Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

iPads!! Too much??

113 replies

TayceOnToast · 09/04/2022 13:29

My 5 year old stepson has had his own iPad since he was 3, possibly younger. He is on it every day, sometimes for several hours and it feels kind of outrageous to me. I feel like it’s way too much for a child this young, and that he should be spending much more time playing with real toys, developing fine motor skills and flexing his imagination.

I want to get a feel for what is “normal” in other people’s houses. Maybe I need to just chill out and get with the times since we’ll all probably be playing out our lives in a simulated universe soon anyway. I’m totally addicted to my phone so maybe it’s hypocritical of me to criticise his screen time.

So, my questions are:

Do you have a child aged 5 or under in your house?

Do they have their own iPad?

How much time are they allowed on it?

AIBU?!?!

Thanks

OP posts:
MacaroniCheeseCat · 09/04/2022 16:40

Mine are 6 and 2. They don’t have their own tablets. The 2 year old is already screen-obsessed! They are allowed to watch things on an iPad and old Kindle at bathtime when it’s just one of us on duty, and the toddler sometimes gets the iPad first thing when I’m desperate for another half hour in bed before getting up. But they don’t have their own devices - I think they’re too young and it will become another thing to argue about and regulate.

I agree with other comments about YouTube - we are pretty liberal on screen time in terms of TV but YouTube is banned on all devices in our house as my eldest’s behaviour was appalling after it, with huge rows about coming off it. Something to do with the instant gratification factor, perhaps.

Mama1980 · 09/04/2022 16:37

BertieQueen if he wants to speak to them or make arrangements he calls - using the landline or my phone.
He goes out all the time, but just as I didn't when I was young he doesn't need to message etc, he has a time to be home, and he shows up then. He's actually out now at running club with his friends. And met a friend to play chess earlier. In an emergency he can use their phones but only a couple of times has he had to - when a friend of his was taken unwell and they were out in town and once when the bus didn't show up.
If he asked for one I'd allow it - I have offered him an iPad and a phone - but he said no - but then he has never had a tablet or phone so doesn't really see the need for one himself.
My younger ones just never use a screen.

latriciamcneal · 09/04/2022 16:36

I agree that's outrageous. These devices and their apps are designed to addict people with dopamine hits. My daughter is 6 and has very little screen time overall, always has. Just doesn't feel right having her sat in front of a screen for long periods.

her biggest consumption of screens is a movie at bed time when she will be laid down staring at it. Other than that the TV can be on (Netflix or youtube) in the background while she plays and she hardly looks at it but still enjoys her favourite shows being on.

You can't get upset by what others do though. Parenting advice is rarely welcome. I'm past caring about other people's kids now to the point where it upsets me their parents make obviously bad or neglectful choices.

RandomNumb3rs · 09/04/2022 16:35

Mine had iPads from age 4/5

They completely self regulated. Basic ground rules about not using them between 1900-0700 and advice about balance and making good, well rounded choices. They each averaged between 30-90 minutes per day (confirmed when the “screentime” function appeared).

They are now 14&15 and don’t seem to have suffered adverse effects. Both A students. One is currently sat next to me reading Descartes essays (yes, really) and the other is programming a game in Unreal Engine, but he did just finish 2 hours of judo.

Giraffesandbottoms · 09/04/2022 16:23

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted as it quotes a deleted post.

ByGrabtharsHammerWhatASavings · 09/04/2022 16:21

My 3 and 5 year olds were given kindle fires this Christmas by my MIL and they are allowed to use them for half an hour a day between 9am and 6pm. They don't use them every day, more like twice a week, unless we are going on a long train journey in which case I let them use it for a bit longer. They have really strict settings so can't access the Internet or any age inappropriate content, and I'm able to monitor everything they are doing from my phone and shut them off remotely whenever I want. The vast majority of the games they use are things like colouring apps, or phonics and maths games. We also sometimes use them for ebooks or books on audible. I was very sceptical about them at first but actually I think they're pretty good and the kids definitely still spend the majority of their time doing hands on playing, lots of time outside etc.

Idonea · 09/04/2022 16:19

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

BertieQueen · 09/04/2022 16:17

@Mama1980

No none of my three children still at home 5,6 and 14 have iPads or phones. We don't do screens. They are all welcome to use mine if they want but they very rarely do.
Interesting that a 14 year old doesn’t even have a phone? How do they talk to their friends? Do they not go out without you?

Not criticising at all just wondering. I have a 12 year old and he uses his phone to message friends, make arrangements etc and I can also contact him on it when needed.

Idonea · 09/04/2022 16:16

No. That's scummy parenting.

Giraffesandbottoms · 09/04/2022 16:16

I have a 4.5-yo, and she keeps herself amply busy with colouring, Lego, dolls, and running around outside. I can’t think of when or why she would need a tablet

Some children don’t do this. My boys won’t just sit happily and colour etc - if I want to cook them fresh food (and I do), then they need an iPad or the tv whilst I’m cooking, otherwise they tear around the house and out of my eyesight and get up to mischief. Plus the iPad has a lot of educational apps that preschool have given us to help with maths and reading etc.

Sprogonthetyne · 09/04/2022 16:13

Ipads are way out of our budget for a young child, but mine have had tables since 2/3. They go through phases of playing everyday but also phases where they don't touch them for weeks. It's handy to have them for long journeys or waiting rooms etc, and for them to know enough to play independently.

One benefit of cheap tables is the battery life is terrible, so after an hour or so "oh dear it's out of battery, let's plug it in for tomorrow". They have not yet realised that you can play while it's plugged in, or that it doesn't take overnight to change.

Cocomarine · 09/04/2022 16:11

It’s possible to have a conversation with your partner about this, that isn’t criticism.

Mama1980 · 09/04/2022 16:06

No none of my three children still at home 5,6 and 14 have iPads or phones. We don't do screens.
They are all welcome to use mine if they want but they very rarely do.

Herecomesthesun2022 · 09/04/2022 16:04

Neither my 4 year old nor my 7 year old have an iPad. The 7 year old is allowed on ours for about half an hour on the odd day to play games

Cakesnbiscuit · 09/04/2022 16:03

5 and 2 year old.

We have a family ipad that we use for education games and YouTube. Definitely not used daily and they are limited to a certain time.

It’s been a life saver when we all got a stomach bug and the kids bounced back while both parents where being sick. They had it unlimited then.

I don’t have an issue with iPads if used in moderation. I would be more worried that my kid might grow up not knowing how to use technology or be bullied for not knowing what an iPad is.

PrincessesRUs · 09/04/2022 15:57

My daughter is 4 - she uses mine and is allowed approx 20 mins a day which she tends to have after dinner and before the bath. I really try to limit it and think 20 mins at her age is probably too much. The exception would be like this morning as she's been unwell she watch a whole film as we don't have a tv in the bedroom but that's a real one off. I agree about wanting to encourage crafts, toys, board games etc

carefullycourageous · 09/04/2022 15:52

I'm not convinced that using iPads lots will ruin your kids lives

I think if 'won't ruin their lives' is the best that can be said it is probably worth doing something else. Most other activities genuinely will improve their lives one way or another, whether through movement, imagination, education, fun etc.

JennyPourQuoi · 09/04/2022 15:47

It's not unreasonable to set boundaries. I'm not convinced that using iPads lots will ruin your kids lives, but you should expose them to a variety of stimulus.

OfstedOffred · 09/04/2022 15:44

My eldest is 5. He does not have his own iPad and wont be getting one until at least secondary school.

Occasionally I let him use my tablet to play educational games (maybe half an hour once a week) or watch a tv program in the car.

Bimblybomeyelash · 09/04/2022 15:43

My 8 and 5 year olds go on their iPads 2 or 3 times a week for an hour/hour and a half. I truth I feel that is probably too much but I’m too weak! I did experiment with daily use, but only for half an hour, but I wasn’t disciplined enough to remember to kick them off. I feel that too much ipad time does have a detrimental effect on their behaviour.

BlossomRussosHatCollection · 09/04/2022 15:42

My kids are 5 and 2. They have a crappy old iPad they share. They have a maximum of 30 minutes a day - usually before school/nursery and if they dick about getting ready they have less time to play it! I get the impression we're a lower usage household.

I'd actually like to get them their own, but would still limit them to an hour or so a day - and probably not till the youngest is a bit older.

FWIW, the iPad basically taught DD1 to read!

Widmerpool · 09/04/2022 15:41

I have a nearly-4 year old DD.
She has some games installed on my iPad, but no tablet of her own.
She uses this for probably an average of an hour a week. Most days none at all, Sat and Sun maybe half an hour a day, but she doesn’t seem to mind if not.
In the car we sing and talk, no iPad. At restaurants we play i-spy or do colouring, etc, no iPad.
(She also usually has limited access to television: 10-15 mins a day.)

To note also that I am careful about the kind of games that she accesses on my iPad: they don’t have to be overtly ‘educational’ but we do avoid competitive/addictive ones with loads of levels to complete, as these have been shown to have detrimental effects: they can create stress which can lead to aggressive behaviour.

Afolnerd · 09/04/2022 15:40

Mine are 8 and 6, they don’t have their own iPads but do have access to ours. Kids are allowed 1 hour every other day. Normally as down time after school. They watch a bit of tv the other days. Dd15 is allowed hers whenever pretty much but she has to have 2 hour long breaks during the day. But it’s up to her when she takes them.

carefullycourageous · 09/04/2022 15:39

@sanityisamyth

*@Mariposista* Children aren't on screen all day at school and they need to use them to develop skills in technology as the world is going more and more that way. If you ban them from using it until they're 12 they will be massively behind. My mother frequently admits that my DS8 is better with her tablet than she is (which is android and he only uses an iPad at home) and teaches her how to use it!!
I'm sorry but this is bollocks. Mine have learnt coding properly, which I agree they need and is inadequately taught in schools, but it really is not a complex business learning to swipe an ipad.
carefullycourageous · 09/04/2022 15:38

@Imsittinginthekitchensink

I'm quite hardcore in terms of tech and refused to give mine any such thing until she was at secondary school. Kids are in front of screens all bloody day in school, she didn't need it at home too.
Yes I agree and none of mine have had their own screens until in later secondary for this reason. They were not even arsed tbh, we had coding stuff and laptops but they were shared.

My honest view is an ipad of their own in primary is a negative and will be hampering their educational and social development not due to anything inherently damaging about screen time but because screen time prevents them doing other more beneficial things.

Swipe left for the next trending thread