Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Really need some help re Dd and her dad’s girlfriend being aggressive towards her.

137 replies

Ostryga · 10/04/2022 20:14

This has all come out this evening. Dd is 5 and we were watching a film together and she suddenly came out with her dad’s gf pulled her hair really hard.

I asked her what happened without any leading questions, she said she’d not turned a tap off and * had been annoyed and pulled her hair.

She then said about another time daddy had gone to change her baby sister’s nappy while Dd was eating dinner, and dd started crying because daddy wasn’t there. His gf asked her why she was crying and then slapped her in the head.

Now I know 5 year olds can be buggers for telling tales, but I know my daughter and the way she told me makes me believe it’s true. The fact she told me that daddy wasn’t there when is rude or nasty to her made my hair stand on end.

I’ve given her a big cuddle and said I’ll sort it out. Not made it into a big thing at all, but said I’ll always be able to fix things and thank you for telling me.

For context DD’s dad doesn’t work his gf is the breadwinner, we haven’t been together since Dd was a newborn and he’s got another 2yr old daughter with his gf. They’ve been together for 4 years. We usually get on well and have a decent co-parenting relationship, I’ve never met his gf though.

Where do I go from here? Dd was meant to be at his tomorrow - Thursday which I’m obviously cancelling, but I don’t know how to go about this properly without causing a gigantic drama but I still need to protect Dd. I have no idea what to do.

OP posts:
Ostryga · 11/04/2022 19:00

Ok so I have started the ball rolling. Can’t talk too much now as an investigation is going to take place. Dd will be with me for the foreseeable future, I’ve got a meeting with her school when she goes back after Easter, and I’ve got a meeting with my boss tomorrow to work out changing my working hours to fit around Dd.

She’s been great today, no meltdowns and really happy. I feel like my head is going to explode, but god it is worth it taking away the stress from her.

Just wanted to say a huge thank you to @Baffledmuch for your advice last night Flowers

OP posts:
MissMaple82 · 11/04/2022 16:14

I'd be stopping contact for sure!

SirVixofVixHall · 11/04/2022 15:51

@Whatsmyname100

I would speak to him and also get SS involved. Speaking to him and trusting him to monitor the situation is very risky. She is abusing your dd, I can't see what speaking to him is going to do? She could easily deny it and hide her abusive ways. She's abusing your child, the only acceptable outcome if she is never around your dd again.
I agree.
OatmilkandCookies · 11/04/2022 15:47

@ViaBlue

"starting with his gf does not discipline your daughter."

Emm..if the 5 year old is in the womens house you can't expect her not to discipline..especially when dad is not there

Discipline is not hair pulling and slapping!! How can you think is OK??!
AuntieStella · 11/04/2022 15:32

I haven't actually suggested OP does differently.

Just highlighted another angle that needs exploration. Because I think crying over that at 5yo is excessive and therefore a matter of concern which also needs proper consideration.

andweallsingalong · 11/04/2022 15:28

Never understand why some adults are reluctant to call the police when it's a child (other posters, not OP). If someone in a position of power pulled their hair and slapped them the police would be the first thought, surely with a more vulnerable person (a child) it shouldn't be up for debate....

Genegenieee · 11/04/2022 15:22

@AuntieStella

Yes That would be one way of achieving the same aim
No it's the best way of achieving it. The little girl has said enough for anyone with a safeguarding responsibility (including her mother) to report to social services and the police. Those agencies are in the best position with trained specialists to ask the child about what has happened and work this out, take appropriate action.
AuntieStella · 11/04/2022 15:17

Yes That would be one way of achieving the same aim

Throckmorton · 11/04/2022 15:15

It's really important OP finds out which it is

No, it's really important the OP reports this to the proper people (police and child services) and they look into it.

AuntieStella · 11/04/2022 15:15

i havent said which if the three scenarios that occurred to me (about tears when dad exits room for a few minutes - which is more than 'concerning' in a 5 yo)

Just that they exist and OP might want to look at many angles

Kanaloa · 11/04/2022 14:51

@AuntieStella

I can think of at least three possible explanations - there may be more
  • she is scared to be alone with the her
  • she is making a large part of it up and isn't always good on adding details. Yes, I know you say it's completely not like her 0, we all think that until one of our DC does it
  • there is a different cause for anxiety, and it is causing an over-reaction to something that was intended as a joke and would be taken that way by someone who wasn't in a stressed state.

It's really important OP finds out which it is

What could be meant as a joke and misunderstood as someone pulling your hair and slapping you? I’m just a bit confused because none of my jokes have ever been misconstrued by a child in my care as pulling their hair or slapping them.
AuntieStella · 11/04/2022 14:47

I can think of at least three possible explanations - there may be more

  • she is scared to be alone with the her
  • she is making a large part of it up and isn't always good on adding details. Yes, I know you say it's completely not like her 0, we all think that until one of our DC does it
  • there is a different cause for anxiety, and it is causing an over-reaction to something that was intended as a joke and would be taken that way by someone who wasn't in a stressed state.

It's really important OP finds out which it is

Kanaloa · 11/04/2022 14:34

@incognitoforthisone

Oh I really didn’t read it that way - to me it seemed like more of the ‘she sounds like a dramatic child.’ The choice of the word ‘excessive’ seems like a criticism of the child’s behaviour. I would have said ‘concerning’ or similar.

Kanaloa · 11/04/2022 14:32

@AuntieStella

As an aside to the immediate issue, you said in OP that she started crying because her DDad left the room to change a nappy

That's excessive in a 5yo

Maybe because she was left with a woman who assaults her? Who then slapped her in the head?

It’s not ‘excessive’ for a child to cry at being left alone with a woman who has previously pulled her hair for leaving a tap on.

incognitoforthisone · 11/04/2022 10:50

Because she knows she is likely to be hurt so not excessive at all!

@Valeriekat I think that was actually the point @AuntieStella was making - that her unusual reaction is a sign that something's wrong.

Valeriekat · 11/04/2022 09:14

@AuntieStella

As an aside to the immediate issue, you said in OP that she started crying because her DDad left the room to change a nappy

That's excessive in a 5yo

Because she knows she is likely to be hurt so not excessive at all!
Mellowyellow222 · 11/04/2022 09:11

I agree there has been some awful advice on this thread. It is worrying how people would respond to a child making a disclosure. There is so much publicity around what to Do - it’s covered in so many tv shows. Yet people would have a kangaroos court, assume the child is lying, assume social services won’t be interested, make friends with the perpetrator and send their child immediately back.

Depressing

Valeriekat · 11/04/2022 08:58

@WomblingWilma

This is not ‘discipline’, it’s abuse FFS. Pulling a 5 year olds hair and slapping round the head!

I’d inform SS first thing tomorrow and let them investigate. There’d be no sit downs or talks. You believe your DD. He will probably minimise and gf will be furious she’s told on her and get more sneaky about hurting her.

She wouldn’t be going back there either. I’d say her Dad can see her in a public place until SS give their conclusion.

Yes it is abusive behaviour.
LondonNQT · 11/04/2022 08:51

@Baffledmuch

I am a child protection social worker. Listening to your daughter and validating her feelings on this, as you have done, are the perfect first steps. She has placed her trust in you and you’re taking this seriously, which will be very important for her to feel secure.

You absolutely should report this, to the police and children’s services. You don’t need to report to the NSPCC and CS as the NSPCC will alert your local authority- I’d personally recommend going straight to CS as this is a clear cut situation where Children’s Services will need to become involved. You need to protect your daughter by not allowing contact with the step mother currently, if your ex could come to you then that would be a good situation as long as he isn’t likely to upset her by trying to ‘investigate’ or discuss things. If in any doubt then follow CS advice based on your specific information (we obviously don’t have that on this forum). You would absolutely not be in any trouble for withholding contact whilst this is being explored, ignore previous posters who say you would be. CS would be far more worried about your ability to protect your daughter if you sent her! Even with a court order (CAO or similar) this can be varied for situations much less extreme than physical abuse- they are pretty toothless for people who wilfully break them with no reason at all.

As much as CS would be worried about the possibility of abuse to all the children, I sadly wouldn’t be surprised if this was limited to your daughter only due to not being her biological daughter, so I’d caution listening too intently to anyone dismissing this because the other children don’t make allegations of a similar nature- although their young ages may preclude this anyway. Sadly, we do see this maltreatment of individual children within families.

It sounds as though sharing this with you has really helped your daughter but the rocky part for you is going to be navigating this with police, CS and your ex. Follow the advice of CS- because you will have shared more specifics with them- and it should be somewhat easier to navigate. I hope all goes as smoothly as possible, well done for taking this as seriously as needed xx

Secondary school teacher here (so safeguarding trained, but not to the degree @Baffledmuch will be) and this is by far and away the best advice on this thread OP.
comfortablyfrumpy · 11/04/2022 08:19

Please ring NSPCC or SS for advice. Thank goodness your daughter has told you

HeDidWhattt · 11/04/2022 08:04

And don’t do the open discussion thing with your daughter there!! No matter how many times you say it’s the case, she will feel like it’s HER doing something wrong and that she HAS to say it didn’t really happen to kee the peace.

HeDidWhattt · 11/04/2022 08:02

I completely believe your daughter, well behaved children don’t make things like this up, their brains done work with malice or cruel intentions yet.
The men normally put up with it and allow it too, well in my case.
I’d be stopping contact with the step mother straight away.

Brefugee · 11/04/2022 07:08

that would depend what the SM is like, no? if OP's DD experiences abuse from SM - in whatever form - when her father isn't in the room, maybe she anticipated something?

AuntieStella · 11/04/2022 06:59

As an aside to the immediate issue, you said in OP that she started crying because her DDad left the room to change a nappy

That's excessive in a 5yo

Genegenieee · 11/04/2022 06:56

@DragonOverTheMoon

Also OP you cannot stop your dd from seeing her dad. If you do that it will not look good on you. It will look like parental alienation. Your dd has a right to a relationship with both parents.

Ring NSPCC. Don't withhold contact unless you're advised (I doubt you will be).

Contact with dad does not need to be at the dad and SM house!

Give your head a wobble - OP needs to take appropriate safeguarding action for her child, or she too can be under SS investigation.

Your repeated posts read as if you are trying to enable the continuation of abusive behaviour.

SS should investigate before there is further contact.

OP, your instincts are right - I'd contact NSPCC for advice on how to navigate thus but I do think the likely outcome is SS and police. My friend's DS was hit around the head by his SM and police were involved.