Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DS (17) has lost ambition for the future now he has a girlfriend. How best to handle?

59 replies

Rightlessmore · 11/04/2022 08:14

DS is year 12. At the start of the year he was really enthusiastic, told me he was going to work really hard to get the high grades he needs to get into University etc.
He’s been going out with his girlfriend since last summer. She doesn’t want to go to university and wants to get a job after school. Gradually since the start of A’levels DS has become less and less interested in his future, he’s completely unwilling to discuss what he wants to do after school. He does enough at school but absolutely no more. He’s naturally very clever and gets away with it, but is capable of amazing results with a bit more effort.
I like his girlfriend and we’re very welcoming, but really don’t want her influencing him too much and limiting his future choices, which I fear is happening.
I really don’t know the best way to handle thisConfused Has anyone else been in this situation and can give me some advice?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
2orangey · 12/04/2022 17:46

Most people (me included) go to Uni because it's what their friends are doing, it's what their parents and teachers expect, it's seen as 'the next step' if you're even slightly academic. A PP mentioned the educational 'conveyor belt' and that really captures it.

They end up doing courses which won't be helpful in their future careers, since of course most teenagers don't have a clue what they want to do with their lives.

No harm at all in a young person experiencing the wider world for a bit before deciding whether uni is for them. And please don't openly suggest the girlfriend is some kind of bad influence - you'll create a star-crossed lovers* situation out of what would usually turn out to be a short-lived romance.

*See? I did an English Lit degree and all I got were a few lame Shakespeare references Grin

pizzacutterbun · 12/04/2022 17:06

@BridgesofMadisonfan

Yes even more so. I'm mid senior and under 40. I've still got a 25 years left of career with a lot of earning potential.

None of my team ( ranging from age 25 to 55) have a degree or any specific technology qualification and we are all the same pay grade.

I also am responsible for employment and have been in the other 3 companies I've worked for and a degree was bottom of the list of requirements. Yeah it may tell me a person understand the technology of whatever they were taught at that particular time but it's a rapidly moving sector so having experience and ability to adapt and learn is the single most important thing I look for. I've hired some great people who have proven themselves ten fold.

I've also worked with grads straight out of uni. Their ego was far bigger than their knowledge. Not their fault really, they were sold the dream of a degree.

Degrees aren't for the elite anymore and that's not a bad thing as it's more accessible but it also dilutes their value

BridgesofMadisonfan · 12/04/2022 15:11

@pizzacutterbun

Uni is a con unless it's something very specifically needed to enter his chosen career.

I quit A levels at 17 before I finished the course, recognises early on that earning my own money was much more appealing than being saddled with debt that will take forever to pay.

I did well. Work in IT with no formal qualifications and earn a decent salary with a tons of opportunity to earn more

Uni isn't the be all. You say his future, but what you mean is his educational future. He still has a future, this GF could be his long term success at life, she may be the mother of his children one day.

The key to life is happiness not uni

@pizzacutterbun

Do you think you could do the same today or has the world of work changed?

PiddleOfPuppies · 11/04/2022 22:07

I've found my yr12 DD is far less mature than her older siblings at the same age - she doesn't want to go to university (older friends have had bad experiences) but doesn't seem to have fully grasped that she's about to become an adult with all that entails. She seems to have lost her love of learning after 2 years of on-off-virtual school and then 6th form is dull (covid knocked all the fun stuff out) but full-on. I'm hoping she takes a year out to grow up a bit, and then she might find herself inspired. It's not the only chance they'll get to decide on a career path - lots of the most interesting and successful adults I know didn't get it right first time.

latetothefisting · 11/04/2022 21:48

[quote ronaldmcdonald123456]@latetothefisting I thought it was quite common for teens here to work PT from 16/17[/quote]
Well it was when I was growing up too (only about 10-15 years ago), but whenever the question comes up on MN everyone seems to think "their education is their job" and DC need to concentrate on school. Then seem surprised when their dc struggle to fill out application forms or get interviews aged 21 when they don't have any work experience!

CrimePodcast · 11/04/2022 21:25

I take my Y12 daughter for a day to the uni/career related facilities she is keen to progress to when if I sense she needs some motivation, it works wonders.

GADDay · 11/04/2022 21:17

Eh, a con? Confused Would love to hear more.

Tulipblacksmith · 11/04/2022 21:15

In other words if you don't get a great job your worthless and no woman will ever look at you.

Well that's one way to ensure your son attracts toxic females who are only with him for what they can get.

Great advice, not!!

WhatTheWhoTheWhatThe · 11/04/2022 20:37

@Genevieva

Tell him that if he wants to keep his girlfriend he needs to continue to be a good catch. If he flunks his exams and ends up in a miserable dead end job her eyes are more likely to be turned by someone with brighter prospects of a more comfortable adult life.
Wow spectacularly shit parenting advice there!
pizzacutterbun · 11/04/2022 20:23

@Genevieva

Tell him that if he wants to keep his girlfriend he needs to continue to be a good catch. If he flunks his exams and ends up in a miserable dead end job her eyes are more likely to be turned by someone with brighter prospects of a more comfortable adult life.
Worst advice I've ever seen on MN

Yeah make him feel like utter shit with a threat his GF will leave him for a man with more money. Top parenting 👍

Weatherwithme · 11/04/2022 19:33

I think alot of boys take year 12 ‘off’ after the insane pressure of gcse. Get into socialising. Do enough to get by. Many then pull it out the bag in second half of year 13. My DS1 attitude was Year 12 exams ‘didn’t count’ so he didn’t have to work that hard. He’s a bright last minute reviser and did well in the end. If he is doing fine at school and naturally very able then I wouldn’t worry too much at this stage or assume he won’t get the grades. If it wasn’t a gf it could be parties / drinking / weed etc. There are lots of distractions at that age and their brains almost seem to work against them experimenting and making what seem like foolish decisions. Chat to the teachers if they aren’t worried and he is doing well in class and doing homework I would back off about ‘the future’. The school will be covering all that anyway. I think this is fairly typical year 12 boy behaviour having had 2 who came out the other side unscathed.

Genevieva · 11/04/2022 19:32

Tell him that if he wants to keep his girlfriend he needs to continue to be a good catch. If he flunks his exams and ends up in a miserable dead end job her eyes are more likely to be turned by someone with brighter prospects of a more comfortable adult life.

Tulipblacksmith · 11/04/2022 19:20

@Blossomtoes

Having worked in my local (Russell) Uni in their wellbeing department there is a staggering amount of young people who are simply there just to please their parents, completing degrees that they are not that interested in. The degree I chose at aged 30 was miles away from the choice I had in mind at 17.

2bazookas · 11/04/2022 19:03

Stop pressuring about university choice. He can apply for university any time in the next few years. Preferably, not until he knows what he really wants to study. Or where. There's much to be said for being an older student.

What matters, is the run up to his A levels, doing enough work to get the best grades he can, so that he then has CHOICES about what to do with them. Try to get him and the GF to focus on that. Persuade them it's in his interest to get his head down for the next few months.

As soon as he finishes the exams, the pressure is off, let him stack shelves in Tesco or whatever dead end job he can get until it finally dawns.. he's bored. He doesn't want to do this all his life. But with A levels under his belt he has other options; university or some other trained career path.

Once they both start working for a living, they'll soon grasp the dullness and limitations of boredom, lack of challenge, low pay etc. So please be all ready to explain that as a working adult, he needs to contribute to household expenses, pay for his own phone, do his own laundry etc.

Blossomtoes · 11/04/2022 18:30

I was the same as @Tulipblacksmith. I was 33 when I graduated.

I think it’s good that he’s questioning the academic conveyor belt and whether it will actually benefit him to accrue £50k debt. Obviously he needs to explore alternative options but I wouldn’t see it as the end of the world. I do wonder how many kids go to uni and end up with a pointless degree just to please their parents.

ronaldmcdonald123456 · 11/04/2022 18:22

@latetothefisting I thought it was quite common for teens here to work PT from 16/17

latetothefisting · 11/04/2022 18:17

Does he have a part time job? I know loads of MNers are against this but for me it was only when I got one that I realised a) how much work it was to earn a small amount of money, and how little that amount went, and b) how much I didn't want to be doing that job for the rest of my life.

Although that can backfire, I was working in a high street shop at the time and hated it, but I then got a job in a cinema and loved it, there were loads of teenagers working there and we had a right laugh! If I'd had the 2nd job first I probably would have been fine at the idea of staying there for a while!

user1471443411 · 11/04/2022 18:14

Actually, if he's not sure what he wants to do, it might be best if he doesn't go to university now anyway. It would use up some of his student loan and may result in him dropping out. Surely it would be better for him to work for a few years and get a better idea of what he wants to do in the future, then maybe go to university as a mature student. He could always do an access course if he doesn't get the best grades this time round.

Stringervest · 11/04/2022 18:12

I think the main thing is that he does his best on his A Levels so he has the choice of going to uni later. Lots of people aren't clear headed about future plans at that age, but redoing his A Levels later would be a pain. DH didn't put the effort in for his GCSEs or A Levels and it's a huge regret of his because it has closed doors which have been complicated to reopen.

Dailyfailcanfeckoff · 11/04/2022 18:09

@Idonea

It depends what he wants to do. If he wants to be a doctor, lawyer, surgeon etc... Sure, go to uni. If he was going to do 'business' or 'poetry' then he can possibly learn at home. Uni for educational enrichment and pleasure is only for the super wealthy these days. The rest of us have tougher choices to make.

If he just wants to work in McDonalds because she does, though, that's pretty shit and I hope he sees sense.

McDonald’s is a decent employer. Ds has a part time job there- much better working conditions than my profession at the same level.

He’s 17 - there is no harm in him not going to uni if he’s unsure, the condition is that he does something like including working full time in McDonald’s if that’s the only job he can get. Which means he won’t have 5months holiday / year and will have to be responsible.
All positive attributes for succeeding at university when he’s worked out what he wants to do.

pizzacutterbun · 11/04/2022 17:59

Uni is a con unless it's something very specifically needed to enter his chosen career.

I quit A levels at 17 before I finished the course, recognises early on that earning my own money was much more appealing than being saddled with debt that will take forever to pay.

I did well. Work in IT with no formal qualifications and earn a decent salary with a tons of opportunity to earn more

Uni isn't the be all. You say his future, but what you mean is his educational future. He still has a future, this GF could be his long term success at life, she may be the mother of his children one day.

The key to life is happiness not uni

Mumdiva99 · 11/04/2022 17:18

I took a year out at 18 before Uni. Best thing I could have done. I was tired of studying and tired of school. I did some temping, I went away a few times, I actually got on a project at work which ended up starting my career after Uni.
I applied during my year out and went when I was ready.

We all make our own paths in life.

hihellohihello · 11/04/2022 17:14

Apprenticeships often offer degrees alongside working. So he could have both.

Lots of people do degrees later on. Lots of people are successful without a degree. Look at what he wants to do rather than what he doesn't want to do.

Tulipblacksmith · 11/04/2022 17:09

@Smartiepants79

I guess if he really wanted to go to University he would. Many bright kids under the age of 17 “express interest” in University. He is choosing to prioritise his girlfriend though. It might work out well? It also might not?

Guess that’s the hardest part of being a parent. Watching your children make mistakes (although it may not be a mistake).

Ultimately it’s up to him isn’t it? He’s a young adult making a choice.

I made that choice at 17 and deep down it wasn’t because I met (my now husband)…. I simply just didn’t want to go.

Smartiepants79 · 11/04/2022 17:05

A degree is not the b all and end all BUT the decision to not do one must be made for the right reasons. There are of course lots of other excellent opportunities but it doesn’t really sound like he’s thought about any of them!
This is a bright child, who has previously expressed a desire to go to university. It is a serious concern that he appears to be jeopardising this possibility due to a teenage romance.