Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To miss genuine veggie food

310 replies

IdiotIntrusion · 10/04/2022 18:08

In the light of all the vegan options coming out, what's happened to veggie food? Granted veggies can eat vegan but I want real cheese or mayo on my burger instead of the fake stuff.

Not even allowed to add a coffee to a 'vegan' meal at burger king, I assume because of the milk. Had to pay separately.

Just having a moan. It's annoying as hell. Anyone else?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
LennyAndTheDucks · 11/04/2022 11:03

[quote DalarnaHorses]**@Fairislefandango So are many ingredients in non vegan foods, but this sort of attack is always (strangely grin) directed at vegans. Even though a vegan diet is not only the most ethically well founded choice in terms of (obviously) animal welfare and the environment, but also the best for human longevity and health outcomes.

Funny how some on Mumsnet are determined to smear our food, all the same. hmm

Thats not true, its not vegan bashing, I think most of us are saying we actually like proper vegan food, you know the kind made with vegetables, pulses, nuts. But not the kind that looks like meat and is full of emulsifiers, stabilisers, enhancers and other additives. I'm not sure there's any health benefit there. I eat mainly vegetarian (and often vegan meals) because I want to be healthier.[/quote]
I don’t think I have ever seen vegan food that looks like meat. Can you give some examples?

And if meat eaters can eat processed crap full of God knows what without people batting an eyelid then why can’t vegans have the same option?

DalarnaHorses · 11/04/2022 10:48

@Fairislefandango So are many ingredients in non vegan foods, but this sort of attack is always (strangely grin) directed at vegans. Even though a vegan diet is not only the most ethically well founded choice in terms of (obviously) animal welfare and the environment, but also the best for human longevity and health outcomes.

Funny how some on Mumsnet are determined to smear our food, all the same. hmm

Thats not true, its not vegan bashing, I think most of us are saying we actually like proper vegan food, you know the kind made with vegetables, pulses, nuts. But not the kind that looks like meat and is full of emulsifiers, stabilisers, enhancers and other additives. I'm not sure there's any health benefit there. I eat mainly vegetarian (and often vegan meals) because I want to be healthier.

Innocenta · 11/04/2022 10:45

@mudgetastic True, but non-vegan foods are generally worse for longterm health outcomes.

mudgetastic · 11/04/2022 10:43

All fats are high in calories
So it doesn't matter if it's vegan or dairy

Innocenta · 11/04/2022 10:36

@EveningOverRooftops

I’m with you on this as a meat eater!

I will happily go to cafes and eat a vegan scone with jam but most vegan milks curdle or are too thin or have a nutty taste or a bitterness. For tea and coffee I want milk.

Vegan cakes taste the same usually but fuuuck they’re usually much much higher in calories and sugar than the dairy and eggs version. And so many vegan cakes have nuts and the fake creams taste foul.

@EveningOverRooftops Dairy and eggs are very high calorie, you must have been buying some pretty strange vegan cakes... Hmm
PaintAndPirouettes · 11/04/2022 10:31

most vegan milks curdle or are too thin or have a nutty taste or a bitterness. For tea and coffee I want milk.

You want the barista versions of the plant milks. I eat dairy but I'm quite partial to Oatly Barista - it's different but I slightly prefer the taste.

Only reason I don't use it routinely is because I find I want more in a cup than I would dairy milk, and it's more expensive than dairy milk, so it works out pricey.

Elmlea Plant doesn't taste identical to normal cream but it behaves in a very similar way (e.g. you can whip it and cook with it). Once you've added in the flavours you would anyway (e.g. if you are making a mushroom stroganoff, or sugar and vanilla for a dessert) it's undistinguishable. Not sure I'd tip a tub over my strawberries though.

EveningOverRooftops · 11/04/2022 10:22

I’m with you on this as a meat eater!

I will happily go to cafes and eat a vegan scone with jam but most vegan milks curdle or are too thin or have a nutty taste or a bitterness. For tea and coffee I want milk.

Vegan cakes taste the same usually but fuuuck they’re usually much much higher in calories and sugar than the dairy and eggs version. And so many vegan cakes have nuts and the fake creams taste foul.

sleepyhoglet · 11/04/2022 10:07

@Amrapaali

YADNBU! I'm supposed to go out to a fancy restaurant with a group. The menu had only two meatless options- both vegan.

Honestly I refuse to eat food where half the words used to describe the dish are in quotation marks- " Not bacon" in a vegan bun with "feta" and "parmesan"

Truly scary frankenfood

If you've been vegan your entire life then you don't care if it's meant to be like feta etc! I completely agree. And fake meat is disgusting.
Innocenta · 11/04/2022 09:56

@PaintAndPirouettes Ah, but what I was referring to was the exploitation and harm of the meat industry. I didn't mean that people are literally eating, say, the 'waste' male chicks. All the 'waste product' of dairy and egg production is treated just as abusively and destructively as the 'waste product' in the meat industry...because it's all animal agriculture. I should have phrased it better and I definitely appreciate your additions!

Innocenta · 11/04/2022 09:53

@PaintAndPirouettes

I need to eat dairy as I have a vitD deficiency. I ended up with a fractured spine in two places last time I cut dairy (weight loss reasons) as my bones became so brittle.

Have you had a DeXA scan for bone density? I'd be concerned you have an underlying condition (such as osteoporosis) and cutting dairy was more of a coincidence than anything else. There are drugs that can help - they're known as bisphosphonates.

Most people in the UK (of all dietary persuasions) are vitamin D deficient to a greater or lesser extent but vitamin D tablets can be bought quite cheaply (there are vegan and non vegan versions of vitamin D tablets too - can't remember what's non vegan about some though)

Non vegan is often derived from sheep's wool! It's the kind they usually use to fortify cereals.
Innocenta · 11/04/2022 09:52

@Roseglen84 Nobody on here has any ability to control what you do. And we are aware of this. It's just the truth; if it's uncomfortable, that isn't my fault.

PaintAndPirouettes · 11/04/2022 09:47

I need to eat dairy as I have a vitD deficiency. I ended up with a fractured spine in two places last time I cut dairy (weight loss reasons) as my bones became so brittle.

Have you had a DeXA scan for bone density? I'd be concerned you have an underlying condition (such as osteoporosis) and cutting dairy was more of a coincidence than anything else. There are drugs that can help - they're known as bisphosphonates.

Most people in the UK (of all dietary persuasions) are vitamin D deficient to a greater or lesser extent but vitamin D tablets can be bought quite cheaply (there are vegan and non vegan versions of vitamin D tablets too - can't remember what's non vegan about some though)

CounsellorTroi · 11/04/2022 09:40

I agree, to many places are using the vegan option to kill two birds with one stone.

Roseglen84 · 11/04/2022 09:35

Oh look, more sanctimonious vegans have arrived to tell us all how to live. Marvellous!

PaintAndPirouettes · 11/04/2022 09:35

[quote Innocenta]@mudgetastic Nope. Eggs and dairy are inextricably linked to the meat industry, so it's not a sustainable argument. (As I said, "I just don't like the taste" [of meat] actually is, because it doesn't claim any ethical stance.) [/quote]
They're only minimally linked, because for the most part different animals are used.

There are huge differences between the breeds used for meat Vs dairy, or meat Vs eggs. They have been optimised for different things.

When, for instance, hens go for slaughter at the end of their most productive egg laying days, understandably they will find a use for the carcass - which could be anything from soup to dog food. But they would be slaughtered regardless of whether or not the carcass can be used. They don't end up as a chicken breast on the shelves of Tesco.

Likewise the male calves from dairy breeds won't grow anywhere near as fast or efficiently as beef breed calves so they're often shot shortly after birth - the carcass may go somewhere like the local hunt kennels for the hounds, but otherwise it would go to waste (they used to be raised for veal, and occasionally still are, but that became deeply unfashionable)

Amelion · 11/04/2022 09:34

@IdiotIntrusion you say you don’t support the egg industry because you don’t by eggs…. On a thread you’ve made about wanting eggs and dairy at a restaurant. The eggs used in vegetarian meals at a restaurant - do you think they’re from home reared chickens? Lol.

Innocenta · 11/04/2022 09:24

@mudgetastic You're misunderstanding what I said. I wasn't referring to a 'sustainable lifestyle' (e.g. someone might argue that shooting an occasional animal for food on their own land is sustainable). I was referring to a sustainable argument, as in one that is ethically consistent and can be coherently defended.

mudgetastic · 11/04/2022 09:21

Nope they may be linked but eggs and diary are perfectly acceptable as part of a sustainable life style

Actually so is a small amount of meat

People who spread misinformation about what a sustainable lifestyle looks like , and make it unnecessary hard will simply turn people away from making the right choices

Innocenta · 11/04/2022 09:19

...also would those be, um, the big food manufacturers who make things like, say, dairy products? Grin Because I don't see how it's worse for a company that makes ice cream or yogurt in vast quantities (i.e. unethical and damaging products) to diversify into vegan products.

Innocenta · 11/04/2022 09:17

@mudgetastic Nope. Eggs and dairy are inextricably linked to the meat industry, so it's not a sustainable argument. (As I said, "I just don't like the taste" [of meat] actually is, because it doesn't claim any ethical stance.)

mudgetastic · 11/04/2022 09:15

There is a sustainable argument for a vegetarian diet

It does far less harm to the planet than a meat diet and eggs and small amounts of cheese are totally compatible with a low carbon sustainable lifestyle

And it often is associated with less heavily processed food - restaurants offering Quorn burgers and cheese alternatives - which many people would rather avoid for health

Actually this take over of the vegan diet by the big food manufacturers is quite uncomfortable for me

Innocenta · 11/04/2022 09:11

[quote Fairislefandango]****@FairislefandangoSo are many ingredients in non vegan foods, but this sort of attack is always (strangely) directed at vegans.

Oh I'm well aware of that and am trying to cut down on highly processed food in my own (non-vegetarian, non-vegan diet). But when the health benefits of vegetarianism and veganism are so frequently stated #plantbased etc, the fake, processed products seem rather at odds with that message (not to mention the fact that the ones I've tried mostly taste horrible and the fake ones taste nothing like the thing they're supposed to be fakes of).[/quote]
@Fairislefandango I actually totally agree that these products are gross af, and I would never eat them myself! I'm repulsed by meat and I have no desire to eat meat substitutes. Apart from chocolate, I'm largely a whole foods vegan. But I'm also not strictly anti PBC because I do think this stuff makes it a lot easier for people (especially Gen Z) to transition, and that it's really helped to open a "vegan conversation". But I'm not personally on the side of these foods Wink

Innocenta · 11/04/2022 09:08

@ButtockUp

I really feel for vegetarians who have battled , for decades, to eat meat/fish free food. Just as the culinary world opened their eyes to vegetarians they were hijacked by vegans. And so menus seem to only cater for omnivores and vegans.

Vegetarians shafted all the way , their hopes truly dashed.

I often don't eat meat at a restaurant but am finding I eat meat/fish more , at a restaurant because there's no vegetarian option.
I can't stomach ( literally) many of the vegan options.
And , strangely enough, neither can my son's girlfriend, who is a vegan.

@ButtockUp Vegetarians are doing their best, but they are, undeniably, inconsistent in their ethics. There is no sustainable argument for being vegetarian (other than "I don't like the taste") and still consuming eggs and dairy, because these other animal products are absolutely inextricable from the meat industry. It's intentionally inflammatory of you to suggest that vegans have "hijacked" anything. On the contrary, vegans (who do have a basically consistent and defined underlying ethical standpoint) have worked long and hard, advocated tirelessly, and in fact are the ones who can be said to have "battled" to get their message out. There are lots of valid arguments back and forth about whether "plant based capitalism" and meat substitutes = good or bad, it's certainly not something vegans tend to agree on! But your read on all this just isn't in touch with the realities of the topic.

Anyone who is curious to find out more could do a lot worse than watching 'Dominion':

www.dominionmovement.com/watch

Fairislefandango · 11/04/2022 09:08

@FairislefandangoSo are many ingredients in non vegan foods, but this sort of attack is always (strangely) directed at vegans.

Oh I'm well aware of that and am trying to cut down on highly processed food in my own (non-vegetarian, non-vegan diet). But when the health benefits of vegetarianism and veganism are so frequently stated #plantbased etc, the fake, processed products seem rather at odds with that message (not to mention the fact that the ones I've tried mostly taste horrible and the fake ones taste nothing like the thing they're supposed to be fakes of).

IdiotIntrusion · 11/04/2022 09:07

I literally said 'farm shop eggs' or home reared chickens Envy

So farms, who have hens running around free who are separated from the males so no chance of eggs being fertilised. These hens will produce eggs irrelevant. Home eggs; I have a family friend who treats his chickens better than his dog. What's wrong with those eggs? I don't support the egg industry as I don't buy them.

This thread isn't even about what is ethically right or wrong. I just want to eat goddamn dairy as that's my personal choice and I don't see why that should be taken away from me to please other people when surely it would be better to offer both options?

I need to eat dairy as I have a vitD deficiency. I ended up with a fractured spine in two places last time I cut dairy (weight loss reasons) as my bones became so brittle.

OP posts: