Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To switch off the power at 10pm tomorrow night

359 replies

Narwhalelife · 09/04/2022 19:58

Just seen this on Instagram.

I’m at the stage anything has to be worth it. Il probably do it, it’s just as I go to bed anyway so why not.

I’m not suggesting it will solve the issue, but might piss a few people off?

Anyone else?

To switch off the power at 10pm tomorrow night
OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
7
ConfusedByDesign · 12/04/2022 08:27

@lemmein I’ve thought about all that. It will take some proper protests to change things.
This could go one of two ways. Either this empowers people so they’re willing to fight a cause and do more or they feel they’re doing their bit already so when things get worse (further price hikes later in the year? Job losses as people stop spending and companies need to make staff cuts to save money? People really struggling to feed their families?) they don’t feel the need to do anything further.
Let’s see how much help the government are going to give people.

LivingDeadGirlUK · 12/04/2022 08:18

The electricity suppliers are private companies.

The government has nothing to do with electricity generation, transmission or supply in the UK (unless individuals hold shares).

If the energy usage of the uk changes from the forecast the generators and suppliers make MORE money.

The forecasters also use social media,

How many people who did this have actually written to their MP, literally sending the government a message?

lemmein · 12/04/2022 05:03

@ConfusedByDesign

I’ve had a think about this today and really, it does seem to benefit the energy company. I can’t quite figure out who has organised it and think it’s not actually a very effective protest. It feels a bit manipulated to me, but that’s just me. It might save me some money if I did it regularly but I don’t think it’ll benefit me any other way.
I don't think it's about saving money (it is only 10 minutes after all) - I don't think it's even about disruption to the grid; I think it's more to do with sending a message to the government. If it gathers momentum and that dip on the usage becomes steeper every week that's a very clear message to the powers that be (pardon the pun!) that there's unrest amongst the public. That 'dip' represents pissed off people - enough to cause disruption? Maybe not at the moment, but imagine in weeks/months to come, if more and more people join in with this tiny protest and in addition to the 10 minute switch-off people ramped it up and delayed, or cancelled their council tax/energy payments?

People got together and made a difference with the poll tax, and that was without the power of social media to organise themselves. This isn't about 'just' sitting in the dark for 10 minutes - it'll ramp up, the more pissed off people get.

ConfusedByDesign · 12/04/2022 00:20

I’ve had a think about this today and really, it does seem to benefit the energy company. I can’t quite figure out who has organised it and think it’s not actually a very effective protest. It feels a bit manipulated to me, but that’s just me.
It might save me some money if I did it regularly but I don’t think it’ll benefit me any other way.

rolllan · 11/04/2022 23:46

@Narwhalelife

I am curious though, through what means do people think such action should be communicated?

I’m being serious, this issue aside, for those who sneered at this, are you happy with the state of the country at the moment?

And if you are not, what would it take for you to say enough is enough?

Genuinely curious.

Also if the BBC news had suggested it (🙄) or Boris had said it was the only way to bring down prices (🙄🙄) would more have you taken part?

I think Martin Lewis seems to be the voice on this area at the moment
Cumbriangal · 11/04/2022 22:08

[quote Narwhalelife]@Cumbriangal we are all ears for your ideas. Unless of course you support the price rises of literally everything[/quote]
Don't have any meaningful ideas, would love wages to treble and bills to halve but it ain't going to happen.
I'm fortunate that 18 months ago I chose to upgrade my boiler from a 15 year old D rated model to an AA type which has saved me quite a lot and will continue to do so.
I have energy saving bulbs, wear a jumper in the house if it's cold,
This Evening I switched off all of my electronic devices after boiling water for a flask of tea, I took the flask to an elderly neighbour 5 doors down who doesn't get many visitors,
We had a cup of tea each (Mine) several biscuit (Hers) and talked about people in Ukraine, Syria, Palestine, Yemen and many more places who were suffering more than we were.
It all seemed to make causing unnecessary problems for Energy Companies pretty trivial and First World really but then what would we know?

SpringsSprung · 11/04/2022 20:16

[quote Designerly]@SpringsSprung
Maybe you came to it via TikTok (I wouldn't know, I dont use it) but I can assure you it is bigger than that. By the way haven't you realised that TikTok is a medium, you might as well have said 'it is just a Newspaper trend' or ' it is just a telephone trend'. And please don't adopt a supercilious attitude with your 'grow up' comment - maybe you have a cynical view of life and other peoples efforts, but I remain optimistic that change can be made by collective actions.[/quote]
It was a figure of speech. I don't use TikTok either but clips from it get shared everywhere. It's not bigger than that anyway! How is it!? All switching off does is SAVE the electricity providers money! 🤣

cakeorwine · 11/04/2022 19:33

@User843976

There was a graph posted earlier which shows a dip but it was a bit pointless as there were no comparable graphs from other times so no control samples, so meaningless.
I agree - you need more graphs to compare.

It did seem to show a sudden dip at 10pm though compared to a gradual decline.

lemmein · 11/04/2022 18:53

@SpringsSprung

Honestly!!! It's like eating laundry pods and saying "It sends a message to Bold" whilst vomiting your guts up! 🤦🏼‍♀️

Disclaimer: DO NOT EAT LAUNDRY PODS!!

It's nothing at all like that though, is it? Hmm

Weird that you thought that little nugget of nothing warranted an additional post!

LemonJuiceFromConcentrate · 11/04/2022 17:00

It isn’t the fact that it was shared on social media op, it’s the fact that there was nothing to it of substance so it was essentially just social media noise.

The thing it was asking people to do was so easy that it was sort of nothing-y, yet it was framed as an empowerment narrative. I mean if it was that simple to make energy providers bend to the will of the people, someone would have tried it before now.

It was a poorly conceived idea for a protest and social media amplified it.

That isn’t to say nothing shared on social media is ever worthwhile.

Designerly · 11/04/2022 16:38

@SpringsSprung
Maybe you came to it via TikTok (I wouldn't know, I dont use it) but I can assure you it is bigger than that. By the way haven't you realised that TikTok is a medium, you might as well have said 'it is just a Newspaper trend' or ' it is just a telephone trend'. And please don't adopt a supercilious attitude with your 'grow up' comment - maybe you have a cynical view of life and other peoples efforts, but I remain optimistic that change can be made by collective actions.

User843976 · 11/04/2022 14:37

There was a graph posted earlier which shows a dip but it was a bit pointless as there were no comparable graphs from other times so no control samples, so meaningless.

User843976 · 11/04/2022 14:33

I wouldn't have taken part if it had been on the news or Boris had said so like I didn't take part in the clapping. People didn't really seem to understand that stuff like that can also put bills up so is counter productive

muimerp · 11/04/2022 14:32

Also if the BBC news had suggested it (🙄) or Boris had said it was the only way to bring down prices (🙄🙄) would more have you taken part?

No, and they didn't suggest it because it makes no sense.

I would happily take part in something that is likely to promote some kind of action. This wasn't. It makes no difference who suggests something like this, applying some critical thinking as to the outcome is the only way for people to make a decision regarding taking part.

VanGoghsDog · 11/04/2022 14:27

@iheartmybeachhut

Halved charges on the strength of a 10 minute switch off really ? Hmm As they say on mn screen shot or it never happened.
Obviously you missed the sarcasm.
Narwhalelife · 11/04/2022 14:14

I am curious though, through what means do people think such action should be communicated?

I’m being serious, this issue aside, for those who sneered at this, are you happy with the state of the country at the moment?

And if you are not, what would it take for you to say enough is enough?

Genuinely curious.

Also if the BBC news had suggested it (🙄) or Boris had said it was the only way to bring down prices (🙄🙄) would more have you taken part?

OP posts:
LemonJuiceFromConcentrate · 11/04/2022 11:24

I honestly believe that, far from being “a start” and motivating people to move on to more effective action, stunts like this are more likely to end in further disempowerment of those who take part. That’s why they piss me off. It is not about sneering at the gullible.

First because misguided/bad faith social media “protests” take genuine motivation and divert it into something completely pointless, wasting the potential of that initial willingness to protest.

And second because quite a lot of people end up thinking “Well, I tried. I did what I could and it didn’t make a difference,” wrongly imagining that there was ever a chance of a suspiciously easy social-media-driven quick action making a difference. And that lowers the chances that they’ll remain motivated enough to do something more effective (which would almost certainly also be more difficult and complicated).

Obviously I hope I am wrong, though, and that the people on this thread who participated will in fact move on to a better informed level of activism. But y’know. There are reasons why most people don’t do that, including that it’s fucking challenging and most of the worst affected people already lead busy, exhausting lives.

DrWhoNowww · 11/04/2022 11:09

@LampLighter414

So guys, did it work?
No, demand dipped by about a GW so some people definitely did it.

But we then sent a lot of that surplus energy down the interconnectors to France where we’ll have sold it for more than we could in U.K.

So actually…did the energy companies a favour Grin…

LemonJuiceFromConcentrate · 11/04/2022 10:52

@Nothappyatwork

I’m still waiting to hear what the oh so intelligent alternative is. come on then genius’s what’s the plan ? If this won’t work what will ?
Nobody owes you an intelligent alternative as someone sort of ‘swap’ for criticising this plan. It’s fine for anybody to point out the flaws in a stupid idea without instantly supplying a different idea to replace it.

If you want to initiate action that stands a better chance of making a difference, you might have to (gasp) come up with it yourself. And I would imagine it’ll take a hell of a lot more time, energy and effort than it took to get swept along in last night’s half-baked effort.

Making a difference is hard work. Collective action has to be underpinned by a proper understanding of what’s happening, if it’s going to have real value. Many people jumping on the 10-minute switch off very evidently didn’t have the faintest clue about what would/would not realistically happen as a result.

SpringsSprung · 11/04/2022 10:40

Honestly!!! It's like eating laundry pods and saying "It sends a message to Bold" whilst vomiting your guts up! 🤦🏼‍♀️

Disclaimer: DO NOT EAT LAUNDRY PODS!!

SpringsSprung · 11/04/2022 10:36

@Designerly

Wow, I can't believe some of the comments on this one.

a) Your fridge/freezer contents will not melt in 10 minutes if the door is shut.

b) It is not just a pointless social media prank/ joke retweeted by fools, it has been reported seriously by regional (and London) press in advance.

c) The point is for this action to send a message to government, and of course no one will notice if one single person switches off their appliances for 10 minutes, but if millions do, then if will register as a serious concern.

d) It is a genuinely democratic and non partisan expression which expresses concern, without the need to block streets or march on Whitehall.

So with minimal personal inconvenience you can show concern for the hundreds of thousands of households who are about to suffer fuel poverty this year.

To my mind, that doesn't seem so pointless.

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 Grow up! It's yet another TikTok 'trend' followed by people without much common sense
iheartmybeachhut · 11/04/2022 10:34

Halved charges on the strength of a 10 minute switch off really ? Hmm As they say on mn screen shot or it never happened.

TwoLeftSocksWithHoles · 11/04/2022 10:15

@Nothappyatwork

I’m still waiting to hear what the oh so intelligent alternative is. come on then genius’s what’s the plan ? If this won’t work what will ?
More nuclear power stations would be my guess.
VanGoghsDog · 11/04/2022 09:59

@LampLighter414

So guys, did it work?
Yes, my supplier has written to me to say utility charges have been halved. Yay!
LampLighter414 · 11/04/2022 09:38

So guys, did it work?