Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

SIL asking siblings to contribute to holiday for my MIL

103 replies

L0stinCyberspace · 10/04/2022 22:46

Please tell me if I am BU. I'm feeling quite cross as DH announced that his his DSis asked (demanded) a £100 contribution from each sibling (4 others) for her upcoming holiday with her DM.

The holiday is to Paris, a treat. My SIL suggested it to my MIL and offered to pay for her originally. ILs are retired, quite comfortable with excellent pensions. DH siad DSis is "doing us all a favour" but I said she was being a CF by offering my MIL a holiday abroad then demanding a contribution from the family. DH said MIL had had a tough time recently and I agreed but said it was ridiculous to expect the family to pay for his DSis holiday especially as our income is so stretched.

SIL'S children are adults and don't live at home and she and her husband have excellent jobs and no mortgage for years. All the other siblings have good jobs, spouses who have jobs, and all have their mortgages paid off. Fair play to them all.

DH and I are quite frugal out of grim necessity (think Aldi skincare, soap - no shower gel, forage for wood, batch cook, low heat in house) and can stretch to one holiday a year. Our DS is still a tern and we'll have to put him through college. We recently had a 2 nighter in London and can't afford another holiday this year. I drive a 10 year old car. We have 17 years left on the mortgage. I can only work part time due to an illness.

Is this fair? Why won't my spineless DH tell his DSis to pay for the holiday she offered? Maybe I'm just being a bit mean because that's what he implied? I keep thinking how SIL heads abroad for over a month every summer and we can't even afford 1 week in a shit hotel on the coast...so cross right now!

OP posts:
expat101 · 11/04/2022 02:14

I think you have a couple of issues going on OP that needs sorting out, but why is DH asking you in regard to the money if he keeps his separate to yours?

Really he could very well slip the SIL ''his'' share and you would be none the wiser unless it was mentioned down the track.

As far as the other matters go, do you know exactly how much he earns? Do you get to see any pay slips or the like? Does he receive any cash renumerations such as tea money or the like?

Some years ago I clearly remember the union delegate voting to stop the employer of where I worked from transitioning to having tea money deposited into an employee bank account simply because many of the wives did not know this money existed at all, and he used his to wine and dine the OW. Anyhow that is side tracking from your problem.

Frankly based on that MIL has already had her birthday in the last 12 months, the answer from me would be no. Let her daughter treat her.

AnnesBrokenSlate · 11/04/2022 02:06

If it's coming from his money, I don't understand why you care. I also think it's likely he knew the siblings were going to pay and just didn't tell you because he knew you'd be unhappy.
You're angry at your SIL when you're actually angry at your DP. This isn't a SIL problem. It isn't a MIL problem. It's a DP problem.
And yy the information about cars and holidays was tone deaf and irrelevant. It doesn't tell us anything except how you prioritise your spending as a family - and lots of people would think treating a MIL who'd had a hard time was more important than a weekend in London.

NoSquirrels · 11/04/2022 01:52

he earns more than twice what I do but despite arguments he refuses to pool our respective salaries. I pay for a lot of the groceries (althoughI got wise to this and I'm packing him off to do the shopping more often recently), my car, DS's summer camps and music lessons, my clothes, save for really big house maintenance purchases (50s house). He pays for the mortgage, his car, his clothes, occasional sportswear purchases for DS.

I suspect you’re not as badly off as he leads you to believe…

L0stinCyberspace · 11/04/2022 01:35

@1forAll74

Buy a second hand dinghy, and send them all off over the channel to France, with a few sandwiches and a flask of tea.
Don't tempt me Grin Actually I am really fond of my MIL. SIL a lot less so.
OP posts:
AhNowTed · 11/04/2022 01:28

OP you have much bigger problems than this.

Thanks
1forAll74 · 11/04/2022 01:25

Buy a second hand dinghy, and send them all off over the channel to France, with a few sandwiches and a flask of tea.

yoyo1234 · 11/04/2022 01:25

Sounds like you cannot easily afford it and should not be roped into it as not asked before hand (and that it is a "pride" thing for your husband to keep up with his siblings. I think 200 for a gift for a comfortable adult is ridiculous with family out goings.

AhNowTed · 11/04/2022 01:25

"I don't have the power to say no. DH doesn't allow me have a say over what he spends his money on TBH."

Your last comment is quite worrying OP. "His money"?

Anyway, if SIL wants to "treat" her mum, fine, but I would decline unless I was positive there was recognition of everyone's contribution.

L0stinCyberspace · 11/04/2022 01:21

@Ivyonafence

How do you arrange your finances in your marriage OP?

Is all the money 'his'? Or do you each have your own? Is it equal?

When you say it's 'his' money, is it coming from money he would usually spend on treats for himself?- in which case I can see why you're annoyed but it's his decision.

Or is it family money that he controls?

@Fadeout83 and @Ivyonafence he earns more than twice what I do but despite arguments he refuses to pool our respective salaries. I pay for a lot of the groceries (althoughI got wise to this and I'm packing him off to do the shopping more often recently), my car, DS's summer camps and music lessons, my clothes, save for really big house maintenance purchases (50s house). He pays for the mortgage, his car, his clothes, occasional sportswear purchases for DS.
OP posts:
LoisLane66 · 11/04/2022 01:19

She has a cheek to organise it without asking your view on a contribution. In other words, a fait accompli. Organised then hands the cap round. It'd be a NO from me.

ifIwerenotanandroid · 11/04/2022 01:18

It's not even the amount, to me: it's the principle of the thing. I had a SIL who would do this sort of thing, so it gets my goat. Just tell SIL she was supposed to pay for it & if she wanted everyone to pay she should've asked you all first.

Midlifemusings · 11/04/2022 01:14

We try to occasionally treat our parents to something a little special and always email all the siblings. I think it would be really weird to contact everyone except one sibling and in my family's case - that sibling would be upset to be excluded. It would also feel strenge to give them a gift from Siblings 1, 2 and 3 with no mention of 4.

We don't specify an amount - just say we are going to buy parents x for Christmas, birthday, significant anniversary - if anyone wants to chip in, these are the details. Other siblings initiate similar.

I can't imagine not including our 'poorest' sibling in the email chains. That would just feel wrong. I have no idea if their wives hate that we do joint gifts together and email about my parents but it is what we do.

Ivyonafence · 11/04/2022 01:07

How do you arrange your finances in your marriage OP?

Is all the money 'his'? Or do you each have your own? Is it equal?

When you say it's 'his' money, is it coming from money he would usually spend on treats for himself?- in which case I can see why you're annoyed but it's his decision.

Or is it family money that he controls?

Fadeout83 · 11/04/2022 01:07

@L0stinCyberspace his money?!?

Teenagehorrorbag · 11/04/2022 01:01

What planet are you all on? I've never understood people who spend huge amounts on adults' presents, whether birthdays or Christmas. Maybe a bit for a milestone event - but really it seems crazy to me! We buy for nieces and nephews when young, but I have never understood this thing where people spend huge sums randomly on other grown ups. I mean - why?

But from what you have said - utterly no way would I then also add a contribution I couldn't afford to something I hadn't planned! Tell Dsis she's doing a very kind thing but you won't be part of it!

SandyY2K · 11/04/2022 00:58

now SIL is presenting it like she's owed the money from everyone!

Well this needs to be challenged. She pays ALL herself, or MIL knows everyone is paying.

L0stinCyberspace · 11/04/2022 00:56

@Fadeout83

Just put your foot down and say no. What an absurd suggestion to have others contribute to her holiday with her mum. Cheeky bugger.
I don't have the power to say no. DH doesn't allow me have a say over what he spends his money on TBH.
OP posts:
Fadeout83 · 11/04/2022 00:53

Just put your foot down and say no. What an absurd suggestion to have others contribute to her holiday with her mum. Cheeky bugger.

L0stinCyberspace · 11/04/2022 00:50

@Oddbobbyboo

I think your husband is saving face and doesn’t want his siblings to know his private life. I have very boastful siblings…. They are all homeowners, married and careers. However, I had my 4 children when I was younger and then had a difficult divorce, I retrained and was fortunate to get social housing but I never let anyone know that I’m struggling. Every part of my income is a methodical maze to ensure the bills are paid, the cupboards are full and we remain debt free. I could get loads on credit - like them…. But I don’t want to. But I am very private regarding my financial affairs.
You're probably correct that he's saving face - it just feels hard to swallow when we have to watch every penny.
OP posts:
L0stinCyberspace · 11/04/2022 00:48

@NellesVilla

Yanbu for not wanting to contribute but yabu for mentioning car and mortgage- some of us have a 20 year car and can’t afford a mortgage, OP!
Not allowed mention my car and mortgage? Confused I mentioned them because they are relevant to the issue as we don't have much disposable income. I'm sorry others are worse off and I know it must grate if you're comparing your situation but I think that is a bit much to suggest that just because your finances are more straightened, I shouldn't have mentioned mine! There are MN's who own investment properties, public school their kids, buy M&S food and Dior skincare, but still have problems.
OP posts:
NellesVilla · 11/04/2022 00:41

Yanbu for not wanting to contribute but yabu for mentioning car and mortgage- some of us have a 20 year car and can’t afford a mortgage, OP!

L0stinCyberspace · 11/04/2022 00:40

@AhNowTed

The short version (seen this before)

SIL wants to "treat" MIL but actually doesn't want to pay for it.

Your contribution will be lost in the ether, and SIL will get all the glory.

@AhNowTed Someone else must have has a similar problem as it was something I only found out today.
OP posts:
L0stinCyberspace · 11/04/2022 00:38

@Kite22

I'm getting deja vu tonight - did you ask this recently ?

Anyway, whether that was you or someone else, my answer remains the same.
If anyone wants to spend someone else's money on anything, they need to agree it with all parties before booking it / buying it / paying deposits for it. This is irrespective of the amount.

In this case, it would be a straight 'no' from me, if I were your dh.
If your SiL wants to go on holiday with her Mum, that is between them. As you say, it isn't even for a special reason. Even if it were a special reason, then SiL needed to have gauged everyone's feelings about it before arranging anything.

Nope, not me.
OP posts:
Flickflak · 11/04/2022 00:28

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

viques · 11/04/2022 00:13

Take Mil to a nail bar for a quick chic manicure before the holiday, or buy her a pretty scarf to take and wear, she will probably much rather have something tangible.