Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

SIL asking siblings to contribute to holiday for my MIL

103 replies

L0stinCyberspace · 10/04/2022 22:46

Please tell me if I am BU. I'm feeling quite cross as DH announced that his his DSis asked (demanded) a £100 contribution from each sibling (4 others) for her upcoming holiday with her DM.

The holiday is to Paris, a treat. My SIL suggested it to my MIL and offered to pay for her originally. ILs are retired, quite comfortable with excellent pensions. DH siad DSis is "doing us all a favour" but I said she was being a CF by offering my MIL a holiday abroad then demanding a contribution from the family. DH said MIL had had a tough time recently and I agreed but said it was ridiculous to expect the family to pay for his DSis holiday especially as our income is so stretched.

SIL'S children are adults and don't live at home and she and her husband have excellent jobs and no mortgage for years. All the other siblings have good jobs, spouses who have jobs, and all have their mortgages paid off. Fair play to them all.

DH and I are quite frugal out of grim necessity (think Aldi skincare, soap - no shower gel, forage for wood, batch cook, low heat in house) and can stretch to one holiday a year. Our DS is still a tern and we'll have to put him through college. We recently had a 2 nighter in London and can't afford another holiday this year. I drive a 10 year old car. We have 17 years left on the mortgage. I can only work part time due to an illness.

Is this fair? Why won't my spineless DH tell his DSis to pay for the holiday she offered? Maybe I'm just being a bit mean because that's what he implied? I keep thinking how SIL heads abroad for over a month every summer and we can't even afford 1 week in a shit hotel on the coast...so cross right now!

OP posts:
ZekeZeke · 11/04/2022 07:54

You don't have a SIL problem, you have a H problem.

Sexnotgender · 11/04/2022 07:51

How much of his income goes on family expenses?

Do you know how much he has in savings?

Cakecakecheese · 11/04/2022 07:50

Yeah the present isn't really what you should be concerned about, the big issue is that you're scrimping and budgeting while your husband is spending 'his money' on whatever he likes...

Pansypotter123 · 11/04/2022 07:47

After your husband has paid the mortgage how much does he have left over? Are both of you named on the mortgage? Did you both pay towards the deposit? Does he juggle finances each month or is that solely down to you because of what you have to pay out for out of your income?

Strictlyfanoftenyears · 11/04/2022 07:44

DH is your real issue. On the money side, if your DH is happy to contribute, then I would get him to give it directly to his mum to "treat herself" on holiday.

PinkSyCo · 11/04/2022 07:43

Haha wouldn’t we all love to take our mums on holiday if other people were paying a good chunk for it?!! I almost admire the brass neck of your CF SIL! Not enough to stump up the cash mind you, especially after already forking out £200 for her birthday! Just say no OP or before you know it you’ll be stumping up for their holidays every year!

Hercisback · 11/04/2022 07:42

Your DHs attitude towards money is the problem. I bet he's got money stashed away while you're struggling to pay the bills. Wanker.

Flickflak · 11/04/2022 07:38

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

rookiemere · 11/04/2022 07:35

The real issue here is that your joint money isn't being pooled.

I'd say to H that if he can afford to pay for MILs and SILs holidays he can afford a few more of the family expenses and stop paying the ones that impact him.

Dairymilk50 · 11/04/2022 07:35

@flyingdream

Why isn't she paying for it anymore? was it her plan all along?
Absolutely this has gone a miss in the thread.

The sister in law is comfortable too it's her idea let her fund it. What does your DH think OP? He could say sorry we have already planned and budgeted mum's gift.

Dairymilk50 · 11/04/2022 07:31

@Viviennemary

It isn't really a huge contribution she is asking for. But if you can't afford it then just say no.
How much do you spend on your mother?
00100001 · 11/04/2022 07:30

@Viviennemary

It isn't really a huge contribution she is asking for. But if you can't afford it then just say no.
Feel free to send OP £100 then, as it's such a trifling amount.
Brefugee · 11/04/2022 07:29

Just say no. Keep saying no. If your DH has other ideas ask him how you are going to afford food/heat/petrol.

SummerWhisper · 11/04/2022 07:26

If it's a done deal, just give the money straight to MIL and tell her to enjoy her holiday. Your DH needs to scrimp on his spends a lot more as a result of this and the rest of you should not be affected. He has a lot of making up to do.

NameGoesHere · 11/04/2022 07:20

I think your dh is taking the mickey about the finances in your relationship.

SniffMyQuiffyHair · 11/04/2022 07:19

Sounds like he's going to doing it anyway. You need to sit down and have a serious talk about how you split your finances, it all sounds rather odd
I'd be really disappointed and sad if my DH didn't listen to my concerns

Georgeskitchen · 11/04/2022 07:15

A big fat no. What a cheeky bstRd
100 quid is a months food money to some people!!

Northernsoullover · 11/04/2022 06:56

Are you genuinely strapped for cash or is the budgeting because your salary is really low? Don't tell me you split bills 50/50 ?

autienotnaughty · 11/04/2022 06:48

It's tricky if you share finances then it needs to be a joint decision, if they are separate then it's upto him? Think you need a finances discussion tho. My dh works ft i work pt. We do a spreadsheet so all finances are listed we work out who pays what in then we make sure we have same left over at end. It's not fair if he has more spare money than you.

Quincythequince · 11/04/2022 06:21

Say no OP.
Just don’t pay.
If she was expecting you all to pay for a holiday for MIL, she should have asked first.

Just say, we have no spare money - we never have agreed to this.

Winkydink · 11/04/2022 02:57

Your DH has already made a £200 contribution to birthday present?! we are one of your aforementioned mumsnet families with Dior skincare, private schooled dc, multiple overseas holidays and a new luxury car on the driveway…and total budget per family member bday present (MIL, SIL etc) is £50. Nephews and nieces £25. Our own DC maybe £100 or so.

YANBU by the way.

Ivyonafence · 11/04/2022 02:56

He earns twice what you do, why are you funding so many joint expenses?

How much are your mortgage payments relative to his income? The mortgage is his only real responsibility and I note it is a consistent and predictable expense while you have the pressure of funding funds for expenses that vary and can come up suddenly.

What a nice life your husband has created for himself.

You have a DH problem.

I suspect your family isn't as strapped for cash as he says.

Do you have oversight of his income and the mortgage? Or are you in the dark about these things?

You're angry at SIL because it's easier to be angry at someone less close to you, who you don't live with, over this one small thing rather than address who you should rightfully be angry at. DH.

TigerLilyTail · 11/04/2022 02:30

This is bonkers!

I suggest that you text his siblings that DH has been feeling stressed recently, so you are taking him out to dinner to cheer him up and can they both send you 50 quid to cover their share. Then, send back the 100 pounds to cover your share of the holiday.

flyingdream · 11/04/2022 02:20

Why isn't she paying for it anymore? was it her plan all along?

flyingdream · 11/04/2022 02:18

If it's going to cause arguments between you and your husband then just give it and after she's been given her treat...tell her I hope you like it...it was from all of us..we all chipped in...

Make sure you tell your husband you're happy to spend on MIL but at the right time with a lot of prep from beforehand...not like this when it's a shock to the system and you haven't budgeted...

Next time SIL goes on holiday mention it to him...how you've not been in ages...