Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Religious preachers shouldn't be shouting and screeching in the street..

187 replies

Theblacksheepforever · 09/04/2022 22:02

I was out with my children today walking down the high street with my two children, reception age DS is autistic and my other DC is a little baby.

A religious preacher with fliers who we hadn't noticed - started shouting at the top of her voice about God and jusgement day as we walked past her. It scared DS stiff and an hour long meltdown ensued. I was annoyed.

My child aside, does anybody else think this shouldn't be allowed? It's antisocial and technicallg illegal given that shouting and screaming in the street is contrary to section 5 of the public order act, so why is this allowed?

AIBU?

OP posts:
Moppincraxy · 09/04/2022 23:50

The verse that @Toomanyradishes quoted in context is:

Jesus stepped into a boat, crossed over and came to his own town.2Some men brought to him a paralyzed man,lying on a mat. When Jesus saw their faith,he said to the man,“Take heart,son; your sins are forgiven.”

3At this, some of the teachers of the law said to themselves, “This fellow is blaspheming!”

4Knowing their thoughts,Jesus said,“Why do you entertain evil thoughts in your hearts?5Which is easier: to say, ‘Your sins are forgiven,’ or to say, ‘Get up and walk’?6But I want you to know that the Son of Manhas authority on earth to forgive sins.”So he said to the paralyzed man,“Get up, take your mat and go home.”7Then the man got up and went home.8When the crowd saw this, they were filled with awe; and they praised God,who had given such authority to man.

So first of all he told the paralysed man that his sons were forgiven. He was called a blasphemer as only God can forgive sins. So as a visible sign of his power to forgive sins he also healed the man that people would be able to see that he had the authority to do this.

There is no relationship between the sin and the disability. But in order for the people to believe the invisible miracle of forgiving sins he performed the visible miracle of healing the paralysed man.

chaosrabbitland · 09/04/2022 23:47

i do agree with you a bit op , im in a large city in bucks , the small town on the other side of it where my mum lives sometimes has one of these preachers complete with megaphone no less and today when i went up to the city for an easter lego set there was one there , yelling away , its the general racket i object to , shouting on and on , when i came back out 30 mins later he was still in full bore , i wonder how they dont lose their voices , and yes i can apreciate how a child might find it frightening

MythicalBiologicalFennel · 09/04/2022 23:41

He also said when healing the disabled that he had the ability to remove the sin from them e.g. they are disabled because they are sinners

Quote please? TIA

AKASammyScrounge · 09/04/2022 23:41

The street preachers are perfectly entitled to havr their say. Holding them responsible for your son's meltdown is ridiculous and no reason to silence the preachers.

Toomanyradishes · 09/04/2022 23:39

@Madhairday

I think YABU just because the idea of a country without free speech is a scary one. I'm a Christian and find these kind of street shouters really frustrating and cringy, but I think we should all have the right to say what we wish, it would be a slippery slope if everyone was cancelled for everything.

He also said when healing the disabled that he had the ability to remove the sin from them e.g. they are disabled because they are sinners

No he really didn't. He said the opposite in fact when his disciples asked him if a blind man was blind because of his sin - he said no. When he healed people he looked at the whole person, not just their disability -- he saw people who needed forgiveness and setting free from stuff in their lives. He did not relate that sin to their disabilities.

Matthew 9:6 But that ye may know that the Son of man hath power on earth to forgive sins, (then saith he to the sick of the palsy,) Arise, take up thy bed, and go unto thine house.

He healed the disabled man by forgiving his sins

Dairymilk50 · 09/04/2022 23:37

@Theblacksheepforever

And I did walk away with my child.. obviously.

Removing the trigger doesn't automatically stop the meltdown does it.

There's lots of triggers and that is my point. Lots of people shout and behave disorderly. Or is it only Church preachers now?

I am not arguing with you and OP. She is being OTT. Wanting police to have a word... then falsely implying that church preachers are shouting hate crime FFS and breaking a law that doesn't exist. Come on!

The police have better things to do to be Frank.. its not emergency.

Madhairday · 09/04/2022 23:34

I think YABU just because the idea of a country without free speech is a scary one. I'm a Christian and find these kind of street shouters really frustrating and cringy, but I think we should all have the right to say what we wish, it would be a slippery slope if everyone was cancelled for everything.

He also said when healing the disabled that he had the ability to remove the sin from them e.g. they are disabled because they are sinners

No he really didn't. He said the opposite in fact when his disciples asked him if a blind man was blind because of his sin - he said no. When he healed people he looked at the whole person, not just their disability -- he saw people who needed forgiveness and setting free from stuff in their lives. He did not relate that sin to their disabilities.

Theblacksheepforever · 09/04/2022 23:22

I can appreciate the angle about free speech and i agree free speech is important, it's just a shame it's used to promote religion in such an aggressive way.

I have nothing against any religion, aside thinking these particular people are far too extreme to be shouting what they do in the street.

OP posts:
ErrolTheDragon · 09/04/2022 23:19

Freedom of speech is perfectly possible without shouting in the streets at strangers and terrifying little children.Hmm

I don't think street preachers intend to cause harassment alarm or distress, they intend to save your soul.

Seems to me that this sort of preacher very much intends to alarm people, even if (in their mind) it's for their own ultimate good.

It's disgraceful behaviour, unlikely to have its intended effect and I rather think it's entirely self-serving, done because it makes the preacher feel good about themselves rather than really caring about other people.

AHungryCaterpillar · 09/04/2022 23:13

There’s people in my part of London that shout and preach in the street, I do find it annoying and there was ones near us that were being racially abusive (I didn’t witness it personally but was all over the local FB group) my daughter has autism and luckily isn’t bothered by them we just ignore them. It’s so often where I am it’s almost unusual not to see them!

Toomanyradishes · 09/04/2022 23:12

*StScholastica

Cottoneyejoeswifestampon

toomany I don't believe Jesus yelled at and harassed people like this people do, I really don't. He was love incarnate, gentle, yes delivered a hard message at times but hung out with the down and puts and rejected in society. When I think of street preachers here in northern Ireland, telling gays and 'adulterers' and they're wicked and going to burn in hell, that's not what Jesus would've done

Didn't he have a bit of a hissy fit in a temple and overturn stalls and tables?*

He also said when healing the disabled that he had the ability to remove the sin from them e.g. they are disabled because they are sinners

Mochudubh · 09/04/2022 23:07

We have an Ian Paisley type with mic and amp in our town centre. It's irritating and sometimes I wish the council would just have a blanket ban on it, or restrict it to a Speaker's Corner type place where you could ignore it.

However, I also believe in freedom of speech so while it's a PIA to be told I'm going to Hell of if I don't repent etc when I'm coming out of M&S, I would definitely not want to stop protest against the war in Ukraine for example and if that is to have an impact it has to be somewhere the general public will see.

In short OP I don't think YABU in feeling the way you do, given your own circumstances but freedom of speach is more important for all of us.

OfstedOffred · 09/04/2022 23:06

Yanbu. Free speech should be protected by that shouldn't mean shouting vitriol when there are passing children. I've seen some preaching etc in a calm way that I have no issue with, but I used to pass one near work who was aggressive and difficult to avoid, carrying a megaphone and talking about stuff I dont really want my kids to hear.

StScholastica · 09/04/2022 23:04

@Cottoneyejoeswifestampon

toomany I don't believe Jesus yelled at and harassed people like this people do, I really don't. He was love incarnate, gentle, yes delivered a hard message at times but hung out with the down and puts and rejected in society. When I think of street preachers here in northern Ireland, telling gays and 'adulterers' and they're wicked and going to burn in hell, that's not what Jesus would've done
Didn't he have a bit of a hissy fit in a temple and overturn stalls and tables?
Theblacksheepforever · 09/04/2022 22:58

And I did walk away with my child.. obviously.

Removing the trigger doesn't automatically stop the meltdown does it.

OP posts:
Theblacksheepforever · 09/04/2022 22:57

@Dairymilk50

There many people with children with autism your the ignorant one why have you assumed I don't have autism myself or my own child?

You are being precious by far. Shouting in the street goes on quite often and you have exaggerated by far in your posts. To imply that it is a crime... I'm sorry OP but you would surely just walk away with your child! Like the rest of us do it takes seconds.

There's bigger things in the world than Street church preachers.

If you or your child has autism then why would you assume I'd have to stand near the preachers for any extended period of time for my son to get so distressed? Confused

Do you know how triggers work?

OP posts:
Neverreturntoathread · 09/04/2022 22:56

It’s mental illness OP. Mad people. Whether it’s shrieking about religion or being abducted by aliens, anyone screaming in the street is not playing with a full deck of cards.

Disagree with those saying it isn’t threatening. Shouting at young children that they’re going to burn in hell is a threat, and clearly your children and you felt threatened.

It isn’t free speech anymore than screaming racist insults at footballers is free speech.

Dairymilk50 · 09/04/2022 22:54

There many people with children with autism your the ignorant one why have you assumed I don't have autism myself or my own child?

You are being precious by far. Shouting in the street goes on quite often and you have exaggerated by far in your posts. To imply that it is a crime... I'm sorry OP but you would surely just walk away with your child! Like the rest of us do it takes seconds.

There's bigger things in the world than Street church preachers.

Theblacksheepforever · 09/04/2022 22:54

[quote Toomanyradishes]@dairymilk50 doesnt soubd unhinged, or rude for that matter[/quote]
I beg to differ.

Calling me 'unhinged' is very rude indeed, as is undermining the struggles my child has when he has a meltdown.

OP posts:
Theblacksheepforever · 09/04/2022 22:52

@Alwayswonderedwhy

I always think they must have poor mental health so not something they can really help. They probably genuinely believe they'll convert people and sadly some vulnerable people will be taken in. It is antisocial too
I've pondered that myself too, whether the ones that scream and shout the extreme stuff have any underlying mental health problems.

The Christians I knew personally would have never behaved like that, as I said in a PP my gran was devout and I have two aunts who are part of the faith - then their friends. It's unfathomable that you'd see any of them screeching about people burning, or outwardly abusing homosexual people.

OP posts:
Toomanyradishes · 09/04/2022 22:51

@dairymilk50 doesnt soubd unhinged, or rude for that matter

Obelisk · 09/04/2022 22:49

Recently encountered this chap at Oxford Circus- a bit unmellow. Doesn’t overly bother me though.

Religious preachers shouldn't be shouting and screeching in the street..
Theblacksheepforever · 09/04/2022 22:49

@Dairymilk50

OP I have read all the comments so far. Do you not think I have heard street preaching before? We all have but your coming across as unhinged and precious by far. Preaching on the bus? I have never witnessed that one... even so.

Shouting about all sorts goes on in public places especially on Weekends when people have had a drink..it is not uncommon.

Just walk on by. For your child to be distressed like your saying how long are you standing by church preachers?? Because if they offer me the leaflets and speeches I just politely decline and go on with my day rather QUICKLY.

Unhinged? It's you that is coming across unhinged with a post like that.

Yes preaching on a bus, ask Smirk she's local and will confirm it happens on a daily basis.

You clearly haven't experienced the sort of preaching that goes on around here..

Do you know sod all about autism? It only takes a split second to trigger a meltdown and can take hours to come out of one. You're a very ignorant person aren't you. Educate yourself on autism before you spout any more of that BS.

OP posts:
Cottoneyejoeswifestampon · 09/04/2022 22:45

toomany I appreciate that the OP didn't mention it but it is my experience quite often, all street preachers I have heard are aggressive and very often extremely offensive. I understand Jesus was a street preacher, and one I would've very much loved to hear, not cringed at, they all sound the same, like evangelical robots

Alwayswonderedwhy · 09/04/2022 22:45

I always think they must have poor mental health so not something they can really help. They probably genuinely believe they'll convert people and sadly some vulnerable people will be taken in. It is antisocial too

Swipe left for the next trending thread