Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Eco protesting

264 replies

Boomerwang · 11/04/2022 05:59

Apparently there's a bill going forward to give police more powers to deal with protests and vigils that cause 'serious unease' or 'serious annoyance' and this bill has been blocked several times by Keir Starmer previously.

AIBU to think police should be granted more powers to stop protestors from blocking access points? I fully agree the right to protest must be protected, but what about when it affects others?

I'd argue to go even further and stop the waste of taxpayer's money by having to involve the police at all but then I know people would get seriously hurt this way and that's not okay.

At the same time, I wonder how effective these protests are by forcing us to confront what's going on and whether ultimately they are doing something good? Would they achieve results by sitting to the side of access points instead? Would anyone listen if daily life were uninterrupted? Does anyone stop to think of the cause just because they were physically stopped? Surely it's impossible to sympathise when you're angry?

Personally protesting is something I read about in the news but it doesn't prompt me to reflect on my contribution or research further.

Has anyone been affected by protests before and did it make you consider environment and ecology after the event?

OP posts:
MangyInseam · 12/04/2022 12:40

[quote Daftasabroom]@Puzzledandpissedoff from a climate perspective we are far far from being a microscopic pinprick and climate modelling is solid applied physics.

As you say any fool can post nonsense.[/quote]
It's not the same as making an airplane fly, though. I don't dispute climate change at all but I think it's rather disingenuous to suggest that modelling of that kind of a complex system with an infinite number of variables is the same as designing an airplane.

MangyInseam · 12/04/2022 12:37

@Thebestwaytoscareatory

the UK bears a significant responsibility for past emmisions and we can only benefit from reducing our future emmisions and developing the technologies and skills to do so.

We bear a significant responsibility for current emissons. The UK, and much of the West, are net importers of CO2e emissions. China, so often highlighted as the big bad polluter, is a net exporter by quite a significant amount. In essence, China are only the biggest source of emissons because we've offshored our production and they're the ones meeting the demand of our consumption habits.

The Global Carbon Project do huge amounts of research into embodied/embedded carbon emissons, which is widely ignored by Western media because it reveals us to be the issue, and we want to continue to pretend there's nothing we can do cause...China!

Tbh this thread has just reinforced the idea that discussion, debate, education, stats, figures, and facts are pointless. Huge chunks of the population don't believe, or just ignore, the truth.

Instead they'll close their eyes, stick their fingers in their ears, and scream "what about...X!" while they march off towards the cliff edge. Which would be fine if only they were going to be affected but, unfortunately we're all chained together and once they go over we're getting dragged over too. It's fucking depressing when you think about it, it's a genuine don't look up scenario.

All the polling suggests that actually, most people are quite concerned about it.

Protests like these actually drive a wedge, it's so counter-productive it's sad. Like a pp said it's mainly about protecting the future for the descendants of the protesters, that's the survival drive for my DNA at work even if they don't realize it.

The elephant in the room, even on this thread, is that "doing something" is a pretty meaningless thing to say. Protesters don't have any really bright ideas, and neither do the political leaders. Use less energy? Use less stuff? Switch to renewable. Lovely, but what does that actually mean?

Right now, the economy, the banking system, is based on oil. People are freaking out right now because of lack of availability of products and inflation and the real fear of food shortages. There are multiple threads with people saying there will or even ought to be riots for the government to "do something." The aftermath of dialing back consumption and energy use is not going to be different economically, that is what it will mean to a lot of people,.

Policies around energy have all kinds of other implications. Look at Germany right now. Or the dirty little secret of the environmental movement which is that renewables will not keep us in anything like the way we have become accustomed to. Probably they would keep us in a way that's just fine objectively, but not with the consumer goods, travel, transportation, big cities, choices in the supermarket, internet access, that we are used to now. People who move away from home to work will have to expect expect, as they did 70 years ago, that they will see their family rarely, or maybe never again. Accepting immigrants will become a serious burden as they create more demands on what will be very limited resources.

For at least a generation the environmental movement has been telling people that tech means we will be able to keep a lifestyle very much like the one we have now and still be light on the planet. That's bs and always has been. Protesters may well be right about the problems on the horizon but they are asking politicians to make choices that they themselves would likely freak out about, and that would crash the banks, make the leaders unelectable.

They are really offering nothing besides self-centered whining towards what is a really difficult problem without clear solutions.

Daftasabroom · 12/04/2022 12:28

@Puzzledandpissedoff

Google is your friend, Daftasabroom, not least because it highlights the difference between the reputable reports available and the kind of nonsense spewed all over Twatter, etc.

And if people genuinely want information I've always found they'll be willing to research it for themselves rather than asking others to do it for them

So actually you can't provide a single link to a single report to support your views.

So let's leave Google out of it for a bit, which particular element of climate change do you think is wrong?

Puzzledandpissedoff · 12/04/2022 12:12

Google is your friend, Daftasabroom, not least because it highlights the difference between the reputable reports available and the kind of nonsense spewed all over Twatter, etc.

And if people genuinely want information I've always found they'll be willing to research it for themselves rather than asking others to do it for them

Daftasabroom · 12/04/2022 11:59

@Puzzledandpissedoff can you link to some of these peer reviewed articles that demonstrate that climate modelling is "wrong" to the extent that you suggest?

Resilience · 12/04/2022 11:36

I believe climate change is real. It concerns me and I try to live greenly. However, the planet is not facing destruction. Humans and a whole range of species maybe, but the planet will rejuvenate in some form (based on our understanding of planets at present). While I don't want my children to suffer, I sometimes think the planet would be better off without us anyway. Personally, I think the focus has to be on targeting governments and big business (especially). Anything else won't achieve meaningful change. Lobby groups can be very powerful.

I support the right to peaceful protest but think the majority are completely pointless. They show a complete inability to understand how humans behave. Saying it's just one day of inconvenience compared to a lifetime of suffering completely fails to take into account the suffering caused by that one day of 'inconvenience.' For the self-employed or those not salaried that lost day of earning can translate to not being able to afford your child's much-needed new shoes or birthday present, going hungry, not being able to pay rent. Live in a city frequently impacted by protests and it's not a one-off either. A lot of people just get really pissed off, even when originally they had sympathy with the cause. Throw in a bit of hypocrisy and it's why a lot of protests are now being seen as an example of privileged virtue-signalling rather than a real desire to effect change. No one likes being dismissed as collateral damage, whatever their political persuasion.

A lot of protests also spiral beyond the original organiser's well-intentioned plans. I've been to way too many where quite a lot of the protesters have come for a social occasion and don't really know what it's all about (kill the bill was terrible for this, with many not knowing the name of the bill or what it proposed).

We're all hypocrites on the subject of climate change to some degree. Protests are largely organised through social media, which we all use regularly on our nice shiny, regularly updated, electronic devices which are incredibly polluting both to make and dispose of...

Puzzledandpissedoff · 12/04/2022 11:05

Climate modelling is solid applied physics

Shame the modelling's so often been shown to be wrong then - goodness knows there are enough scholarly articles about it, if you care to use actual information rather than soundbites

Puzzledandpissedoff · 12/04/2022 11:00

Thats the thing isn't it the human race sees itself as most impoRtant and that we can control nature
A lot of assumptions they make are based on xyz and what we may know from the past , but we don't know the future and we can't predict everything

Precisely, worried, but it plays well on social media and to some that seems the greater aim

I'd forget the running for office thing though, at least among the type whose real ambition is to get dragged away at a demo so they can howl "police brutality" and get a few more likes and strings of emojis. Too many struggle even to form a coherent sentence unless it's just slogans, so I expect a properly organised campaign would be beyond them

Neverreturntoathread · 12/04/2022 10:59

The tactics used by Extinction Rebellion and those morons at Insulate Britain crossed a line. In particular putting buggies in the road was awful. But a lot of those tactics were already illegal.

I’m very nervous about giving the police more powers because they don’t seem to use their current powers well. Look at the violence used my groups of male police against women at the vigil for Sarah Everard.

In general I resent that protesters go on a march or whatever and feel like they have done their bit. Tackling climate change is a long hard road and protests achieve little, lobbying politicians and journalists is more effective, as is actually getting work in the relevant areas and trying to become a decision maker.

Daftasabroom · 12/04/2022 10:59

@worriedatthistime every time you get on a plane or in your car or walk in through your front you are relying on engineers and scientists to accurately predict flight physics, crash safety and building integrity. You can't pick and choose when physics does and doesn't apply to you.

Daftasabroom · 12/04/2022 10:49

@Puzzledandpissedoff from a climate perspective we are far far from being a microscopic pinprick and climate modelling is solid applied physics.

As you say any fool can post nonsense.

DdraigGoch · 12/04/2022 10:43

For example, better, affordable environmentally friendly public transport would really help with traffic and being able to get to work

How does gluing oneself to a DLR train improve access to public transport?

Let's see how the workers of Canning Town felt about having their journeys (again by electric train) disrupted:

worriedatthistime · 12/04/2022 10:33

@Thebestwaytoscareatory why don't these protesters set up a political party or join existing ones , many of them come from the money to do so, then they could advocate for real change, rather than cause misery and disruption to the average person just trying go get by

worriedatthistime · 12/04/2022 10:31

@Puzzledandpissedoff thats the thing isn't it the human race sees itself as most impoRtant and that we can control nature
A lot of assumptions they make are based on xyz and what we may know from the past , but we don't know the future and we can't predict everything
We can al try and do better and live more sustainably but a bunch of rich people telling others what they should do isn't going fo change the world

worriedatthistime · 12/04/2022 10:28

@Thebestwaytoscareatory typed from non essential chinese smart phone

Puzzledandpissedoff · 12/04/2022 10:25

Business as usual is naive, arrogant and will harm us as much as anyone else

This can be true, but isn't there also a certain arrogance in believing we're all that counts with the planet, when from a climatic perspective we're a microscopic pinprick?

Personally I believe a lot of the angst is down to social media, where any fool can (and often does) post utter nonsense in the knowledge there'll be enough credulous folk to form an audience. Doubtless someone will mention modelling, but as we've seen with Covid, it amounts to little more than guesswork

worriedatthistime · 12/04/2022 10:22

@NeverDropYourMooncup exactly and they we are all stupid and think they are doing it for us and our children

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 12/04/2022 10:21

the UK bears a significant responsibility for past emmisions and we can only benefit from reducing our future emmisions and developing the technologies and skills to do so.

We bear a significant responsibility for current emissons. The UK, and much of the West, are net importers of CO2e emissions. China, so often highlighted as the big bad polluter, is a net exporter by quite a significant amount. In essence, China are only the biggest source of emissons because we've offshored our production and they're the ones meeting the demand of our consumption habits.

The Global Carbon Project do huge amounts of research into embodied/embedded carbon emissons, which is widely ignored by Western media because it reveals us to be the issue, and we want to continue to pretend there's nothing we can do cause...China!

Tbh this thread has just reinforced the idea that discussion, debate, education, stats, figures, and facts are pointless. Huge chunks of the population don't believe, or just ignore, the truth.

Instead they'll close their eyes, stick their fingers in their ears, and scream "what about...X!" while they march off towards the cliff edge. Which would be fine if only they were going to be affected but, unfortunately we're all chained together and once they go over we're getting dragged over too. It's fucking depressing when you think about it, it's a genuine don't look up scenario.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 12/04/2022 10:18

@RagingRagingAndMoreRaging

MeasureTwice

TBH it’s not you they want to influence. Your opinion is irrelevant here. Im not being rude. Mine isn’t relevant either. You will have seen the protests and marches, perhaps the petitions, you may have read the scientific reports or the media coverage of them, you might have watched David Attenborough etc but if none of that made you see what is happening and what needs to be done, nothing will.

Everything that can be done to help people to understand and make changes, has been done, for well over 30 years.

Direct action and civil disobedience isn’t about changing public opinion. It’s about disruption, sending a clear message. It’s an act of deliberate defiance to try and get Governments to act in the best interests of the people.

If an otherwise law abiding, emotionally stable, professional, middle aged woman is ready to be arrested and go to prison to get her message to the Government then that says something.

I know people whose working lives have been dedicated to studying climate change and they are SCARED! They lose sleep worrying about their childrens future. Trying to figure out which country might be the safest for them (space to avoid social unrest, cooler climate to grow crops,etc). We should all be out there protesting and shouting because our Governments have sequentially chosen profits before planet and people. Across the globe. Their decisions are putting lives at risk and they KNOW it. The science could not be clearer. For years now.

Again, I’ll ask, what else can be done, other than nothing - which in the face of very possible complete extinction of the human race, seems a bit silly?

Yes. It says that she is financially secure and will not face eviction for failing to pay rent - unlike the poor fuckers she's preventing from getting to work.

And that she doesn't give a shit about whether they end up dying because they can't get to a hospital appointment because 'ideals' and the future of future inheritors of her wealth and DNA is of more value to her than the immediate risk to the people she is harming.

The best thing that could happen to the planet as a whole is that those grandchildren do suffer and do not make it to reproductive age. The planet would be fine, different, but fine. People on the whole, however, not so. But that's what has been happening for millennia. Poor people get shafted, the rich wish to protect their assets and genetic line. The protestors don't appreciate that they are the rich to the vast majority of the world and explain this as being oh, so very distraught at the thought of the future where their genes might not get propagated and great grandchildren may not inherit the comfortable houses and work in comfortable offices with the knowledge that there will be enough money to go and get themselves arrested.

Daftasabroom · 12/04/2022 10:07

@worriedatthistime apologies. One thing is certain and that the world will change....

NeverDropYourMooncup · 12/04/2022 10:05

The trouble is that people having lower energy bills directly contradicts their motives for protesting - to reduce use. Higher costs result in non essential use being reduced. So in reality, what they would actually want is homes insulated AND prices raised even higher.

It's the same with water. Water meters reduce usage. It's a fact. But they also cost poor people and disabled people a far greater proportion of their lower incomes. Because if the prices are so low that it doesn't negatively affect somebody on a low income to use what they actually need, it has even less effect upon the people who can easily afford it and don't care about the size of the water bill filling up their baths and Jacuzzis and putting the sprinklers on through the day.

worriedatthistime · 12/04/2022 10:03

@Daftasabroom sorry it doesn't make sense

Daftasabroom · 12/04/2022 09:51

@worriedatthistime one thing is certain, and that is the will change and now is the opportunity for us to drive and influence that change for the better.

worriedatthistime · 12/04/2022 09:44

@Daftasabroom i never said they were doing more than good maybe read my post
The average person is not listening to them now due to latest antics
And as another poster said where were they all winter

worriedatthistime · 12/04/2022 09:41

@Daftasabroom but we can't change the world and its ignorant to think we can
These protesters are not doing good most everyday people hate the disruption and switch of when most of these privileged people come on and talk
When they protested in my small town , they all drove from miles away

Swipe left for the next trending thread