Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not to want mum alone with DS

160 replies

Beekeeper555 · 10/04/2022 16:58

Live far from mum. Have 9mo DS and meet up for long visits every few months. DS is her first grandchild She professes to love babies but often get the vibe she loves how babies make her look and feel. AIBU to want to keep DS away from her and hold to a hard rule that she is never alone with him for more than a few minutes? The latter will cause issues as she is explicitly asking to have him alone, and asking why I don’t trust her with him.

Generally worry that she is bad at reading him and he gets stressed with her. More importantly that she is more interested in taking videos/photos of him to share with her friends on social media- and now DS is mobile, there is a risk she is too distracted by her device to keep him safe.

A few things that I find off:

  • she interacts with high intensity, making the smile request pattern coo (heLLO!!!) non stop, for minutes. No pauses for response and if DS tries to babble back she talks over him until he stops, confused. Unless DS is actively screaming she doesn’t take a cue to stop.
  • she baits DS with her phone, trying to video him or just enjoying having him climbing on her for it. Even though I have said many times I am trying to keep DS as device free as possible, and DS is crying with the frustration by the end of the “game”
  • at mealtimes, she often leaves her food to get up and play/interact with DS even if he is still eating. We are BLW so often he is working through something scary and chokable. But she still eg puts on a video call and baits DS with the device so her friend/sibling/mum can see the baby while he is sat up and cute in high chair.
  • she seems always to look for an opportunity to get DS alone, whether taking him for a walk outside during family meals (“so we can eat”) or into her bedroom with the door shut. When either me or DH go to retrieve him after a few nail biting minutes she says things like “see, he doesn’t care about you. He’s happy with me”
  • the last time we let her have DS alone in her room for 15 mins, we found her asleep on the bed with him on a deep soft down cushion (at the time he was 2mo). This was the day after we’d had the safe sleeping convo with her. I told her it wasn’t safe and she cut me off saying she’d raised three children and it was fine.

Ps. We have left DS with other family members before. They’re not all experts with babies but we feel DS is calm with them and they read his cues well enough to try to figure out what he needs, even if not right first (or second) (or third) time

OP posts:
caringcarer · 11/04/2022 03:02

You sound ott about your baby. Your Mum raised you ok, she just is proud of her GC and wants to capture it on her phone do she can look back on it when dgs is not there.

Beekeeper555 · 11/04/2022 02:42

Thanks all. @jjjjjjjjjjjjjjj, @Demelzaza you got it spot on… relationship with mum is tricky, abuse was physical and emotional. Yes I have issues with anxiety, ironically much better with baby as DS is by all standards very easy.

PFB is very much a thing, you should listen to me and DH debating how we’ll make DS’s formula… hot vs cold water, microplastics vs salmonella… it’s insanity and we know it! But what else would we talk about Hmm

I agree it sounds crazy, I think the upshot is I am hyper vigilant because I don’t trust her. DS won’t explode if left with her for an afternoon, but ultimately I don’t want DS to have the childhood I did and this is probably what I’m really obsessing about.

Promise I don’t follow DMIL around with a stopwatch checking how often she lets DS respond. I honestly couldn’t tell you as once she takes him my attention is on showering/eating/reading/chatting. Same with other family and non family members who look after him occasionally. I gather that is the norm, and most people do just leave their babies with trusted family without batting an eyelid.

Thanks MN !

OP posts:
AnnesBrokenSlate · 11/04/2022 02:23

I'd love to know which relatives passed all the hidden tests that your mum has failed Hmm
Like PPs I also did BLW. You're sounding ridiculous about all of it. The only part that sounds like a risk is the cushion but I do not believe that in 15 mins with you hovering in the other room that she fell sound asleep.

ZeroCaffeine · 11/04/2022 02:12

YAB SO U. Poor kid 🤦🏾‍♀️

PingPages · 11/04/2022 01:10

If you’re chilled with other people and let him be alone with them, then doesn’t sound like you’re just being PFB. She sounds overwhelming and doesn’t really seem like she’s thinking about he wants most, just what she wants.

God knows how you have the conversation without leaving to massive drama though OP, sorry. I wouldn’t feel comfortable leaving her alone with him if she’s so out of sync with his needs, he’s so little and likely to be into everything soon

AntiHop · 11/04/2022 01:08

@RazzleDazz1e

OP I totally get it- don’t leave the baby alone with her if your instincts tell you not to. I suspect that there is a long back story about your own relationship with your Mother, and those posters who have had loving, normal non abusive mothers will just not be able to comprehend. Even if this isn’t the case, trust your instincts!
I agree with this.

You've said you happily leave him with other people. But she isn't paying proper attention to the baby.

Fadeout83 · 11/04/2022 01:02

Re nail biting minutes you allowed her - perhaps she made the snide comment about baby not needing you because you’re constantly in her face hovering and putting pillows around your child and pre chewing his food lest he choke on it. Geez. You really need to calm down and let your mother enjoy her grandson unless there is more to the story you’re not telling us that would lead to these ridiculous concerns.

Fadeout83 · 11/04/2022 00:57

Haha are you serious? First child? Youll grow out of it. Let grandma be excited about her grandchild for goodness sake. My MIL is like this too - constantly taking photos and videos to share with others. They’re proud!! They’ve raised kids before and now they want to enjoy grandchildren without needing to actively parent them. Stop hovering over her and the kid.

That said, the safe sleep thing is an issue and should definitely be reiterated (though it sounds like it happened only once ages ago)

Superhanz · 11/04/2022 00:42

Christ!

I thought I was PFB, but this is next level! I always want to hover when anyone has my daughter but I have a word with myself and let her grandparents enjoy her. I expect your mum wants to take him to another room as you sound really intense. It's natural for grand parents to want to take the baby for a walk or to offer to help. It's normal!

Sorry to be harsh but you really need to unclench!

Changeee1546789 · 11/04/2022 00:30

The safe sleep thing is not ok but everything else is PFB OP, sorry. Unless there is huge backstory.

Fuck knows what smile request pattern coo is? Can you explain?

WhereYouLeftIt · 11/04/2022 00:12

Go with your gut. I don't think you're being PFB, because this is specific to her and her alone - "We have left DS with other family members before."

The constant photographing/videoing would set me on edge. It smacks of Performance Grandparenting. It's not about having a relationship with her grandchild, it's about showing her friends the photos/videos and presenting herself to them as Grandmother of The Year. (When you can clearly see she isn't.) Your child is not a sodding prop.

"the last time we let her have DS alone in her room for 15 mins, we found her asleep on the bed with him on a deep soft down cushion (at the time he was 2mo). "
So desperate to have him all to herself - and is asleep within 15 minutes? Odd. So odd.

RazzleDazz1e · 11/04/2022 00:10

OP I totally get it- don’t leave the baby alone with her if your instincts tell you not to. I suspect that there is a long back story about your own relationship with your Mother, and those posters who have had loving, normal non abusive mothers will just not be able to comprehend. Even if this isn’t the case, trust your instincts!

Shelby2010 · 11/04/2022 00:00

I think the OP is getting a hard time here. If you reframe the question:

I am happy to leave DS (9mths) with my friend or sister. However, my DM doesn’t pay attention to his needs & is more interested in getting Insta shots. He often cries with frustration because she ignore his cues. I take DS see his GM but don’t feel comfortable in leaving her in her sole care - am IBU?

Basically, it’s your baby, your decision.

sst1234 · 10/04/2022 23:59

@MissChanandlerBong80

Taking someone else’s baby into your room and shutting the door is bonkers behaviour.
Taking your grandchild into a room and shutting the door is bonkers behaviour? Honestly, this please get weirder by the minute.
greenlynx · 10/04/2022 23:59

I don’t trust my Mum and her judgment so I’m not surprised at OP’s post. It’s very difficult to explain when you haven’t experienced that. It took quite a while to my DH to get what I meant because it’s mainly my gut feeling. I can put it in words now which is not surprising- DD is older teen and I’m more experienced.
I think all these little things about being distracted, unfocused, not adapting your behaviour to baby’s needs are very significant when you are looking after a small child. Also the attitude “I’ve raised certain amount of DC so I know better” is always a red flag to me. It means that parents are not listened to and not respected and that’s wrong.
I don’t think OP that you are controlling, I think you just don’t trust your mum. Go slowly and hopefully it will be ok. You don’t have to leave your baby with anyone, there is no obligation.

MenopausalMomcat · 10/04/2022 23:44

So, DS is 9 months old, you live far away and DM only sees DS every few months. Seems to me that DM is trying to make memories of her and DS to get her through the months that she doesn’t see him. Being a DGM is hard, trying to second guess what mummy needs/wants, and at the same time being desperate to spend time with the DGC.
Most parents of young babies that I know would be over the moon at being able to eat a hot meal together, make the most of it.
And some of the language you use, seriously? “ Nail-biting minutes”, “Scary and chokeable”? Rather dramatic!
PFB at its finest 🙄

sst1234 · 10/04/2022 23:33

Wow OP. Your poor mother. Feel sorry for her about your behaviour.

littleshep · 10/04/2022 23:19

I just wrote you a long reply OP and then bloody lost it, so will just say that you're getting an unnecessarily hard time on here.
A lot of the above would have done my head in and what previous posters said about those with normal families not getting it makes a lot of sense to me.
I don't know if your mum is overexcited or undermining you, but you are allowed to ask someone not to wind your kid up with a phone or distract him when he's eating.
You may find that some of these worries and annoyances will become non issues in a few months once he's dashing about too quickly for photos and directing the conversation, so perhaps a full Co frontation isn't necessary just yet xx

NoToLandfill · 10/04/2022 23:16

I totally understand your concerns. Listen to your mummy instincts and do whatever you have to, to keep your baby safe.

Onceuponachime · 10/04/2022 23:08

A 12 inch sub, by the sounds of it

Onceuponachime · 10/04/2022 23:07

@MissChanandlerBong80

Taking someone else’s baby into your room and shutting the door is bonkers behaviour.
..Probably the only way she could get peace to spend any time with her grandson, without the constant whirring of helicopter blades
pookieandgarfield · 10/04/2022 23:06

There are problems on both sides here, @Beekeeper555!

What do you mean by "working through something scary and chokable"? I did BLW and at no point was I worried my DCs would choke.

Your mum needs to calm down, and you need to step away from the parenting books Confused

groeggmeg · 10/04/2022 22:47

@MissChanandlerBong80

Taking someone else’s baby into your room and shutting the door is bonkers behaviour.
How an earth is grandparent walking away with the baby and shutting the door bonkers behaviour?! She likely was trying to give them a few child free minutes. Mumsnet is so bloody depressing at times.
MissChanandlerBong80 · 10/04/2022 22:34

Taking someone else’s baby into your room and shutting the door is bonkers behaviour.

saraclara · 10/04/2022 22:33

@Cherrysoup

She doesn’t get to take him out of your sight, why would that happen? Also, if you live far apart, there is no way she gets him alone, you’ll always be with him. I think you need to have an honest conversation with her.
Why? My MIL lived 2.5 hours away from us, but she got to have my babies/toddlers/kids alone when we visited and when she visited us.

We would happily nip to the local shops or for a little walk while she watched the babies when we visited and they were that kind of age or more/less. And when she and FIL came to stay with us we'd take advantage of being able to go out for an hour or so.

Now that I'm a grandma, I can't imagine my DD not daring to leave the room when I was with her own baby, or resenting me walking out into her garden, say, with the baby and without her. Pretty sure she wasn't biting her nails when I did, either.