Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Or is £21 a day not enough to cover 3 meals for a student?

111 replies

SunshineLollipopsAndRainbows · 09/04/2022 15:46

This is a language school advertising for people to accommodate students in their homes. I don’t think £21 would be enough to cover breakfast, packed lunch & dinner plus things like extra hot water etc. It’s out of my area anyway but I do wonder if they will get anyone to do it.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
toconclude · 10/04/2022 20:32

It's plenty. Don't know what you eat but it's obviously quite a bit different to what I do.😁

BritWifeInUSA · 10/04/2022 20:24

It’s to cover costs, it’s not meant to be a career move.

It’s an extra plate on the table and extra person through the shower each day.

BitOutOfPractice · 10/04/2022 20:16

My food shop this week (from Waitrose!) was £78 for 3 adults and that included done extra treat stuff as dd (19) is back from uni.

When she’s at uni she shops at Aldi and feeds herself for £25-30 a week.

£21 a day is loads!

MurmuratingStarling · 10/04/2022 20:10

Is £21 a DAY (£147 a week,) enough to feed one student?

OR

Is £21 a day (£147 a week,) a reasonable amount to charge for board, lodgings, and food?

Which is it @SunshineLollipopsAndRainbows

Because your TWO posts on here say/ask totally different things.

livingthegoodlife · 10/04/2022 20:08

The school near me only pays £12 a night! It's not enough. I previously hosted in a different area which paid a lot more and loved it. Don't know why this place pays so little.

irregularegular · 10/04/2022 19:38

It's plenty if it is just supposed to cover costs for people who are hosting a student because they want to (but don't want to be out of pocket). Not enough to attract someone to do it for the money. But I don't think they would want to?

spongedog · 10/04/2022 19:31

I did this a few years ago with short-term European teenage students. Trips 2-4 nights. I was paid then £15 per night per student. Each student had to have their own bed, but no limit on beds in the room.

I had to cover food-wise - breakfast, lunch and dinner. The meals were specified as to contents. PLUS transport the students to and from their daily activity.

The idea was that the students experienced typical British food. The only way to "make" money was to offer the cheapest quality food possible (per advice from the organiser). I wouldnt do that. So I offered a range of cold breakfast foods, big choice for packed lunch and I always cooked fresh for their hot evening meal.

I would mostly host 3 students - so 3 lots of bedding/towels to wash and iron (so minimum wage per hour ?). I loved doing it - we met some lovely students. I hope they enjoyed their time. The money I was paid was considered by HMRC (income tax) to be a subsistence allowance. I stopped when I couldnt get the same confirmation from HMRC (Tax Credits). I felt that I earned each time a few pounds per visit. I might do it again - but perhaps would want the students to make their own way to collection points.

Every family I met hosting was doing it for their own reasons but it certainly isnt a money spinner. You need to consider the time involved.

Waxonwaxoff0 · 09/04/2022 20:42

I lived on £20 a WEEK food budget before. Of course it's doable.

Kite22 · 09/04/2022 20:32

It must be bloody difficult to live healthily on £20 a week though esp given recent price rises.
DS (also a student) lives close to 3 supermarkets Lidl, Morrisons and Asda, he gets by on approx £35- £40 a week and thats buying reduced items.

Nope. She eats well. She does like a bargain, and chooses to walk a little bit further to Aldi rather than using the Co-op round the corner. She is my 3rd student, and both said the same re amounts they need to spend. (Hers is slightly more than dc2 who had slightly more than dc1 to allow for inflation). Before dc1 went, we talked with nephews and nieces and other friends already at University to see what they spent and all were similar (well, less, as was a few years ago). They can all cook and understand about eating leftovers or freezing spare portions.

Itloggedmeoutagain · 09/04/2022 19:43

It's plenty
If it's out of your area why are you bothered?

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 09/04/2022 19:34

It must be bloody difficult to live healthily on £20 a week though esp given recent price rises Ds does ok, he's super fit and eats really cleanly, shops at Aldi or Tesco, definitely doesn't eat crap.

RaRathebravemouse · 09/04/2022 19:32

Your title says 3 meals a day but the. Your subsequent post says it's board and lodging so that's two different things. It's definitely enough to cover food and I wouldn't have thought your bills would go up that much.

StScholastica · 09/04/2022 19:30

My DD is a student and spends £60 a week on food and toiletries. She lives in a city centre and can't drive, so admittedly her options for budget supermarkets are few (it's Tesco express or M &S) It must be bloody difficult to live healthily on £20 a week though esp given recent price rises.
DS (also a student) lives close to 3 supermarkets Lidl, Morrisons and Asda, he gets by on approx £35- £40 a week and thats buying reduced items.

Kite22 · 09/04/2022 19:15

@Dishwashersaurous

Sounds like a great deal.

Cereal and toast for breakfast. Less than a pound.

Packed lunch. £2 max

Evening meal £2.

Extra heating and electricity £2 a day.

Therefore costs £49 per week. Income £147.

Almost a hundred profit a week for minimal effort really

There you go, the maths done for you.

How can you possibly think that isn't enough ? Confused

We spend only a little over 1/3 of that to feed 4 adults each week.

My student dc reckons £20-£25 is more than enough for her food and other groceries (toothpaste, w-up liquid, shampoo etc) and of course it is more expensive to shop for an individual than to buy bigger packs of things when shopping for a family.

SilverDoe · 09/04/2022 19:03

I was going to say you are obviously being unreasonable but actually costing it out when you are trying to buy for a single person, which I imagine you may be when catering for someone who's visiting and not part of the family. This is just a quick example I've put together based on stuff I typically buy, and when trying to provide for one person it is still weirdly expensive. However it's still well in budget and is quite a nice varied shop.

Breakfast - 3 days = oats so simple porridge and a banana. 3 days = Scrambled eggs on toast/ hard boiled eggs and toast. 1 day = blueberry pancakes. Accompanied by glass of fruit juice and tea/coffee.

Lunch each day - various sandwiches, veg crudites with either hummus of Philadelphia, fruit pot, savoury snack, crisps.

Dinners - Mushroom and cheese omelette, spaghetti bolognese, nicer ready/oven meal, beans on toast, stir fry, soup and crusty rolls, takeaway.

Small punnet of blueberries £2
Bunch of bananas - 75p
6 medium eggs - 89p
Butter - £1.50
Pancake mix - £1
4 pints milk x 3 for tea, coffee, cereal etc - £3
2 x bottles of fresh juice for 1 glass with breakfast - £2.70
Oats So Simple Big Bowl - £2.20
PG Tea Bags x 40 - £1.40
Small jar of coffee - £2
Small bag of caster sugar for tea and coffee - 60p
7 x little lunch side e.g. fridge raiders, olive pot - £8

7 x various fruit pots - Tesco do a variety all for £1.15 each = £8.05
Loaf of nice bread - £1.50
Block of cheese - £2
Pack of naice ham - £3
Romaine Lettuce - £1
Tomatoes - £1
Peppers - £1
Carrots - 50p
Hummus - £1
Garlic and herb Philadelphia small - £1
Large cucumber - 60p
Bacon - £1.55
Branston Pickle - £1.55
Helman's Mayo - £2
Multipack Walker's Crisps - £2.50

Jamie Oliver tray bake meal - £8
Spaghetti - 55p
Nicest pasta sauce - £2
Pack of bolognese seasoning - £1
Mince beef 250g - £1.80
Heinz Beans - £1
Mushrooms - £1
Hard cheese - £2
Takeaway - £20
Fancy soup carton - £2
Crusty rolls - £1
Stir fry deal with fresh noodles, veg pack, sauce and protein - £5

~ £100

FYI the lunch stuff works out actually cheaper to buy a meal deal but there's more food and you'd have leftovers plus some of the veg is used in the meals.

But yeah that clocks in at around £100 and it's way on the higher end of what you'd need to buy. You could provide someone a decent menu for half that or as a PP said, even every meal out would be less than £21 per day.

itsgettingweird · 09/04/2022 18:52

£600 a month would more than cover what having 1 extra person would cost.

OutingHobby · 09/04/2022 18:50

It's enough for food wtf are you cooking that it isn't?

EssexLioness · 09/04/2022 18:49

I think that’s loads of money tbh. We feed 2 adults for £40-45 per week, including cleaning products and do most of our shopping at Tescos. Sure we could do it for even less at Lidls/ Aldi.

Mellowyellow222 · 09/04/2022 18:47

@NumberTheory

For food alone it’s generous. For food, heating, loss of a room, another person added to the bathroom rota, etc. It’s not great but probably reasonable for most people who aren’t that profligate and want to make a little extra from a spare room.
Agreed. I assume the daily rate is to ensure the student isn’t a financial burden on the host family. It’s not the same as getting in a lodger to help with your bills.

OP I am not really sure why you have posted about this. You don’t seem to be familiar with the concept and you don’t live in the area it has been advertised so you aren’t going to do it.

londonrach · 09/04/2022 18:23

That's perfectly ok

5128gap · 09/04/2022 18:23

Well the government thinks a single person under 25 can pay for everything they need, not just food, with around £60 universal credit per week, so presumably some unfortunate young people make it stretch.

Diverseopinions · 09/04/2022 18:22

I was noting that the gent staying with my colleague actually requested for the heating to be on more, because he wasn't used to cooler temperatures. If we have a cold snap, well, yeah, you would feel you have to leave the heating on all day, if guests are uncomfortable.

Makes one think of other examples of how fuel price hikes will affect life. I can imagine lots of people will spend the day in the local library. Tough if you live in a village, and tiny library only opens two days per week.

Svara · 09/04/2022 18:11

Adult and teen. Food £50, energy £25, water £10 a week, so £85/2 each, about £6 a day.

HesterShaw1 · 09/04/2022 18:04

Of course it is.

mumofEandE · 09/04/2022 17:58

I have done this in the past- you couldn't pay me £210 a day to do it again!