Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who's in the wrong here - him or her? Me?

155 replies

namechange58928585 · 09/04/2022 13:00

Name changed just as not to be identifiable.

Good friend of mine, a male colleague from 2 years ago. We've always got on well and kept in touch after his leaving - mostly via text but have met very occasionally for a walk or coffee.

My partner is aware and my relationship is OK. His partner had an issue with it (not sure how aware she was of the detail of the friendship but she decided it couldn't possibly be friendship and he wasn't to contact me again)

It's definitely friendship, but not sure anyone can reassure her - she seems quite insecure and suspicious of him. I am aware their relationship isn't strong and a big part of their staying together is the children (but I don't know her to get the full picture)

Anyway - he has been told zero contact with me or there will be a divorce. This is where I'm uncertain who is doing wrong. He's said fine to her on this, however still wants a friendship with me, just without her knowledge.

I can 100% confirm he has never made a move or been inappropriate with me in the past. If she weren't so reactive about it all I'd assume there would be no need for the secrecy.

So if we remain friends, who is in the wrong here? His wife for having no trust in him and disallowing him female friends? Him for staying friendly with me when she's insecure about it? Me for wanting to stay in touch with my friend when my partner has no issue and they've even briefly met?

It's not an affair, nothing physical has happened. It's not anything beyond the same friendships I have with my female work friends from previous jobs. There's no extreme emotional attachment or anything like that but sometimes we do talk about our lives and offer advice. Nothing I wouldn't be happy with my other half seeing.

I'm just not sure who is being unreasonable - I like to think neither of us are, but appreciate he is now hiding this friendship from her.

OP posts:
Gowithme · 09/04/2022 14:44

I disagree with those saying she's being unreasonable because we haven't heard her side of the story. For all we know this bloke might spend all his time telling his partner how wonderful the OP is and not stop talking about her. He might come in from their coffees with a big smile on his face and have a face like a slapped arse the rest of the time. She might just have that gut feeling that he wants more than friendship from the OP and she might be right.

She might be wrong and it's all purely platonic but how are we to know? the fact that he's prepared to risk his relationship for the OP suggests to me at least that there might well be more to this.

Luredbyapomegranate · 09/04/2022 14:42

She is being unreasonable. But of course you don’t know what previous experience that’s based on.

He’s accepted this from her, so of course he’s also being unreasonable for suggesting you both go behind her back. The fact he’s doing this rather than standing up to her does make me wonder the history.

You aren’t being unreasonable, but have some sense, back off and don’t entangle yourself in their weird dynamic. He’s not a best friend of 20 years, he’s a casual friend of a couple years. Message to wish him well and block.

IncompleteSenten · 09/04/2022 14:35

He's being very unreasonable.
Either he does as she asks or he says no and she decides whether she wants to stay with him or not.
He's dragging you into this and that's not fair.

Gowithme · 09/04/2022 14:35

She doesn't trust him and he's happy to do things behind her back. He's saying he's prepared to risk his relationship to meet you to talk and have coffee - it's not a mess I'd want to be in the middle of. There are a gazillion other people you can be friends and go for coffee with, you really don't need the potential drama.

oviraptor21 · 09/04/2022 14:34

She's unreasonable. I couldn't care less about going 'behind her back' because of that.
On the other hand, he is being unreasonable expecting you to keep his secret. He shouldn't have told you about that aspect of it because it's an unfair expectation on you to keep quiet about it.
I'd urge him to be a bit more assertive about it with his partner but I wouldn't stop being a friend - he probably needs one with a partner like his.

MrsWinters · 09/04/2022 14:33

She is being unreasonable, no one should ever try to control their partner and dictate who they can and can’t be friends with.
Personally even though she’s in the wrong I’d back off-you don’t want to be seen to be the reason why their marriage breaks down. Just be there for your friend when it inevitably hits the skids, she sounds like a right cow

WhoWants2Know · 09/04/2022 14:26

I think the wife has explained very clearly where her boundaries are. It doesn't really matter whether you feel anything inappropriate would ever happen. Something about your friendship has made her feel that her marriage can't continue at the same time as the friendship.

What her husband does with that information is up to him, but he needs to be prepared to accept the consequences of his actions. He's kidding himself if he thinks he can carry on and hide the friendship.

LittleBearPad · 09/04/2022 14:24

I’d stay well out of it OP.

JustLyra · 09/04/2022 14:24

@Grapewrath

I think it’s bizarre that people are justifying the wife’s behaviour tbh. It’s not ok to not allow your partner friends of the opposite sex.
There’s not a single post that I can see saying it’s fine and dandy.

Just some folks pointing out that there’s a reason for it (either she’s controlling or he’s given her reason to be wary) and sneaking around is not the answer to any of those reasons.

SickAndTiredAgain · 09/04/2022 14:24

She is unreasonable to make such an ultimatum.

He is unreasonable for agreeing to it and then lying.

MulberryBush700 · 09/04/2022 14:24

*unreasonable

MulberryBush700 · 09/04/2022 14:22

@Grapewrath

I think it’s bizarre that people are justifying the wife’s behaviour tbh. It’s not ok to not allow your partner friends of the opposite sex.
Yes, but it's up to him to him to deal with his wife's supposedly u reasonable behaviour and the solutions is not that he lies to her. He either tells the wife that she is being ridiculous and carries on with his friendship with the OP or tells the OP goodbye and deals with his wife completely separately afterwards. It's not OK to lie.
KirstenBlest · 09/04/2022 14:22

@Grapewrath

I think it’s bizarre that people are justifying the wife’s behaviour tbh. It’s not ok to not allow your partner friends of the opposite sex.
No, it is not, but chances are when there is this sort of dynamic, should the female friend becoes single, the male friend makes a move
MulberryBush700 · 09/04/2022 14:20

It's Him.

He needs to be an adult about this and ultimately has two options.

1.) He can come to you and say that his wife (rightly or wrongly - I don't know) doesn't approve, and your friendship is not worth making her miserable and upset. Tells you goodbye and gets on with his life and you with yours. However they deal with the wife's insecurities after that is between them.

2.) He can also tell his wife that she is being unreasonable and he is to carry on his friendship with you regardless how it makes the wife feel and she needs to sort out her insecurities and unfounded jealousies. Whatever the wife does after that (divorce, gets counselling) is down to her.

Under no circumstances should you get involved and him lying to the wife and making the friendship a secret is wrong, whether she is being unreasonable or not. It's for them to sort out - in either one of the ways I mentioned above. Anything else and it soon becomes deceitful.

KirstenBlest · 09/04/2022 14:19

You all are

Grapewrath · 09/04/2022 14:13

I think it’s bizarre that people are justifying the wife’s behaviour tbh. It’s not ok to not allow your partner friends of the opposite sex.

Grapewrath · 09/04/2022 14:11

He is the problem for remaining in a controlling relationship with his wife tbh. I wouldn’t continue the friendship in secret though because I’d want to be well out of that fucked up dynamic

gamerchick · 09/04/2022 14:10

I wouldn't touch that with a 10ft pole OP. Tell him you won't be someone's secret and wish him well. Definitely have no part of it.

Madrenetterhere · 09/04/2022 14:05

He is unreasonable but you will be too if you continue the friendship knowing its now a secret and against his wife's wishes. Try and put yourself in her shoes. If all your relationship consists of a few texts occasionally and the odd meet up for a walk or coffee I would wonder why this man is risking his marriage and family for that? What I mean to say is, you see this as a platonic relationship, but I would wager he doesn't.

Hutchy16 · 09/04/2022 14:04

Everyone is unreasonable. She has an excuse, he is clearly happy to lie to her and sneak around so of course she is going to be concerned about your friendship. But you and he both have no excuse, walk away

Vsirbdo · 09/04/2022 14:00

In the main him for keeping it a secret; it seems odd on her part but you don’t know it from her point of view as you say.
In all honesty though I’m not sure I’d still keep up the friendship with him as i couldn’t be doing with the drama when (and there’s always a when) she finds out

Hertsgirl10 · 09/04/2022 14:00

He’s been caught wanking at your pics or she’s a total nutter.

If its that innocent then he wouldn’t agree to cutting ties with you surely? I don’t get why women hate their partners having females friends unless there’s been an issue with the friend in the past.

It’s controlling to forbid a person to see another person, why would he agree anyway to that? Have you asked him.

montysma1 · 09/04/2022 13:55

Well there relationship. problems are her problem as she is clearly contributing to them.
If the husband is prepared to put a friendship then there is a problem. If its a secret friendship...... x100.

Nocutenamesleft · 09/04/2022 13:55

@HollowTalk

I think a lot of women wouldn't be happy with their partner going off for walks and coffee with another woman. Does he want to compound that by meeting in secret?
Why?!?

Wouldn’t bother me at all. I have complete trust in my husband. As he does with me. He’s got female friends and they are lovely!

FirstTimeMum6666 · 09/04/2022 13:53

She has every right to feel this way! I'm sure you would if your partner was close to another woman! But the guy needs to man up and say he will still be friends with you because if she finds out you two are still "secretly " friends then it looks like a very sus affair.

Swipe left for the next trending thread