Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you have replied, or not?

62 replies

aibuainbu · 10/04/2022 18:41

Friendship with a close friend broke down without any reason reason.

I text my friend saying I was mourning the relationship and said I didn't completely understand why the breakdown had happened, and asked for her opinion on it.

She said she was busy but would reply later. 24 hours passed. I text asking if I should expect a reply, or if she'd decided not to. She said she was busy and would reply when she had the time to articulate properly.

It's been 3 days.

Do you think she should have replied by now? Or indeed just said she wasn't going to reply?

I find this waiting game weird.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Kite22 · 10/04/2022 21:00

Your first text was very intense.
Then you chased it up very quickly without giving her time.
So many posters have said it comes across as being very intense but you aren't willing to accept that others might perceive it as such.

Even apart from that, you didn't let her into your life, and let her help you when you were having a difficult time, and then, on top of that you have moved to the other side of the country. Both of those separately alter a friendship considerably.

Nobody owes you an explanation of why they don't particularly want to put in the effort to to maintain a long distance friendship.
If you are anything like you are coming across in this post, in real life, then she has probably been wondering how to phrase it - whether to be honest and upset you further, or diplomatic and not resolve anything, so she might well have decided, on reflection it is better to say nothing, and let things lie. Her choice to do that is as valid as your desire to pick over the bones of why you have moved apart, rather than remembering the good times and thinking it is a shame they have been lost.

Concestor · 10/04/2022 20:54

I don't think you sound intense or hard work, people on here like to say that about others, I've noticed. On Mumsnet it's the done thing to ghost people and not give a shit about friends, it's really odd.

I think your message was fine, but unfortunately she sounds like a flakey ghoster and you're unlikely to get the answer you deserve.

I'm sorry your friend has been shit. I do think if you drop someone they deserve a brief explanation, it's basically a break up and it's so rude just to stop speaking to someone you were close to. But you can't force her so take some time to heal. You've done all you can.

Regularsizedrudy · 10/04/2022 20:47

You asked her to explain, which of course she doesn’t have to, she said she needs times which is understandable given you’re dramatic text, so give her time.

PeachesToday · 10/04/2022 20:37

She said she needs time and will reply so I guess you have to sit in this uncomfortable limbo if you’d like the friendship to remain/bounce back.

I don’t reply to messages immediately either. Can be hours, can be days. I still care.

Kinder456 · 10/04/2022 20:34

OP I could have written this myself. I have a very close friend. More like sister. There has been times where she has left me hanging and I felt exactly the same. I realised today it’s me making all the effort. I care way too much. I need to step back. Sometimes it’s best when people don’t reply or else we would never give up on them. Hope you feel better soon. I know it’s hard though.

givingupchocolatemonday · 10/04/2022 20:29

All seems very intense.
I have a friend that would text me something like that and it makes me cringe.

godmum56 · 10/04/2022 20:27

If you had mnessaged me saying that you were mourning the relationship I deffowouldn't have replied. Thats crazy talk

SlashBeef · 10/04/2022 20:27

I think its really immature of you not to just ask her directly if she's upset about whatever thing you think she's upset about. Instead your playing a bit of a game. The whole "mourning for months" spiel would have had me rolling my eyes too.

AreYouDaveGorman · 10/04/2022 20:23

OP very similar happened to me. I totally understand. Well, a friend just basically ghosted me. I jumped from upset/angry/confused all the time until I decided to just message her.
I was very nice, asked what happened, apologised if I had done anything without realising etc.
She just replied "you haven't done anything, sorry, just been really busy"
If I'm totally honest that reply hasn't helped or given me any kind of closure. So I've treated this like I would treat the end of any relationship. They're just not that into me, I've deleted them from my social media/phone and am moving on. Tbh I don't even know what I'd say if she got in touch now, but I really would have liked closure.

lemongreentea · 10/04/2022 20:20

I text my friend saying I was mourning the relationship and said I didn't completely understand why the breakdown had happened, and asked for her opinion on it.

Did you text the friend you had a falling out with or a different friend to discuss it and get her opinion? Am a bit confused.

MrsTerryPratchett · 10/04/2022 20:15

You've had months to think about this. She's had three days.

You were ready for the conversation. She may well not be.

NippyWoowoo · 10/04/2022 20:09

You've based this on?

Your OP.

MolkosTeenageAngst · 10/04/2022 20:04

It’s only been 3 days. I can take longer than that to get back to friends even when I’m not messaging about something I want to ensure I articulate properly! A few years ago it was completely normal not to respond to correspondence immediately, certainly in the days of email or letters nobody expected a reply within a couple of days. Messaging comes with so much pressure now to stop whatever you’re doing and send a reply immediately or to be assumed to be rude or ignoring the person but really I don’t see the problem with somebody taking their time to reply.

I can appreciate you want the answer but it sounds like it’s not a top priority for her (understandably if she no longer sees you as a friend) and so I would expect it could be a week or more before she makes the time to compose a reply, it sounds like it may need to be long and detailed and so is probably not going to be something she can address quickly and no doubt she is leading her own life and so I think it’s reasonable to at least give her a week or two to get back to you before you assume she won’t bother.

melj1213 · 10/04/2022 19:59

What's intense about it?

You have gone from not messaging for months to messaging about mourning your relationship and wanting to explain the breakdown of the friendship.

For you it is something you have been thinking about for a while so seems perfectly reasonable but for a message that someone is going to receive out of the blue and without warning it comes across as demanding of attention and reflection.

She, after receiving your message sent an acknowledgement but said she was busy. You have no idea what is going on in her life right now.

You then followed up with a second text 24hrs later chasing a reply that comes across as demanding of her immediate attention in asking her if you were going to get a reply when she had already replied.

She then again responded and provided more explanation in that she basically wanted time to get her thoughts and feelings straight in her own head before she responded, but that she would do so when she was ready.

2 days later you're not happy she still hasn't responded.

You messaged her mid-week, if she is busy with work/family and had plans for this weekend then you can't expect her to prioritise you over her existing plans. She may not have felt that she had the headspace to deal with her daily life and dealing with the discussion of your friendship breakdown so she prioritised her current relationships.

You are expecting too much too soon and need to give her the courtesy of the time and space she needs to process her feelings, formulate a response and be ready to have a discourse about it. You have had all the time you need so allow her the same.

ThistlesAndUnicorns · 10/04/2022 19:58

I think your message was a bit intense - particularly for using the word mourning - and it will have came out the blue for her.

People are very busy and as PP has mentioned, anything could be going on in her life right now.

She could have easily just ignored or blocked you instead of saying she will reply once she has time to articulate it. If I had other things going on in my personal life I would find it really suffocating if someone demanded a heartfelt conversation within 24 hours when I wasn't expecting to hear from them.

I wouldn't write off a response yet but I also wouldn't send any more texts. Hope it works out for you.

Madrenetterhere · 10/04/2022 19:58

What is your inkling ? I'm curious. I think I would leave it. Simply if she wanted to reply or talk then she would make the time. I know the pain though and believe me in time this will hurt less.

WhenISnappedAndFarted · 10/04/2022 19:48

@Furrbabymama87

Sounds like she doesn't want to be friends again and doesn't know what to say to you. Busy or not, when someone you care about sends a heartfelt message, you respond to it as soon as you can, so I don't think she does care about you as a friend anymore. Just let it go.
I don't necessarily agree with this. I am not very good at putting together my thoughts/words at all and it can take me forever to write down how I'm feeling and have to chop and change all the time. I have left it overnight before to make sure I'm happy with what I'd written the next day.

Obviously I wouldn't ignore it but would say I'd get back to you but it might take me a couple of days.

aibuainbu · 10/04/2022 19:45

@Youcansaythatagainandagain

Leave her be.

Tbh I wouldn’t respond to the message you sent if in your friend’s situation as it’s intense.

Friendships end and it’s sad but you have to accept it and let it go. She knows where you are if she wants to get in touch.

What's intense about it?

Genuinely curious. I asked for her opinion on it?

Our friendship was extremely close, to not say a thing about it would have been odd imo.

I'm happy for her to not ever reply and I'll not text her again (unless she wants a conversation).

It's honestly strange to me, goes to show how we don't really know anyone really.

OP posts:
Ohyesiam · 10/04/2022 19:44

@GeorgieTheGorgeousGoat

So are you saying it was the friend who your relationship has broken down with that you were messaging?

That's even worse!

In what way? Are you saying that if your friend stopped contacting you you would ask them about it? That is a very odd definition of friendship.
Youcansaythatagainandagain · 10/04/2022 19:42

Leave her be.

Tbh I wouldn’t respond to the message you sent if in your friend’s situation as it’s intense.

Friendships end and it’s sad but you have to accept it and let it go. She knows where you are if she wants to get in touch.

SisterRuth · 10/04/2022 19:41

If some people call you intense, so be it. I'd be exactly the same with a few, very good friends who are more or less sisters to me. If they acted as you describe, it would really hurt & I'd want to understand wtf. And, naturally enough, you've said you won't bother her again if there's truly no conversation forthcoming. You've acted & felt exactly as I would. Not much help, I realise but at least I don't think you're hard work Hmm

mistermagpie · 10/04/2022 19:38

@melj1213

Honestly you need to give her the time she has asked for and back off.

You have been stewing over this for months and so you have reached the point of contacting her on your own terms and when you were ready to go looking for answers. However your friend was not aware of this so for her she has just had a message out of the blue asking her to discuss the breakdown of your friendship.

Firstly she did the right thing in not responding immediately as she wanted time to consider what she said and possibly even think about your friendship for the first time in months. You've had time to think about messaging her, allow her the same courtesy.

Secondly, if you're not in contact for months you can't expect an immediate reply, and I would consider 24hrs immediate under the circumstances. You have no idea what is going on in her life, she could be going through any number of things that are higher priority for her or it could literally just have been bad timing - if she was in the middle of Tesco doing the weekly shop then she isn't going to drop everything to text you back, and if she had weekend plans and didn't have time to sit and reflect on her feelings/your friendship then it's not fair to keep pressuring her her an answer she is not ready to give you yet.

This.
aibuainbu · 10/04/2022 19:36

@Furrbabymama87

Sounds like she doesn't want to be friends again and doesn't know what to say to you. Busy or not, when someone you care about sends a heartfelt message, you respond to it as soon as you can, so I don't think she does care about you as a friend anymore. Just let it go.
I will let it go.

It's very obvious she doesn't want to be friends anymore, and I'm quite sure I don't want to be either.

The irony is, she drained me completely and used me as her emotional ground. With that said, I do miss the good times and how close we were.

OP posts:
Furrbabymama87 · 10/04/2022 19:34

Sounds like she doesn't want to be friends again and doesn't know what to say to you. Busy or not, when someone you care about sends a heartfelt message, you respond to it as soon as you can, so I don't think she does care about you as a friend anymore. Just let it go.

Greatoutdoors · 10/04/2022 19:32

I think a better approach would have been to say something like -

hey, how’s things? Hope your settling into your new life. I miss seeing you - we’ve not fallen out have we?

In the kindest possible way, I think the message you sent sounds a bit… intense?

But what’s done is done. Give her space and she will either come back to you or let it slide