Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To miss genuine veggie food

310 replies

IdiotIntrusion · 10/04/2022 18:08

In the light of all the vegan options coming out, what's happened to veggie food? Granted veggies can eat vegan but I want real cheese or mayo on my burger instead of the fake stuff.

Not even allowed to add a coffee to a 'vegan' meal at burger king, I assume because of the milk. Had to pay separately.

Just having a moan. It's annoying as hell. Anyone else?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Pixies74 · 11/04/2022 14:54

I'm not strictly veggie (or vegan!) but in recent years I've really gone off meat and often just prefer the veggie option anyway.

My big beef (sorry! Grin) is what seems like a recent explosion of quorn or otherwise fake meat options instead of 'proper' food that is vegetarian.. Like, I don't want a fake meat burger, I want a bean burger or mushroom or halloumi...

MrsAvocet · 11/04/2022 14:52

We do feed our chickens some of their eggs back actually, plus I grind the shells of the ones we've eaten to use as a calcium supplement. Its cheaper and less wasteful than buying a commercial preparation and quite effective.
Ours usually lay 1 egg per chicken per day in the summer and less in the winter. At the moment we're getting between 0.5-1 egg per chicken per day which is more than enough for us.
What would happen to chickens if everyone stopped eating eggs altogether I wonder? Whilst they are lovable pets, I can't see many people keeping them and then not eating the eggs (if we don't eat them, rats etc seem quite happy to and I don't really want a garden full of vermin) and I can't really envisage flocks of wild chickens roaming the country unchecked.

PaintAndPirouettes · 11/04/2022 14:20

The eggs should be fed back to the chickens to replace the nutrients that they have to use to produce the unnatural amount that they now do.

I've heard it all now.

Good quality layers pellets will provide what they need to produce eggs and stay healthy.

Carpy88999 · 11/04/2022 14:06

@PaintAndPirouettes

I’m aware that the egg laying and meat breeds are generally different but the meat industry is bigger than just meat fit for human consumption. My family member owns a chicken farm, she sells eggs and sells egg laying and fancy breed chickens to people wanting to keep chickens and some of their older males and expired hens will be sold for meat, I presume for things like animal feed although admit I’m not 100% sure.

Sounds like she's very much at the small end of chicken farming, if she's selling purebreed chickens to the public? It's not a typical sort of farm that supplies the supermarkets by the sound of things.

Ex laying hens / breeding cockerels will be (a) tough and (b) if off an egg laying breed, scrawny. If they're being sold for meat, it'll be for soup, pet food and other similar low grade uses. You wouldn't roast one if you had any sense.

In terms of eating eggs from rescue hens, some of the vegans I know would argue that if the meat/ egg industry didn’t exist then there wouldn’t be a situation in which hens could be rescued, and that as such eating the eggs of them is still supporting an industry they disagree with. I think for many vegans (at least the ones I know) the underlying thought isn’t just that it is wrong to eat animal products because it is cruel but because using an animal for produce is ethically/ morally wrong.

I find this argument bizarre tbh.

The BHWT literally goes to egg farms on the day the hens are going to slaughter. They take as many as they have homes for, and the rest go to slaughter the same day. These hens will exist and will go to slaughter unless people rescue them.

Once rescued, there's literally no way to stop them laying - and at that point I take the view that the eggs should be used for something, though if the owner themselves doesn't want to eat them all they should be sold / given to friends, family and neighbours. Food waste is a major environmental issue, and there are far too many people going hungry in this country as it is.

Would they also say that rescuing a dog, via a charity, is supporting puppy farming if that dog was originally born in a puppy farm? Mind you I did once have a lodger whose vegan girlfriend told me that keeping pets was a form of slavery...

The eggs should be fed back to the chickens to replace the nutrients that they have to use to produce the unnatural amount that they now do.
wink1970 · 11/04/2022 13:58

Meat eater here who also likes the veggie option some times, but as most of it is now 'fake meat' vegan burgers, I am eating it less.

My local pubs were all terrific for veggies until about a year ago - now the main 'V' option in one is baked squash and the main in another is roasted cauliflower. Both of these should be side dishes!

PaintAndPirouettes · 11/04/2022 13:46

I’m aware that the egg laying and meat breeds are generally different but the meat industry is bigger than just meat fit for human consumption. My family member owns a chicken farm, she sells eggs and sells egg laying and fancy breed chickens to people wanting to keep chickens and some of their older males and expired hens will be sold for meat, I presume for things like animal feed although admit I’m not 100% sure.

Sounds like she's very much at the small end of chicken farming, if she's selling purebreed chickens to the public? It's not a typical sort of farm that supplies the supermarkets by the sound of things.

Ex laying hens / breeding cockerels will be (a) tough and (b) if off an egg laying breed, scrawny. If they're being sold for meat, it'll be for soup, pet food and other similar low grade uses. You wouldn't roast one if you had any sense.

In terms of eating eggs from rescue hens, some of the vegans I know would argue that if the meat/ egg industry didn’t exist then there wouldn’t be a situation in which hens could be rescued, and that as such eating the eggs of them is still supporting an industry they disagree with. I think for many vegans (at least the ones I know) the underlying thought isn’t just that it is wrong to eat animal products because it is cruel but because using an animal for produce is ethically/ morally wrong.

I find this argument bizarre tbh.

The BHWT literally goes to egg farms on the day the hens are going to slaughter. They take as many as they have homes for, and the rest go to slaughter the same day. These hens will exist and will go to slaughter unless people rescue them.

Once rescued, there's literally no way to stop them laying - and at that point I take the view that the eggs should be used for something, though if the owner themselves doesn't want to eat them all they should be sold / given to friends, family and neighbours. Food waste is a major environmental issue, and there are far too many people going hungry in this country as it is.

Would they also say that rescuing a dog, via a charity, is supporting puppy farming if that dog was originally born in a puppy farm? Mind you I did once have a lodger whose vegan girlfriend told me that keeping pets was a form of slavery...

BlueEyesUltimateDragon · 11/04/2022 13:33

I feel your pain OP (and all the other veggies!) I also can't stand that lots of restaurants around here have decided to make their veg/vegan options as meat-like as possible. Hello?! Some people eat plant based diets because they DON'T LIKE MEAT. My choices of eating out are fairly limited now. Bring back the bean burger!

MolkosTeenageAngst · 11/04/2022 13:27

@PaintAndPirouettes

Most will be killed after hatching or they will be passed onto the meat industry.

Egg laying chicken breeds and meat chicken breeds are totally different.

Egg laying breeds are scrawny things optimised for laying lots of eggs. You'll never get enough meat off one to make it financially worthwhile rearing it, when the cost of incubating another egg from a meat breed is so low.

If, however, the friend has rescue chickens (which you can get via www.bhwt.org.uk/ ) then those hens have been saved from slaughter, will continue to lay (albeit at a reduced rate) and even the most ardent vegan would struggle to find a welfare issue with those eggs.

I’m aware that the egg laying and meat breeds are generally different but the meat industry is bigger than just meat fit for human consumption. My family member owns a chicken farm, she sells eggs and sells egg laying and fancy breed chickens to people wanting to keep chickens and some of their older males and expired hens will be sold for meat, I presume for things like animal feed although admit I’m not 100% sure.

In terms of eating eggs from rescue hens, some of the vegans I know would argue that if the meat/ egg industry didn’t exist then there wouldn’t be a situation in which hens could be rescued, and that as such eating the eggs of them is still supporting an industry they disagree with. I think for many vegans (at least the ones I know) the underlying thought isn’t just that it is wrong to eat animal products because it is cruel but because using an animal for produce is ethically/ morally wrong.

That said I do personally agree that there isn’t much direct harm to eating eggs from rescue hens, but I suppose the argument is if everybody stopped eating eggs then the entire industry would have to end and so on some level eating eggs (regardless of where they come from) sends out a message that eating eggs is fine, when many vegans would feel like it’s not.

KittenKong · 11/04/2022 13:08

My sisters rescue chooks lay eggs. Not a cock in sight.

PaintAndPirouettes · 11/04/2022 12:42

Most will be killed after hatching or they will be passed onto the meat industry.

Egg laying chicken breeds and meat chicken breeds are totally different.

Egg laying breeds are scrawny things optimised for laying lots of eggs. You'll never get enough meat off one to make it financially worthwhile rearing it, when the cost of incubating another egg from a meat breed is so low.

If, however, the friend has rescue chickens (which you can get via www.bhwt.org.uk/ ) then those hens have been saved from slaughter, will continue to lay (albeit at a reduced rate) and even the most ardent vegan would struggle to find a welfare issue with those eggs.

MolkosTeenageAngst · 11/04/2022 12:35

@IdiotIntrusion

I literally said 'farm shop eggs' or home reared chickens Envy

So farms, who have hens running around free who are separated from the males so no chance of eggs being fertilised. These hens will produce eggs irrelevant. Home eggs; I have a family friend who treats his chickens better than his dog. What's wrong with those eggs? I don't support the egg industry as I don't buy them.

This thread isn't even about what is ethically right or wrong. I just want to eat goddamn dairy as that's my personal choice and I don't see why that should be taken away from me to please other people when surely it would be better to offer both options?

I need to eat dairy as I have a vitD deficiency. I ended up with a fractured spine in two places last time I cut dairy (weight loss reasons) as my bones became so brittle.

Again you’re being very naive. For your friend who has home reared chickens, how many roosters does he have? Anybody keeping chickens for eggs will only need female hens. You won’t know whether an egg will procure a male or female chick until it’s hatched, so what do you think happens to all those male chicks? Most will be killed after hatching or they will be passed onto the meat industry. Yes, the part of the chain where a chicken running around your friend’s garden producing eggs looks pretty cruelty free but if you look further up the chain there will be male chicks slaughtered because they are useless to the egg industry and because almost nobody keeping chickens in their garden wants to buy roosters.

Most vegans have chosen to be vegan because there isn’t really a way for the average person in the UK to enjoy eating and using animal products without exploiting the animals in some way, yes you might be able to keep a couple of happy chickens in your garden and eat their eggs but those chickens will have come from a place which slaughtered the excess males as chicks or sold them for meat so you’re still supporting an industry which is harmful to animals. The only way not to support this industry would be to abstain from eating and using animal products at all which is what many vegans try to do.

To reiterate I am absolutely not judging your choice to eat eggs or be vegetarian rather than vegan, as stated previously in the thread I am also vegetarian, but I just wanted to point out why eating eggs from a happy chicken or ethical farm isn’t really cruelty free.

LennyAndTheDucks · 11/04/2022 12:25

@RockyRoadster

“If you can make bacon out of processed ground up and seasoned pig then why can’t you make it out of processed ground up and seasoned vegetables?”

Bacon is not processed ground up pig! It is cured pork, sliced.

Okay then.

If you can make bacon out of pig then why can’t you make it out of vegetables?

Turkey bacon is a thing after all.

Carpy88999 · 11/04/2022 12:25

@PaintAndPirouettes

I need to eat dairy as I have a vitD deficiency. I ended up with a fractured spine in two places last time I cut dairy (weight loss reasons) as my bones became so brittle.

Have you had a DeXA scan for bone density? I'd be concerned you have an underlying condition (such as osteoporosis) and cutting dairy was more of a coincidence than anything else. There are drugs that can help - they're known as bisphosphonates.

Most people in the UK (of all dietary persuasions) are vitamin D deficient to a greater or lesser extent but vitamin D tablets can be bought quite cheaply (there are vegan and non vegan versions of vitamin D tablets too - can't remember what's non vegan about some though)

Sheeps wool is used and its also the reason a lot of fortified breakfast cereals are not vegan.
Innocenta · 11/04/2022 12:24

@LennyAndTheDucks Absolutely true. It's not a zero sum game, and plenty of vegans have allergies and medical conditions too. People in this thread and other MN threads about vegans are verrrry ready to blame the rise in veganism for any difficulties they have finding suitable food!

RockyRoadster · 11/04/2022 12:22

“If you can make bacon out of processed ground up and seasoned pig then why can’t you make it out of processed ground up and seasoned vegetables?”

Bacon is not processed ground up pig! It is cured pork, sliced.

Fairislefandango · 11/04/2022 12:16

I agree that these hyper processed vegan options are unappealing and not very healthy

That's all I was saying.

I myself eat largely whole foods vegan. But it's naive to think that the vitriol directed at processed vegan options isn't because they are vegan.

Maybe some people express vitriol towards vegans or veganism, but I haven't seen any of that on this thread. I have no issue whatsoever with people being vegan, and I dislike artificial, highly processed meat-based foods as well as vegan ones.

I guess that for a lot of non-vegans, the idea of eating a healthy, natural plant-based dish is very appealing. They see eating vegan for a meal, or a week, or a month as being a healthy, nourishing thing to do. But I guess if you're vegan it's nice to have the option of eating some easy, indulgent crap once in a while.

LennyAndTheDucks · 11/04/2022 11:34

@DrCoconut

I feel properly cheated. I waited years to have a good range of non meat options. Now vegan is everywhere I go and get coeliac disease which means I'm back to the crappy "special diet" option again, usually a jacket potato or something. And even then they sometimes manage to contaminate it. Why is everything filled with wheat? Why are gluten free options lumped in with everything else free so I can no longer get a nice ice cream on a cone for example? And don't get me started on the effect of some vegan milks at coffee shops. They contaminate the machines with gluten, making them unusable for coeliacs. It could be prevented so easily by using GF oat milk but in many cases they just don't care. There are some good ones but generally no one is bothered about those of us with health related dietary needs.
The contamination in coffee shops has always happened. If someone is allergic to cows milk then they have always been contaminated. When the only non dairy milks a available were soya and almond then they were also contaminated with nuts and soya.
DrCoconut · 11/04/2022 11:29

I feel properly cheated. I waited years to have a good range of non meat options. Now vegan is everywhere I go and get coeliac disease which means I'm back to the crappy "special diet" option again, usually a jacket potato or something. And even then they sometimes manage to contaminate it. Why is everything filled with wheat? Why are gluten free options lumped in with everything else free so I can no longer get a nice ice cream on a cone for example? And don't get me started on the effect of some vegan milks at coffee shops. They contaminate the machines with gluten, making them unusable for coeliacs. It could be prevented so easily by using GF oat milk but in many cases they just don't care. There are some good ones but generally no one is bothered about those of us with health related dietary needs.

Innocenta · 11/04/2022 11:19

[quote DalarnaHorses]**@Fairislefandango So are many ingredients in non vegan foods, but this sort of attack is always (strangely grin) directed at vegans. Even though a vegan diet is not only the most ethically well founded choice in terms of (obviously) animal welfare and the environment, but also the best for human longevity and health outcomes.

Funny how some on Mumsnet are determined to smear our food, all the same. hmm

Thats not true, its not vegan bashing, I think most of us are saying we actually like proper vegan food, you know the kind made with vegetables, pulses, nuts. But not the kind that looks like meat and is full of emulsifiers, stabilisers, enhancers and other additives. I'm not sure there's any health benefit there. I eat mainly vegetarian (and often vegan meals) because I want to be healthier.[/quote]
The reason why it's vegan bashing is because there are actually way more disgusting, crappy foods which contain animal ingredients. But no one levels this sort of criticism at them.

I agree that these hyper processed vegan options are unappealing and not very healthy; I myself eat largely whole foods vegan. But it's naive to think that the vitriol directed at processed vegan options isn't because they are vegan.

LennyAndTheDucks · 11/04/2022 11:19

@Innocenta

How many field mice do you think have been churned up in tractors when harvesting vegetables?

The net impact of farming vegetables is minuscule compared to animal agriculture

Do you check your beauty products are vegan/cruelty free?

Yes. All of mine are.

Does your car have a leather steering wheel?

No.

@IdiotIntrusion I'm genuinely not sure why you think vegans would not do these things.

Not to mention I highly doubt that many animals are actually killed in the production of crops. Machines and tractors are very loud. Do people honestly believe that small prey animas hear them and just sit there? They don’t run away when they hear the machines approaching? Come on now Grin
Innocenta · 11/04/2022 11:17

@IdiotIntrusion a healthier one that included dairy

Dairy is not healthier.

Innocenta · 11/04/2022 11:16

How many field mice do you think have been churned up in tractors when harvesting vegetables?

The net impact of farming vegetables is minuscule compared to animal agriculture

Do you check your beauty products are vegan/cruelty free?

Yes. All of mine are.

Does your car have a leather steering wheel?

No.

@IdiotIntrusion I'm genuinely not sure why you think vegans would not do these things.

LennyAndTheDucks · 11/04/2022 11:16

@Fairislefandango

You're correct, but why do you have to be so derogatory towards vegan food - 'fake'

But some vegan (and vegetarian) foods are fake versions of something else. Vegan bacon is not bacon! The OP isn't being derogatory towards vegan food in general. The fake stuff may not be literally made of plastic, but it's very highly processed and often full of dubious-sounsing ingredients you wouldn't find in a domestic kitchen.

But why is vegan bacon not bacon?

If you can make bacon out of processed ground up and seasoned pig then why can’t you make it out of processed ground up and seasoned vegetables?

If you can make mayo with eggs then why can’t you make it without? If you can make cheese with cows milk then why can’t you make cashews or coconut oil?

Food adapts and changes constantly. Traditionally pizza should not have cheese on for instance however we have adapted it so now cheese is standard. An Italian would probably have a heart attack if they saw you putting pepperoni on a pizza but nobody would say pizza with cheese or pepperoni on was fake pizza. Indian food served in the UK is vastly different to Indian food in India but nobody would say that stuff you can buy in the UK is fake.

So why refer to cheese, bacon, etc that has been adapted as ‘fake’?

LennyAndTheDucks · 11/04/2022 11:05

@EatsQuorn

For the vegetarian or vegans out there , be aware when buying from fast food outlets , there isn't a special place the burger is cooked , it's all cooked on the same hotplate / grill .
And ethically this is fine. You are still paying for the plant based product therefore increasing demand for the vegan options and reducing demand for meat. The fact it may have come into contact with something non vegan does not change that.
IdiotIntrusion · 11/04/2022 11:04

@PaintAndPirouettes

I need to eat dairy as I have a vitD deficiency. I ended up with a fractured spine in two places last time I cut dairy (weight loss reasons) as my bones became so brittle.

Have you had a DeXA scan for bone density? I'd be concerned you have an underlying condition (such as osteoporosis) and cutting dairy was more of a coincidence than anything else. There are drugs that can help - they're known as bisphosphonates.

Most people in the UK (of all dietary persuasions) are vitamin D deficient to a greater or lesser extent but vitamin D tablets can be bought quite cheaply (there are vegan and non vegan versions of vitamin D tablets too - can't remember what's non vegan about some though)

I did. They were extremely concerned at first and thought I had severe osteoporosis or cancer that had spread to my bones. A really worrying time and a kick up the bum to change my diet to a healthier one that included dairy.

As for wanting eggs and dairy at restaurants - how often do you actually think I eat at restaurants? How many field mice do you think have been churned up in tractors when harvesting vegetables? Do you check your beauty products are vegan/cruelty free? Does your car have a leather steering wheel? There is nothing anybody can do in this world that does not in some way have a negative impact on animals. We can minimise it but we cannot completely stamp it out. Unless you're a vegan living completely off the grid and grow your own vegetables then you have absolutely no right to school me on what I can and cannot eat.

OP posts: