Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

SIL being a CF?

132 replies

Shinyballs · 09/04/2022 20:51

My children play a popular online game with their cousin. They pay for a server out of their own money so they can play with close friends and cousins without me worrying about strangers. My ex-SIL has asked that they stop playing with their cousin at 8 pm as he needs to get to bed. I agreed as I would like my younger son to start getting ready for bed at that time as well. However, this apparently means that after 8pm, my children have to stop playing online as well, and if they continue playing with each other after 8. (weekends for example or holidays) then it is UNFAIR and I am not sticking to the rules. It is possible for my nephew to tell if they have played after a certain time the next time he logs on somehow. One of my children is significantly older and doesn't go to bed at 8.

This is one of many disagreements I am currently having with my ex-SIL about online gaming. I am happy to ask my children to stop playing online with their cousin to help get him to bed at a decent time, but I don't see why this rule extends to what happens in my house after this time. She has also decided that it is not fair that my children play online together when her son can't. There is a lot of context obviously but the bare bones is that my children pay for this space out of their own pocket money, why should she try to control when they can and can't access it.

OP posts:
saltinesandcoffeecups · 10/04/2022 00:03

Sorry should have said, replace the details with whatever terms you are willing to go with

saltinesandcoffeecups · 09/04/2022 23:59

Op, I think you need to crystal clear on what you are willing to do and not do.

“SIL, there’s been a lot of discussion about the game. I’ve had a think and here’s where I come down on the issue. I agree that my boys will take a break from playing at 8. However they will be allowed to log back in after 15 (or whatever) minutes, this should give you time to get DN logged off. Then according to house rules my boys may log back in and continue playing. Their play time is not going to be affected by DN’s circumstances, I.e. if he’s banned by you for example. I can understand that this may cause some difficulties for you, and I’ll be happy to help separate his game from the server as I’m able. I’m glad that they have this shared interest, but we need to be fair all around.”

Needcoffeecoffeecoffee · 09/04/2022 23:57

Although their cousin also cant dictate all the play but it sounds like the other rules cover that

Needcoffeecoffeecoffee · 09/04/2022 23:56

The equivalent in the "olden days" (the 80s) is when your mum shouted you in from playing with your mates because tea is ready or its bedtime. But your friends are a bit older /have "cooler" parents than you
They dont all go in and go to bed!!
Although I do remember that horrible summer sound of everyone still playing out while i was getting ready for bed Grin
I think as long as your dc are fairly respectful of their cousins build ie not finishing something they want to finish it or destroying it then it's fair and part of growing up

Herja · 09/04/2022 23:41

@NannyKrampus It's just so much more effective than being diplomatic though! I don't have the patience to pussyfoot around idiots taking the piss. I save my patience for reasonable people I like Grin.

BOOTS52 · 09/04/2022 23:41

She sounds beyond controlling and you do what suits you and your children and tell her she is acting unreasonable and she does not make the rules for your children on their holidays and when they play or don;t.

JustLyra · 09/04/2022 23:39

The other request is if my nephew is removed from the realm for poor behaviour, that I don't allow my other child to play when he is absent, because it isn't fair.

Punishments aren’t meant to be fair, that’s the point.

You wouldn’t expect an entire swimming lesson or Scout meeting to be cancelled because one kid was grounded - this is no different.

Shinyballs · 09/04/2022 23:38

I haven't actually done this by the way. I tell my children to stop playing with their cousin at 8, but I haven't insisted that they stop. I just wanted some sane replies from people who are not embroiled in our tricky family system!

OP posts:
SpringsSprung · 09/04/2022 23:35

@Shinyballs The other request is if my nephew is removed from the realm for poor behaviour, that I don't allow my other child to play when he is absent, because it isn't fair.

So both kids are punished for her child's misdemeanour/s!?

Batshit

ElegantlyTouched · 09/04/2022 23:32

The other request is if my nephew is removed from the realm for poor behaviour, that I don't allow my other child to play when he is absent, because it isn't fair.

But surely that makes it more of a punishment, which is a good thing?

Stick to what you're doing and let your dc play by your rules.

NannyKrampus · 09/04/2022 23:30

@Herja

She is so lucky you are even giving this headspace! I'd have laughed her face and told her to fuck off. Genuinely. I don't see family relationships as a thing to be maintained unless I like the family member though. Life is so much nicer now I don't see or speak to twats through obligation.
We seemed to attended the same diplomatic charm school... Grin
medicmummm · 09/04/2022 23:29

I think this belongs on the PFB thread …. Hmm

Agree, this is just unfair. The world doesn’t stop because one child goes to bed.

Herja · 09/04/2022 23:29

She is so lucky you are even giving this headspace! I'd have laughed her face and told her to fuck off. Genuinely. I don't see family relationships as a thing to be maintained unless I like the family member though. Life is so much nicer now I don't see or speak to twats through obligation.

Shinyballs · 09/04/2022 23:28

Thank you all. I feel more sane now!

OP posts:
dontdivorceoverchacha · 09/04/2022 23:25

So your child has to endure the punishment too!!!! She's missing the point. If he's not allowed to play due to poor behaviour the consequence is missing out 🤷‍♀️ she clearly has some behavioural issues of her own. I don't envy your situation. Choose your words carefully regarding your rules and repeat repeat repeat. Good luck x

NannyKrampus · 09/04/2022 23:25

Your SIL is utterly bonkers and controlling as hell. I'd stop pandering to her and your nephew. Your kids pay for it and are old enough to stay up later and play on it. That is no one else's business. If actually taken out of the context of games and presented as someone wanting to stop other people doing something in their own time with their own money and resources because they cannot be around, you'd soon tell them to fuck off!

Shinyballs · 09/04/2022 23:19

@VerbenaVerbena

I knew this was minecraft realms! The real issue is that her son wants to control people and situations when it isn't appropriate. It's pretty common, and of course it seems easier to her that you all just capitulate to his current whims, but it'll only get worse if you do.

He can be in control of his own realm.
He can join in with others.
He can't control others' play routines.

It is indeed realms so lots of issues around 'ownership' and who is allowed to what. I know far more than is necessary about Minecraft now!

The other request is if my nephew is removed from the realm for poor behaviour, that I don't allow my other child to play when he is absent, because it isn't fair.

OP posts:
Shinyballs · 09/04/2022 23:15

@grapehyacinthisactuallyblue

old enough not to have a bedtime at 8

End of gaming time doesn't mean bed time. Mine doesn't go to bed until at least 11.
If the child's bed time is 8, they must be very young. You do expect that the normal parents don't want their children playing the game until the bed time, do you? But then, if you do, it's none of other people's business either.

It is more getting ready for bed I think rather than straight into bed for my nephew's case. Bedtime takes a long time for him due to ASD.
OP posts:
TokenGinger · 09/04/2022 23:14

@Beercrispsandnuts

Op yes, it’s hard to comprehend because you wrote you agreed as you wanted your kid to go to bed, this does not say you agreed as you,wanted your kid to stay up,playing with their sibling.

I suspect you know that.

Can you really not read?

She clearly said to stop playing with their cousin. She said she wouldn't mind her own younger child going to bed earlier. But now SIL is demanding older child cannot play online at all after 8pm as cousin complains he can see they've been online.

She agreed that her children wouldn't play with their cousin after 8pm.

I'm really not sure what's so difficult to comprehend.

VerbenaVerbena · 09/04/2022 23:10

I knew this was minecraft realms!
The real issue is that her son wants to control people and situations when it isn't appropriate. It's pretty common, and of course it seems easier to her that you all just capitulate to his current whims, but it'll only get worse if you do.

He can be in control of his own realm.
He can join in with others.
He can't control others' play routines.

Flickflak · 09/04/2022 23:07

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

lemongreentea · 09/04/2022 22:57

If your dc paid for it then she is being YABU and I feel bad for you having a batshit ex-SIL like her. I imagine you are trying to keep the peace and allow the cousins to have a relationship which is really good of you.

I'm annoyed at the 1% wally who has voted yabu when you're clearly taking into account your nephews ASD.

She needs to learn that different families have different rules at different ages and your children cant be expected to follow the same rules as hers. That would be very unfair on them.

grapehyacinthisactuallyblue · 09/04/2022 22:44

old enough not to have a bedtime at 8

End of gaming time doesn't mean bed time. Mine doesn't go to bed until at least 11.
If the child's bed time is 8, they must be very young. You do expect that the normal parents don't want their children playing the game until the bed time, do you? But then, if you do, it's none of other people's business either.

UndertheCedartree · 09/04/2022 22:40

My DD plays a few online games with her cousin and school friends. There are all sorts of different rules, different families have about when they can play. They often have to stop for dinner, to do homework, to go to gymnastics (etc), to get ready for bed. They just message 'Got to go my dinner is ready (for example). Noone would dream of telling the others they had to stop playing just because dinner was ready in one household or piano had to be practiced or whatever! Your SIL needs to deal with her DC and let everyone else deal with theirs!

Shinyballs · 09/04/2022 22:40

[quote Sushi7]@Shinyballs text her (if you haven’t already): “Hi SIL. Sorry but that rule doesn’t work for us. My ds is much older than yours and has a later bedtime. My ds uses his pocket money to pay for the server that all our dc play on. I can send you a link about how to purchase a server for your ds? That way he can keep track of his own achievements?”[/quote]
Thank you

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread