Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say to dsis...they are not average? Or are they!?

132 replies

jazzyjeffs · 09/04/2022 12:53

Name change for this...

Dsis always claims that they are an "average" family...she says it so breezily. Like for example...the whole Rishi Sunsk fiasco at the moment. She'll say things like, all well and good for him but we couldn't do that as an average family!! But...they are NOT average! They have no mortgage,(her dh played the whole property ladder thing very well from a young age!) they have no loans or debts, they don't pay for childcare as they work around each other etc. they make A LOT work.

Now on the outside, yes, they are average as in they have two working parents, 3 bed detached, two working cars (not brand new obviously!) but they're not AVERAGE? Are they??...

OP posts:
bigbluebus · 09/04/2022 13:40

With no mortgage or childcare costs I'd say that their disposable income us way above average on that income. Obviously compared to Rishi's household income it's miniscule but most if us aren't measuring against that!

bellac11 · 09/04/2022 13:39

@ActonBell

I’m really puzzled that people are saying this is average. The IFS actually has a calculator based on household income: ifs.org.uk/tools_and_resources/where_do_you_fit_in

If, say, they are a family of 2 adults and 2 children, they earn £80k a year and pay e.g. £1900 council tax then they have more income than 89% of the population. So they are very nearly in the top 10%. Add to that that they don’t have to pay for housing which is a, if not the, major outgoing for most households and that puts them in a considerably more well off position than the vast majority of people.

I think what’s confusing is that the gap between being in the top 10% and the top 1% is massive. You would think once you’re in the top 10% you’re close to being in the top 1% with Sunak but if the gap were a time period it would be like saying that the Elizabethan era is ‘nearly’ in the Jurassic age compared to today. Of course it’s not - the gap is still massive.

They are no where near ultra wealthy and they are not average. Both things can be true.

Thats very interesting

Its shows our situation as being in the top 5%

I find that hard to believe, we drive old bangers, have debts and no savings, live in a cheap deprived area of the UK!!! Still have a mortgage

Im failing to see the benefits!

thewhatsit · 09/04/2022 13:38

@Pitafalafel

A 3 bedroom home could cost anywhere between 100k and 1 million depending on where in the country we are talking about. And pretty normal to have two cars these days seeing as many households now have to rely on two wages.

And the fact is that in relation to Rishi Sunak, anyone earning between 20k and £1 million is average.

Yes so much of this is region specific.

50k salary might be pretty high in some areas of the U.K. and really not in London.

I am in London and I can only think of one or two families that own two cars off the top of my head, even amongst the richest people I know, but in other parts of the country owning two cars is completely standard.

MapleMay11 · 09/04/2022 13:36

@fizzyfood

The average family are not mortgage free in my opinion.
That could depend on where you in the country you live. Being mortgage free in a house worth 150k is very different to one worth £1.5 million. Having paid off your mortgage is pretty meaningless as an indicator of wealth.
Pitafalafel · 09/04/2022 13:35

A 3 bedroom home could cost anywhere between 100k and 1 million depending on where in the country we are talking about. And pretty normal to have two cars these days seeing as many households now have to rely on two wages.

And the fact is that in relation to Rishi Sunak, anyone earning between 20k and £1 million is average.

ActonBell · 09/04/2022 13:32

I’m really puzzled that people are saying this is average. The IFS actually has a calculator based on household income: ifs.org.uk/tools_and_resources/where_do_you_fit_in

If, say, they are a family of 2 adults and 2 children, they earn £80k a year and pay e.g. £1900 council tax then they have more income than 89% of the population. So they are very nearly in the top 10%. Add to that that they don’t have to pay for housing which is a, if not the, major outgoing for most households and that puts them in a considerably more well off position than the vast majority of people.

I think what’s confusing is that the gap between being in the top 10% and the top 1% is massive. You would think once you’re in the top 10% you’re close to being in the top 1% with Sunak but if the gap were a time period it would be like saying that the Elizabethan era is ‘nearly’ in the Jurassic age compared to today. Of course it’s not - the gap is still massive.

They are no where near ultra wealthy and they are not average. Both things can be true.

Squidlette · 09/04/2022 13:29

I'm not sure people's spending at the moment is indicative of how people WILL be struggling.
Lots of these holidays will be covid carry overs.
People won't yet be massively affected by price rises. I expect it to hit me around autumn, so probably won't have any holidays next year. Night a 2nd hand car last year, so hoping for 10 years out of that.

TiddleyWink · 09/04/2022 13:29

You’re way overthinking this. She just means ‘typical’. Which they are far more so than Rishi and co. You sound very jealous.

bellac11 · 09/04/2022 13:28

@BluntWithAC

I wouldn't say the average person their age has their house paid off, thats not average.

The childcare cars etc is fairly average as lots of couples work round each other/nightshifts and make it work.

They are just above average in my opinion.

The OP didnt say how old they were?
fizzyfood · 09/04/2022 13:28

The average family are not mortgage free in my opinion.

elliejjtiny · 09/04/2022 13:28

I would say they were rich. I think most people would think their experience is average or normal. For example I had nearly 9lb full term babies so when someone has a 6lb baby I think that's tiny. Also I had a baby at nearly 37 weeks who was really poorly so I always nervously ask if a baby is ok if born around that gestation. Before my son was born I would assume a baby born after 34ish weeks would be small but otherwise fine. We are low income enough to rely heavily on tax credits but not entitled to FSM. So I would say that getting FSM means you are poor and anyone earning more than about 20k but less than 60k is in the middle. More than £60k is rich to me although I'm sure people earning 60k think they are average.

thewhatsit · 09/04/2022 13:27

If your sister was renting and on a below average salary would you also insist they are not average?

I don’t know how we are defining average. If it’s basically within 1k either way of mean income you won’t get many people or families that are “average” will you?* Or maybe we mean within 1 standard deviation from the mean, which will include 2/3 of families? In which case, she probably is average.

  • in the same way that the average person possesses 1.99999 arms and 1.99999 legs etc
shinynewapple22 · 09/04/2022 13:27

I suppose 'average' would be a 3 bed semi and joint earnings closer
to £50-£60k, given average salary is around £30k. But they are not that far off are they? They are comfortable rather than rich. Yes there are an awful lot of families in rented accommodation, in cramped conditions, minimum wage or no job, but equally there are people living in mansions, owning more than one property and earning money that most people can't imagine.

2pinkginsplease · 09/04/2022 13:27

They sound pretty average to me!

Why does it bother you so much, are you jealous of your sister?

FairyCakeWings · 09/04/2022 13:25

They sound pretty average to me. Lucky to have been in the position where they can play they game and own a house, but they’re not out of the ordinary.

If they weren’t working as much as they do and had to make no sacrifices, then it would be out of the ordinary.

bellac11 · 09/04/2022 13:22

[quote jazzyjeffs]@lljkk yes I think she means to say typical! Maybe,

But even at that I just find it hard to listen to...yes they are hard working. They bring in good wages between them (somewhere between 80-100k)

@Sexnotgender there's little benefit I suppose but I do wonder is she stuck in a little bubble of "everything is awesome" whilst everyone else is struggling to keep up with mortgages, car payments etc. [/quote]
Well they do have a much higher than average income thats true.

But its also not true to say that 'everyone else' is struggling to keep up with mortgages and car payments. The majority of people are JAMs so are getting on with it and not struggling although not particularly well off.
You can see that by listening to the news this weekend, the busiest weekend since before covid at airports, people have got money to burn going on holiday. People are buying new cars all over the shop. Housing prices continue to go through the roof.

HollowTalk · 09/04/2022 13:21

In terms of wealth she's nowhere near Rishi's level - I think that's all she means. Their income is from wages; Rishi's isn't.

BluntWithAC · 09/04/2022 13:19

I wouldn't say the average person their age has their house paid off, thats not average.

The childcare cars etc is fairly average as lots of couples work round each other/nightshifts and make it work.

They are just above average in my opinion.

Beercrispsandnuts · 09/04/2022 13:17

Op are you struggling financially? Is that what’s driving you are you envious of her?

Seeline · 09/04/2022 13:17

Is she actually basing it on their income?

As a 2 parent, 2 DC family in a 3 bed property with a couple of older cars they sound pretty average.

Beercrispsandnuts · 09/04/2022 13:16

Yes she’s fairly average. Average covers a wide spectrum, but she’s defintely not some form of special case.

nervousnelly8 · 09/04/2022 13:12

They sound considerably average when compared to Rishi's wife with a £700m stake in her father's business - everything is relative. Whilst there are many people feeling the squeeze, I wouldn't say it is "average" to be struggling to make your mortgage (yet).

Svara · 09/04/2022 13:12

Depends how far from the median you still call average. You could say the middle 50% or the middle 90% are average. Like I don't call myself low income on 20k as there is a big section of society with children on FSM, but others would include our family as low income too.

BogRollBOGOF · 09/04/2022 13:08

She may be above the mean, but she's within the median, so yes "average" is a realistic description.

Pyri · 09/04/2022 13:07

They sound absolutely average to me!

Swipe left for the next trending thread