Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Eco protesting

264 replies

Boomerwang · 11/04/2022 05:59

Apparently there's a bill going forward to give police more powers to deal with protests and vigils that cause 'serious unease' or 'serious annoyance' and this bill has been blocked several times by Keir Starmer previously.

AIBU to think police should be granted more powers to stop protestors from blocking access points? I fully agree the right to protest must be protected, but what about when it affects others?

I'd argue to go even further and stop the waste of taxpayer's money by having to involve the police at all but then I know people would get seriously hurt this way and that's not okay.

At the same time, I wonder how effective these protests are by forcing us to confront what's going on and whether ultimately they are doing something good? Would they achieve results by sitting to the side of access points instead? Would anyone listen if daily life were uninterrupted? Does anyone stop to think of the cause just because they were physically stopped? Surely it's impossible to sympathise when you're angry?

Personally protesting is something I read about in the news but it doesn't prompt me to reflect on my contribution or research further.

Has anyone been affected by protests before and did it make you consider environment and ecology after the event?

OP posts:
CapMarvel · 11/04/2022 14:47

@PinkSparklyPussyCat

Individuals can't make the changes necessary by changing their own habits - not enough people doing it plus our infrastructure etc isn't designed for it.. It has to be systemic change. Policies, subsidies, tax etc

So what you're saying is they used fossil fuels to get there.

So?

Such an utterly inane argument. If driving to a protest using 10 litres of petrol helps lead to a low/zero carbon future down the road obviously that's justifiable.

gaharghgah · 11/04/2022 14:43

I was at the protests this weekend. I am 'normal hard working people' just like nearly everyone else there. I am a single parent, I am busy going to work every day. But I went because the climate emergency is going to directly impact on all of our children, and I am very scared for their future.

And I flew in on my broomstick, so no fossil fuels used.

woodhill · 11/04/2022 14:26

@CapMarvel

The right to peaceful protest - even if it does involve inconveniencing some people - is a vital part of a functioning democracy and should be protected at all costs.

All those sneering at people who do get out there and protest might have something which they care about enough to get off their lazy arses about one day, and they'll be glad that the right exists.

Perhaps they are too busy commuting and having to be in work every day
daimbarsatemydogsbone · 11/04/2022 14:20

At the moment everything is geared to protect the interests of the very rich.
I agree and that's why buggering things up for ordinary people by blockading refineries or gluing yourself to a motorway is just about the stupidest and most ineffective way to get the very rich to act differently.

You do seem to be proposing the overthrow of capitalism and I agree that will probably have to happen for the centralised control needed to arrest climate change. It's a very hard sell though for people who are used to democracy.

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 11/04/2022 14:20

Individuals can't make the changes necessary by changing their own habits - not enough people doing it plus our infrastructure etc isn't designed for it.. It has to be systemic change. Policies, subsidies, tax etc

So what you're saying is they used fossil fuels to get there.

SucculentChalice · 11/04/2022 14:18

Momijn maybe they're race walkers then?

CapMarvel · 11/04/2022 14:17

The right to peaceful protest - even if it does involve inconveniencing some people - is a vital part of a functioning democracy and should be protected at all costs.

All those sneering at people who do get out there and protest might have something which they care about enough to get off their lazy arses about one day, and they'll be glad that the right exists.

Momijin · 11/04/2022 14:15

@SucculentChalice

Momign I happen to know many of them. They are teachers, doctors, mums, grandparents, scientists, marketeers, filmmakers, vets, musicians, priests, rabbi, engineers, Every activist I know is very busy with work and families and take time out of their very busy lives to do this.

They must all be superstar cyclists too, in order to cycle to their demos not using fossil fuels or adding to climate change by using polluting public transport!

Individuals can't make the changes necessary by changing their own habits - not enough people doing it plus our infrastructure etc isn't designed for it.. It has to be systemic change. Policies, subsidies, tax etc

At the moment everything is geared to protect the interests of the very rich.

woodhill · 11/04/2022 14:14

I'm thinking about Extinction rebellion, are they linked to the insulation group

SucculentChalice · 11/04/2022 14:11

Momign I happen to know many of them. They are teachers, doctors, mums, grandparents, scientists, marketeers, filmmakers, vets, musicians, priests, rabbi, engineers, Every activist I know is very busy with work and families and take time out of their very busy lives to do this.

They must all be superstar cyclists too, in order to cycle to their demos not using fossil fuels or adding to climate change by using polluting public transport!

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 11/04/2022 14:10

Piss off. I happen to know many of them. They are teachers, doctors, mums, grandparents, scientists, marketeers, filmmakers, vets, musicians, priests, rabbi, engineers, Every activist I know is very busy with work and families and take time out of their very busy lives to do this.

They are stopping people from working, you know, making the money to keep a roof over their heads. They have stopped ambulances reaching hospitals and I bet it would be different if one of their loved ones needed an ambulance. And as for their new idea of door knocking, they can piss off.

Momijin · 11/04/2022 14:06

Keep fossil fuels in the ground. Add environmental costs to products and services - from manufacturing to disposal. There are many solutions and not one solution will fit all. But it will mean a nice life for the many and not for the few. And what you don't get is that we will have to change anyway. The way we live, burn and waste isn't sustainable. But by the time we are forced to chance, we will have hit irreversible tipping points.

toomanydogsandcats · 11/04/2022 14:06

You can't assume everyone shares the climate angst, plenty of people, me included, couldn't care less about it. I ge uiny do not care if the world ends, I deplore waste and hate shops like Primark and the ghastly stylist on Lorraine who says this nifty little bag comes in at £2 and Lorraine has an orgasm. Throwaway culture is immoral and we should not be producing clothes or food for below their value. I have a lot of shoes and bags and they are all hand made, I never buy tat or poor quality. But the hysteria about oil? Genuinely don't care.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 11/04/2022 14:01

@Momijin

No, climate change is here. This is climate and not weather. The frequency and extent of weather events happening is unprecedented. Listen to what scientists are telling us. What we are experiencing ourselves.
What needs to be done?

It seems to me that we must leave our entire consumerist lives behind, all move to huge crowded cities, embrace veganism and dismantle capitalism.

This is going to be rather hard to achieve, isn't it?

Momijin · 11/04/2022 14:00

@PinkSparklyPussyCat

What the protestors do is nothing compared to that. It is the only way they make the news. They would much rather be doing other stuff, trust me.

No they wouldn't, it might involve working.

Piss off. I happen to know many of them. They are teachers, doctors, mums, grandparents, scientists, marketeers, filmmakers, vets, musicians, priests, rabbi, engineers, Every activist I know is very busy with work and families and take time out of their very busy lives to do this.

When you have so many clever people who personally gain absolutely nothing from doing this. When you have the world's scientists telling you what is happening, you listen and do something about it.

Momijin · 11/04/2022 13:55

No, climate change is here. This is climate and not weather. The frequency and extent of weather events happening is unprecedented. Listen to what scientists are telling us. What we are experiencing ourselves.

SucculentChalice · 11/04/2022 13:52

@Momijin

There are protests all the time. You don't understand that they don't make the news unless they cause a nuisance like this. The world is dying. The scientists are telling us that if we don't do something now we won't have a future worth living. We can make the changes but they have to be now. The climate is causing floods, fires, wars and famine all over the world. What the protestors do is nothing compared to that. It is the only way they make the news. They would much rather be doing other stuff, trust me.
So pretty much what history tells us has been normal on this planet for its entire history - fires, floods, volcanos erupting, wars, famines, etc. Its actually a bit colder than it was prior to around 1250 - we know that because there were Norse vikings living on Greenland who died out due to the cold meaning they didn't have a long enough growing season to grow hay for their animals in winter.

But don't let hysteria get in the way of history!

And as for insulation - it has to be the easiest thing to install yourself. I really don't need a patronising attention seeking pressure group to tell me how to install something I installed years ago.

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 11/04/2022 13:47

What the protestors do is nothing compared to that. It is the only way they make the news. They would much rather be doing other stuff, trust me.

No they wouldn't, it might involve working.

Reluctantadult · 11/04/2022 13:46

Quoting @woodhill above, "I know a couple of people involved in this group and they are privileged, they don't work on a payroll as such and have dhs in good jobs so tbh they get on my nerves".

But this is where the government /system has us over a barrel. We're all too busy working hard to make ends meet to look up. And that's the way they want us to stay. They are invested in maintaining the status quo, because it works for them.

Momijin · 11/04/2022 13:38

There are protests all the time. You don't understand that they don't make the news unless they cause a nuisance like this. The world is dying. The scientists are telling us that if we don't do something now we won't have a future worth living. We can make the changes but they have to be now. The climate is causing floods, fires, wars and famine all over the world. What the protestors do is nothing compared to that. It is the only way they make the news. They would much rather be doing other stuff, trust me.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 11/04/2022 13:36

but I have yet to meet anyone who thinks reducing the need to turn on your boiler is a bad thing.

I agree, and I've never said otherwise.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 11/04/2022 13:35

For the avoidance of doubt - I have stuffed my loft with insulation and the antics of ER don't make me inclined to throw it out of the window.

My sole point was in reply to the poster who had characterised it as a simplistic and guaranteed cost saving to consumers if the government "listened" to Insulate Britain. It's far from clear - that is my only point.

carefullycourageous · 11/04/2022 13:34

not understanding that should say

carefullycourageous · 11/04/2022 13:34

@daimbarsatemydogsbone

So just to be clear - you wouldn't want to see reduced energy usage and associated costs because of higher standing charges?

Please tell me where I said that?

I guess I am just understanding what your point is.

Yes there are lots of other issues around energy markets and priving, but I have yet to meet anyone who thinks reducing the need to turn on your boiler is a bad thing.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 11/04/2022 13:23

So just to be clear - you wouldn't want to see reduced energy usage and associated costs because of higher standing charges?

Please tell me where I said that?