Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think university halls may be hell for me?

114 replies

Rompastom · 10/04/2022 22:27

I am an 18 year old girl who has applied to go to university in September. My mum browses this forum and has advised me that there are lots of parents on here with kids my age that could offer some advise based on their experiences.

So I have applied to do English lit, my passion since being a child, at Manchester, MMU, Sheffield, Leeds, and Liverpool. I live in Manchester so opted for some ‘safe’ options to have the option to commute from home and be close to my family. You may have noticed I picked all northern cities too, just really close to my family and want to be somewhere cheap since I’m used to having a decent standard of living Grin I also wanted the option of a studio flat and the rent is pretty cheap in all these cities. I wanted a big city since I’m used to living somewhere with loads to do, but I love Sheffield and the rural dynamic of it with the Peak District.

So my issue is this…. I have been really shy all my life until recently. I was bullied all through high school and pretty much had no genuine good best friends after primary school. I actually got anorexia during GCSEs due to the immense stress despite me getting amazing results. I think I poured all my stress into studying and having no social life helped. I had to go to outpatient treatment for 6 months and could have died due to my bad health. Thankfully fully recovered now 3 years on. The experience kind of made me start to not give a fuck, and I began to gain a lot of confidence. I still had bad mental health along with coronavirus so haven’t made any good friends at college and just have kept to myself.

I really am starting to feel like I haven’t ‘lived yet’ and am watching my youth pass me by and am wasting my life. I have never drank, partly due to my family being Muslim before they became atheists, and they barely ever drink. I also have never had a boyfriend, never gone clubbing. I want to do all that but being so out of it I feel like i’m scared of new experiences. I’m scared it’s a luck draw with flatmates and there is a high chance we won’t click and will argue. I’m scared of small things like them bringing rowdy mates in the kitchen and making me not want to go in, or taking the piss out of my cooking and complaining about the smell (I am south Asian and love to cook family curry recipes)…. Just ganging up on me I guess. My dad has said he had shitty experiences at Uni but also found some amazing friends and met my mum there, but he told me I will have to put up with a lot and learn to tolerate people and deal with situations.

Having been sober all my life I’m scared of the uk Uni drinking culture, I feel like I may be pressured to try to act cool, knowing my personality and how I’m currently desperate to make friends and ‘fit in’, whereas I don’t want to go crazy on the drinking, and am way more into sports and hobbies as an amateur boxer and powerlifter. I guess I want a happy medium, watch a movie, not go out clubbing every night, but still have fun. My dad told me it can get really noisy and I’m already a really light sleeper, need a fan for white noise every night…. Now I’m considering would flatmates be able to hear it and complain……

My parents have told me they would pay for me to have my own studio flat so I could socialise on my terms and not take a chance with the flatmates, but I feel like that could be isolating and lead me to make no friends. I feel like I could easily get a studio for the second and third years (or if I go to manchester live at home)…. And the first year should be a real student experience. I should be able to put up with not ideal flatmates for a year… but at the same time I’m not so sure.

Do most students make friends with their flatmates? I have always imagined it is them that you go out with during freshers week…. I also have a small feeling I would be lonely in a studio flat, I love having my family around to chat to and just having people there, and i imagine good friends could replace family in that way.

Another aspect is that my family is particularly close knit due to my younger sister having a severe disability and being nonverbal. It makes living at home really hard and stressful sometimes but it has also meant my mum and dad and me have been driven close together to cope. Living away would be freeing in a way for me from that. I can’t imagine doing Uni work due to the noise disruption she unfortunately causes due to her disability.

So would you suggest I pick Leeds, Sheffield or Liverpool to totally get away from my city and have a ‘fresh start’ and make do with any flatmates I get, move to them and get a studio flag to have my own space and not have kitchen/flat space worries…. Choose Manchester and live at halls to have the option to change to stay at home if I really can’t gel with the people in my flat, choose Manchester and live at home first year to get to know people and then maybe live with them later if I make good friends…..

Have any of your kids also had similar worries and how have they gotten on with the people in their flat?

OP posts:
Nerdymummy · 11/04/2022 09:14

I was painfully shy when I went to university, didn't drink and was not one to go clubbing. Halls were good for me (I did live in one of the smaller accomidations) I found first few weeks difficult just as I had never been away from family but it forced me to make friends and socialise. University is different from school everyone is starting fresh and it's q really mix of people. I got on with my flat mates in first year and in 2nd and 3rd choose the people I lived with. I met my husband there and I am glad I gained independence at university. I think if I lived alone I could have easily isolated myself without trying. Choose what you find best for you

Weirdwonders · 11/04/2022 09:04

Definitely try and stay in halls. I was very shy too and wanted to move out at first but I’m so glad I stayed and persevered. Take the opportunity to meet as many people as you can, if your plan is to live anywhere other than at home then you have nothing to lose. Good luck.

lljkk · 11/04/2022 08:42

Just go to Manchester, OP, and live at home. this is perfectly respectable decision that suits you. DS may live at home for Uni, btw. We get along, so why not?

I was a non-drinker at notorious party-University, "hilarious". Naturally I viewed the binge drinking with contempt. I still made friends, had as much social life as I wanted, got a 'good' degree.

JamJamJamJamJam · 11/04/2022 08:41

I'd jump straight in. Go to Manchester, go into halls, give it a go. You can always "escape" back to your parents if it's too much or you want a break. This is similar to exposure therapy which I think would do you some good.

theresapossuminthekitchen · 11/04/2022 08:40

I teach A Level and the main piece of advice that I always give students who are unsure where to go is: Wherever you go will probably end up being the best place - I had friends who ended up at a uni they'd never have chosen, through 'Clearing', and they loved it. But also, it isn't set in stone and if you are really unhappy you can often change part way through your course.

My husband chose a uni that was the best uni in the country for his course. But he didn't investigate the extra-curricular stuff well enough. He had a main sport that was basically his life, and this uni didn't have a club for that sport. He joined other clubs but it was a dealbreaker. He moved to a uni close to his home at the end of first year (taking his first year grades with him - not starting again) and had a brilliant time for the rest of his course. And was captain of the sports club, etc. (He also met me through that sports club... so that's another bonus!)

You've had great advice for the other parts of your post. Again - whatever happens you can always change it and find a better solution if you need to. I hated my roommate and her friends, my first term at uni was awful. I cried on the train on the way back after Christmas and seriously considered heading straight back home. But it got better from there and I found some good friends to live with for second and third year, joined some clubs and had a great time.

In short - don't panic. Weigh it all up, using the advice and experiences people have given here, and make your choice knowing that if it doesn't work you will find a way to improve it. It's not like school - you're not stuck with it if it's difficult. You sound like you have a very loving and supportive family behind you.

Good luck!

Thursday37 · 11/04/2022 08:35

Leicester is a really good choice if you want somewhere without such a strong drinking culture, because it is an Asian majority city there are a high proportion of people that don’t drink and the student body is similar. Obviously there is still binge drinking but also very easy to find friends that don’t drink and it’s not at all surprising to people. It’s a very tolerant place.

Accommodation wise, I hated halls personally. Didn’t have your issues but am very weird about sharing with people. I lasted a term and moved out. If I had my time over I would have loved a studio. I just didn’t get on with communal living despite liking my course.
I’d get somewhere with your own bathroom and kitchen but within a building that is all students. Many of the new halls have this option, it’s expensive though.

Alexisrose16 · 11/04/2022 08:28

Have you considered Nottingham uni? It’s lovely, the campus is very green with good links to a city. The halls are nice, you can do catered so that you can socialise as much as you like. One thing I would say is that choose a mixed halls. I studied English as well but at Sheffield and Sheffield is lovely but I think you would prefer a campus uni rather than one spread out all over the city with halls everywhere.

RufustheFloralmissingreindeer · 11/04/2022 08:26

You sound exactly like my ds2

Ds1 went to a close to home uni, halls for the first year, moved in with friends the second year and lived with boyfriend the 3rd year

He is a drinker and had a lot of fun in halls, he also is shy and has anxiety (diagnosed) but when i tell him how brave he is /was he tells me that his FOMO is bigger than his shyness 😀

Ds2 (18) is very shy, we also think he has social anxiety though he isn’t diagnosed, he isnt a drinker and doesn’t have FOMO. He is in halls close to home as well

He has been home just about every weekend and intends living at home for the next two years

My advice would be to go to halls in a uni closer to home ….assuming that the uni is a good one that you would have considered anyway

Then if you love it you can live away moving forward and if not go home

My friends son went to the same uni as ds2 about 30 minutes drive away….and his mum barely saw him for three years so it is possible to still be very independent

Good luck in whatever you choose

nosyupnorth · 11/04/2022 08:21

I think if you already struggle socially then getting a studio flat to avoid having flatmates is setting yourself up for a habit of isolation.

Your flatmates don't have to be your best friends, but they're a good starting social circle until you have had chance to get to know your coursemates better etc and most people will want to get along well with the people they are living with so unless you get really unlucky there is no reason to think they'd want to cause problems for you. And in the unlikely event of that, if you are in proper halls then there will be some sort of team responsible for student well-being who can either mediate or worst case scenario you move. And halls are not like american roommate scenarios, you will still have your own room to go back to, but it is good to learn how to share a common space.

If you are worried about the drinking/party culture many unis now offer alcohol free flats/halls you could get a spot in.

Blurp · 11/04/2022 08:15

I would recommend halls - there is such diversity there, and people are keen to make friends. Some unis have designated "quiet halls" which are much stricter on noise levels and drinking - eg it would be fine to have a glass of wine with dinner, but you'd get in trouble if you come home roaring drunk - check whether that's an option?

Honestly, I loved living in halls, and I'm quite shy. Don't feel you have to go out socialising with people you live with - I never did, but would have got to know people by sitting and chatting over a cup of tea mix-afternoon.

Join lots of university clubs too, and get to know people who have similar interests to you.

Don't worry about the smell of your food - honestly, people are more likely to want to try some than they are to complain! And they won't hear your white noise fan (though it may be worth trying to wean yourself off that, just so you don't have to take it everywhere you go).

Lulu1919 · 11/04/2022 08:13

My daughter went to uni in halls - the type where 8 en-suite too,s with shared kitchen / dining space.
Before she left she hated talking on the phone ...wouldn't answer the house phone or door ,hated walking down the high street alone etc
She has a couple of close friends at school but certainly wasn't really part of the 'in group ' in 6 th form
She rarely drank ..maybe the odd half glass of wine !
Went to uni ....she just flourished ...the whole experience made her realise she could do what she wanted and be who she wanted to be and still join in and have fun.
I guess all I'm saying is ...don't over think it ...see how it goes ...give it a chance ...
My daughter is now a primary school teacher who is flying high !!!!
She's a joy

rollwith · 11/04/2022 08:12

I'm sure most unis offer the option of "quiet halls" if you're not the partying type. My dd didn't drink before she went to uni but she made some really good friends who she's still close to ten years later (she also started drinking at uni!)

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 11/04/2022 08:06

DS1 is a sporty non-drinking Muslim. He is in his first year in a shared flat with 9 people. He has had no problems at all. He goes out with his friends but doesn’t drink. He’s cooked for them and will be sharing a house some of them next year.
He was a bit shy before he went but has loved it.

Patented · 11/04/2022 08:04

I would live.in halls. You probably won't get on with 100% of the people there, but you will likely find at least one really good close friend for the rest of uni and beyond. Everyone's new to it and a.bit nervous and it's really an amazing opportunity to chat to anyone, try to open up & put yourself.in new situations. Been there,.done that and didn't maximise it because of my own shyness, but if I was.tl.so it again, I'd try to grab loads of opportunities and.not worry about first impressions or.how.i might come across because everyone is winging it!

comfortablyfrumpy · 11/04/2022 07:37

I agree with other suggestion of smaller town
My DD is at a snall town Uni surrounded by countryside.

She doesn't really drink. Doesn't like clubbing did try it at fewshers week and hated it!

Dje has found friends like her abd gas a house share arranged for year 2.

Not all 18 year old want to drink and go clubbing.
You will find your tribe
Good luck x

FishFingerSandwiches4Tea · 11/04/2022 07:29

I just saw your post about people moaning on student rooms - bear in mind people are far more likely to start or comment on a thread complaining - if you got on really well with your housemates you'd be unlikely to start a post about how great it is!

I also had a younger sibling at home with severe learning disabilities, non-verbal etc and was super close to my parents. I moved to a different part of the UK for uni and lived in halls and on my first weekend went home- well I tried to but there were big delays with the trains so I went back to halls instead and had a great weekend. I'm very glad I did! The first couple of weeks are when you get to know your flatmates.

Ime most people stick with their housemates for the first few weeks and then as your course gets properly underway you meet new people. So while it would be lovely to make best friends with your flatmates it really doesn't matter of you don't gel that well.

I'm feeling all nostalgic now and wish I could do it all again! It is scary, it's unknown, but it's one of the few times in life where everyone is in the same boat.

Best of luck with your exams and uni applications. Your world is about to open up massively !

SeaInelegans · 11/04/2022 07:29

A third option is to see if your uni has any “quiet halls”. My uni had this option and I considered it but ultimately went for standard halls and regretted it. I just didn’t gel with my housemates and didn’t enjoy going out partying. Sometimes it felt a little lonely. Everyone in halls was nice to me, I just didn’t make meaningful friendships.

However I did find “my people” through societies and made friends who I am still friends with 10+ years after graduation, despite being spread our over the country. You mentioned you play sport, that is an excellent way to meet people. I will caveat that at my uni there was a very heavy drinking culture associated with the sports teams, but this was a different uni and several years ago so things may be different now. But you can try out loads of clubs and the beginning and then later on narrow down to as many as you have time for. There were societies for pretty much everything, for example I joined the knitting society. I had no idea how to knit at the time but it was a nice relaxed society where we would meet up once or twice a week, go for coffee and knit and chat which was a great way to meet people.

QuebecBagnet · 11/04/2022 07:20

I think you should pick the course/city which feels best for you. But don’t just pick Manchester because you have the option of moving home. A studied flat elsewhere would be better than that unless the course at Manchester is your favourite.

My Dd is in her second year at uni and lives at home. She has found it harder to make friends. She’s also not into the uni drinking culture. But she has made friends via societies and on her course.

When I was at uni there wasn’t space in halls so they put me in a three bed terrace house. So I never made friends in halls but had plenty of friends.

Some universities have “quiet flats” in halls. So you can specify you’d like one and they would put people who don’t want that party scene together. Talk to the different accommodation offices.

Join different societies and you’ll probably find one or two you really click with.

Mummadeze · 11/04/2022 07:02

I was a loud, outwardly loud, confident, binge drinker at Uni and my room mate was the opposite. We were polite to each other but didn’t become friends, but as everyone is saying, I found my crowd and she found hers. She was v quiet but soon had a lovely boyfriend who was a computer scientist and a group of intellectual friends. She had just as many friends as me and had just a good experience. Being sporty, I think you will find it easy to fit in and if you don’t gel with everyone in your halls, it doesn’t really matter.

babyjellyfish · 11/04/2022 07:02

New city, fresh start, live in halls.

There will be people in halls you gel with, and people you don't. That's the point. You'll meet hundreds of people.

And even if you don't meet lifelong friends in halls (I didn't), you'll have the opportunity to meet plenty of other people on your course and through joining societies.

But living in a studio flat most probably will be isolating, especially at the beginning. It doesn't much matter who you go out with in freshers week as long as you do have people to go out with.

Motherhippo · 11/04/2022 06:52

Don't have kids that age but I had the Uni experience so didn't want to read and run.
First of all you can't make any choice on any university before looking round so make sure you attend open days to get a feel before making a choice.
University's attract people of all ages with all different backgrounds, passions and interests. Not everyone will want to drink themselves into oblivion but others absolutely will. I would recommend living in halls the first year for at least the first year. You can experience Freshers at the heart of the action.
You don't know what housemates you'll get before you go to University. You could get a group of rowdy party animals or you could get a group of quiet reserved individuals. There is really no way of telling.
You may make friends for life in your housemates or perhaps not. My first year I lived on campus and we didn't have a communal area to hang out. I literally had one of the neighbours knock on my door and invite me to her room with some others. My neighbours were really nice but we studied different courses and were just different people. I don't make real friends very easily and only left university with one friend I keep in contact with. But I had plenty of casual acquaintances at university to talk to during classes or go on nights out with.
Once you've picked a university you could try reaching out on social media to those starting the same time who may have similar interests to you. You could make a friend or 2 before even starting 😊
If you've never really drunk or gone clubbing just watch yourself. I've seen this go one of two ways. Either the person has a good amount of self control and goes out and drinks within reasonable limits. I've also seen the other side where they go absolutely mad. Out literally every night if the week. Hit the Drink and drugs hard. Go to no lectures or seminars blow through their student finance in like a month and end up getting kicked out of university or dropping out. You seem like a sensible level headed person so I'm sure you'll be fine but don't end up person number 2.
If it helps I went to a university in Leeds if you have any questions about the area.
Well done and good luck 😊

Blimeyherewegoagain · 11/04/2022 06:51

When DS applied for halls he had to fill out a questionnaire about himself- eg quiet or party animal, night owl or early bird etc . I think they got the match pretty well because he’s met some great people in halls . It’s maybe worth asking the unis how they match people for accommodation.

JunhaLamra · 11/04/2022 06:49

Ds1 is home for Easter but is in his first year at uni. He is introvert, doesn't like clubbing in fact never went clubbing until 1 time before uni as he is summer born so couldn't even get into a club, not that he wished to.

He is in a modern hall with a shared kitchen with 7 other people. It hasn't been the best time for him but it hasn't been the worst either. Everyone is cordial and friendly but no one is best mates with each other either. They all just bumble along, some are more messy than others but there are flat inspections that mean an adult from the university is the one who messages the flat to say wash your stuff up as you are breaking your tenancy agreement to keep the communal areas clean and tidy, and it worked.

Ds has said that if he was in a studio flat he would have been very isolated. This isn't just about making friends but daily social interactions with people, and who knows you could meet someone just like you! Ds has made friends with all sorts of people from all different backgrounds.

Ds is having a studio flat in his final year just because it gives him the opportunity to be alone when he wants and not have to interact in the kitchen. However, this is for his 3rd year only. Next year he is in a shared flat again with random people. Dh had a great time at uni, mine was meh but I still loved the experience and would do it again in a heartbeat. You will be fine, truly. There is a lot of support from uni staff from your personal tutor to the mental health and well being staff. Stop believing that every person is a party animal getting trashed every night.

This is Jade, an A* student who was part of StudyTube on YouTube which helped to make studying easier and cool. She did an international degree where she lived in different cities around the world. She recently posted this video which I think is worth a watch

BurningTheToast · 11/04/2022 06:46

I would give halls a go. You might not feel comfortable at first but everyone's in the same boat and I think everyone learns important life skills from being forced to live around other people that they might not normally encounter. Learning how to deal with the flatmate who leaves your favourite pan dirty in the sink or has loud friends over is part of life.

Please don't get a studio flat from the start (although there are private halls that operate these which might be better) as I think you'll feel very lonely. If you live alone you have to make a lot more effort to be sociable as you don't have the opportunity to get chatting to people in your shared kitchen and so on.

As for drinking, my son's just about to graduate and he doesn't drink at all. Apparently lots of people don't as it's so expensive. I checked, and he says he's never been made to feel bad about it and he just goes clubbing etc with the others and drinks water. When I asked him about that, he also reminded me that his best friends are people he lived with or in the next flat from in his first year halls. Don't miss out on that.

miramia · 11/04/2022 06:30

I was pretty much you OP. I made one choice and I'm urging you to make the other.

I studied from home and went in every day instead. I regret it hugely. I have seen on Facebook ever since that various little groups who lived together at the time have stuck it out over the decades and are still super-close. I wish I had that and think I could have done if I'd been a bit braver.

While I'm not saying it's impossible to have a high quality "studying from home" experience, for me, it ended up feeling like a slightly different version of school.

I don't think it was worth the expense looking back and wish I'd taken that leap and had more of an experience.

Please give it a try! Worst case scenario, you hate it, you can move out. But this could be the making of you! Do it for me OP Grin