Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Cheeky request to buy parents house - AIBU?

585 replies

SewingMum46 · 11/04/2022 07:03

My DPs still live in the same house they built when first married in the 60s. It’s in quite a nice area and because DF is an amazing gardener has a lovely garden which can be seen through the gate. It’s split level so although DM has some mobility problems and is quite frail, it still works for them. They’d only leave if something happened to one of them.
They got a card through the door last week with a message that basically said this couple who live in a very posh house up a very posh street nearby want to downsize because their kids have left home, so please would they consider selling their house to them? It included something along the lines of “Of course we’d pay full market value but it would be good to avoid those annoying estate agents fees”. It was handwritten with the name and address of the couple.
I feel it’s a bit cheeky and tbh on the verge of being entitled. DPs don’t know these people at all - they said in the card they’ve “always thought the house is lovely” and now they’ve decided it would suit them better as their “current property is on 4 floors”.
DF hasn’t shown the card to DM. I told him to ignore it but hold onto it. He’s adamant that if he sold to them it would be above market value, but he doesn’t want to sell - it would be up to DB and me to sell the house after they are gone.
What would you feel if this happened to your DPs? I find it really upsetting.

OP posts:
Doggirl · 11/04/2022 11:18

@Octomore

This is going back 20 years+ (hence the comment about the Rent Act change being relatively recent). I have no idea about the profile of private landlords nowadays, but at that point many landlords were 'accidental' and few had more than a couple of properties. Dealing with correspondence from the public as I did, it would have been no particular surprise to find a fair number without much commercial awareness.
Also you have to be aware of what Rent Act protection meant. In many areas the 'fair rent' charged was so low by the late '90s/ early '00s that owners were struggling to break even on the rental. I can quite see that if you were an individual struggling with cash flow, the idea of getting a lump sumfrom a business that could afford to take the long viewmight have been tempting. After all, equity release works on a similar 'jam today instead of more jam tomorrow' basis.

milkyaqua · 11/04/2022 11:10

I think it's different because they are elderly people. In MN-world, older people should stop 'hoarding' their houses and gardens, and move out because younger people want and feel entitled to what they have.

Octomore · 11/04/2022 11:07

it was apparently a known thing that estate agents would sift through domestic rubbish bins in areas of private tenanted housing

Say what now?

Also - I'd be really surprised that landlords weren't savvy enough to (a) know how old their tenants are, and (b) know that when the tenant dies they will be able to get a higher profit from the rental.

Private rental landlords are not naïve, vulnerable owners, prime to be ripped off by EAs who have rooted through the bins.

Blackberrybunnet · 11/04/2022 11:07

This seems to be a fairly common practice nowadays, and when it pays off, everyone benefits. I don't see how it's cheeky, it's just an enquiry, and a complimentary one at that.

Octomore · 11/04/2022 11:04

I have had folk do this to my car. I have also stopped people in the street and asked them where they got their bag/shoes. I am not sure why its entitled or presumptuous?

This is at the extreme end of MN-world, where any enquiry at all is seen as threatening and intrusive! Grin

Even saying 'Hi' to your neighbours, or knocking on someone's door seems to prompt some people to enter a tailspin of catastrophising and fear that they are being spied on!

milkyaqua · 11/04/2022 11:04

Tell your Dad to bin and ignore, and if another note arrives call them yourself and tell them to stop.

I agree with this. Your parents are not here on this earth to people-please real estate hunters who are after their home.

Doggirl · 11/04/2022 11:03

Haven't RTFT, but colour me sceptical that it's actually from a private individual wanting the house for their own use. There seems to be this idea nowadays that painting a commercial enterprise with whimsical folksinesseg on Innocent drinkssomehow makes it more endearing to punters. And yes, my DH who is in his 70s regularly gets approaches about our house (his details are the only ones on the deeds).
Back when I worked in housing policy, it was apparently a known thing that estate agents would sift through domestic rubbish bins in areas of private tenanted housing, looking for clues to the ages of the tenants. If you got an elderly tenant, there was a high chance it was a Rent Act protected tenancy (this was less than 15 years after new protected tenancies stopped being created), which heavily restricted the rights of the landlord to either evict the tenant or raise the rent. So you buy a property at below-market price, and wait a few years for the sitting tenant to die, before either selling or renting at full market value. Nice.

Oaktree55 · 11/04/2022 11:03

It’s very common to direct target particular houses. Estate Agents do it all the time as do occasionally savvy purchasers.

What’s the issue? They just ignore if not interested.

Octomore · 11/04/2022 11:02

@iwantmyownicecreamvan

I had similar happen to me twice in 2 years. One after my elderly uncle died. His house wasn't up for sale at that point and a neighbour put a letter through the door. I made the mistake of ringing her number, and as PP have said, it was the fact that she thought she would be doing me a favour by saving me estate agent fees - I presume she would have wanted some of the savings passed onto her - which really irritated me.

As it happened, I needed to use an Estate Agent anyway as I didn't live locally and couldn't do viewings, so I just blocked her number and never heard from her again.

The second seemed worse. Both my parents died within a month of each other at the start of the pandemic. Their house was empty but not up for sale - we didn't even have probate. A random local resident knocked on the neighbour's door asking after my parents, and on being told they had died (which I think he already knew) immediately asked about the house, saying he would love to buy it. She took his number and rang me - again all this malarkey about saving me EA fees - ffs don't do me any favours. I declined to even take his number and told her it would be going up for sale with an estate agent. She was really put out, said they seemed a lovely couple, and she never contacted me again.

When the house was put on the market it made a heck of a lot more than the initial EA valuation - and I'm talking like £50k more - we had to pay capital gains tax because the probate valuation had been a lot lower. So yes, they certainly would have got a bargain wouldn't they.

People who do this after people have died really annoy me - they are out to get a good deal on the back of other people's bereavement.

Using an EA was obviously the right decision in your case, but this:

I needed to use an Estate Agent anyway as I didn't live locally and couldn't do viewings

doesn't really make sense. The whole point of a private sale is that you don't need to do viewings at all. You allow the interested buyer to look around once, agree a price, and then proceed.

godmum56 · 11/04/2022 11:01

@LeastofLeicester

I agree OP. I know it is a 'normal' thing to do and quite often encouraged, but I find it really entitled too. And quite presumptuous. You wouldn't do it with anything else. You wouldn't put flyers on car windscreens saying "I really like your car, want to sell?" Or stop someone in the street and ask to buy something they're wearing/carrying.

Estate agent ones I don't find so bad, it's not personal then, just a tactic to get more houses on their books.

I have had folk do this to my car. I have also stopped people in the street and asked them where they got their bag/shoes. I am not sure why its entitled or presumptuous?
Prescottdanni123 · 11/04/2022 10:57

Sorry to hear that your mum isn't well at the moment OP. I can totally understand why the timing has made you feel a bit suspicious over this couple's motives. From other replies on here, this does seem to be quite common so hopefully this has just been a random coincidence. If it wasn't, then the couple are not going to achieve anything anyway because your parents do not want to sell.

IamtheDevilsAvocado · 11/04/2022 10:57

@Viviennemary

I agree. I think its extremely cheeky indeed. But there are folk who do this. I wouldn't sell to such a person.
I would...

Assuming you could get a decent independent valuation.... Saving thr EA fees. One pal just sold her mum's place... Almost 20k in EA fees... Shock

SirVixofVixHall · 11/04/2022 10:57

I totally agree with Succulentchoice that it is something to be wary of.
I also understand how this has made you feel. Elderly people are more vulnerable to pushy people and things like this can worry them in a way that it would not worry a younger person. They might feel it is impolite to ignore it etc, I know my parents would have.
I think these notes can seem really pushy and that this one was very badly worded. Randomly sending notes when you have no idea of the circumstances of the home owners is not a nice thing to do, there could be someone dying or recently bereaved, someone with mental health problems or dementia, it is thoughtless.
Tell your Dad to bin and ignore, and if another note arrives call them yourself and tell them to stop.

iwantmyownicecreamvan · 11/04/2022 10:57

I had similar happen to me twice in 2 years. One after my elderly uncle died. His house wasn't up for sale at that point and a neighbour put a letter through the door. I made the mistake of ringing her number, and as PP have said, it was the fact that she thought she would be doing me a favour by saving me estate agent fees - I presume she would have wanted some of the savings passed onto her - which really irritated me.

As it happened, I needed to use an Estate Agent anyway as I didn't live locally and couldn't do viewings, so I just blocked her number and never heard from her again.

The second seemed worse. Both my parents died within a month of each other at the start of the pandemic. Their house was empty but not up for sale - we didn't even have probate. A random local resident knocked on the neighbour's door asking after my parents, and on being told they had died (which I think he already knew) immediately asked about the house, saying he would love to buy it. She took his number and rang me - again all this malarkey about saving me EA fees - ffs don't do me any favours. I declined to even take his number and told her it would be going up for sale with an estate agent. She was really put out, said they seemed a lovely couple, and she never contacted me again.

When the house was put on the market it made a heck of a lot more than the initial EA valuation - and I'm talking like £50k more - we had to pay capital gains tax because the probate valuation had been a lot lower. So yes, they certainly would have got a bargain wouldn't they.

People who do this after people have died really annoy me - they are out to get a good deal on the back of other people's bereavement.

CrotchetyQuaver · 11/04/2022 10:55

It's very common when you live in a nice area. Or have a nice house. My dad gets them all the time.

Tomselleckhaskindeyes · 11/04/2022 10:49

We had one of these through the door. I just ignored it tbh.

MrsSkylerWhite · 11/04/2022 10:48

(We’ll be downsizing in the next few years. Would be delighted to receive such a note and save so much hassle!)

Cakesnbiscuit · 11/04/2022 10:48

I have a house I would love to buy, if I was in the same position I would consider doing this. Not sure it’s really an issue to get upset over.

If they want to sell get it valued by a few people, if they don’t want to sell throw it away or keep it for a rainy day

MrsSkylerWhite · 11/04/2022 10:47

Common practice can’t understand why this would upset you. Sounds perfectly polite.
All they have to do is say no thank you, we’re happy here 🤷‍♀️

PlainJaneEyre · 11/04/2022 10:47

I imagine you are very sensitive to this as you know there is an inevitable change coming in your parents' lives. What they have done is quite normal though.

SpinMeRightRoundBabyRightRound · 11/04/2022 10:46

I get why it upset you. When your parents are ill it has the feel of vultures circling whether the letter writers knew of the circumstances or not.

Yes, it is a nice house, that’s why they live in it!

Flowers for you all. We’ve also experience of home being much preferable to care elsewhere.

IGotAVaxAndILikedIt · 11/04/2022 10:45

I live in a 'hot' Sydney suburb, this has happened around 5 times over the last couple of years, and am in a 'perfect' triangle of good schools, shops and transport - all while being a sleepy tree lined street with lovely houses, one of which I live in.

I am not at all offended. I contact them back and name my price - which is about twice market value.

No-one has taken me up on it yet, but if someone ever does I will toss them the keys and skip on out.

No harm in asking.

5zeds · 11/04/2022 10:44

I think it’s normal and not creepy or upsetting at all

IamtheDevilsAvocado · 11/04/2022 10:44

@SewingMum46

It’s the wording really - “Of course we’d pay full market value but avoid estate agents fees”. DPs aren’t particularly aware of the value of the house, they were surprised when they asked me how much it might be worth. It also felt a bit like they were being watched.
Someone just noticed and liked your parents house... And was saying if they'd like to sell the letter writers would be interested... And not expect a knock down rate...

Think you're way over thinking thisGrin

GreenFingersWouldBeHandy · 11/04/2022 10:42

It's really common practice these days. The note sounds very politely worded and you are massively overreacting.

Swipe left for the next trending thread