Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Religious preachers shouldn't be shouting and screeching in the street..

187 replies

Theblacksheepforever · 09/04/2022 22:02

I was out with my children today walking down the high street with my two children, reception age DS is autistic and my other DC is a little baby.

A religious preacher with fliers who we hadn't noticed - started shouting at the top of her voice about God and jusgement day as we walked past her. It scared DS stiff and an hour long meltdown ensued. I was annoyed.

My child aside, does anybody else think this shouldn't be allowed? It's antisocial and technicallg illegal given that shouting and screaming in the street is contrary to section 5 of the public order act, so why is this allowed?

AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Theblacksheepforever · 14/04/2022 22:22

@knowinglesseveryday

"Screeching " is a silly exaggeration, as you know. And no, I'm not religious.
Ha far from an exaggeration, have you seen or heard these particular people in my area.

If you had you'd know they bloody screech.

OP posts:
Dairymilk50 · 14/04/2022 21:08

@Abitofalark

There are so many nuisances and sources of unwanted noise and behaviour in the streets that preachers are a small part of it and they are harmless, though annoying. Some people are very intolerant of anything to do with religion but will tolerate plenty of other things. I am very intolerant of noise but I know that and I have to put up with it.
This
user1471447863 · 14/04/2022 15:18

Religion is like a penis
It's fine to be proud of yours but when you start waving it about in the street and trying to ram it down people's throats then there a problem.

SaskiaRembrandt · 13/04/2022 17:53

I like to quote Matthew 6:5 to them.

dannydyerismydad · 13/04/2022 17:41

The "sinner or a winner" man who used to bellow down a megaphone at Oxford Circus was a sight to behold. For that reason YABU.

ErrolTheDragon · 13/04/2022 16:53

[quote Nightlystroll]@ErrolTheDragon
Quite. I haven't seen anything that you say which suggests street preaching should be banned.

In her opening op she says... given that shouting and screaming in the street is contrary to section 5 of the public order act, so why is this allowed?

Isn't this saying that it shouldn't be allowed as it falls conrary to section 5? And if it's not allowed, it's banned.[/quote]
No, she suggests 'shouting and screaming' (subject unspecified) should be banned. Not street preaching. I don't see any indication she objects to that if it's not scary and too loud to avoid.

Obviously banning shouting and screaming isn't realistic or appropriate

Nightlystroll · 13/04/2022 16:22

@ErrolTheDragon
Quite. I haven't seen anything that you say which suggests street preaching should be banned.

In her opening op she says... given that shouting and screaming in the street is contrary to section 5 of the public order act, so why is this allowed?

Isn't this saying that it shouldn't be allowed as it falls conrary to section 5? And if it's not allowed, it's banned.

codeVeronica · 13/04/2022 16:14

@knowinglesseveryday

I imagine it was shouting you heard.
No it was both. But thanks for telling me what I did and did not hear.
ErrolTheDragon · 13/04/2022 15:46

@knowinglesseveryday

I imagine it was shouting you heard.
But as the OP was there and you weren't, I see no reason at all to doubt her impression of the tone.
knowinglesseveryday · 13/04/2022 15:35

I imagine it was shouting you heard.

Yellowhighheels · 13/04/2022 15:30

I've seen plenty screeching from religious preachers

Same here

codeVeronica · 13/04/2022 15:16

@knowinglesseveryday

"Screeching " is a silly exaggeration, as you know. And no, I'm not religious.
I've seen plenty screeching from religious preachers.
knowinglesseveryday · 13/04/2022 15:15

"Screeching " is a silly exaggeration, as you know. And no, I'm not religious.

codeVeronica · 13/04/2022 15:10

It seems it's a dangerous time to be a woman in certain parts of America.

Yellowhighheels · 13/04/2022 09:50

I have also heard plenty spreading messages that are much more positive, regardless of whether one believes.

Suppose the problem is that the bible (and most religious texts) is pretty varied and colourful and includes a lot of messaging that has now been rendered unsuitable for broadcasting in this way by legislation on inclusion and hate speech. Perhaps churches should be reminded that they do not operate outside the law.

Yellowhighheels · 13/04/2022 09:45

I don't think the OP sounds bitchy or unhinged and I think she has every right to ask the question. It sounds like an alarming and avoidable incident.

I voted YANBU since I have heard street preachers shouting all sorts of sexist and homophobic crap, also have received abuse from one in particular for being 'promiscuous'. He continued shouting at me all the way down the street with his loudspeaker.

I agree with the principles of free speech and don't think evangelists should be banned, but I've witnessed plenty crossing the line into hate speech or abuse. Different part of S London.

ErrolTheDragon · 13/04/2022 09:30

Quite. I haven't seen anything that you say which suggests street preaching should be banned. We've had plenty of mentions of people who manage to do it considerately. I'll add the small bunch of Jehovah's witnesses who stand in a particular place every Thursday morning with a few posters, and say nothing other than 'good morning' unless you choose to talk to them.

Theblacksheepforever · 12/04/2022 23:04

There are lots of things I see out and about that upset me but are perfectly legal so I just have to learn to live with them. Is it right that others have to curtail their legal lifestyle because others find it upsetting? I personally don't think it is so I just suck it up. And I'm afraid that your son has to learn the same.

The chances of him "learning" to tolerate people shouting at the top of their voice within arms reach of him is extremely unlikely. He's severely autistic.

Let's take him out of the equation as it's clear a number of posters don't care about small children with autism being terrified. Nobody, regardless of whether or not they're vulnerable, should be frightened by people shouting in the street.

There is just no need to shout at all. It doesn't bring the positive attention they want anyway, it makes them seem unapproachable.

OP posts:
goaskmum · 12/04/2022 22:38

YANBU. I’m not religious and I agree that other people are entitled to believe in what they want to believe in, but I don’t like walking through city centres and hear them screaming about it but yeah as PP said, I guess they are entitled to their free speech as long as they aren’t pestering people about it

ErrolTheDragon · 11/04/2022 14:41

I think there's a very significant difference between disturbances caused by children and/or people with various specific issues vs adults who are deliberately shouting using scary words. It sounds as though the preacher was all too literally trying to 'put the fear of God' into passers by. Such people are also not comparable with the milder forms of preacher mentioned on this thread.

I'm not in favour of bans but I sincerely hope the woman who upset the OPs child realised and moderates her tone and/or volume. Her current approach is both unkind and liable to be counterproductive.

Dairymilk50 · 11/04/2022 14:16

@Nightlystroll I absolutely agree. You sumed it up beautifully.

Nightlystroll · 11/04/2022 14:07

But that is what people expect. In my experience people are not tolerant of things like shrieking, rolling around on the floor and self injurious behaviour in people with severe disabilities and expect people who those things to stay away from public places.

This is exactly my point. I hate going to the supermarket and hearing screaming children, regardless of whether they have a disability or not. I think I have sensory issues so it causes me quite a bit of irritation - very similar to the person shouting in the street. But I don't think they shouldn't be allowed to go out in the same way as the op is proposing preachers shouldn't be allowed to preach. We all live together as a society and we have to tolerate other people's behaviours as they have to tolerate ours. People can think or want others to stay away, I've no argument with that. But there shouldn't be a law to enforce it.

Xenia · 11/04/2022 13:50

They are very interesting issues as to what people should be able to do on the street - walk naked, be totally covered including their face, walk 10 a breast blocking the way, noisy mobiles, eating in public or in school uniform (used to be banned for secondary school children), eco warriers glueing themselves to things left right and centre and much else. I see in Ireland Russian supporters have taken to driving in long lines down a motorway displaying the Russian flag in support of Putin (and in London I think there were anti Israel supporters driving down Jewish streets as a provocation last year).

In general I want freedom to prevail and those of us who hate all this stuff never mind so many people are able to retreat to our own homes away from it all. I believe London Underground has a new campaign to stop men looking at women or staring which is going a bit far. A cat can look at a Queen as they say.

Thehundredthnamechange · 11/04/2022 13:33

@Dairymilk50

And people with kids can't walk past also? It's exaggeration here OP is not in an enclosed room with the church preacher.... it can be annoying for a matter of a minute literally and then the church preacher is out of sight surely.

Causing distress really Confused you see lots of disorderly behaviour in public places all the time. I would just move away promptly with my child.

Comparing a church preacher to someone with mental health is not remotely the same scenario! It's annoying at times yes but to imply they are similar to someone with mental health is wild also.

This
Sleepyblueocean · 11/04/2022 13:01

"He, like all of us, will have some behaviours that others don't like, does that mean he shouldn't go out where he can annoy people?"

But that is what people expect. In my experience people are not tolerant of things like shrieking, rolling around on the floor and self injurious behaviour in people with severe disabilities and expect people who those things to stay away from public places.