Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Eco protesting

264 replies

Boomerwang · 11/04/2022 05:59

Apparently there's a bill going forward to give police more powers to deal with protests and vigils that cause 'serious unease' or 'serious annoyance' and this bill has been blocked several times by Keir Starmer previously.

AIBU to think police should be granted more powers to stop protestors from blocking access points? I fully agree the right to protest must be protected, but what about when it affects others?

I'd argue to go even further and stop the waste of taxpayer's money by having to involve the police at all but then I know people would get seriously hurt this way and that's not okay.

At the same time, I wonder how effective these protests are by forcing us to confront what's going on and whether ultimately they are doing something good? Would they achieve results by sitting to the side of access points instead? Would anyone listen if daily life were uninterrupted? Does anyone stop to think of the cause just because they were physically stopped? Surely it's impossible to sympathise when you're angry?

Personally protesting is something I read about in the news but it doesn't prompt me to reflect on my contribution or research further.

Has anyone been affected by protests before and did it make you consider environment and ecology after the event?

OP posts:
JennyForeigner · 12/04/2022 07:03

Pretty much all of your fundamental rights were established through protest.

Complacent to think it can just be junked now.

SScoobiedoo · 12/04/2022 07:01

So, I will ask you, the OP, what else (other than nothing) can a human being, who knows that we are all in danger, has tried EVERYTHING else, for YEARS, do to try and effect change?
Errrrrr. Stand for parliament?
Join the greens and try to sort them out?

SScoobiedoo · 12/04/2022 06:58

It is anti-British to ban protest, freedom of speech is and always has been a cornerstone of the British democratic system.
So some comfortably off, middle class retirees can stop the lorry driver doing his job and providing for his family cos they're cross about something ....... Nah that's not British.

Tumbleweed101 · 12/04/2022 06:52

Protests should never be forbidden. One day any one of us could come across an issue we feel passionate about or will affect us so negatively that it becomes our only option.

With climate change I think the pandemic has shown that when it wants to the world can work towards one goal. Stopping movement of people around the globe, for example. Lockdowns, home working. If the world wanted global climate sanctions in place it could be done but this would have to be balanced against quality of life and freedom.

RagingRagingAndMoreRaging · 12/04/2022 06:48

Boomerwang

You are right that there are other, less disruptive ways of protesting. They have all been tried before. For well over 30 years.

We are facing mass extinction. People are already dying or suffering due to climate change. We now have a tiny tiny window of opportunity to make radical changes to avert the worst effects and minimise how many people suffer and die.

For over 30 years there have been petitions, marches, protests, scientific reports etc etc. government after government have ignored this, allowed big oil companies to sway decisions and chosen profits over planet and people. They have recently watered down their environmental policy despite the science clearly pointing to the way forward.

For over 30 years they have not acted in our best interests in this matter. They are not making decisions that will protect us from harm. And they could.

So, I will ask you, the OP, what else (other than nothing) can a human being, who knows that we are all in danger, has tried EVERYTHING else, for YEARS, do to try and effect change?

RagingRagingAndMoreRaging · 12/04/2022 06:37

MeasureTwice

TBH it’s not you they want to influence. Your opinion is irrelevant here. Im not being rude. Mine isn’t relevant either. You will have seen the protests and marches, perhaps the petitions, you may have read the scientific reports or the media coverage of them, you might have watched David Attenborough etc but if none of that made you see what is happening and what needs to be done, nothing will.

Everything that can be done to help people to understand and make changes, has been done, for well over 30 years.

Direct action and civil disobedience isn’t about changing public opinion. It’s about disruption, sending a clear message. It’s an act of deliberate defiance to try and get Governments to act in the best interests of the people.

If an otherwise law abiding, emotionally stable, professional, middle aged woman is ready to be arrested and go to prison to get her message to the Government then that says something.

I know people whose working lives have been dedicated to studying climate change and they are SCARED! They lose sleep worrying about their childrens future. Trying to figure out which country might be the safest for them (space to avoid social unrest, cooler climate to grow crops,etc). We should all be out there protesting and shouting because our Governments have sequentially chosen profits before planet and people. Across the globe. Their decisions are putting lives at risk and they KNOW it. The science could not be clearer. For years now.

Again, I’ll ask, what else can be done, other than nothing - which in the face of very possible complete extinction of the human race, seems a bit silly?

RagingRagingAndMoreRaging · 12/04/2022 06:22

Gilead

I blame the government, there wouldn’t be a need for protest if they started listening to common sense. We need a clear and fast track environment policy.

Me too. We (any human living on this planet that wants to avoid a mass extinction event) have nothing left to try now except civil disobedience and direct action. Sad

RagingRagingAndMoreRaging · 12/04/2022 06:19

MangyInseam

I get that. I do. But again, what SHOULD they do? Everything else has been tried. For 30+ years. Civil disobedience is all that’s left.

MeasureTwice · 12/04/2022 02:35

Disruptive protests only make me angry, tbh. They certainly don't change my attitude in a positive way toward the groups responsible. If anything, they make me feel less inclined to listen to what they have to say.

Gilead · 12/04/2022 00:27

I blame the government, there wouldn’t be a need for protest if they started listening to common sense. We need a clear and fast track environment policy.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 12/04/2022 00:14

@Momijin

Such shortsightedness and ignorance will be the end of us all
Yeah, nice accusations but you've been very light on what you actually want and how it will work in practice.

You may be right about the outcome but I guarantee people gluing themselves to tube trains isn't going to help anyone.

In the words of the Beatles "you say you want a revolution - we all wanna change the world"

MangyInseam · 11/04/2022 23:36

Frankly, their actions suggest they don't give a shit at all.

MangyInseam · 11/04/2022 23:35

@RagingRagingAndMoreRaging

www.scotsman.com/news/opinion/columnists/how-climate-change-has-become-a-deadly-threat-to-people-in-somalia-daud-jiran-3548305

www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-africa-61036465

The effects of climate change are already killing people and this is before the temperature rises predicted. The two articles above are about drought in Somalia but we have all seen footage of flooding and fires too.

Climate chaos is here and it’s only going to get worse. We do still have a small window of time to limit the worst of it.

If we don’t take drastic action now, the above will be the reality for much more of the world. Food will get harder and harder to grow, everywhere. Pollinators are dying, soil is degrading, weather is getting warmer, wetter and wilder.

Some crops have already failed here in the UK due to climate change.

This isn’t something we can ignore. This isn’t something we can wait to vote on (like with the pandemic) - this requires strong and immediate action.

Those that saw this coming have tried petitions, peaceful protest, writing to MPs, campaigning in all its forms and presenting the best scientific information to governments for 30+ years. Governments have been too invested in votes and keeping oil companies happy. Of course, oil companies have done a great job of PR, lobbying and smearing environmental scientists too. So all in all, progress has been way too slow.

Of those of you who are damning the protestors. Please, tell me what else we (the people) can do to implore our government to act in our collective best interests, other than these direct, disruptive actions and civil disobedience. What else is there that hasn’t already been tried, time and time again. I can’t see any other option than direct action and civil disobedience.

People are already dying. These protesters at least give a shit about that.

If you believe this is serious, the last thing you should want is protesters purposefully alienating the public.

Do you seriously think pissing people off will somehow force the government to do what you want? Or make those same people put pressure on the government to do what you want?

RagingRagingAndMoreRaging · 11/04/2022 22:45

www.scotsman.com/news/opinion/columnists/how-climate-change-has-become-a-deadly-threat-to-people-in-somalia-daud-jiran-3548305

www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-africa-61036465

The effects of climate change are already killing people and this is before the temperature rises predicted. The two articles above are about drought in Somalia but we have all seen footage of flooding and fires too.

Climate chaos is here and it’s only going to get worse. We do still have a small window of time to limit the worst of it.

If we don’t take drastic action now, the above will be the reality for much more of the world. Food will get harder and harder to grow, everywhere. Pollinators are dying, soil is degrading, weather is getting warmer, wetter and wilder.

Some crops have already failed here in the UK due to climate change.

This isn’t something we can ignore. This isn’t something we can wait to vote on (like with the pandemic) - this requires strong and immediate action.

Those that saw this coming have tried petitions, peaceful protest, writing to MPs, campaigning in all its forms and presenting the best scientific information to governments for 30+ years. Governments have been too invested in votes and keeping oil companies happy. Of course, oil companies have done a great job of PR, lobbying and smearing environmental scientists too. So all in all, progress has been way too slow.

Of those of you who are damning the protestors. Please, tell me what else we (the people) can do to implore our government to act in our collective best interests, other than these direct, disruptive actions and civil disobedience. What else is there that hasn’t already been tried, time and time again. I can’t see any other option than direct action and civil disobedience.

People are already dying. These protesters at least give a shit about that.

Wintersonata · 11/04/2022 21:58

I agree - I sometimes wonder if some of these groups are actually helped and encouraged by the "rich people" they hate

Yes it would be interesting to know who donated and how much. Don’t the owners of Lush give money to causes like this? Presumably they are very rich.

Momijin · 11/04/2022 21:29

Such shortsightedness and ignorance will be the end of us all

sst1234 · 11/04/2022 21:26

Unfortunately too many thickos think that they are changing the world by ‘protesting’. While the smart ones get on with solving problems with real engineered solutions.

Fimofriend · 11/04/2022 20:47

Why are climate protesters always such wankers? After the Greenpeace demonstration in Copenhagen in 2009 there was so much garbage left in the streets that it cost the equivalent of one year's wages for two nursery nurses to clean up after them. A huge team started cleaning right after the demonstration stopped Saturday afternoon. There were people cleaning all through the night and it continued until late afternoon Sunday. In the afternoon on the Sunday three people from Greenpeace showed up and claimed that the council workers really didn't have to clean it up as they had every intention of doing it themselves. Three people. As if. It would have taken them more than a month.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 11/04/2022 20:05

Why weren't they active during winter

That's what I keep asking and there's never been an answer. If it's all such an emergency you'd think they'd be out whatever the weather, but no - they only come crawling (or rather, driving) out once the weather improves

FWIW I also agree with the right to protest responsibly, but there's nothing responsible about blocking ambulances and so on, and for me that's when they should be shifted

MangyInseam · 11/04/2022 19:33

What I find amazing is that these protesters seem to think the reason you protest is to disrupt the lives of other citizens, so that they will be pissed off and the government will take action to placate them.

It's a softer version of the philosophy of terrorism, which says that you threaten citizens in order to force the state to negotiate.

That is not "protest." That is not showing the state that the citizens at large want a certain change or something addressed. Or even just that a group has a problem with a certain policy or action or lack of action.

When protesters start to use pressure on other citizens to get their way, they become a lobby group trying to force society to do what they want. And they should not be surprised if society returns the favour by using the power of the law to stop them doing it.

Whether on not they think it's justified is irrelevant, that's always what authoritarian factions think.

Daftasabroom · 11/04/2022 18:47

@chitofftheshovel what would convince you that "climate chaos" is real?

chitofftheshovel · 11/04/2022 17:38

I absolutely agree with the right to protest. However, to cause mass upheaval and risk to life does their cause no good.

I am yet to be convinced that we are in "climate chaos" - floods, fires, earthquakes, volcano eruptions etc have all occurred since long before humans.

What ER and their ilk have been doing has been absolutely risking other peoples lives. Those twats who dangled on a rope from a London bridge had to be "rescued" by professionals putting not only the rescuers lives at risk but also other people who may have had a genuine emergency.

Personally, I would have cut their ropes and let them get on with it. Idiots who glued themselves to the road would have been pulled off, none of this namby pamby gently taking the glue off with specialist solvent.

MangyInseam · 11/04/2022 17:27

History gives us examples of campaigns that both changed the geopolitical landscape to those that although unsuccessful, highlighted oppression. Spartacus’ uprising, the Protestant Reformation, the Boston Tea Party, the Haitian Revolution, the Storming of the Bastille, Nat Turner’s Rebellion, the Hungarian Revolution, Gandhi’s Salt March, the Stonewall Riots, Vietnam war protests, Tiananmen Square, the anti- Apartheid movement are just a few examples of struggles throughout history that represent the human need to make their own choices, to be free from oppression in all forms as well as to be given a voice.

I suspect Gandhi would not have thought of protests intended to pressurize regular people into doing what you want are a good or moral idea.

Just because you think a cause is worthy does not mean any way you try and achieve it is ok, or even pragmatic.

Cherryblossoms85 · 11/04/2022 17:13

What I find fundamentally bizarre is when the protestors from Just Stop Oil are interviewed and say they're just providing a future for their children. If oil production stopped overnight, we would all starve well before we got to this utopian future. What's needed is huge investment in alternatives, and that doesn't happen in countries where basic infrastructure has ground to a halt in the meantime.

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 11/04/2022 17:07

What is more important than your future and your children's future??What?

If someone I loved had been in one of those ambulances that couldn't get through they would have been much more important to me than anyone or anything else.

Swipe left for the next trending thread