Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL controlling summer holidays.

34 replies

charlottecruz · 11/04/2022 00:13

AIBU for being annoyed that MIL wants to control summer holidays.

We have just had a 10 week DS and up until now, DP and I did not live together. Pregnancy was unexpected, and we only recently since DS was born have started living together. We were both living with our parents, so going on holiday with our parents, though we often would meet mid holidays and he would come over to my parents city, and I would go to his. (as we are originally from the same country, so go on holidays every year to the same country.

FIL lives in said country, and not with us, and MIL, so DP only really sees FIL during holidays. My MIL has demanded, or more so expected that in 4 weeks that we will be on holidays, I spend 4/5 days with my family and the rest with his and in her city, and claims it's "he's also got family back home" and "his father lives there" yet fails to acknowledge that I too have family, and whilst I understand he doesn't see much of his dad, I think it's only fair to split the holidays 50/50 as our DS should be able to spend the same amount of time with both sides of the family. Apparently it's unreasonable of me to demand 50/50 split since FIL lives abroad.

AIBU for standing by 50/50 holidays spent?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
NotSoLittle · 11/04/2022 20:54

Not RTFT but my parents are from different parts of Ireland (they met in Engand) and when I was a kid my mum used to take us for a week to her family first, then my dad would join us and we'd go to his part of the country and then we'd have a week somewhere else in the country with just my mum & dad (no extended family). This way we got to see all the extended family but still had a "family" holiday. Maybe something like this might work for you

CarmenThePanda · 11/04/2022 17:09

Start it as a conversation about what the two of you will do, and what YOU would like to do (50 /50) rather than starting with opposition to his mother.

“When we go on holiday shall we do the first 2 weeks with your family and the second 2 weeks with mine, or would you rather do it the other way round?”

Calmly stick to your guns, and I know you feel you want to spend your whole holiday together call his bluff. “That’s fine, if you want to spend the extra week with your Dad I will be happy enough spending time with my family, my Mum can help me with the baby, and I can join you a week later”

Guineapigssweak · 11/04/2022 16:48

I wouldn't want to be anywhere near your MIL she is too controlling. I would rather stay home than put up with that but I am older and wiser now.

Ikeptgoing · 11/04/2022 09:14

An earlier poster pointed out to you the language and assumptions in this is all wrong.

You and DP are the ones who decide who and where you spend your time off with baby.

Your MIL gets no say and she certainly doesn't get to start demanding 50:50 with DPs dad and herself and ignore OPs DParents. What proportion is ridiculous so don't start saying 25% each parent /50:50 each side of family either, OP and DP are not children - they are parents themselves now. Don't set up any future rod for your own backs.

Just reply "MIL we will let you know our holiday plans when we have decided. Its not up to you to tell us who we will visit and when"

Really do not give any leeway to MIL. If I were you, I'd find time in those holidays to have at least a week just you DP and DBaby

Lollypop701 · 11/04/2022 08:35

Op has said the holiday to home suits her and dp so that is fine. Things may change as dc gets older. Or not. Re mil start as you mean to go on… speak to Dp tell him it’s not going to happen and next time it comes up just say it’s 50/50 and you can’t wait to see both side of family. I suspect You may have to repeat

ilovechocolate07 · 11/04/2022 08:33

We used to do the whole 50/50 thing with time at Christmas and visits home and it was tiring. It wasn't requested so much as I felt guilty for leaving and put pressure on myself. We had Christmas to ourselves more recently and it was amazing and made us realise that we do a lot of the running around. We now 'visit family' but we don't spend all day with them. We have our own plans and visit each for an hour or two here and there. If it's a trip out somewhere it's easier to spend longer but I feel that I can't do a lot of sitting inside.

Morechocmorechoc · 11/04/2022 08:26

So all your partners hokiday is used up seeing family? You know you will want to start making your own family holiday memories, taking your toddler good places they can experience things too if you're able. It all seems a bit odd.

theresapossuminthekitchen · 11/04/2022 08:21

Like a PP, when I was a SAHM I used to take my son back to see my parents (we were living overseas at the time) by myself quite regularly. I used to take him to visit my husband's family too, as I wanted him to have a relationship with them and for them to feel more involved, but you don't have to do that (and tbh, I'm not sure it really was worth it, as they're still not that interested in my kids, but I tried).

Family then visited us regularly, so husband saw them plenty and could keep more annual leave for going on other holidays just the 3 of us. He did see less of wider family and friends for a few years as a result, which didn't really bother him but may mean it's a less appealing prospect for your partner if he's keen to spend more time in his home city.

I agree with PP about setting clear boundaries now - you will want to change how things work for holidays and family time over the coming years, so you need to make it clear that you and your partner are in charge, not MIL or your mum, but also that you have equal say with your partner.

Sweetmotherofallthatisholyabov · 11/04/2022 08:14

The key issue is you and MIL are discussing it and not you and dp. But if he didn't want a fair split I'd understand why his dad might trump your family in his mind- unless it's siblings or parents aswell.

Sirzy · 11/04/2022 08:03

If you don’t want to spend some of the time apart from each other then I do think spending more time with his Father makes sense - 1/3 his dad and then 1/3 each extended family maybe?

But the key thing is it needs to be the choice of you and your partner not your MIL

underneaththeash · 11/04/2022 07:59

The next time your MIL bring it up, you say. We're going to do 50/50 from now on, it's only fair.

The end the conversation.

Fadeout83 · 11/04/2022 07:59

Ah parents in law. Gotta love them. They don’t control you OP. Your baby, your family, your life, your choice. The fact that you’re choosing to spend any of your precious time together as a young family with others should be appreciated, especially so early on. Your DP and you will need to be on the same page though, so get on it before you address MIL. The cheek of the entitled woman!

alrightfella · 11/04/2022 07:50

Just because you have a child together doesn't mean you have to do everything together! Before my dc were in school I used to often go to my parents for a week at a time while dh was working.

HikingforScenery · 11/04/2022 07:45

@Fupoffyagrasshole

Oh gawd don’t you ever get to go on an actual holiday somewhere else

🙈

I have a 1 year old and on my maternity leave I flew back to my parents house a good bit just me and the baby for a week here and there - my partner stayed home

Just visit your family alone as you don’t have to take annual leave

Then can’t your husband visit his family for 1 week at some point leaving 3 weeks for you guys to have other holidays as a family

Good suggestion
BorderlineHappy · 11/04/2022 07:44

As an only child with a DM like your mil you need to put your foot down now.
Start as you mean to go on.

sirensscreech · 11/04/2022 07:42

As long as you keep living with MIL she will continue to treat you as children.

If you want to be treated as autonomous adults, start by moving out!

Fupoffyagrasshole · 11/04/2022 07:38

Oh gawd don’t you ever get to go on an actual holiday somewhere else

🙈

I have a 1 year old and on my maternity leave I flew back to my parents house a good bit just me and the baby for a week here and there - my partner stayed home

Just visit your family alone as you don’t have to take annual leave

Then can’t your husband visit his family for 1 week at some point leaving 3 weeks for you guys to have other holidays as a family

AdaColeman · 11/04/2022 07:37

You are grown up now, just make your own holiday plans.
Learn to say “no” to relatives when you disagree with their suggestions. While this might cause upset or tension initially, in the long term it will make your life better.

ConfusedByDesign · 11/04/2022 07:34

Is the country far? Could you go without your dp to see your family at other times as well?

TenoringBehind · 11/04/2022 07:32

Time to start doing your own thing and setting firm boundaries.

Brefugee · 11/04/2022 07:26

tbh i'd say to DP "meh. I will spend as much time with your family as you do with mine. And see how that plays out. There is no need for you to spend any time discussing your holidays with MIL at all.

Your MIL can only control you if you let her. Boundaries are way overdue here.

charlottecruz · 11/04/2022 07:24

@Womencanlift

You sound very young OP but you and your DP are parents now so it is time to find your voice.

You will be the one deciding where you spend your holiday time not anyone else.

Also do you and your DP not work? As spending 4 weeks away is the majority of most people’s annual leave allowance. What if you need holidays or emergency childcare days at other points in the year?

I'm a SAHM, partners work luckily allows him to take over 4 weeks per year. Maybe it's how we've been raised, our parents always used to go back home in summer, which we both WANT to do. When we think of holidays we both want to go back.

You are right we need our own voice and I think I will talk to DP about this because MIL should not be trying to dictate our holidays or anything for that matter.

OP posts:
charlottecruz · 11/04/2022 07:20

@MeasureTwice

Unless you need him for support with the baby (maybe less of an issue when you're with your family), would you be willing to have him continue to spend less than two weeks with your family? Or is her demand for more time more to do with spending more time with your child?
Neither me or him want, or think it's the right decision for us to not spend holidays as a family, the 3 of us. So this would never work. I don't think it's absurd that we both want to spend time with our families, and we're more than happy to spend our times with each side. What the issue is, is my MIL wanting to demand that we spend the majority with her family and me almost ignore mine.
OP posts:
charlottecruz · 11/04/2022 07:14

@TidyDancer

I don't understand why this needs to be so controlled. You can have a holiday with his family and a holiday with yours. There's no need for a rigid split and it's not up to your parents (either of them) how you do it.

It does sound like quite an odd/controlled arrangement anyway though. Are you very young? I'm wondering if that's why your boyfriend's DM seems to think she can have that much control over you.

DP is 28 and I'm 23. He's an only child and has always been a mummy's boy, she very much always requires him around. I believe it's the idea of him not always being around her is the issue. It's the fact that we are living together, we've got a baby and do not need to live by anyones rules. Typically we have always gone on holidays in summer to see family and friends, so the idea of being equally fair to both seemed logical. The controlling is not just the issue it's the unfairness she wants to demand.
OP posts:
Womencanlift · 11/04/2022 07:11

You sound very young OP but you and your DP are parents now so it is time to find your voice.

You will be the one deciding where you spend your holiday time not anyone else.

Also do you and your DP not work? As spending 4 weeks away is the majority of most people’s annual leave allowance. What if you need holidays or emergency childcare days at other points in the year?