Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be mildly shocked at DF only insuring one twin on car?

216 replies

Partyrocks · 10/04/2022 14:19

DF* has 18yo twin girls.

The both passed the driving test within a week of each other. And grandparents have bought a Car for them to share.

As insurance is so expensive, DF and her DH and the grandparents made a decision to just insure one daughter. With the thinking that if anything happened to the uninsured one it'll all be fine as they'll be able to pretend that they're the insured one.

The girls are going to same University and taking the car.

The girls are fully aware and a literal coin was tossed to decide which one would be It.

AIBU to think this is not on?

  • [Post edited by MNHQ. OP had originally typed DD, when she meant to type DF (dear friend)]
OP posts:
HaveringWavering · 11/04/2022 18:44

LICENCE LICENCE LICENCE.

This is not America.

YDBear · 11/04/2022 18:40

Just done a search on confused. com and it seems to be the same to insure two 18-year-olds as it is to insure one.

BeforeGodAndAllTheFish · 11/04/2022 18:36

@YDBear

So the girls swap driving licenses so that the insured girl's license is always with the one driving the car? Otherwise, if the uninsured one gets stopped by the police and they see her real license then she will be facing a 'driving while uninsured' charge before you can say 'buy more insurance'. Of course, being in an accident would be a catastropheeverything would come outbut even a casual police stop for any reason at all could land the uninsured girl in a world of trouble. I appreciate that insuring an 18-year old is expensive, but this just seems stupid. the consequences of getting caught totally outweigh the benefits.
You dont need to carry your license whilst driving in the UK. If you get stopped, you've got 2 weeks ri present your license.

Even if you give a fake name, theyll take the details of your car and everything so you cant just disappear and have no consequences.

So the uninsured twin would give her sister's name and then get her sister to present herself with her license and take any consequences.

It's just an awful thing to do.

Chely · 11/04/2022 18:34

Shockingly bad idea, cheap arses!!

timeFlyers · 11/04/2022 18:34

That means the one twin would have to accept any and all consequences for the other twin's driving.

This is all kinds of wrong

HaveringWavering · 11/04/2022 18:34

Sounds like the plot of a shit ITV crime drama. Shock twist ending- it was twins!

skodadoda · 11/04/2022 18:34

@BoredZelda

FFS totally illegal and invalidates the insurance for both of them!

The insurance for the insured twin won’t be invalidated.

Not necessarily true. They would be falsely claiming that one person is driving the car. It’s failure to disclose a material fact.
YDBear · 11/04/2022 18:30

So the girls swap driving licenses so that the insured girl's license is always with the one driving the car? Otherwise, if the uninsured one gets stopped by the police and they see her real license then she will be facing a 'driving while uninsured' charge before you can say 'buy more insurance'. Of course, being in an accident would be a catastropheeverything would come outbut even a casual police stop for any reason at all could land the uninsured girl in a world of trouble. I appreciate that insuring an 18-year old is expensive, but this just seems stupid. the consequences of getting caught totally outweigh the benefits.

nannykatherine · 11/04/2022 18:26

Who are the 5% here who think this is ok ???

BeforeGodAndAllTheFish · 11/04/2022 18:26

@Weareallvirgins

Dont report it to dvla and 101 has nothing to do with driving. Tell your girls they can't take the car until both are insured
I doubt two 18 year olds are going to listen to stranger who tracks them down and tells them not to drive their car.

If it illegal activity isnt for the police to deal with then it also isnt for the OP to deal with. Why would she track down the children of a woman she sometimes sits in a groups to tell them not to drive?

Weareallvirgins · 11/04/2022 18:13

Dont report it to dvla and 101 has nothing to do with driving. Tell your girls they can't take the car until both are insured

Weareallvirgins · 11/04/2022 18:11

Dont be silly

dropoutdoreen · 11/04/2022 18:02

How much is the insurance ffs? Why doesn't the parent insure in their name with kids as named driver

Or Cant the twins get a bloody job and save up between them for the orher half of insurance

JaycDeeC · 11/04/2022 18:01

I am aware of an incident where the police caught siblings (not twins) for fraud spewing because they were aware that the one who it was claimed was driving, wasn’t even in the country (the other already had several points and was trying to avoid sanctions).

ilovechocolate07 · 11/04/2022 17:58

Is it something you can report? At least to the DVLA or 101, see what they say?

diddl · 11/04/2022 12:20

@Fulmine

Is this friend known for stupidity, OP?
Hopefully one of the twin's isn't!

If it won't cost that much extra to add another on, why don't the twins & their parents look into funding that?

Fulmine · 11/04/2022 12:01

Is this friend known for stupidity, OP?

TheCatterall · 11/04/2022 11:16

So one twin will get all the issues with no insurance protection and also all the issues of increased insurance costs due to accidents that either twin has.

If stopped the police will expect ID on the spot. That’s not going to work.

CrimsonPermanentAssurance · 11/04/2022 11:08

You're very unlikely to end up liable for millions for killing someone in the UK, but a student who's giving a lift to her mates and has a crash which leaves one of her passengers with life changing injuries (brain damage or quadriplegia) can easily be liable for ten million pounds or more.

The twin's insurance company would pay the passenger, but could in theory sue the uninsured driver for the money they paid out and put them into bankruptcy. I'm not sure whether the average student would have enough assets to be worth any form of litigation though.

Octomore · 11/04/2022 10:57

Not everyone lives in England.

But if you are sitting A levels then you 're not sitting Scottish highers, are you? A levels are part of the English (also Welsh etc.) system)

Fulmine · 11/04/2022 09:59

@ClareBlue

They can if not insured. Payout for killing someone is usually 1 million plus if they have family. This is against you. Your insurance pay for you. No insurance it is all on you, that's what insurance is.
Being insured or not makes no difference. Unfortunately in the UK it is cheaper to kill someone than to injure them. Damages are basically bereavement loss currently limited to around £15,000, plus damages for loss of dependency IF others were dependent on them. If you kill, say, a young single adult, there will be no dependency damages.

If someone does have dependents, then damages for their death if they are part of a couple with no children will be 66% of the joint family income, less the income of the surviving partner,. For a couple with dependent children, damages for the death of one of them will be 75% of the joint family income, less the income of the surviving partner. Therefore again, if you cause the death of a SAHP with no income, then your damages will be limited to bereavement damages.

SoupDragon · 11/04/2022 07:33

(The simplest explanation is that it was a re-sit in the following exam session though)

SoupDragon · 11/04/2022 07:32

They could have been in Scotland

Does Scotland call them A Levels?

Changechangychange · 10/04/2022 23:40

@cardibach Maybe one was resitting a module that the other had already passed?

Back when A levels were modular, if you did badly in your AS paper you could retake it the following Christmas. Obviously twin who did well wouldn’t have needed to retake, so would be free to turn up in twin 2’s place.

BeforeGodAndAllTheFish · 10/04/2022 23:28

[quote BeforeGodAndAllTheFish]@Octomore

They could have been in Scotland. I dont know about england, but in Scotland (if they're in their thirties) then they would have sat highers and advanced highers in 5th and 6th year.

You could take 5 highers in 5th year and then another 5 higher in 6th year, or 5 advance highers or a mix of advanced highers and highers. I did 5 highers in 5th year and 3 advanced highers plus 2 highers in 6th year.

If one twin did biology higher in 5th year and the other took biology higher in 6th year, then the original twin could sit their exam for them.[/quote]
@cardibach

I already gave an example of how the exam thing would work. Not everyone lives in England.