Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not to want mum alone with DS

160 replies

Beekeeper555 · 10/04/2022 16:58

Live far from mum. Have 9mo DS and meet up for long visits every few months. DS is her first grandchild She professes to love babies but often get the vibe she loves how babies make her look and feel. AIBU to want to keep DS away from her and hold to a hard rule that she is never alone with him for more than a few minutes? The latter will cause issues as she is explicitly asking to have him alone, and asking why I don’t trust her with him.

Generally worry that she is bad at reading him and he gets stressed with her. More importantly that she is more interested in taking videos/photos of him to share with her friends on social media- and now DS is mobile, there is a risk she is too distracted by her device to keep him safe.

A few things that I find off:

  • she interacts with high intensity, making the smile request pattern coo (heLLO!!!) non stop, for minutes. No pauses for response and if DS tries to babble back she talks over him until he stops, confused. Unless DS is actively screaming she doesn’t take a cue to stop.
  • she baits DS with her phone, trying to video him or just enjoying having him climbing on her for it. Even though I have said many times I am trying to keep DS as device free as possible, and DS is crying with the frustration by the end of the “game”
  • at mealtimes, she often leaves her food to get up and play/interact with DS even if he is still eating. We are BLW so often he is working through something scary and chokable. But she still eg puts on a video call and baits DS with the device so her friend/sibling/mum can see the baby while he is sat up and cute in high chair.
  • she seems always to look for an opportunity to get DS alone, whether taking him for a walk outside during family meals (“so we can eat”) or into her bedroom with the door shut. When either me or DH go to retrieve him after a few nail biting minutes she says things like “see, he doesn’t care about you. He’s happy with me”
  • the last time we let her have DS alone in her room for 15 mins, we found her asleep on the bed with him on a deep soft down cushion (at the time he was 2mo). This was the day after we’d had the safe sleeping convo with her. I told her it wasn’t safe and she cut me off saying she’d raised three children and it was fine.

Ps. We have left DS with other family members before. They’re not all experts with babies but we feel DS is calm with them and they read his cues well enough to try to figure out what he needs, even if not right first (or second) (or third) time

OP posts:
MissChanandlerBong80 · 11/04/2022 06:29

How an earth is grandparent walking away with the baby and shutting the door bonkers behaviour?! She likely was trying to give them a few child free minutes. Mumsnet is so bloody depressing at times.

Taking someone else’s baby away into your room without being invited to do so and shutting the door then, when they come to retrieve them, telling them that their child doesn’t care about them, is absolutely bonkers.

On the other hand saying ‘would you two like me to look after DS for a few minutes while you finish dinner/clear up/watch telly/whatever?’ then taking him off if the answer is yes is less bonkers. Although even then, if it were me, I’d probably just play with the baby wherever his/her toys are, which in most houses is usually in the living room or the baby’s bedroom.

Calphurnia88 · 11/04/2022 06:20

I don't think YABU.

One of the very few scenarios I can envisage where it wouldn't be odd for a person to take baby to a seperate room in the house for a prolonged period (when the parents are there) is for a nap, and if that guest is not following safe sleep guidelines (despite being told what they are), and is therefore putting baby at risk, I would not feel comfortable leaving my baby alone with that person again.

The constant photo/video taking is less of a concern, but would annoy me. Totally understandable that GPs will want to capture some photos/videos, but if it's all the time, and it's distracting them from what baby is actually doing, then it wouldn't give me confidence that they would give the required level of attention if left on their own with baby.

Generally speaking, I think there are some people you feel comfortable leaving baby alone with, and others you are happy to spend time with baby accompanied. Sounds like your mum falls into the latter group.

Momijin · 11/04/2022 06:15

I don't think you're being PFB and even if you are a bit, better to be safe than sorry. As you say, when he's with someone you can trust like your MIL, you're relaxed. Keep your child safe and away from an abusive person like your mum.

ASandwichNamedKevin · 11/04/2022 06:14

Reading your second post, I'm wondering why you even go to see your mother at all and if you'd benefit from some therapy.

You dont have to go there, if you do go you don't have to leave the baby alone with her.
DH and I don't leave our baby alone with MIL (his idea and I agree). We do leave them with other family members but don't trust MIL for safety reasons.

I didn't care about being PFB by the way, babies are precious.

The weaning sounds a bit anxiety-inducing, maybe look again at that.

Whatdidhearyousay · 11/04/2022 06:12

As if people are wasting your precious time by drip feeding. I think the fact that we are scrolling through mumsnet posts probably indicates that we do indeed have a bit of spare time on our hands!

RantyAunty · 11/04/2022 06:08

Your DC is only 9 months and you say you visit every few months so that's 3 times at the most she's even seen him.

You weren't getting the answers you wanted so you decide to say you were abused.

Seems you really just don't like your mum.
The solution is simple. Don't visit anymore.

Whatdidhearyousay · 11/04/2022 06:08

This drip feed thing that people moan about on mumsnet is totally unreasonable. Such a peculiar concept that people have to have the ability to get their whole painful story in to one post purely to benefit the precious time of the readers so they don’t waste their time with inappropriate replies. Perhaps if people were a little bit insightful and considerate then they could try and read between the lines and attempt to see the real picture. There’s always a reason for peoples behaviours

Whatdidhearyousay · 11/04/2022 06:03

Hi op, I also understand how you feel. I grew up with an inconsistent and emotionally abusive mother. Depending on her emotional state then I feel reluctant to leave my kids with her. I think the people that have posted negatively to you won’t have had these experiences so they don’t understand. If you feel you need to protect your baby from her then follow your gut instinct. Take care. 💐

HELLITHURT · 11/04/2022 05:48

Ok massive backstory, which makes your first totally OTT post void.

Dairymilk50 · 11/04/2022 05:40

did you have issues with your mother before?
This with bells on.

If you read your post back OP it's all just so exhausting almost like your DS is in danger.... unless there's a back story to this?

Changeee1546789 · 11/04/2022 05:11

@Anycrispsleft

Well I hope youre all pleased with yourself. The lassie has now disclosed a history of abuse (which a few of us predicted) but in the meantime you have all convinced her that she's being unreasonable and her mother is totally safe, which is not something any of you could possibly know.
Jesus Christ. I know your post probably makes you feel morally superior but the point is that people giving advice might have had a better idea had she not DRIP FED the history of abuse which was clearly a major factor in her "AIBU" post which initially made her sound totally U.
Tilltheend99 · 11/04/2022 05:00

My MIL is the same about demanding a response from baby but not waiting for one. She asks for claps and stomps etc but always in a different order and when baby has hands full etc so after trying really hard to oblige for a while baby just ends up staring back in confusion. Drives me (silently) bonkers and she is not potentially abusive like your mother so UANBU

Anycrispsleft · 11/04/2022 04:56

Well I hope youre all pleased with yourself. The lassie has now disclosed a history of abuse (which a few of us predicted) but in the meantime you have all convinced her that she's being unreasonable and her mother is totally safe, which is not something any of you could possibly know.

RustyShackleford3 · 11/04/2022 04:44

Most of what you have listed is very over the top and sounds PFB. Don't sweat the small stuff.

However the thing about her saying "he doesn't care about you" is very weird, and her falling asleep with him like that is scary. I wouldn't leave him alone with her again until he's old enough that you don't need to worry about the safe sleep stuff.

autienotnaughty · 11/04/2022 04:31

Read the first post and thought you just sound like over the top first time parents and need to chill out. Include the second post and yeah I get it. I'd try to be more trusting when you visit of letting mum spend time with ds but no I wouldn't leave him alone with her.

Midlifemusings · 11/04/2022 04:26

You do come across as having a pretty significant case of first time parentitis. You should deal with your anxiety. Your thinking can get skewed where you start to think your anxiety is good for your child and protective - rather than seeing the harm it does.

You seem intent on assuming your mother's intentions through the most negative lens you can think of. I am sure there is some history behind that but you need to separate out your issues from her current behaviour. It is clear you don't trust her generally - so you are assuming each thing she is doing is something that isn't trustworthy.

It sounds like therapy to deal with those issues and your anxiety and figure out what are healthy boudaries for your particular situation might be helpful

DailySheetWasher · 11/04/2022 04:25

I think it's important to separate your thinking into the non-negotiables and the 'annoying-but-not-harmful' things.

Non negotiables like sleeping safely - you have every right to expect she follow the guidelines, or she won't be able to have him alone.

The rest sounds like excitement and maybe lack of familiarity. She'll chill as she gets to know him better - restricting their time together will probably make it worse.

Changeee1546789 · 11/04/2022 04:21

@Ivyonafence you may not be aware but this section of the internet is called "AIBU - Am I Being Unreasonable?". This is where people come and invite people to tell them whether they are being unreasonable or not.

Ivyonafence · 11/04/2022 04:16

Ffs.

Cut it out with the PFB and anxiety stuff.

My mother agreed that my baby was precious. She didn't scoff at my concerns, she listened to me and shared them. If I was anxious about something like safe sleeping, she listened to me and sought to relieve my anxiety by being careful.

In doing so she builds trust. That's what you need.

Some mums are anxious- it's no help to tell them they are being silly. People need compassion and support not a bunch of people sneering and dismissing them from the internet, let alone from their mother in real life.

Your mum sounds like a PITA. She isn't empathetic to you or your child. She might be great fun when your child is bigger and less fragile and better able to tell her to back off or whatever - but it's a bad idea to leave your baby with her.

You deserve to feel comfortable and have trust with people you leave your baby with.

Trust your gut.

Kuachui · 11/04/2022 04:01

your a helicopter parent.

yabu

NumberTheory · 11/04/2022 03:37

I think any grandparent who does something that’s been recommended against for more than 30 years but argues that she’s raised x number and it’s fine is someone to be a little bit cautious of. It’s one thing to do something that used to be common without knowing advice has changed, it’s another to be completely dismissive because the risk isn’t so great that one of your own three didn’t automatically die.

Most of your concerns do sound, as others have put it, a bit pfb. Though Inthink her inability to read your dc is, all by itself, a good reason not to leave him with her for more than a few minutes. If you thought this of every adult who interacted with your dc it would, by itself, look like more pfb. But you accept that some other adults can read your dc well, so I don’t think that’s it. Given this is your mother, who raised you, I’m guessing there’s more behind it than that and the basis of your concern is also informed by how she was with you as a child? Not necessarily anything specific, but generally it would seem that you don’t really, fully trust her? If that’s the case, with the dismissive attitude towards safety issues you had just raised and the inability to read dc, I think even if you are pfb your lack of trust is well founded and you should let it guide you.

Echobelly · 11/04/2022 03:28

I think the abuse part really needed to be upfront - that makes it seem much less U! I do understand you keeping your distance and being concerned by certain things - TBH I don't think all of these things are issues but clearly given your relationship I can understand your unease and that the way she behaves could ring alarm bells for you and you're entitled to keep some distance between her and DS.

Ivyonafence · 11/04/2022 03:22

Some people are being really mean to OP.

OP, you're not comfortable with leaving baby alone with her, that's fine. You're the mother and it's where you are at. You don't need to justify your feelings to anyone,

The safe sleeping thing was dangerous. The fact that she did it immediately after you spoke to her about it makes it clear she doesn't care about following your instructions. That alone is a reason not to leave your baby with her.

You don't trust her. For good reasons, reading your update. It doesn't matter if other people trust their mothers- you don't trust yours. She hasn't earned your trust. That's the truth, and you need to live your own reality not what other people think or expect.

All this 'PFB' stuff is dismissive and mean. Babies are very precious. Don't leave them with people you don't trust.

Changeee1546789 · 11/04/2022 03:18

"relationship with mum is tricky, abuse was physical and emotional"

Come ON, OP. That is a drip feed of the highest order. People have taken the time to reply to you but you've left out the most major part of the backstory.

RantyAunty · 11/04/2022 03:08

Give your mum some credit. She managed to raise you without killing you! Grin

You're being over the top controlling.

She just thrilled with the new grandbaby. Not one thing in your post is harmful. Let her enjoy him.

Yes, I'm a grandmother who managed not to kill 2 DC and 3 DGC Grin