Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say to dsis...they are not average? Or are they!?

132 replies

jazzyjeffs · 09/04/2022 12:53

Name change for this...

Dsis always claims that they are an "average" family...she says it so breezily. Like for example...the whole Rishi Sunsk fiasco at the moment. She'll say things like, all well and good for him but we couldn't do that as an average family!! But...they are NOT average! They have no mortgage,(her dh played the whole property ladder thing very well from a young age!) they have no loans or debts, they don't pay for childcare as they work around each other etc. they make A LOT work.

Now on the outside, yes, they are average as in they have two working parents, 3 bed detached, two working cars (not brand new obviously!) but they're not AVERAGE? Are they??...

OP posts:
LegMeChicken · 09/04/2022 16:36

@carefullycourageous

I'm not using it to knock anyone down, I just think that being mortgage free and having no childcare costs is at the lucky end of normal. They do not sound super rich, but they seem to have fewer money pressures than most.

And it is not true that only a small number are affected by bad luck, IMO. Millions were affected by the most recent mortgage contraction, I felt very lucky this did not affect me unduly.

I said a small proportion, which is still a large number. I was also referring to things like ill health. 'Most' people are healthy. Unprecedented catastrophe on a global scale is another thing.

I agree that they're fortunate, and you're just pointing that out. But the OP's derisive attitude got my back up, because I encounter it lots IRL. Ironically it's not from 'less fortunate' people. But those who could have made my choices.

Idonea · 09/04/2022 16:16

No debts, don't pay for childcare as my DH and I balance WFh with caring. Mortgage. Car. So yeah they sound pretty average. Having debts shouldn't be normalised.

SparklyLeprechaun · 09/04/2022 16:08

Of course they are average.

carefullycourageous · 09/04/2022 16:04

I'm not using it to knock anyone down, I just think that being mortgage free and having no childcare costs is at the lucky end of normal. They do not sound super rich, but they seem to have fewer money pressures than most.

And it is not true that only a small number are affected by bad luck, IMO. Millions were affected by the most recent mortgage contraction, I felt very lucky this did not affect me unduly.

RussianSpy101 · 09/04/2022 15:59

Sounds perfectly average

wishingitwasfriday · 09/04/2022 15:59

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

LegMeChicken · 09/04/2022 15:55

[quote carefullycourageous]@bellac11 It is lucky not to have anything throw a spanner in the works. I personally do not really believe in hard work being the distinguishing thing between those who have no ill health, disability, redundancy, unexpected issues and those who do.

I am very lucky and I count my blessings every day. I do not work harder than my colleagues who have e.g. had a bad car crash and ended up having a year off work.

If you have experienced rising house prices and uninterrupted work, you are lucky. If you can get jobs that tie in with each other (as me and my DH have) you are lucky. So many people have to juggle.[/quote]
'Lucky' implies something above normal. It's really not 'normal' to have a major issues. it's a large number of people, because of the UK population, but not a large proportion. if you go down that route ... everyone in the UK even if dirt poor are lucky to b here, rather than another country with no benefits! Yes, benefits are abysmal and not enough.. but better than nothing... etc etc.

I really don't see the relevance of this race to the bottom when discussing other people's personal circumstances. IME it's always use to either justify that the poor are lazy, or to sneeringly knock down people's achievements. Rarely used in a sensible context and degenerates into a bun fight

bellac11 · 09/04/2022 15:54

There is inherent luck, thats without a doubt. Lucky that you are well enough to work, have the intelligence to get through education and qualifications for a good job, etc etc

But its also choices that are made within the limitations or abilities you have. So did they buy a cheaper property in order to make sure they could be mortgage free at a particular point, did they get qualified to make sure they had access to good jobs, did they choose to have a particular number of children rather than too many to afford etc etc

MySecretHistory · 09/04/2022 15:47

Sound average- a 3 bed is small- if they lived in a larger house they would have a mortgage

HardyBuckette · 09/04/2022 15:45

If they're of an age to still have DC still needing childcare and are also mortgage free, there's probably an element of luck there even if it was only being born at the right time. But no more so than anyone else born in eg 1975.

carefullycourageous · 09/04/2022 15:45

@bellac11 It is lucky not to have anything throw a spanner in the works. I personally do not really believe in hard work being the distinguishing thing between those who have no ill health, disability, redundancy, unexpected issues and those who do.

I am very lucky and I count my blessings every day. I do not work harder than my colleagues who have e.g. had a bad car crash and ended up having a year off work.

If you have experienced rising house prices and uninterrupted work, you are lucky. If you can get jobs that tie in with each other (as me and my DH have) you are lucky. So many people have to juggle.

bellac11 · 09/04/2022 15:41

@carefullycourageous

Your DS sounds like she is at the very lucky end of average to me? I would not say her situation is completely exceptional, but certainly she is fortunate to have such secure finances and low costs.

Lots of people don't like to think they are lucky.

Its impossible to say whether they are lucky.

They clearly organise their working lives to make sure they dont have the expense of child care, which suggests to me that they organise their finances to their benefit too.

Of course they might have been given a shed load of money to put them in this position, or got prestigious jobs with high income by nepotism or friend of a friend. In which case, yes thats 'lucky' rather than hard work.

Moody123 · 09/04/2022 15:40

They sound very average to me, however it's all a matter of prospective isn't it
I think their are a lot of people struggling and a lot of rich people however I also think a good % of people are in the middle (average)

Thesefeetaremadeforwalking · 09/04/2022 15:39

@jazzyjeffs

"I'm not jealous, I have no need to be jealous as I'm very lucky in lots of ways!"

So why bring it up? How does their situation affect your life ? Confused

HardyBuckette · 09/04/2022 15:35

I suppose also them doing opposite shifts to avoid childcare costs is probably causally linked to not having a mortgage or any other debt, and owning two cars. Because of how brutal opposite shifts are, I think a lot of people who could in theory do it choose instead to spend money on childcare. But there's bound to be some people who do it as an active choice to save money, rather than because they simply can't afford childcare.

howtomoveforwards · 09/04/2022 15:34

I think you need to ask yourself why it's so important to you to put your sister in her place? And then ask yourself why it's so important to put your sister in her place over this?

Tigofigo · 09/04/2022 15:31

I'd say not average looking at the stats.

The average wage is something like 29k so they earn a fair bit above average.

The average mortgage debt is £137k so to have none is well below average (you don't mention their ages however).

Only 24% of people live in detached houses (60% in semis).

The majority of households only own one car.

I wouldn't say their circumstances are UNUSUAL though.

JoshLymanIsHotterThanSam · 09/04/2022 15:28

I would say if you chopped all of the millionaire’s and billionaires out of the equation then your SIL would be way above average. Obviously that is how maths works but my point is that for an average working family your sil is at the top end of the scale.

DrSbaitso · 09/04/2022 15:28

They're certainly not "average" on that income and to be mortgage free while with young dependent children. But I can see why she'd say they aren't on the level of the Sunaks, who are much, much further from average than she is.

LegMeChicken · 09/04/2022 15:26

@Kite22

Another who thinks she would be better saying "typical". Yes, their income is clearly much higher than most, and it is probably not very common to be mortgage free when you still have a young family, but I think most of us understand what she means about having two parents out at work and having to be aware of what is being spent.

But, as Just10moreminutesplease says, most of us look at those people we see around us and think that - whatever it might look like - is 'normal'.

I've worked with lots of families where the Mum had a teenage pregnancy, as did her Mum and her Mum before her. They have never worked and live off benefits. In their eyes - that is completely normal, and it is the same for their neighbours in the high-rise blocks they are housed in. I've also got some friends who fly first class and go on two or three 'big' holidays a year. Again - that is completely normal for them and the other people they bump into in the airport lounge and the hotels they stay in, and presumably with their colleagues who earn the same salary. If your dc go to Private school, then you meet other parents whose dc go to Private school, and so, in your social circle, that is completely normal even though only a very small % of UK children go to private school, same with the families you mix with at the private tennis club etc etc. and so it goes on.

The other thing to note is that even 'small' proportions, in the UK is several million people. To demonstrate 5% of people in poverty is 3 million people. 10% would be 6 million.

That's a LOT of struggling people, but in % terms not the majority of the country...

Ponderingwindow · 09/04/2022 15:24

If they have to work opposite shifts to avoid child care expenses then they are likely an average family. That is a huge strain on a family and a marriage.

I recognize that my family is not average, despite not being part of the elite. That is because we have very high incomes as defined by a comparison to national median income and live in a relatively low cost of living area. A family who earns closer to the median or that lives in a high cost of living area so their income needs to reflect that is indeed average.

HardyBuckette · 09/04/2022 15:17

The term average is just so broad, and the information you've given is so imprecise, it's really hard to say.

What you've described here could very well cover a mid to late 40s couple in any number of UK cities where one of them bought a cheapo flat in like 2001, then upgraded to maybe a 100k or 150k property when they got together and pooled resources, paid it off recently and never saw any reason to buy a bigger home after that, while both working shifts around each other with one Band 6 and one Band 7 NHS.

Obviously any combination of factors that specific is unusual, but equally none of it would raise any eyebrows. Fairly bog standard. And there are lots of people who got lucky with the timing of the housing market whilst also not having wanted to upgrade to a particularly expensive home. Obviously if they're in fact sitting on a multi million property mortgage free and they're both 31, that would be a bit different!

Kite22 · 09/04/2022 15:10

Another who thinks she would be better saying "typical".
Yes, their income is clearly much higher than most, and it is probably not very common to be mortgage free when you still have a young family, but I think most of us understand what she means about having two parents out at work and having to be aware of what is being spent.

But, as Just10moreminutesplease says, most of us look at those people we see around us and think that - whatever it might look like - is 'normal'.

I've worked with lots of families where the Mum had a teenage pregnancy, as did her Mum and her Mum before her. They have never worked and live off benefits. In their eyes - that is completely normal, and it is the same for their neighbours in the high-rise blocks they are housed in. I've also got some friends who fly first class and go on two or three 'big' holidays a year. Again - that is completely normal for them and the other people they bump into in the airport lounge and the hotels they stay in, and presumably with their colleagues who earn the same salary. If your dc go to Private school, then you meet other parents whose dc go to Private school, and so, in your social circle, that is completely normal even though only a very small % of UK children go to private school, same with the families you mix with at the private tennis club etc etc. and so it goes on.

Unsureaboutit9 · 09/04/2022 15:10

They arnt exactly well above average like I was expecting to read. They sound hard working and good with money, good for them. You sound jealous with your ‘it’s hard to hear’ stuff.

Beercrispsandnuts · 09/04/2022 15:09

I’m also curious why it bothers you, is your statement you’re lucky in lots of ways indicate maybe not as “lucky” as them financially?

Swipe left for the next trending thread