Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be mildly shocked at DF only insuring one twin on car?

216 replies

Partyrocks · 10/04/2022 14:19

DF* has 18yo twin girls.

The both passed the driving test within a week of each other. And grandparents have bought a Car for them to share.

As insurance is so expensive, DF and her DH and the grandparents made a decision to just insure one daughter. With the thinking that if anything happened to the uninsured one it'll all be fine as they'll be able to pretend that they're the insured one.

The girls are going to same University and taking the car.

The girls are fully aware and a literal coin was tossed to decide which one would be It.

AIBU to think this is not on?

  • [Post edited by MNHQ. OP had originally typed DD, when she meant to type DF (dear friend)]
OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
AtomicBlondeRose · 12/04/2022 20:40

It’s a really really terrible idea, sure. But not the absolute over-dramatic “they’ll have to SWAP IDENTITIES!!!!” idea that it’s being made out as here. It’s just a common-or-garden fraudulent shit idea, not the plot of some Harlen Coben Netflix series.

Octomore · 12/04/2022 18:55

And also gets charged with TWOCing the car.

Unless the insured twin says they gave permission, in which case the insured twin has also committed an offence.

So you're putting both twins at risk of criminal records / fines etc. just to save a few hundred quid.

I don't think posters are being ridiculous at all in pointing out what a massively bad idea it is.

AtomicBlondeRose · 12/04/2022 18:02

Ok, so at that point they’re liable for, at the most, driving uninsured which is “an unlimited fine” or losing your licence. Which, isn’t all that bad tbh. Not worth having to switch your whole life over for!

Octomore · 12/04/2022 17:19

They would be in deep shit and at that point driving without insurance would really be the smallest part of the problem and not really a big deal to own up compared to the massive offence of killing someone!

Killing someone in a car isn't always an offence. E.g. if someone runs out in front of you without warning, and without you having time to stop, when you are travelling at a safe speed for the road - that's not, prima facie, an offence.

Unless you're driving uninsured that is.....

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 12/04/2022 17:14

That’s one of the stupidest things I’ve ever heard!

AtomicBlondeRose · 12/04/2022 17:11

There’s some massive over-dramatic stuff here. I mean, it’s illegal and not great but…if one twin caused an accident and killed someone while driving on her sister’s insurance, she wouldn’t have to pretend to be the other twin ffs 😂😂

They would be in deep shit and at that point driving without insurance would really be the smallest part of the problem and not really a big deal to own up compared to the massive offence of killing someone! For a start, as soon as the police looked at the driving licence they would know who they were dealing with, or any of the cards or ID on their person. They don’t just blindly accept you are who you say you are, because people lie to the police all the fucking time!

TDCtomorrow · 12/04/2022 07:41

@SoupDragon

They’d be millions in debt forever

They wouldn't.

Just about to say the same. So dramatic
mogsrus · 12/04/2022 06:14

Is this for real? Fraud at the highest level. & utter stupidity on both parts. Driving licences won’t match for a start, it won’t take the system 5mins to uncover the truth. Absolutely astounding thinking

LoisLane66 · 12/04/2022 06:09

Unbelievable, that any adult thinks it's ok to purposely commit a crime, as that is what it is... and for the grandparents to collude with the parents...😳😲🤐

Mamanyt · 11/04/2022 23:44

It's illegal, and in the US would carry a possible prison sentence. Not necessarily what you want to be teaching your children!

NippySweetie16 · 11/04/2022 22:34

Insurance company would take precisely 10 seconds to say insurance is invalid. They are not stupid and have come across every scam - fraud - known to man. DF is bonkers.

Cj19877 · 11/04/2022 22:32

If a policy is being used fraudulently and this is discovered, it absolutely can be invalidated.

ThistleTits · 11/04/2022 22:22

@Partyrocks

Unfortunately not really someone I'm close enough to to get involved and point out the pitfalls, just someone I sit in a group with while we watch the DC do a hobby twice a week.

She has said in the past when anecdotalling that "they're the same genetic person obviously".

What would it be like if after and accident, one of them was charged with a driving offence and sent to prison but it was the other who was driving? Someone's life destroyed because of a crime her sister committed.
HaveringWavering · 11/04/2022 22:16

@BeforeGodAndAllTheFish

You know that people all over the world use this forum, yes?
It’s obvious that the people concerned are in the U.K.
Myotherusernamesafunnyone · 11/04/2022 20:54

Also sarkymarky is right about the criminal offence of an owner permitting the use of a vehicle without insurance
Rook and Imtryingveryhard are mistaken, although perhaps confusion has arisen because they are talking about the validity of the insurance and any civil claims arising and not the criminal offence.

Myotherusernamesafunnyone · 11/04/2022 20:32

Twins don't have the same fingerprints
If they were in a crash whereby the police attended this could create an awful mess, in addition to the medical implications already pointed out

lemonsorbetinthesun · 11/04/2022 20:14

@Changechangychange

It’s because in theory the novice isn’t driving the car 100% of the time.

Also the cost bracket always shocks me! Literally a £1 or 2 and it changes the premium.

Changechangychange · 11/04/2022 20:00

In this situation you can insure other people who have been driving much longer to bring down the cost.

Yep - I added my mum to my car insurance in my late 20s, and it halved my premiums. Seemed weird to me, but I was completely upfront about who lived where, where the car was being kept, and how often she was driving it, so just assumed it was a quirk of their algorithm.

lemonsorbetinthesun · 11/04/2022 19:47

My DH worked in insurance for a short time. He says that the cost is based on risk and how much time the person is likely to drive.
In this situation you can insure other people who have been driving much longer to bring down the cost.
Also moving cost of cover from £6000 to £5999 moves it into a different bracket.

Lovely13 · 11/04/2022 19:06

Driving without insurance is shockingly common. Some seem to think it’s optional. 😳

caringcarer · 11/04/2022 18:59

Outrageous behaviour. One child will have NCD and the other not.

BeforeGodAndAllTheFish · 11/04/2022 18:54

You know that people all over the world use this forum, yes?

HaveringWavering · 11/04/2022 18:50

But I wasn’t specifically singling you out @BeforeGodAndAllTheFish. The use of “license” as a noun (or worse, calling it a “driver’s license”) is a plague in the U.K. these days.

HaveringWavering · 11/04/2022 18:47

Why so your autocorrect set to US English?

BeforeGodAndAllTheFish · 11/04/2022 18:45

@HaveringWavering

LICENCE LICENCE LICENCE.

This is not America.

Yes. But autocorrect. And I'm not waiting time correcting autocorrect for a silly forum post.
Swipe left for the next trending thread