Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Eco protesting

264 replies

Boomerwang · 11/04/2022 05:59

Apparently there's a bill going forward to give police more powers to deal with protests and vigils that cause 'serious unease' or 'serious annoyance' and this bill has been blocked several times by Keir Starmer previously.

AIBU to think police should be granted more powers to stop protestors from blocking access points? I fully agree the right to protest must be protected, but what about when it affects others?

I'd argue to go even further and stop the waste of taxpayer's money by having to involve the police at all but then I know people would get seriously hurt this way and that's not okay.

At the same time, I wonder how effective these protests are by forcing us to confront what's going on and whether ultimately they are doing something good? Would they achieve results by sitting to the side of access points instead? Would anyone listen if daily life were uninterrupted? Does anyone stop to think of the cause just because they were physically stopped? Surely it's impossible to sympathise when you're angry?

Personally protesting is something I read about in the news but it doesn't prompt me to reflect on my contribution or research further.

Has anyone been affected by protests before and did it make you consider environment and ecology after the event?

OP posts:
daimbarsatemydogsbone · 11/04/2022 11:11

@RagingRagingAndMoreRaging

jytdtysrht

What about the impact on people because of climate chaos - which will only get worse - which is what the protesters are trying to highlight?

Already we are seeing floods, fire and food shortages due to climate change. This will only get worse.

What should a human being do to try to save us from the worst of climate change when ALL other options haven’t led to enough change? What’s the alternative? Just sit, roll our eyes and say ‘oh well, let’s just let millions die, because really, this is just too inconvenient. Let’s allow a mass extinction event because we don’t want to inconvenience people.’

I’m thankful that people are willing to incur the wrath of others and risk jail time to try and save us from the worst effects of climate change.

Unless you are successful in ending democracy, most protests of the type we've seen will be counter-productive. You'd be better off arming yourselves and staging a coup so you can impose a government that does what you want.
C25kBecky · 11/04/2022 11:11

Yanu. This current lot blocking the fuel lorries need to be arrested.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 11/04/2022 11:09

Compulsory seatbelts is hardly comparable with the massive changes climate activists advocate is it? Also whilst there is a large degree of compliance I also see people driving without their belt on daily - and people using their phones whilst driving - these are things that largely rely on goodwill. Most of what climate change protesters are seeking would be massive changes to our entire daily lives that were not in any way optional and would have to have 100% compliance - presumably enforced by the draconian type measures they argue against for protests.

RagingRagingAndMoreRaging · 11/04/2022 11:08

jytdtysrht

What about the impact on people because of climate chaos - which will only get worse - which is what the protesters are trying to highlight?

Already we are seeing floods, fire and food shortages due to climate change. This will only get worse.

What should a human being do to try to save us from the worst of climate change when ALL other options haven’t led to enough change? What’s the alternative? Just sit, roll our eyes and say ‘oh well, let’s just let millions die, because really, this is just too inconvenient. Let’s allow a mass extinction event because we don’t want to inconvenience people.’

I’m thankful that people are willing to incur the wrath of others and risk jail time to try and save us from the worst effects of climate change.

Stabbitystabstab · 11/04/2022 11:03

@Stellaris22

I find it hard to believe protestors do this 'because it's fun'. It's frustration and desperation at continual failure of governments. It can't be business as usual and we need a dramatic shift in energy policies which we aren't getting. Not finding these issues important is ignorance. Of course people are rightfully angry and protesting.
Why weren't they active during winter then?
daimbarsatemydogsbone · 11/04/2022 11:02

@RagingRagingAndMoreRaging

daimbarsatemydogsbone

There isn’t time to wait for the next election. We need to change really quickly - we were poised to do this, I think, and then covid happened and focus changed. This is a global emergency- not something that can wait - it transcends geographical boundaries and party politics. It’s too important to wait and see if ‘the people’ vote for extinction or not.

Lots of people wouldn’t have voted for seat belts in cars but legislative measures were put in place because the science was that it would (and has) saved lives. There is no other option if we want to survive as a species. Sometimes Governments HAVE to do things that are unpopular for the safety of the people they lead. Sometimes the people HAVE to take direct action to push for this.

So we need to abolish democracy ?

I can see a few issues with that TBH.

SucculentChalice · 11/04/2022 11:02

I always wonder how they get to their protest sites. Do they all cycle/walk miles? Or are they all conveniently located next to public transport? How does the protesting affect the work they do and therefore the taxes they pay? I know if I had my face plastered on social media or received a criminal penalty, it would be gross misconduct and I would be sacked.

RagingRagingAndMoreRaging · 11/04/2022 10:58

daimbarsatemydogsbone

There isn’t time to wait for the next election. We need to change really quickly - we were poised to do this, I think, and then covid happened and focus changed. This is a global emergency- not something that can wait - it transcends geographical boundaries and party politics. It’s too important to wait and see if ‘the people’ vote for extinction or not.

Lots of people wouldn’t have voted for seat belts in cars but legislative measures were put in place because the science was that it would (and has) saved lives. There is no other option if we want to survive as a species. Sometimes Governments HAVE to do things that are unpopular for the safety of the people they lead. Sometimes the people HAVE to take direct action to push for this.

jytdtysrht · 11/04/2022 10:54

The impact on other people is currently unacceptable. Laws are needed IMO.

The video of the woman trying to get to her mum who'd been taken to hospital being stopped by Insulate Britain disgusted me. What about the kid not able to get to their chemo. In fact these people made me want to throw my roof insulation out of the window.

These people would happily stop public transport such as the tube, containing kids going to GCSE exams.

Climate change is a severe problem and needs action immediately. Protesting isn't the way to achieve this though. In some cases it will be a threat to life - a trapped diabetic, people trying to get to hospital etc. People blocking roads need jailing.

Stellaris22 · 11/04/2022 10:53

I find it hard to believe protestors do this 'because it's fun'. It's frustration and desperation at continual failure of governments. It can't be business as usual and we need a dramatic shift in energy policies which we aren't getting. Not finding these issues important is ignorance. Of course people are rightfully angry and protesting.

RagingRagingAndMoreRaging · 11/04/2022 10:52

BoodleBug51

Peaceful protests are one thing.

Blocking roads and causing misery for hundreds of thousands of drivers by causing fuel shortages is wankerish.

There have been peaceful protests about climate change for years and years. Massive marches through London.

There have been so many scientific reports imploring change to protect us. So many petitions. So many protests. There is not enough time now to do anything but this kind of direct action. Everything else has been tried.

If I was in a position to do this kind of thing I would because I’m scared for my DC future and I can’t trust the Government to do what is needed. Being a massive pain in the &@“£ is now the only option left.

So - if you are informed about the current science and what is needed, you can see climate chaos already killing people, you have protested peacefully, signed petitions, written to your MP for the last 30 years, and yet still your government makes decisions that place your future at risk, tell me, what SHOULD you do?

How else can we, the people, force the Government to do what is needed to protect our future safety?

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 11/04/2022 10:47

@Stellaris22

I am 100% behind these protesters.

People are forced to take these actions when governments continually fail to take climate change seriously.

EV range anxiety is quaint when you can't even get diesel.

They are highlighting key issues and anger should be directed at governments not those actually doing something about it. If you are angry at protestors then you aren't understanding the importance of this.

We shouldn't ban protests, but we effect change via the ballot box.

If people choose to exercise their democratic right to continue voting for parties who do little or nothing to address the issue that is their right.

Gluing yourself to things and disrupting everyday life isn't really very likely to produce a mass shift in thinking - people will get angry with government but not for the reason you wish and people will demand authoritarian measures to stop people disrupting daily life.

It is a massive luxury that many people can't afford to have a level of financial independence that allows you to take a day off to glue yourself to a road or a tube train.

Stellaris22 · 11/04/2022 10:42

I am 100% behind these protesters.

People are forced to take these actions when governments continually fail to take climate change seriously.

EV range anxiety is quaint when you can't even get diesel.

They are highlighting key issues and anger should be directed at governments not those actually doing something about it. If you are angry at protestors then you aren't understanding the importance of this.

CMZ2018 · 11/04/2022 10:33

They need dealing with and the police need the powers to move them by force immediately

BoodleBug51 · 11/04/2022 10:07

Peaceful protests are one thing.

Blocking roads and causing misery for hundreds of thousands of drivers by causing fuel shortages is wankerish. We've had a nightmare getting fuel in Gloucestershire and we rely on a work van for bringing work in/taking it out again.

I'd personally turn water cannons on them.

RagingRagingAndMoreRaging · 11/04/2022 10:05

Chloemol

They can protest, but they get no support from me. In fact I go out of my way now not to support

What do you mean by ‘go out of my way’? Do you mean you are actively trying to make climate chaos worse? Confused

RagingRagingAndMoreRaging · 11/04/2022 10:04

Soringhaze

There is far more at stake than people being inconvenienced. You chip away at your democracy when you lose the right to protest.

Well said! Much more succinct than I managed.

Soringhaze · 11/04/2022 09:52

There is far more at stake than people being inconvenienced. You chip away at your democracy when you lose the right to protest.

LampLighter414 · 11/04/2022 09:31

Yabu because you can't trust the government and police to determine what is 'serious annoyance' and it could be used to close down all kinds of peaceful protest e.g. Iraq war march, Brexiteer occupation of Parliament Square

Chloemol · 11/04/2022 09:26

They can protest, but they get no support from me. In fact I go out of my way now not to support

The police do need more powers, which they then need to use, to move them on

The courts also need to back the police up with jail sentences for all involved, not wishy washy fines that won’t get paid

RagingRagingAndMoreRaging · 11/04/2022 09:12

carefullycourageous

I do not understand how pointing out the scientific reality being faced by us all would make me want to make it happen faster.

Indeed. It’s like saying ‘I don’t like the campaigns about smoking causing cancer so I’m going to smoke even more and increase my risk of cancer’. Totally illogical regardless of how you feel about the protests.

carefullycourageous · 11/04/2022 09:09

@toomanydogsandcats

Those assholes make me want to guzzle as much oil as I can. Its not a protest, they don't give a shit its just a bit of fun for them. I wish there were more powers to remove and punish them.
This is completely illogical.

I do not understand how pointing out the scientific reality being faced by us all would make me want to make it happen faster.

DrBlackbird · 11/04/2022 08:30

From experience, it is bloody annoying being stuck on the M25 because someone has glued themselves to the road. However, protests are an important element in an open and democratic society because they work. Maybe not immediately, but it’s the one tool open to every citizen. And the day that protests are banned, is the day that the UK has become an authoritarian state.

toomanydogsandcats · 11/04/2022 08:09

Those assholes make me want to guzzle as much oil as I can. Its not a protest, they don't give a shit its just a bit of fun for them. I wish there were more powers to remove and punish them.

RagingRagingAndMoreRaging · 11/04/2022 08:05

The situation is that we are facing mass human extinction if we don’t make significant changes. Before that we will go through food shortages, starvation and social instability.

Morality is a higher human need and once our basic needs for food, shelter and safety are effected then our morality is going to be much lower on our list of priorities. Just watch that film about the Fyre Festival to see what happens when resources are suddenly scarce. Here in the UK, we are mostly used to stability, food security and our physical safety, being secured. If we have lived here all our life then mostly, we have no concept of how harsh life can be when these things are threatened.

This is a pivotal point in history.

What are our government doing to prevent this future harm? Very little. In fact making decisions that are the exact opposite to what we need to be doing.

So what can informed people, who are concerned about the future of human kind (us, our children and grandchildren) do?

There have been marches upon marches, peaceful protests upon peaceful protests, petitions after petitions, scientific reports after scientific reports. For at least 30 years in fact. What is there left to do?

We should be making ourselves the biggest pain in the governments ass that we can, until they do what is actually needed to protect us from harm.

I’m not in a position to glue myself to roads (professional job that a criminal record would put an end to and DC that a prison sentence would effect) but I fully support direct action at this stage. I appreciate that there are people willing to do this to try and protect our future. To try and show the Government that this is so important that people are willing to make such sacrifices.

I think that laws to criminalise this are frightening and yet another way to keep us in our place, not complain and accept the dreadful policies that put peoples lives at risk (not just climate related either).

Swipe left for the next trending thread