Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be mildly shocked at DF only insuring one twin on car?

216 replies

Partyrocks · 10/04/2022 14:19

DF* has 18yo twin girls.

The both passed the driving test within a week of each other. And grandparents have bought a Car for them to share.

As insurance is so expensive, DF and her DH and the grandparents made a decision to just insure one daughter. With the thinking that if anything happened to the uninsured one it'll all be fine as they'll be able to pretend that they're the insured one.

The girls are going to same University and taking the car.

The girls are fully aware and a literal coin was tossed to decide which one would be It.

AIBU to think this is not on?

  • [Post edited by MNHQ. OP had originally typed DD, when she meant to type DF (dear friend)]
OP posts:
viques · 10/04/2022 14:53

@BoredZelda

FFS totally illegal and invalidates the insurance for both of them!

The insurance for the insured twin won’t be invalidated.

It will if they try to claim for an accident caused by the uninsured twin.
FOJN · 10/04/2022 14:53

Even if neither has an accident and the fraud goes undetected it means one of the twins is not building up their "no claims".

countrygirl99 · 10/04/2022 14:53

@woodhill

Absolutely bonkers

Could you pay to insure the other twin on the policy yourself?

I Think DF is friend not father. Why would you insure a friends DC
Threetulips · 10/04/2022 14:52

I agree the insured driver would be fined for speeding or the uninsured one in an accident.

Besides it isn’t that much more as only one at a time can drive anyway

SoupDragon · 10/04/2022 14:52

They’d be millions in debt forever

They wouldn't.

viques · 10/04/2022 14:52

Do they get alternate year birthday presents and Christmas presents? Do they only get one meal when they go round to grandparents? What have the gp written into their wills?

The car insurance idea is both bonkers and illegal. One of them could end up dead or injured as others have said, or with points on their licence, or having to take speeding fines and speeding awareness courses for the other one. . And what if they injured or killed another person ?

Imtryingveryhard · 10/04/2022 14:51

@Blossomtoes

Jesus. Are people seriously this stupid?
I work in the insurance fraud industry and you will be amazed what people do to either save money, or get a payout. And how easy it is to trip them up and secure a fundamental dishonesty finding that will ruin their careers and financial standing for life. All for a few hundred/thousand £. It’s shameful.
AtomicBlondeRose · 10/04/2022 14:50

If one of them kills someone in an accident being uninisured is surely the least of their worries at that point?

Ahgoonyegirlye · 10/04/2022 14:49

The assumption is that they might have a little prang but if they had a serious accident it wouldn't hold up, would it? If the uninsured woman was driving then there would be serious consequences and it would all come out right away. There could be medical issues.
Not to mention - is the other twin happy to pretend to have caused a serious accident for her sister? To have maybe really hurt someone else, killed them? Lose her licence, take the points etc?
Mad idea.
If only one woman has insurance then she'll have to do the driving.

Partyrocks · 10/04/2022 14:48

Just spotted typo in OP!

DF (DEAR FRIEND) has 18yo twins.

Nothing to do with me, someone I sit with watching children perform a hobby.
Many apologies

OP posts:
Cascais · 10/04/2022 14:47

Who is DF?

NotTheOW · 10/04/2022 14:45

@Partyrocks

Unfortunately not really someone I'm close enough to to get involved and point out the pitfalls, just someone I sit in a group with while we watch the DC do a hobby twice a week.

She has said in the past when anecdotalling that "they're the same genetic person obviously".

I'm so confused. Are these not anything to do with you? Or is your dad paying for one of your daughter's insurance and not the other?
woodhill · 10/04/2022 14:44

Absolutely bonkers

Could you pay to insure the other twin on the policy yourself?

BoredZelda · 10/04/2022 14:43

FFS totally illegal and invalidates the insurance for both of them!

The insurance for the insured twin won’t be invalidated.

WabbitsAndWeasels · 10/04/2022 14:43

But identical twins are only identical at the point they become twins, by the time they're born DNA has already started to mutate so although they will share more DNA than other siblings they won't have identical DNA samples. They also don't have identical finger prints for example.

As PP have mentioned as well as being illegal and invalidating any insurance either holds its clearly mortally questionable too and could have very very serious repercussions.

impossible · 10/04/2022 14:42

Very very stupid. You need to put your foot down as one of your DDs will be driving without insurance. Your uninsured DD could find herself in any number of horrible scenarios - eg, picking up points which go on sister's licence, being pulled over for something minor and having to lie about identity or confess to driving without a licence - both crimes. And if she is involved in accident the outcome could be catastrophic

If I these were my DDs I would refuse to let them have the car unless both are insured. It is a poisoned chalice and grandparents should not be putting them in this position.

Mummyoflittledragon · 10/04/2022 14:41

Please pay the extra. If the uninsured twin accidentally kills someone, it could ruin their life. They’d be millions in debt forever and go to prison for a very long time.

Georgeskitchen · 10/04/2022 14:41

There are so many things wrong with this. I sincerely hope they come to their senses

Aquamarine1029 · 10/04/2022 14:40

This is unbelievable.

fairislecable · 10/04/2022 14:38

I have identical twin daughters and they were both insured to drive my car, they were hit head on by a huge lorry on the wrong side of the road.

They both needed hospital treatment and one of them had two nights in hospital.

I had to take the driving license to the police station to show validity.

Fortunately they were OK but I dread to think what the ramifications would have been if we had attempted to fiddle the insurance.

finebutfedup · 10/04/2022 14:37

I think seeing as she has told you about it, and seeing how dreadful it could be, saying something along the lines of:

“I’ve been thinking about the car insurance issue we discussed last week. If the uninsured twin causes an accident, would the insured one take criminal record, fine and possibly prison sentence on her sister’s behalf? The alternative would be owning up, where the guilty twin is convicted not only of the offence but also driving uninsured”.

It really could be ruinous, they could both be banned at the very least.

BurnDownTheDiscoHangTheDJ · 10/04/2022 14:36

I went to school with a pair of identical twins. They both did things as the other twin to work to everyone’s advantage including one sitting the others driving test and one sitting the others A Level Biology exam. Shocking, but they got away with it and are now both late 30s with no consequences having come back to bite them that I know of.

Thepaintedgarden · 10/04/2022 14:35

It's also not double (or anywhere near it) to insure 2 new drivers on the same car. We have two drivers in their first year and to add the second was a lot less.

Blossomtoes · 10/04/2022 14:31

Jesus. Are people seriously this stupid?

Partyrocks · 10/04/2022 14:30

Unfortunately not really someone I'm close enough to to get involved and point out the pitfalls, just someone I sit in a group with while we watch the DC do a hobby twice a week.

She has said in the past when anecdotalling that "they're the same genetic person obviously".

OP posts: