Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Eco protesting

264 replies

Boomerwang · 11/04/2022 05:59

Apparently there's a bill going forward to give police more powers to deal with protests and vigils that cause 'serious unease' or 'serious annoyance' and this bill has been blocked several times by Keir Starmer previously.

AIBU to think police should be granted more powers to stop protestors from blocking access points? I fully agree the right to protest must be protected, but what about when it affects others?

I'd argue to go even further and stop the waste of taxpayer's money by having to involve the police at all but then I know people would get seriously hurt this way and that's not okay.

At the same time, I wonder how effective these protests are by forcing us to confront what's going on and whether ultimately they are doing something good? Would they achieve results by sitting to the side of access points instead? Would anyone listen if daily life were uninterrupted? Does anyone stop to think of the cause just because they were physically stopped? Surely it's impossible to sympathise when you're angry?

Personally protesting is something I read about in the news but it doesn't prompt me to reflect on my contribution or research further.

Has anyone been affected by protests before and did it make you consider environment and ecology after the event?

OP posts:
PinkSparklyPussyCat · 13/04/2022 18:34

We do not need fossil fuels. That's it.

We do though and will do for a long time. People will have petrol and diesel cars for years after they stop being sold. I've got a new car, I'm in no position to change to electric even if I wanted to as I'm paying for that. Even if I hand it back after 3 years it'll be too new to be scrapped so it'll be around for a good few years.

Momijin · 13/04/2022 14:46

[quote mmmmmmghturep]@Momijin Im talking about the blocking of the oil refineries and well you know it despite your attempt at obfuscation It caused a shortage at the pumps People need fuel to get to work and things like out patient hospital appointments[/quote]
Shame that our government didn't want to subsidise electric cars like some scandinavian countries (until economies of scale take over) which would mean that our reliance on fossil fuels would be less.

The fossil fuels that is destroying the planet and causing wars? That is making us reliant on countries that we would rather not be reliant on..

Yep, that one.

We do not need fossil fuels. That's it.

We only use them because our government is made up of wealthy people with their hands in the fossil fuel pie.

Did you see how the whole world had to stop because of covid? More of that is coming.

There will be food scarcity. Because global warming messes up the eco system. Global warming is happening too quickly. It means our eco system can't adapt in time.

Extreme weather events will cause huge disruption. You won't be able to take anyone to any hospital when the roads are flooded or there are big fallen trees blocking the roads. Or a fire blocking your access.

Momijin · 13/04/2022 14:38

@QuebecBagnet

The lead XR person famously said he’d block an ambulance
If you're referring to Roger Hallam, he is no longer a member of XR. XR is about non violent direct action.
mmmmmmghturep · 13/04/2022 14:20

@Momijin Im talking about the blocking of the oil refineries and well you know it despite your attempt at obfuscation It caused a shortage at the pumps People need fuel to get to work and things like out patient hospital appointments

worriedatthistime · 13/04/2022 07:52

@Daftasabroom im fully aware that led don't contain mercury , thats why I said low energy ( cfl) , but they aren't being phased out and there are millions of them and they will be around for years and years to come
Most people don't even know and when they smash them they sweep yp as normal or when they burn oit they chuck them in bin
There will be millions of broken ones in landfills all over.
They have put people at risk when they should of been putting money into led technology as it was right around the corner.
Have you read the clean up instructions for a cfl and what to do if it gets on your carpet or clothes

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 13/04/2022 07:42

@QuebecBagnet

The lead XR person famously said he’d block an ambulance
I bet he'd feel different if it was him that needed the ambulance, which he might one day if this carries on.

They should just be moved on whether they are glued to the road or not. The skin will grow back eventually.

QuebecBagnet · 13/04/2022 06:24

The lead XR person famously said he’d block an ambulance

Daftasabroom · 13/04/2022 06:06

@MangyInseam I'm guessing you don't do much system modelling; there is a whole world of difference between inaccurate and wrong. For over thirty years climate predictions have been clear and consistent. Ever increasing accuracy does not make previous studies wrong.

Momijin · 13/04/2022 02:29

@mmmmmmghturep

Protestors will let emergency services through

@Momijin People also need fuel so they can drive to out patient appointments. Or should they think. Fuck it i will call an ambulance to make sure i can get to my appointment.

Fgs, they don't gridlock a whole city. Usually it is just one tiny place. I have worse every day with roadworks and accidents.
MangyInseam · 12/04/2022 23:43

[quote Daftasabroom]@Puzzledandpissedoff I'm definitely not trying to score points. The burden of proof is on you to support your argument, that's pretty fundamental to debate don't you think?[/quote]
It's really not difficult to find examples where climate modelling has been inaccurate, it happens all the time, and it's not even like there is only one model.

Daftasabroom · 12/04/2022 17:52

@Puzzledandpissedoff I'm definitely not trying to score points. The burden of proof is on you to support your argument, that's pretty fundamental to debate don't you think?

Puzzledandpissedoff · 12/04/2022 16:56

Which particular element of climate change do you think is wrong?

The reaction to it, as in competitive hyperbole, pointless virtue signalling all over social media, and the more ridiculous activities of ER and the like

And you might try to be a bit more original with the depressingly predictable "So you can't provide a single link", when what I actually said was that I'm not prepared to post links if people aren't interested beyond attempting to score silly points

mmmmmmghturep · 12/04/2022 15:12

Protestors will let emergency services through

@Momijin People also need fuel so they can drive to out patient appointments. Or should they think. Fuck it i will call an ambulance to make sure i can get to my appointment.

mmmmmmghturep · 12/04/2022 15:06

So what if one of these eco warriors has an accident on a protest and has to be taken to hospital to be treated by NHS staff..............oh wait NHS staff who wont be there because they cant get the petrol/diesal to get to work!!

Daftasabroom · 12/04/2022 15:01

@PinkSparklyPussyCat correct there would be little point in swapping out good boilers. Boilers in new builds will be phased out in 2025.

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 12/04/2022 14:52

The big change will be to air source heat pumps - there are specific high temperature versions for retrofit.

I presume this will only be when a boiler needs replacing and millions of perfectly good boilers won't be sent to landfill (I wouldn't put it past the government!)?

Daftasabroom · 12/04/2022 14:42

@worriedatthistime LEDs don't contain mercury and fluorescents are being phased out.

Daftasabroom · 12/04/2022 14:36

@worriedatthistime @MangyInseam And fucking protesters solution is to go around pissing off the very people they need to support. on this I agree.

So a few of the things that are in the pipeline.

Decarbonising electricity generation. This is well underway, wind supplied 25% in 2020 and a 500% increase is planned within the next ten years. Floating wind demonstrators are planned and installations likely to be operation with the next ten years in the Celtic Sea. LPG and waste to energy will provide short term base load and this will be replaced by small modular nuclear. Tide and wave are unlikely to be competitive. Solar will be the first option for onshore and industrial building installation.

Decarbonising heating of buildings. More insulation, up to 20% H2 in the existing supply. The big change will be to air source heat pumps - there are specific high temperature versions for retrofit.

Decarbonising transport. A mixture of electricity and H2. Road transport, a mix of electric with some H2 for HGV and buses etc. Off highway - again a mix of electric and H2, maybe some biofuels such as biobutanol. Shipping, electric short run, biofuel and wind for long distance. Aerospace; UAM market is currently looking at electric, regional LH2, inter/transcontinental biofuels.

This is all in development right now and would address about 75% of our emissions.

worriedatthistime · 12/04/2022 14:16

@Daftasabroom you cannot compare the whole world some of which we still know little about with aircraft design
We haven't even explored the whole ocean , why are you using a mobile now ?
Do any of these people live in a fully solar powered house , eat mostly from their land and live a while different life , judging by what many of them wear - no
The alternatives may be seen as greened bit like the revolution of energy light bulbs and how much electric they save , lets ignore the mercury in them though that can be released when broken, in a fragile glass container, some scientist thought they were a good idea

worriedatthistime · 12/04/2022 14:11

@Daftasabroom i don't even not necessarily not believe in climate change but What I don't agree in is these groups which are causing chaos and risking lifes here and now
We could change everything and it still might not make a difference as I said if mother nature has other plans, if you believe in the science then we descended from a different form than today
But these groups are nothing more than trouble makers
The only time I have seen anything from them is when they are causing choas

worriedatthistime · 12/04/2022 14:03

@Daftasabroom they don't even all agree on this though
And i know when I fly there is also always a risk as with anything designed or decided by a human , their wouldn't br accidents then
Scientists don't trump mother nature

Notanotherwindow · 12/04/2022 13:51

If someone I loved had been in one of those ambulances that couldn't get through they would have been much more important to me than anyone or anything else

If someone I loved was in one of those ambulances, I'd be in jail for murder. Possibly several murders.

There are ways to effect change that don't endanger others.

fedupwithitnow · 12/04/2022 13:32

@NeverDropYourMooncup

The trouble is that people having lower energy bills directly contradicts their motives for protesting - to reduce use. Higher costs result in non essential use being reduced. So in reality, what they would actually want is homes insulated AND prices raised even higher.

It's the same with water. Water meters reduce usage. It's a fact. But they also cost poor people and disabled people a far greater proportion of their lower incomes. Because if the prices are so low that it doesn't negatively affect somebody on a low income to use what they actually need, it has even less effect upon the people who can easily afford it and don't care about the size of the water bill filling up their baths and Jacuzzis and putting the sprinklers on through the day.

So true
MangyInseam · 12/04/2022 13:18

[quote Daftasabroom]**@MangyInseam* Or the dirty little secret of the environmental movement which is that renewables will not keep us in anything like the way we have become accustomed to. Probably they would keep us in a way that's just fine objectively, but not with the consumer goods, travel, transportation, big cities, choices in the supermarket, internet access, that we are used to now.*

This is simply untrue, there huge technology shifts coming over the next decades, yes we will have to change our behaviour but life overall will be better if we take action now.

There are not an infinite number of variables in climate models, the physics is the same. I think you'd amazed at the level of detail and complexity currently used to model aircraft and aviation operations.[/quote]
No, I don't think I would be amazed.

And I am not disputing we should take action now. That's not the real issue. What action? How? What will be the fall out?

You need to have some level of political realism.

I think you are being fundamentally naive about tech changes. It's not all about emissions and climate change. Look at farming - industrial farming right now, and that includes grains and other plants, is having a significant negative impact on soils that is soon going to come home to roost. It's also oil based. Look at mining.

And fucking protesters solution is to go around pissing off the very people they need to support.

Daftasabroom · 12/04/2022 13:11

@MangyInseam Or the dirty little secret of the environmental movement which is that renewables will not keep us in anything like the way we have become accustomed to. Probably they would keep us in a way that's just fine objectively, but not with the consumer goods, travel, transportation, big cities, choices in the supermarket, internet access, that we are used to now.

This is simply untrue, there huge technology shifts coming over the next decades, yes we will have to change our behaviour but life overall will be better if we take action now.

There are not an infinite number of variables in climate models, the physics is the same. I think you'd amazed at the level of detail and complexity currently used to model aircraft and aviation operations.

Swipe left for the next trending thread