my pregnancy) that has been ruined.

OP posts:
fingerscrossedagain2022 · 11/04/2022 18:12

I was pregnant on my wedding day and miscarried (again) shortly afterwards. It took me a long time to be able to think about my wedding and when I see the photos they make me very sad. So I understand. I can see both sides. I don't know what I would do. But I wish I could look at my wedding photos without crying.

BuddhaAtSea · 11/04/2022 18:02

It would break my heart, if I was your mum.
Think about it for a minute. It’s a stressful time in your life and you’ve been through so much.
In your shoes, I’d get a pretty outfit, something between smart and casual, invite both sets of parents, have a meal afterwards, the 6 of you. Make it clear to your mum that this is the legal bit you’re doing for your child, not for anyone else. So no hats, marquee, just close immediate family. Take it or leave it.
I understand that MIL is probably not up for a knees up, but if she wishes so, she’s invited, it takes less than 20 minutes. Are you sure she’d be totally incapacitated? I know I would drag my arse over there, it’s my child.
More importantly, although you’ve been through the mill and you’re worried about the baby and all the rest of it, please stop and consider the rest of the family as well. You come across a bit tantrumy, maybe that’s not your intention, but that’s what I perceive.

BuanoKubiamVej · 11/04/2022 16:49

Given that the "wedding day" is going to be a destination wedding abroad anyway, you would probably need to have a separate registry office formality in the UK anyway as destination weddings are often not entirely sufficient legally. Given that, there's hardly much difference in having that legal bit happening sooner rather than later for purely practical abd administrative reasons as per yhe OP. Not worth making a fuss about.

greyinganddecaying · 11/04/2022 16:47

OP - I completely get where you're coming from. Your anxiety must be crippling at the moment - I'm really hoping all goes well with your pregnancy. Please remember that the post-natal period can be hard on your mental health too and make sure you have plenty of support.

We did similar to you in terms of wedding. It was great, it took all the pressure off on the "official" wedding day & put all the legal protections in place. Does your mum need to know you've done it? Can you keep it quiet until much later? Under your circumstances I would be seriously tempted to do this.

One thing to consider though as you said your partner is not a UK National. When we were choosing the "streamlined" (bare minimum) wedding vows etc there were lots of raised eyebrows from the registrar and we had to reassure them that this wasn't a marriage of convenience. Make sure your partner brings every bit of paperwork just in case you have a similar experience.

TimBoothseyes · 11/04/2022 16:26

Ah, three boys here myself. Perhaps that's why we think op should have the wedding she wants and be supported by her parents

I have a DD and, honestly, I don't care what kind of wedding she has or, indeed, who is invited. As long as it makes her happy then that's fine by me. Just because I gave birth to her it doesn't mean she owes me anything. Have the wedding you want OP, with who you want, your mum is BVU.

JustSmallFry · 11/04/2022 16:24

This is the "normal" way of doing things in many countries. I really can't see what all the fuss is about. You have a town hall wedding followed by an optional religious ceremony.

DH and I had a "legal" wedding with no-one there. We, some weeks later, had a wedding, with a celebrant, with our families and friends, in a place that was special to us. It's been several years and no-one has complained of feeling cheated or deceived

JoeGio · 11/04/2022 16:24

You're getting a really hard time because this is AIBU, but I don't think you're being unreasonable.
We found when we planned our wedding that pleasing everyone else wasn't possible, so we decided we'd do everything exactly as we wanted, even if that meant other people would have to get over their own feelings about certain decisions (like not inviting distant uncles we never see, not having a disco etc). Our day was perfect and we have no regrets.
Your reasoning is completely logical ‐ obviously you would rather have had the destination wedding before your baby was born but that's impossible now so the very best option in the circumstances is to sort the legalities first then have your dream wedding celebration later. It sounds wonderful. Don't mention it to your mum again, just do it.

MoiraNotRuby · 11/04/2022 16:18

Firstly, I hope you have as smooth as possible remainder of pregnancy and safe delivery op. I totally understand how you cannot relax. I agree your 'paperwork wedding' won't be a relaxing day. It is a good step forward for safety and security though. If you were my DD, I would be very happy for you to have this security and I would see it as something to celebrate, even in a low key way. I would rather see a couple make their vows than any of the rest of it.

SleepingStandingUp · 11/04/2022 16:16

[quote HardbackWriter]@SleepingStandingUp tbf I'm the mother of boys so clearly my presence at the wedding would be an optional extra of no relevance anyway. Perhaps if I'd birthed a girl I would have realised the moment that she was born that my key and most important role, something that I was owed above all else, was mother of the bride...[/quote]
Ah, three boys here myself. Perhaps that's why we think op should have the wedding she wants and be supported by her parents. Because we don't know better and are no better than we ought be 🙄😁😁

CPL593H · 11/04/2022 16:12

Your fiance is wise, with good priorities. Get the legal stuff done ASAP like you planned, if anyone kicks off remember they will get over it, and themselves.

I mean this gently because it sounds like things are tough for you, but I'd also say that learning to say no and meaning it to your mother would be a good thing for the future, rather than being pressganged into multiple baby showers and balloon arches. you don't want.

Staffymumma · 11/04/2022 16:10

I’m baffled at these comments honestly.

OP do whatever it is you want to do. I’m so sorry about your losses (I had a stillborn at 24 weeks and I know how utterly anxiety ridden the subsequent pregnancy is). Clearly I’m in the minority, but if that’s how my daughter wanted to do it, I’d encourage her. All Id want for HER AND HER HUSBANDS day is for THEM to be happy. I’d be devastated if I’d caused her this stress.

Me and my DH eloped, didn’t tell anyone, just ran away, got married and told everyone after because that’s how WE wanted to do it.

Also, I was invited to a destination wedding where the legal ceremony had taken place 18 months prior and I didn’t give a hoot, it was their special day, we all saw it as their actual wedding day and it was fabulous.

All the best OP, please follow your heart and do what you want to do.

babyjellyfish · 11/04/2022 16:09

If you invited your mum as a witness, could his parents watch via video link?

And stick to your guns about not wearing a fancy dress or having a celebration afterwards.

Allsorts1 · 11/04/2022 16:07

I have a few friends who have had a legal wedding seperate to their wedding day. The first tried to do what you have done, but family got upset and so they invited a few people, it sort of snowballed into a dinner out and flowers etc - so now they are unlikely to have the wedding that they wanted. The second told no family, only had two witnesses. Three years later (due to covid delays) they are now having their wedding day as planned. Because they kept the legal one small and secret, they were able to have the big day they wanted.

Don’t feel bad about your plan, it’s perfectly reasonable.

However, I would invite your parents and his parents as the witnesses, not two friends. Simply because you’ve already told your mum. If you had actually just kept it secret it wouldn’t matter, but she knows now. A lot of her upset will be because she’s not involved, rather than that she hates the plan generally. If you include her, ask her to be in on the secret with you, to be part of this small legal ceremony but then to plan with you the big day that you want - I’m sure she will be on board and you will get to have the small ceremony ASAP and the big day, and not hurt anyone.

Essentially, the cat is out of the bag so you might need to adjust your plan slightly. Take it from me, in a few years you will have forgotten why you were so adamant you wanted to do a certain thing, but you will always remember hurting your parents. So I would find a way to include them in the legal ceremony but still keep it small enough that you can have the big wedding later on.

HardbackWriter · 11/04/2022 16:07

@SleepingStandingUp tbf I'm the mother of boys so clearly my presence at the wedding would be an optional extra of no relevance anyway. Perhaps if I'd birthed a girl I would have realised the moment that she was born that my key and most important role, something that I was owed above all else, was mother of the bride...

Andacherryonthetop · 11/04/2022 16:06

I haven’t read the full thread OP but I just think people should be able to get married in the way that works for them. If it works for the couple getting married then that’s all that matters in my opinion. It’s not up to your mum. Don’t keep it a secret. You’ve explained your reasonings you don’t need to explain anymore. Do what feels is best for you and your fiancé, you are the ones getting married and however you both want to do it is how it should be.

SpiderinaWingMirror · 11/04/2022 16:00

Go ahead and do the registry office and just not tell anyone. That's what I would do. Just don't mention it again.

SleepingStandingUp · 11/04/2022 15:59

@HardbackWriter

I'm sure when you are a mother (and I wish you a safe and healthy pregnancy) then eventually the reality of your choice will hit you.

This is such patronising nonsense. I have children and can't understand what on earth you're on about, it isn't some sort of grand realisation that'll hit OP the moment she has a baby in her arms Hmm

Omg I missed this.

Yes op will be happy with her legal service and planning her fancy wedding until they place the baby in her arms at which point she'll wail desperately how her wedding choices should all have been about the woman who pushed HER out of her body. Anyone without a child birthed already is just so dense and selfish 😂

titchy · 11/04/2022 15:53

I think if you go ahead with your plan you'll have to come to terms with deeply upsetting either your parents or his.

The only very very very tenuous possible solution would be if you did a civil partnership instead of marriage ceremony - would that be enough to sort out the nationality issue, placate your mum and allow you to have a marriage abroad?

HardbackWriter · 11/04/2022 15:48

I'm sure when you are a mother (and I wish you a safe and healthy pregnancy) then eventually the reality of your choice will hit you.

This is such patronising nonsense. I have children and can't understand what on earth you're on about, it isn't some sort of grand realisation that'll hit OP the moment she has a baby in her arms Hmm

zoeFromCity · 11/04/2022 15:42

This thread is so hard on you, OP.

Your logic is valid and complete:
"Proper" wedding isn't in cards now - both because of your high risk pregnancy & anxiety and PILs options.
Your reasoning for getting legal marriage is totally valid and you need to do it.

There isn't any compromise possible, because your mother can't do a compromise and you are in too hard position now to be expected to teach her how to.
The only way how to improve the situation would be to move your registration office appointment to even earlier day. Just do it as soon as possible and that will be it. Waiting a month will give your mother a month of time to display her lack of understanding for your conditions.

SleepingStandingUp · 11/04/2022 15:40

@Viviennemary

Do shat you like. But it does seem a very topsy turvy way of doing things. I wouldn't go to a fake wedding. Especially as mother of the bride. It would be totally pointless IMHO.
So your daughter says this day is really important to me and Bob, I really want you to be there to see us exchange our wedding vows, spend time with us and the baby, be a part of our celebrations and yous say "nah sorry love, I'd only come if I can see you sign the legal bit of paper"? I hope your kids are young so you have time to grow up and be less self-centered
babyjellyfish · 11/04/2022 15:38

@HangingRock25

The registry is the real wedding, and even if something did happen to your daughter, your real wedding would be marred by it. Those who don't see the legal vows as the real wedding generally are only wanting a wedding for the party, not the actual marriage. Quite often these people seem to have destination weddings. On average, the marriages last a year or 2 years at most.

The legal vows IS the real wedding. If you don't respect this, don't get married.

This is absolute nonsense. Grin

People who get legally married before their wedding celebration (particularly those who do it quite a long time before) are doing it because they can't have the wedding celebration they want right now, but they want to get the legal bit done sooner, for, er, legal reasons.

Clearly they want to be married, not just have a party. But they want to have a party as well. And that is fine.

weaseleyes · 11/04/2022 15:35

I think it's easy to understand why you feel the way you feel, and it's also easy to understand why your mother would be upset. I would be too in her position, no matter how much I would support my daughter's decision. The thing is, you can't make her un-upset. I feel like you're hoping that if others see your choices as rational and defensible, then it will be somehow unreasonable that your mother's upset and this will solve things - but it won't, of course. Really, all you can do is do it the way you want, and just accept that she will be upset. I know you love her and it's important to you to feel like you're a good person - you are, but you can't have everything. Stop talking to her about it and expecting her to come round, she clearly can't manage actual happiness about your choices. It's a shame there's no perfect compromise here that will make everyone happy, but just own your choices and leave her be. Have a lovely day.

babyjellyfish · 11/04/2022 15:30

OP, you are getting some very strange replies on this thread.

I don't think Mumsnet is a great place to ask this sort of question, because there are a lot of people on here who for some bizarre reason get their knickers in a twist about the part with the registrar being the "real" wedding ceremony.

My husband and I got legally married about 10 months before our church wedding. We did it for legal reasons. Although both our sets of parents did attend the town hall part, most of our friends did not, and that was never supposed to be the real wedding celebration for us. Our proper wedding celebration involved a church ceremony, vows, readings, hymns, photos, dinner and dancing...in short, all the things you would expect from a wedding.

I don't even know which of our wedding guests knew we were already legally married and which of them didn't (quite a few of them but probably not all), or whether anyone who didn't realise beforehand figured it out on the day. As far as we were concerned it was a total non issue, and certainly nobody has ever said anything to us about it. We also got married abroad (which is where we both live), so yes, half our guests travelled abroad for our non legal wedding.

As for the issue with your mum, that's more tricky.

Have you explained it to her the same way you did to us in this thread? That as far as you're concerned, the wedding you have planned, abroad, with your vows and celebration, will be your "real" wedding, but you want to get the legal part done before your baby is born in case the worst should happen?

In your position I probably would let your mum attend the registry office if it's really important to her, but don't do anything to celebrate afterwards. That way, your mum gets to be there to witness it, but your in laws won't be missing much.

Could that be a suitable compromise?

confuseddotcom1234 · 11/04/2022 15:19

I understand what you want but the thing is I know a couple of married during covid so was really small with few ppl there. Groom was not a national so getting married also helped with visa things. They then planned and sent out save the dates for a wedding for exactly a year later. The reality is now they are legally married the push to to a wedding for everyone else just don't there so instead of the big do they planned it's just a casual bbq in a garden. Absolutely nothing wrong in anything they have done but priorities change. Once you have a baby money will be tighter and will you really want to do something that is for others when you are legally married. I understand your mums hurt she just wants to see you make those vows. It's your choice but you can't control how others feel about it. They have dreams of their own.