Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Driver wanting me to give way

92 replies

Bootwall · 10/04/2022 07:20

If cars are parked on your left and an oncoming car is, well, coming, it's up to you to give way/move out of the way, right?

A driver bombed it around a corner, vehicles parked on his left (my right) we came to be about 10 meters apart, he's now on my side of the road, so we both stopped. He gestured for me to reverse back, but there was only a very small space I would have needed to parallel park on my right, further around the corner, into an awkward space - he had lots more room to reverse into.

I refused and indicated for him to reverse. He then inched forward and forward and forward, looking furious, until we were bumper to bumper. I turned my ignition off.

Luckily a neighbour (I was on my street) came out and came over to my car, asking if I was okay - at this point the other car then decided to reverse (badly) and I still had to mount the pavement to get by.

The cars were on his side- his problem to get out of the way, or WIBU?

Often I do give way if it's obviously easier for me to do so, been driving 20 years and never had an issue like this before! Second guessing myself because he was seemed so adamant I needed to move!

OP posts:
Hrpuffnstuff1 · 10/04/2022 09:22

Listen the idea is to generally give way, however, this is dependent on other factors. I'll often just let the other through if it is possible.
I've never ever gotten into a standoff with another driver, it's utterly pointless, there is no right or wrong just perception over a set of circumstances.

I think you both need to chill out. Both of you are shit drivers.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 10/04/2022 09:22

I really don't see how anybody can expect their perpetual-potential priorities to trump everybody else's needs in using the road.

That is, you have priority when arriving at a pinch point at the same time and the parked cars are on their side, but that doesn't mean that somebody who arrived there before you isn't allowed to pass the parked cars, just in case a wally like you gets there half a minute later.

Similarly, with roundabouts, you give way to traffic on the right that is already there or approaching when you enter the roundabout - it doesn't mean that somebody suddenly turning up out of nowhere, 10 seconds later, from your right is justified in speeding on to the roundabout that you're already on and hooting at you for supposedly not having given way to them before they were actually there.

Tothepoint99 · 10/04/2022 09:16

Good on you for standing your ground and switching off your engine! I might try that in future!

EvilPea · 10/04/2022 09:15

There’s a road like this near dcs school. I can’t tell you how often you stop to give way but the car behind sails past. It really enrages me! Especially if there’s cars behind them, they follow thinking I’m a shit Parker.

I never mount the kerb though. It’s for pedestrians not me.

My favourite incident was my old street, car wouldnt give way to a bus, bus driver refused to reverse (he could have stopped easily in a gap prior to needing to reverse). We had a long running thing with bus drivers driving at you and aggressively.

Car owner got out, sat in his bonnet. Residents were making him tea, police were called. It was a glorious stand off. The bus was more courteous after thst

DownNative · 10/04/2022 09:12

@Nennypops

I once had a similar situation at a road junction, where the driver of a van turned in without looking as I was coming out and there wasn't room for both of us. All he had to do was go back a short way or move over and we could both go on our way, but he made it very obvious that he wasn't going to.

So I decided that if he thought I was a feeble little woman, then that's what I would be, and I made a big show of reversing incredibly slowly and hesitantly, occasionally going forward a bit as if I needed to adjust the steering. I reached a space I could have reversed into but decided that that was obviously going to be too difficult for poor little me, and carried on. White van man could see I was talking to DS and laughing and he was going ever redder in the face. When I eventually relented, just before I let him pass I called out of the window "Just think, you could have been a mile down the road if you'd only let me out" and I thought he might have apoplexy. It was deeply satisfying.

Van driver was turning IN to your junction - meaning it was on main road.

You were coming OUT of a junction - meaning you were behind the Give Way markings and sign (if there).

Van driver has right of way in that situation. You had an obligation to reverse backwards for safety reasons and in a timely manner.

WonderingWanda · 10/04/2022 09:10

I've had this before op. Lots of narrow roads near me and for the most part people are courteous and give way to one another. Every now and again I encounter an aggressive man who usually accelerates towards me hoping to bully me out of the way. I smile sweetly, engage my handbreak and laugh at them. Always more than happy to reverse when it's a polite driver and we've both pulled out at the same time ir it's not my right of way. Just refuse to those bell ends who see you're already committed and then slam their foot on the accelerator so they shoot forward and then wildly gesticulate that they are further along than you as some sort of justification for their twatty behaviour....despite the fact that they looked you in the eye as they did it so clearly knew you were already there!! These people can also be found in both lanes of any merge in turn situation!

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 10/04/2022 09:06

It's definitely not always as black and white as "the obstruction is on your side so you need to stop" - on most roads around here, the obstructions are on both sides half the time Grin

In your case, if he was already overtaking the parked cars and going around the corner he wouldn't have seen you until it was too late. It sounds like he couldn't see anyone coming, started his manoeuvre and then saw you.

In that scenario tbh would have mounted the pavement (if safe) and allowed him past. I'm sure I'll get leapt on for that being illegal - but in the real world, it happens all the time on roads where it's far too tight for two cars to pass otherwise.

5foot5 · 10/04/2022 09:02

@Theunamedcat

I've had to do this before she wanted me to reverse all the way down the road I wanted her to reverse a car and a bit length I won but she was a dinner lady at my sons school so it was a bit awkward
Once when picking DD up from school after club I was in a situation in school grounds where the obstruction was on my side but there was nothing coming the other way. I started to go carefully through and was almost at the end when a car came from the other way and was clearly NOT going to give way and seemed insistent that I revered.

I did so but with a bad grace, very obviously shrugging and shaking my head in disbelief. Thing was the sun was shining in such a way that I couldn't clearly see the other driver, they were just a shape. When they finally drove past me I turned to give them another outraged eye roll only to discover it was the head mistress!

WlNDMlLL · 10/04/2022 08:58

If people drove with courtesy then most incidents would not even happen.

This. MN is far too black and white about driving issues. Sometimes people make mistakes or misjudge or pull out having been stuck somewhere for ages. Use give and take and life is much more pleasant.

Howabsolutelyfanfuckingtastic · 10/04/2022 08:56

Some drivers are just inconsiderate. I've experienced this recently with a crazy woman who drives down my road and doesn't like me reversing into my own driveway 🤷🏼‍♀️ she has been abusive and threatening to me for no reason a few times now, i even started to doubt myself. She's clearly very unstable because it's not normal behaviour at all! OP i think you were in the right as you describe it.

Molecule · 10/04/2022 08:54

When I did a speed awareness course we were told there is no such thing as a “right of way” in such circumstances (as of course we had all said there was) and it’s basically a give and take situation. So if you’re half way along a row of parked cars on your left, the car coming in the opposite direction does not have priority. As I live in a hilly, bendy village with long lines of parked cars this is a nugget of information I have always retained.

gamerchick · 10/04/2022 08:53

I had something similar once. Cars parked to the right of me and only enough room on the road for one car. Gets a bloke coming towards me who then had to half park in a little gap because I just stopped and waited. Screaming at me as I passed. I wonder if he realised it was a one way system and he was going the wrong way.

Some men like to intimidate women.

WrongWayApricot · 10/04/2022 08:47

Yep. I got verbally abused by a man the other day for not getting stuck in a yellow box junction, then later he undertook me🤷‍♀️

Inklingpot · 10/04/2022 08:46

There’s definitely a case for not being a dick, even if you do have right of way.

We had a situation last year where a line of parked cars on our side extended for several hundred metres around a bend so we had to move forward. The problem with that bit of road is well-known and obvious to anyone who sees it so the majority of people don’t insist on right of way and just do their best to pass.

Yet we were just about to clear the parked cars when two women in a 4x4 came up from the opposite direction and decided they were going to insist on their right of way, stopped in the middle of the road to block it and tried to force us to reverse the whole way even though they only needed to reverse about 5m and move over to make room.

I did the same as the OP, switched the engine off and sat there waiting, by which time traffic had built up behind them and other motorists got out to tell them to stop being such twats and move. They eventually did but shouted abuse at us as we drove off.

Some people just engage cunt mode as soon as they get behind the wheel.

gettingolderandgrumpy · 10/04/2022 08:44

Recently was driving on a roundabout and a man ( on my left ) didn’t give way to me I was on his right , I drove after looking right and this guy nearly drove into me . I broke hard he shouted it’s a roundabout I said I know then drove off shaken up . I was like wtf I was right wasn’t I he should of given way? He was so determined older man shaking his head at me like I don’t know how to drive on a roundabout but he was on my left and should give way to his right . Like you op been driving years go on that roundabout all the time and you second guess yourself . Some men do not like woman driving yes some of us are shit and if I had done something wrong I’d hold my hands up but always seems to be a man that’s aggressive.

IamtheDevilsAvocado · 10/04/2022 08:29

@Afolnerd

Good for you for standing your ground. There is traffic calming chicanes outside our house. With clear signs about who has the right of way. There is a stand off about once a week. One lasted about 15 minutes, the woman with the right of way got out and sat on the bonnet of her car!
Yup! She rocks!

I think many many women drivers experience men who demand right of way when they don't have it!

Pal has a dash cam... She just points to it when faced with one of these idiots.....surprisingly, they change their minds when they see that.... Wot a surprise... Grin

Whooshaagh · 10/04/2022 08:18

I feel ya OP.
A white van man tried to get me to reverse when he had much more room and I was almost through the gap if he hadn't come flying down the road.
I'd just finished work at 2pm and figured he would still be working and needed to move sooner than i did.
I shook my head at him and he eventually reversed.
I used to drive in a really busy area and I don't put up with male driver bullying.

LittleRedRidingHood187 · 10/04/2022 08:08

What's meant to happen; person with obstacle on their side gives way

What actually happens; person who gets there first comes through

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 10/04/2022 08:07

He sounds like an absolute arrogant idiot, and completely wrong in this case; but I don't think it's always as cut and dried as that - sometimes it requires compromise.

Sometimes, you do have to pull on to the other side to overtake the line of parked cars and you can't legislate for the driver who will roar up from nowhere - technically their right of way - and get angry at you, as though they seem to think that, having encountered a line of parked cars, you're expected to stop there forever and never venture on to the other side to make your way forward.

It also depends on other circumstances, such as how far each of you would have to reverse or whether one of you is in a massive vehicle that's much more hassle to reverse and the other is just in a car.

One thing I think is often the case, though, is that it's the classic cowardly bully scenario: sometimes, people will tough it out and tell you that you must be the one to reverse because they're actually not very confident at reversing themselves, especially the ones who deliberately buy the most massive car they can find but don't have the basic driving skills to deal with it - like they believe that having the bigger car automatically means that everybody else has to give way to them at all times.

I've encountered people like this when it comes to parking: they're such poor drivers, that they will angrily come over and blame you if you haven't left them five car lengths in which to manoeuvre.

Some of them realise that they're bad drivers, but others - of the driving branch of the 'none so stupid as those who don't know they're stupid' school - genuinely believe that something simple that they can't do is categorically too difficult for anybody to do - even if they're standing there mouthing off and clearly expecting you to do it!

Nennypops · 10/04/2022 08:02

I once had a similar situation at a road junction, where the driver of a van turned in without looking as I was coming out and there wasn't room for both of us. All he had to do was go back a short way or move over and we could both go on our way, but he made it very obvious that he wasn't going to.

So I decided that if he thought I was a feeble little woman, then that's what I would be, and I made a big show of reversing incredibly slowly and hesitantly, occasionally going forward a bit as if I needed to adjust the steering. I reached a space I could have reversed into but decided that that was obviously going to be too difficult for poor little me, and carried on. White van man could see I was talking to DS and laughing and he was going ever redder in the face. When I eventually relented, just before I let him pass I called out of the window "Just think, you could have been a mile down the road if you'd only let me out" and I thought he might have apoplexy. It was deeply satisfying.

Bootwall · 10/04/2022 08:01

@Dunkling

QuitMoaning explains it perfectly.

If the car with the obstruction sees nothing coming they are supposed to proceed with caution. But once in the manoeuvre, they have priority, so you need to wait for them to clear your side.

If this is a known passing problem area you are familiar with, you should be entering your side with caution too.

I 100% take on board it's not black & white and both drivers have a responsibility to read the road - my issue isn't so much that there was a problem - it happens - but that the 'solving' was far easier for him to reverse 5 meters, into 'his' side of the road, rather than me reversing 20 meters or so into an awkward space not on 'my side'.

Also, if he hadn't been going so fast he would have seen me approaching and simply held back - but I do understand it can be a grey area of wrong/right!

OP posts:
Afolnerd · 10/04/2022 07:55

Good for you for standing your ground. There is traffic calming chicanes outside our house. With clear signs about who has the right of way. There is a stand off about once a week.
One lasted about 15 minutes, the woman with the right of way got out and sat on the bonnet of her car!

Dunkling · 10/04/2022 07:54

QuitMoaning explains it perfectly.

If the car with the obstruction sees nothing coming they are supposed to proceed with caution. But once in the manoeuvre, they have priority, so you need to wait for them to clear your side.

If this is a known passing problem area you are familiar with, you should be entering your side with caution too.

HowlongWillThisTakeNow · 10/04/2022 07:50

It sort of depends, if the oncoming driver has committed to the overtake by passing parked cars, the they do have the right of way, even though they are driving on “your” side of the road.

If you are “your” side of the road with park cars on your right, you have right of way and the oncoming driver should wait

www.passmefast.co.uk/resources/driving-advice/passing-parked-cars

Lunar27 · 10/04/2022 07:49

Maybe needs a diagram?! grin

I understand exactly what you're saying and he was definitely in the wrong, not only for whizzing round the bend but for not giving way.

What sounds more amazing is that there was a space to your right but that he didn't pull into it. Idiot.

For info though, I think the only time you'd pull into that space on your right is if a larger or emergency vehicle had pulled round the corner. In this case, giving way like you did, would be the logical and preferable outcome.