Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DS (17) has lost ambition for the future now he has a girlfriend. How best to handle?

59 replies

Rightlessmore · 11/04/2022 08:14

DS is year 12. At the start of the year he was really enthusiastic, told me he was going to work really hard to get the high grades he needs to get into University etc.
He’s been going out with his girlfriend since last summer. She doesn’t want to go to university and wants to get a job after school. Gradually since the start of A’levels DS has become less and less interested in his future, he’s completely unwilling to discuss what he wants to do after school. He does enough at school but absolutely no more. He’s naturally very clever and gets away with it, but is capable of amazing results with a bit more effort.
I like his girlfriend and we’re very welcoming, but really don’t want her influencing him too much and limiting his future choices, which I fear is happening.
I really don’t know the best way to handle thisConfused Has anyone else been in this situation and can give me some advice?

OP posts:
DeathMetalMum · 11/04/2022 16:57

I personally wouldn't push him towards university unless he is 100% certain. I'm not sure he sounds ready. Not everyone is ready for university at 18. I went at 18 when tuition fees were 'only' 3k mainly because it was the next step. I had a great experience but part of me wishes I had waited, maybe picked a different course or considered other options. It's a lot more debt now if he's not 100% sure.

I'd be supporting and encouraging him to focus on his A-levels and do his best but not necessarily with his aim being university yet. Maybe a degree apprenticeship or even a 'gap' year working somewhere. Things may fizzle out with his girlfriend

planetme · 11/04/2022 16:54

@Boood

Would it work to call his bluff? Start talking to him about what his options would be if he stayed put and found a job or apprenticeship near home instead. Dig up a few boring, dead-end prospects and be really enthusiastic about them. Emphasise how proud you are that he’s being sensible and realistic rather than chasing pipe dreams. Produce a plan showing how he could save all his salary for a mortgage deposit and be ready to have the first baby by the time he’s 23. Ask to meet the girlfriend’s parents as you’ll all be family soon.
This is genius🤣 I dread this happening to my kids, I see too many late teenagers get saddled with their first ever relationship and have their wings clipped. I want mine to live their lives.
Idonea · 11/04/2022 16:37

It depends what he wants to do. If he wants to be a doctor, lawyer, surgeon etc... Sure, go to uni. If he was going to do 'business' or 'poetry' then he can possibly learn at home. Uni for educational enrichment and pleasure is only for the super wealthy these days. The rest of us have tougher choices to make.

If he just wants to work in McDonalds because she does, though, that's pretty shit and I hope he sees sense.

CatsArePeople · 11/04/2022 16:37

He never "lost" his ambition, he never had it in the first place, and was just going with the flow. He's 17, of course he's not sure what he wants to do for the rest of his life. Uni isn't the only way. How about military? Or apprenticeship?

ronaldmcdonald123456 · 11/04/2022 16:16

Even if he wants to apply for an apprenticeship having good a levels helps.

hangrylady · 11/04/2022 16:04

@daimbarsatemydogsbone

YABU - it's his life.
Good parents don't just stand back and do nothing when a child is about to make a shit decision.
LampLighter414 · 11/04/2022 16:04

@Rightlessmore

Thanks there’s some really interesting perspectives on this that I’d not considered. I don’t think there’s anything he wants to do an apprenticeship in but I do think it’s a brilliant scheme and would be encouraging it if there was. I can see the downside of university but for what he wants to do (or did want to do) it would be a massive advantage. I somehow need to have a friendly chat with him in a low key way to point out his options I think.
Go on. What did he want to do? Will be a lot easier to suggest alternative training paths if there are any
Trippingslippingx1 · 11/04/2022 15:23

@LampLighter414

Go to uni. Get saddled with debt that you'll only ever pay off if super successful. Have to move away from family, friends, partner.

Or stay local, get a job, no student loan repayments and probably get your own place with your gf pretty quickly who you can sleep with all the time.

I can see the appeal.

What was he hoping to study and onwards career path? There may be similar options that do not involve university and debt. I have an accounting background and honestly if I knew any young people wanting to pursue similar I'd be telling them to get on school leave programmes/higher apprenticeships instead of degree followed by grad scheme. They will be far better off

agree 100%
Trippingslippingx1 · 11/04/2022 15:21

My sisters and and I all did 5/6 years at all

We all ended up in debt
Could not afford a mortgage until our mid 30s
Being career woman made it impossible to continue relationships moving around all the time

Now we all live alone, have student debts ongoing, rent flats ongoing. But we do have degrees from the most prestigious universities in the most prestigious subjects.

I regret it and wish I had stayed with my school boyfriend, worked in superdrug and stayed close to family.

My friends who were as ‘smart’ as me stayed home, got jobs working locally and managed to save up. They all have gorgeous families, normal income and normal lives.

I am sorry but the projection of University is everything and the sign of drive and success is a complete nonsense. I tell people that who are getting stressed out about exams all the time. And we went to uni years ago when it was cheaper - it is worse now.

Also the amount of drugs, mental health issues and sexual assaults that take place is rife. I am really against University TBH and I can say that as someone who graduated from two top Universities (my sisters all did the same)

I would let him live his own life - hes probably being wise TBH

howrudeforme · 11/04/2022 15:18

A friend’s DD is like this. Was looking forward to uni but then met her first love in year 12. Didn’t go to uni but now works in a restaurant and is still very much in love. Her parents don’t seem to mind. I look at her and wonder if this is her ‘gap’ year.

WeirdlyKind · 11/04/2022 15:11

He's 17. He has the rest of his life in front of him, and a degree isn't the be all and end all.

ikeepseeingit · 11/04/2022 15:06

@Rightlessmore

Thanks there’s some really interesting perspectives on this that I’d not considered. I don’t think there’s anything he wants to do an apprenticeship in but I do think it’s a brilliant scheme and would be encouraging it if there was. I can see the downside of university but for what he wants to do (or did want to do) it would be a massive advantage. I somehow need to have a friendly chat with him in a low key way to point out his options I think.
FWIW my brother didn't get the best A-level results, but he still went to uni and worked his way into a really good job role now in his 30s. I think a chat is a great idea and as long as he does 'well enough' in A-levels if he's determined in uni and at work, he'll be okay.
Tulipblacksmith · 11/04/2022 15:03

This was me at 17! I was headstrong and no one was telling me what to do.

I had to live and learn. I’m still with my husband (our young love was intense) so at least that was a success.

Due to graduate at age 34 so I did get there in the end (after the marriage, 3 kids etc).

There’s nothing really to sort, he isn’t taking drugs or going off the rails. You’re just going to have to let him get on with it. Maybe Uni will not be his path. It’s not the be all and end all.

Rightlessmore · 11/04/2022 14:58

Thanks there’s some really interesting perspectives on this that I’d not considered. I don’t think there’s anything he wants to do an apprenticeship in but I do think it’s a brilliant scheme and would be encouraging it if there was.
I can see the downside of university but for what he wants to do (or did want to do) it would be a massive advantage.
I somehow need to have a friendly chat with him in a low key way to point out his options I think.

OP posts:
ikeepseeingit · 11/04/2022 14:48

@Boood

Would it work to call his bluff? Start talking to him about what his options would be if he stayed put and found a job or apprenticeship near home instead. Dig up a few boring, dead-end prospects and be really enthusiastic about them. Emphasise how proud you are that he’s being sensible and realistic rather than chasing pipe dreams. Produce a plan showing how he could save all his salary for a mortgage deposit and be ready to have the first baby by the time he’s 23. Ask to meet the girlfriend’s parents as you’ll all be family soon.
Comments like this baffle me. I'm 24, my husband had an apprenticeship at 17 we both saved as much as we could and bought a house at 22 together. Am I a failure because I knew what I wanted? We skipped over the whole expensive uni stage because it wasn't for us. I run my own business and he has a well-paying job in IT. How awful 🤣
Hont1986 · 11/04/2022 14:33

"He’s naturally very clever and gets away with it, but is capable of amazing results with a bit more effort."

I hate to break it to you, but this is what literally everyone says about their mediocre children. Everyone can talk big, but the people who can walk the walk tend to actually do it, in my experience.

wonderwoman26 · 11/04/2022 14:24

I think blaming his GF is a bit far given the limited amount of info you have given.

When i reached year 12 i realised i didnt want to go to UNI, not because of any relationship - but because i didnt actually like education. I would have hated going there and then coming out up to my eyeballs in debt, and still starting on a low - mid 20k job because post grad jobs are few and far between.

I instead got an apprenticeship, are are now 26 years old on a 35k job with much more earning potential. Just because he is indecisive about his future and career ( can you honestly say you knew what you wanted to do at his age? Cause i surely didnt) doesnt mean he will end up not using his potential.

There are more than one path to success, University is not the only way.

ronaldmcdonald123456 · 11/04/2022 14:19

@daimbarsatemydogsbone

YABU - it's his life.
Doesn't mean his mum should stand back and watch him waste his education and watch him actively harm his future.
Fandangoes · 11/04/2022 14:18

have you looked at graduate apprenticeships with him? Could be a good compromise with him, he gets to work and earn a salary and also gets a degree at the end of it. If you can get him excited about that he might find his enthusiasm to try harder to get selected?

WhatTheWhoTheWhatThe · 11/04/2022 14:11

@Boood

Would it work to call his bluff? Start talking to him about what his options would be if he stayed put and found a job or apprenticeship near home instead. Dig up a few boring, dead-end prospects and be really enthusiastic about them. Emphasise how proud you are that he’s being sensible and realistic rather than chasing pipe dreams. Produce a plan showing how he could save all his salary for a mortgage deposit and be ready to have the first baby by the time he’s 23. Ask to meet the girlfriend’s parents as you’ll all be family soon.
I think it’s a bit off to lump apprenticeships in with dead end jobs tbh. There’s some rubbish ones out the for sure but there are some really very good apprenticeship options as a starting base to launch a career.

I do think rather than pushing uni, help him look at all the options available after uni also highlight that doing well in a levels now will give him more options whatever he decides to do (some apprenticeships are highly competitive so mediocre a levels won’t cut it) and good a levels will keep the door open for uni if he decides to go as a mature student at some point.

LampLighter414 · 11/04/2022 14:10

Go to uni. Get saddled with debt that you'll only ever pay off if super successful. Have to move away from family, friends, partner.

Or stay local, get a job, no student loan repayments and probably get your own place with your gf pretty quickly who you can sleep with all the time.

I can see the appeal.

What was he hoping to study and onwards career path? There may be similar options that do not involve university and debt. I have an accounting background and honestly if I knew any young people wanting to pursue similar I'd be telling them to get on school leave programmes/higher apprenticeships instead of degree followed by grad scheme. They will be far better off

veronicagoldberg · 11/04/2022 14:05

@daimbarsatemydogsbone

YABU - it's his life.

Do you know what being a parent involves?

yoyo1234 · 11/04/2022 14:04

Watching this with interest as DS is going through a change of motivation (put politely....). No girlfriend/boyfriend involved that I know just a computer obsession.....

loopylindi · 11/04/2022 13:46

Also, show him how much flats, food, fuel actually cost and what % of his potential income that would be. Teenagers are motivated by money and not having enough to do what he wants might bring him up short

Rightlessmore · 11/04/2022 13:17

@Boood you could actually be onto something. He definitely does need a reality check.

OP posts: