Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

GRAND NATIONAL

142 replies

PIPSUE · 10/04/2022 15:07

AIBU to think that a £400 fine for excessive use of a whip by a jockey is not enough. In this case, the jockey was the winner and received £560000. I think he should lose his place to the second finisher, and still pay the £400 fine, otherwise it isn't fair on the other jockeys in the face.

OP posts:
TheOriginalEmu · 11/04/2022 00:30

@TurningUpMyStereotype

I love how all these people who care SO DEEPLY about horse welfare all show up to object to it, only ever on national weekend. Where are you the rest of the year?? Oh yeah, you don’t care.

Cant speak for others but I’m campaigning, looking after our rescue animals and volunteering at a shelter all year round. Thinks like the grand national do tend to focus people’s minds and any awareness is good.

If you work all year round to deal with animal cruelty, I’m not talking about you.

I’m talking about the kind of people who choose to post on SM about how much they hate the GN, but then don’t mention a horse the rest of the year.

bluebaul · 11/04/2022 00:21

@Nat94

Race horses are extremely well looked after and are bred for running. When a jockey falls off they carry on racing without the rider so they are in no way distressed or being forced to run.

Always baffles me with how appallingly other animals are treated that people are actually concerned about horses jumping over a few fences.

This kind of ignorance is dangerous. Horses do move when in pain ffs.

Nat94 · 11/04/2022 00:08

Race horses are extremely well looked after and are bred for running. When a jockey falls off they carry on racing without the rider so they are in no way distressed or being forced to run.

Always baffles me with how appallingly other animals are treated that people are actually concerned about horses jumping over a few fences.

toastfiend · 10/04/2022 23:27

@Moanranger

I have owned horses most of my life & am not sentimental, BUT horse racing, both flat & National Hunt, makes me very uneasy. A couple of the defenders upthread have spouted nonsense: sure, horses in race training are treated well, but the vast majority have short professional careers, and only a tiny number get successfully retrained after they stop racing. The statistics on this come from the industry itself: many thousands of foals produced, but only a few hundred, low thousands get re-trained. It is a fact that most unsuccessful racing horses end up slaughtered. National hunt horses fare slightly better, as they can be used for hunting & point to point, and there are fewer of them produced. Horse-racing is not defensible.
I think you're spouting nonsense too.

Can I ask where you're getting the statistics on those who are successfully retrained from? There's no repository (that I'm aware of) that holds the data on all those that have been retrained/rehomed privately? Passports, yes, but that's relying on people updating them, which they often don't. There's ROR, sure, but I never did that with any of mine and it doesn't cover those who are happy hackers/hunters etc. How is it possible to know? The RSPCA themselves admit that they don't really have a clue as there is no current traceability system for racehorses leaving racing (which is wrong, there absolutely should be). My Dad's racehorses retired home to us. Barring the ones that went point-to-pointing, no one would ever be able to trace them to add them to any statistics.

Moanranger · 10/04/2022 23:05

I have owned horses most of my life & am not sentimental, BUT horse racing, both flat & National Hunt, makes me very uneasy. A couple of the defenders upthread have spouted nonsense: sure, horses in race training are treated well, but the vast majority have short professional careers, and only a tiny number get successfully retrained after they stop racing. The statistics on this come from the industry itself: many thousands of foals produced, but only a few hundred, low thousands get re-trained. It is a fact that most unsuccessful racing horses end up slaughtered. National hunt horses fare slightly better, as they can be used for hunting & point to point, and there are fewer of them produced. Horse-racing is not defensible.

Lineofconcepcion · 10/04/2022 22:23

I suppose if there were no racing, these horses wouldn't exist.

randomsabreuse · 10/04/2022 22:10

Horses tend to want to stay with their herd, so if the rider is unseated and the horse is still with the pack it will stay with them. There are generally people on calm horses dotted around the racecourse at strategic points for loose horses to hopefully join, but they don't always choose to. Not easy to catch any horse on foot and any corral would be potentially dangerous/another fence to jump...

A proper fracture of a long bone is not possible to heal in a horse, regardless of the money thrown at it.

Horses need to stand up and move or their guts stop working, if they're lying down for too long (in an operation under GA for instance) their own weight can damage nerves and stop legs working.

If weight isn't on all 4 feet the bones of the feet will come through the bottom of the hooves on the other 3 legs.

Horses (and similar prey animals like antelope) have long spindly fairly fragile legs so they can run fast. If the can't run fast they're dinner (hence why foals are basically all legs when they come out) so the ability to survive on 3 legs for a period of time is not something that has developed.

People have attempted to save horses with major leg injuries money no object, they have not succeeded as yet that I'm aware of - and ethically the outcomes in these cases are worse than a quick death on the race course!

riotlady · 10/04/2022 22:07

The whole thing is horrible :(

danadas · 10/04/2022 22:04

Love National Hunt racing but I am into most equestrian sports, however I do agree the fine is insufficient.

There are run off areas in the National fences to try and encourage loose horses not to follow the field for the poster that asked.

Partyatnumber10 · 10/04/2022 21:58

Something that always worries me about the grand National (we'll all racing probably)
Is what happens to the horses that keep on racing when their riders fall off.
It always looks really dangerous that they're careering along there with no guidance.
Are there systems in place for them to be collected and kept safe?

Sorry if that's a daft question but it bothers me hugely and I thought somebody on here might know.

abbey44 · 10/04/2022 21:52

Edit - I've just seen the update about the horse at the third Fence - I'll take that bit back then.

abbey44 · 10/04/2022 21:51

I watched the Grand National yesterday - which were the two horses that died? I can only find one - it wasn't the one behind the screens at Fence 3, it was the one who was pulled up at about Fence 12 which had sustained an untreatable pelvic injury and had to be put down.

I'm not defending racing - I'm not sure I can, in my heart - but I really feel it's wrong to say that the horses are put down for financial reasons only. I've had horses all my life, and (as others have said) an injury such as a leg break simply isn't treatable in 99% of cases. Keeping a horse on three legs while it heals is difficult, and leads to further problems in the other limbs and other complications. Read about a horse called Barbaro, a Kentucky Derby winner, who had hundreds of thousands of dollars in various surgeries when he broke his leg, and ended up with laminitis and other complications and had to be put down some months later anyway. If you really care about a horse's welfare, that certainly isn't the way you'd want to see one treated.

Theyulelog · 10/04/2022 21:50

@bluebaul Like I said in my experience all our horses have been loved and cared for.
I can only go on what I’ve experienced.
Ive seen some nasty things outside of the sport including in an equine college, livery yards. There are some cruel bastards out there and they are not supported.
I couldn’t own a horse and send
It in the grand national personally because of the risks…there are owners
And trainers who obviously will but those stable staff who care, ride and feed these animals everyday have a massive bond with them and only want them to be safe. Coming home in an empty horse box is not what anyone wants.
Ive re homes a few racehorses in my time. One was an ex racehorse who didn’t enjoy racing, we bred her and she was an amazing mother who thrived. She was then brought into light work and loved nothing more than going out hacking, she hated competing. Ive had others who love competing and jumping. They are all different but there is always a place in this world for them.
I’m not saying it’s totally cruelty free, I’m sure it happens but I’ve never met anyone in the racing industry that’s just shot horses for the sake of it etc. Never once….I have however met people that have done this outside the industry.

bluebaul · 10/04/2022 21:42

Every yard

bluebaul · 10/04/2022 21:41

As someone who has worked in the industry with a wealth of equine experience I can tell you those animals are loved and cared for by all the staff on the yard, like pets.

Unless you are on every year at every point in time you cannot tell us anything or the sort.

Theyulelog · 10/04/2022 21:37

As someone who has worked in the industry with a wealth of equine experience I can tell you those animals are loved and cared for by all the staff on the yard, like pets. They all have pet names, lots of fuss and attention, are attended to all day and even through the night.
However, they are athletes and not pets. They are bred for a job, a sport…as with all sport horses, not just racehorses.
All horses that have been injured, retired etc have been sold on to horse owners who want to retrain in another sphere or go on to be used in light work in a nice home. All horses are vetted and have proper passports.
Yes there will be a number of dodgey owners and trainers who have them put down, sent away for meat or what ever but I’ve
Certainly never met any and they are not supported!
Everyone is entitled to their opinion but that’s just my view as someone who has worked in the industry.
The grand national is a tough race, most horses don’t reach that level.
I much prefer flat racing for this reason. I love horses and don’t like to see injuries, and unfortunately when a horse breaks a bone in the leg or pelvis etc there is nothing else that can be done.
Have your view, fine but please don’t say things like the stable staff are barbaric because we love our animals.
The whip is light weight, and jockeys are trained to use it in a way where it hits in the right place, the whip never breaks the skin and is usually just a slap down the neck or fleshy hind quarters. It’s an important aid for keeping the horse straight so they don’t run into the rail or eachother. Yes it can be overused and every jockey will be punished for that. There are rules. Whips are used in most horse disciplines.

GucciBear · 10/04/2022 21:37

Another died died during treatment at an Equine hospital after falling and damaging his head at the third fence in the National. \The race claimed two hoses this year.

BlusteryLake · 10/04/2022 21:22

Would we all be cheering on a human race where 1 in 20 of the competitors die? That's the death rate for this year's Grand National. Oh, hang on, people are making pots of money out of it.....

LeggyLinda · 10/04/2022 21:14

@PIPSUE

I stand corrected. Like I said, I know little of the sport and horses in general. But it still doesn’t sit right with me. In my little brain, if you’re going to force an animal to risk their health for human enjoyment then extra effort should be made to protect them.

bluebaul · 10/04/2022 21:12

Oh and as for the 'little bit of knowledge' I would suggest you get yourself some - the whip is 100% used on the horse.

www.britishhorseracing.com/regulation/the-whip/

Scarybutnecassary · 10/04/2022 21:11

@EdgyNeonAnt

Well it's just one of a long list of reasons why this awful event shouldn't continue.
This…should be banned
bluebaul · 10/04/2022 21:09

A whip is not used to hit the horse but is waved to keep it in eyesight which encourages going forward as the horse thinks something is coming up behind. Honestly a little knowledge goes a long way

Why is 'excessive use' a thing then? If the whip is simply being waved about?

OnoNotagain · 10/04/2022 21:02

I'm a horse owner and lover and wouldn't watch the GN if you paid me. It's vile abuse and should be banned.

toconclude · 10/04/2022 20:54

@DentonsFringeArnottsWaistcoat

You think excessive use of the whip is unfair on the other jockeys?
A whip is not used to hit the horse but is waved to keep it in eyesight which encourages going forward as the horse thinks something is coming up behind. Honestly a little knowledge goes a long way
70isaLimitNotaTarget · 10/04/2022 18:31

When they were chatting to the race goers on Friday BBC1 news there was a woman trilling on about the great day out , the fun and the win:win.

2 horses paid with their lives to give this and other vacuous punters their Great Day Out .

My palm fucking itched I tell you Angry

Swipe left for the next trending thread